Elizabeth Smallwood; Whether Smallwood States A Claim Sufficiently Outrageous To Support The Intentional Infliction Of Emotional Distress

1279 words - 6 pages

TO: Deborah S. Gordon

FROM: 11773476

DATE: September 19, 2008

RE: Elizabeth Smallwood; whether Smallwood states a claim sufficiently outrageous to support the intentional infliction of emotional distress

Question Presented
Under Florida law, does Smallwood state a cause of action sufficiently satisfying the outrageousness element of the intentional infliction of emotional distress if her neighbor Melnyk was merely acting within his legally permissible rights?
Brief Answer
Probably not. Smallwood’s complaint probably falls within the scope of mere indignities or unpleasantness, which is insufficient to constitute outrageousness. In addition, aggregate factors ...view middle of the document...

Smallwood’s situation, which resulted from her neighbor Melnyk’s failure to turn off his security lights, is probably insufficient to satisfy the “outrageous” element of a claim for the intentional infliction of emotional distress. To be considered outrageous, “conduct [must be] so outrageous in character, and so extreme in degree, as to go beyond all possible bounds of decency, and to be regarded as atrocious, and utterly intolerable in a civilized community.” Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. McCarson, 467 So. 2d 277, 278-279 (Fla. 1985). The standard is extremely stringent and extends beyond conduct that may be humiliating or reprehensible. Lay v. Roux Laboratories, Inc., 379 So. 2d 451 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 1980) (conduct not sufficiently outrageous where defendant was alleged to have used verbal attacks and racial slurs during parking space dispute).
In evaluating the conduct, a court will also look at aggregating factors, such as susceptibility to emotional distress. McAlpin v. Sokolay, 596 So. 2d 1266 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 1992). For example, in McAlpin, a physician verbally abused and refused medical treatment to a patient he knew owed a debt to his friend. Id. at 1268. The court found that the doctor’s knowledge of the plaintiff’s medical problems and his subsequent behavior exploited her vulnerability to emotional distress. Id. at 1269. The knowledge of such susceptibility may make the outrageousness of a claim more pervasive. See id.
Taking advantage of an unequal power relationship also helps heighten the efficacy of the claim. Liberty Mut. Ins. Co. v. Steadman, 968 So. 2d 592, 596 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 2007). In Steadman, the defendant’s calculated delay of a lung transplant hinged on knowledge that the plaintiff was likely to die in a short time. Id. at 595. The court held that, independently, the delay was not outrageous conduct, but in conjunction with the defendant’s knowledge of the plaintiff’s life expectancy and previously litigated entitlement to a lung transplant, the claim became sufficiently outrageous. Id. at 596. A party asserting disproportionate power like the defendant had in Steadman may help elevate a claim to the level of outrageousness. Id. at 597.
Even if a claim is sufficiently outrageous, a party escapes liability if it exercises its legal rights in a permissible way. McCarson, 467 So. 2d at 279. In McCarson, the insurer (defendant) stopped making payments to the insured when they received no response after requesting proof of ineligibility for Medicare. The plaintiff theorized that this action caused the premature death of the insured. Id. at 278. The McCarson court held that there was no liability even if the conduct was sufficiently outrageous because the defendant was merely “[insisting] upon [its] legal rights in a permissible way. Id. at 279. However, the courts have also recognized that legal rights may be exercised in an impermissible way. Liberti v. Walt...

Other Essays Like Elizabeth Smallwood; Whether Smallwood States a Claim Sufficiently Outrageous to Support the Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress

Claim: Government Must Ensure That Their Major Cities Receive the Financial Support They Need in Order to Thrive

717 words - 3 pages 5. Claim: Government must ensure that their major cities receive the financial support they need in order to thrive. Reason: It is primarily in cities that a nation's cultural traditions are preserved and generated. As some people put forward, government must ensure that their major cities receive the financial support they need in order to thrive on the grounds that in these cities, a nation's cultural traditions are preserved and

The Claim of Consumption Essay

1325 words - 6 pages usage of these commodities.  Hetherington states that items that were once “a novelty for the wealthy might come to be seen as an everyday essential for the majority” (p.25). This is shown during the industrial society, where it is argued that “only the very wealthy – the aristocracy…rich merchants, and factory owners…and a few well-paid professionals” could be defined by a luxury lifestyle whilst the society we now live in, a consumer society

“Residential Segregation Shapes the Social Life of Cities and People’s Sense of Who They Are”  Explain How Different Types of Evidence Used in Dd102 Support This Claim. 

1536 words - 7 pages )   Data – qualitative and quantitative, graphs, maps, academic writings, social surveys, interviews and census reports are some of the evidence within DD102 which will be examined, explained and used in order to support the claim.  The assumption that people living in one place are all connected by proximity, may, in theory, be true, but, this can also act as a disconnection as the following evidence shows, with residential segregation shaping

A Response To Teri Schiavo And The Life Support Issue

640 words - 3 pages For months now, the Schindler and Schiavo families, who are the parents and husband of Terri, have been fighting over how to handle Terri's care. She has been on life support for over a decade. However, without a living will, Terri's fate is undecided. Her husband, Mark, states that her dying wish was not have any external means of continuing life, such as a feeding tube or respirator. Her parents argue that is not the case.Wednesday, the

The Meaning of Emotional Intelligence and Dimensions Attached to It

3724 words - 15 pages on a goal. It also allows us to create better networks of support, overcome setbacks. Leadership – I enable to build stronger teams by strategically utilizing the emotional diversity of their team members to benefit the team as a whole and build stronger bonds. They are able recognize what the needs of the people, so that those needs can be met in a way that encourages higher performance and workplace satisfaction NB. Emotions play a very

Assess The Claim That The Labour Governments Of 1924 And 1929 Were Unable To Achieve Anything

935 words - 4 pages Assess the Claim that the Labour Governments of 1924 and 1929-31 Were Unable to Achieve Anything In 1924, for the first time the Labour government was appointed, headed by leader Ramsay Macdonald. At this time, a topic of much political debate was trade, Conservatives adopting a protectionist policy contrasting with the Liberal and Labour views in favour of free trade, and as the strongest free trade party it was asked to take office

Evaluate the Claim That Miracles in the Bible Are Not a Reliable Form of Experience

854 words - 4 pages Evaluate the claim that miracles in the Bible are not a reliable form of experience. Prior to discussing this, it’s important to understand what it means to read the Bible. There are two common interpretations of the Bible, a literal reading and a non-literal reading. Having said this, I will argue that miracles in the bible, on balance are not a reliable form of religious experience and will consider the case studies of Jesus’ resurrection

Critically Analyse the Influence Early Support Has on the Support Given to a Young Disabled Child or Their Family

2182 words - 9 pages guidance requires key workers to provide personal and emotional support, sensitive to needs and family circumstances”. However is this being done? According to Townsley et al: 2004, the families that were interviewed, only half who had a key worker, felt the key worker would provide emotional support, if they needed it. According to Judith Cavet: 2007, “Practical support put in place by key workers may be in the form of help or advice directly

Whether the Amount of Noise in an Environment Affects an Individual's Ability to Memorize Words in a Limited Amount of Time

914 words - 4 pages Whether the Amount of Noise in an Environment Affects an Individual's Ability to Memorize Words in a Limited Amount of Time Hypothesis ---------- In a noisy environment, fewer words will be memorised, as it will be harder to concentrate and memorise words. Method ------ Design The type of experiment we did was a lab experiment as it was controlled, as the participants knew they were taking part

“the Puritans Were Never a Serious Threat to Elizabeth” How Far Do You Agree?

1148 words - 5 pages The rise of Puritan ideology in Elizabeth I’s Church and Government was potentially an extremely dangerous threat to her power. Although it may be perceived that Elizabeth was continuing to control her position soundly, it does not mean that the Puritans did not pose a threat to royal authority. Nonetheless, attempts to promote Puritan ideas were indeed crushed quickly and effectively by Elizabeth, which meant that the movement never got the

The Emotional Intelligence of Leaders

557 words - 3 pages Source: Goleman, D. (1998, fall). The emotional intelligence of leaders. Leader to Leader, 10, 20-26 To be a successful leader there are two attributes that are essential in order to fully execute this: Rational and Emotional intelligence It has been found that there are more leaders that have made it to the top with mostly their technical or professional skills leaving a huge gap of emotional intelligence unattained or uncultivated. This is

Related Papers

Building A Brand Leadership, Ulrich & Smallwood

1152 words - 5 pages Building A Leadership Brand addresses the issue of leadership development which bumps up an organization's market value and creates competitive advantage. Ulrich and Smallwood point out that leadership brand represents an intangible value and shared identity among organizational leaders, which differentiates what an organization can do versus its competitors. The article demonstrates how to create value for investors, customers, and employees

Arguments In Support Of The Claim That It Is Not Wrong To Eat Animals

1837 words - 8 pages more houses were being sold, the supply increased and lowered the hosing price. In 2006 and 2007, when the price of the housing price dropped, those house owners would be unwilling or unable to pay off their loans. The mortgage-backed investment lost support and no one wanted to buy it anymore that led to the credit crisis. 2.2 Securitization Securitization is a process that allows banks to transform a future revenue into an

Nurses Must Provide Emotional Support To Patients

3112 words - 13 pages relationship with the people present in his or her surroundings. An individual must be a part of an effective social process. This could mean that he or she should be able to give and to receive emotional care from other people. Rendering care and comfort to someone is such a good feeling, but to receive those kinds of affection is much better. It is normal for people to seek and long for affection because it enhances their worth. People usually

Compare Sources A And B As Evidence For Henry Vii Claim To The Throne Of England

1121 words - 5 pages Compare sources A and B as evidence for Henry VII’s claim to the throne of England [30] On comparing sources A and B as evidence for Henry VII’s claim to the throne in 1485, it can be said both have relevant use as both give an account of events at the time of Henry VII’s coronation. However it is questionable how reliable each of the two sources are because of the position of the authors in relation to King Henry VII and their willingness to