Employment At Will Legal 500 Essay

3811 words - 16 pages

Employment-at-Will Doctrine

Professor Augustine Weekley
Legal 500
Law, Ethics & Corp. Governance
April 28, 2014


Employment at Will is a legal rule that developed in the nineteenth century, giving employers’ unfettered power to “dismiss their employees at will for good cause, for no cause, or even for cause morally wrong, without being thereby guilty of a legal wrong.” The economic philosophy of laissez-faire provided theoretical support for employment-at-will. Its legal underpinnings consisted mainly of “freedom of contract,” the idea that the individuals are free to choose how to dispose of what they own, including their labor, as ...view middle of the document...

Although at this writing only a fairly narrow slice of the U.S. workforce is unionized, collective bargaining agreements typically cut against employment-at-will, protecting workers from being fired except for “good cause” (Halbert, & Ingulli, 2012).

Keywords: employment at will, ethics, whistleblowers

Recently hired as the Chief Operating Officer (COO) in a midsize company preparing for an Initial Public Offering (IPO), I have discovered several personnel problems that require immediate attention and action! As a company we must ensure that we abide by the Corporate Governance: corporate roles, rights, and responsibilities. In contrast, employees must abide by company policies in respect to his/her rights and privacy. Each of the following points must be addressed individually and on a case by case scale. They are as followed:

Scenario (1). John posted a rant on his Facebook page in which he criticized the company’s most important customer. John is violating the company’s “social media” and “code of ethics” policies which called for grounds of termination. Of course, his employee rights consist of “freedom of speech,” but he has duty of loyalty to remain professional and comply with the company’s code of conduct policies. Before he was hired, John signed an employer/employee disclosure agreement (re: social media and code of ethics, etc.) stating that speaking against or about any customer(s) or client(s) associated with or doing business with the company in a negative manner via social media or publicly is absolutely unacceptable behavior. This form of behavior will not be tolerated. It is against the company’s policies, fair warnings have been given to John therefore, this could lead to being terminated. According to company records, this is John’s second offense in a year. He received a warning for his first offense which was filed in his employee records. John portrayed a negative image of the customer and it had a negative impact on our relationship with the client. Fair warnings were provided for his first offense therefore, John has been terminated.

Scenario (2). Jim sent an email to other salespeople protesting a change in commission schedules and bonuses and suggesting everyone boycott the next sales meeting. Once again, every employee has his/her right to exercise freedom of speech within the organization, but with limitations. Jim is attempting to persuade his fellow workers to join him in a protest and to boycott the next sales meeting. Jim should request a one on one meeting with higher management and discuss his concerns and/or objections of the commissions and bonuses. As an astute manager, they should compromise with Jim and any other disgruntle employees by negotiating the commission and bonuses numbers that’s more appeasing. No need to make thing worse by emailing other salespersons that may not even have a problem with the commission schedules and bonuses. He can not be fired because of the...

Other Essays Like Employment at Will Legal 500

Employment at Will Essay

787 words - 4 pages contractors and employees are not the same. The characteristics of each affect the manner in which a variety of taxes are withheld and the legal consequences that may arise. Each employee will have a set amount of social security, medicare, federal, and states taxes withheld from his or her pay. This paper will distinctively explain the difference between employees and independent contractors and how employment-at-will exceptions can protect

Employment-at-Will Essay

1659 words - 7 pages Employment-at-Will Doctrine Professor: May 1, 2014 Assignment # 1 Employment-at-Will Summary of the Employment-at-Will Doctrine The concept of At-will means that an employer can terminate an employee because of any reason but the illegal dismissals does not come under this category. Similarly, the employee will also have a choice to leave the job at any time with or without any reason. There would not be any adverse legal consequence


1154 words - 5 pages Employment-At-Will Doctrine By Carla Anderson Professor Shaun Koenig Law, Ethics, and Corporate Governance November 9, 2014 Employment-At-Will is a legal doctrine which gives employers broad discretion to fire employees for a good reason, a bad reason, or no reason at all (Halbert, & Ingulli, 2012). With employment-at-will, an employer has the right to change its policies or terms of employment without notice. Therefore, benefits

Employment At Will Doctrine

2273 words - 10 pages employer vs. employee situation, will contain a list of steps to address the situation. Considering the following informative legal outcomes to the Employment-at-Will such as: the firms allowance legally in firing the employee based on the employment-at-will doctrine; the legal implications for the employer vs. the employee in the particular situation at hand; preventative measures that the employer should have or put into place in order to

Employment at Will

1405 words - 6 pages the liability and termination decision. Out of these situations, there are some with a clearer cut answer and some that have a little more depth to them. There are three main exceptions to the employment-at-will doctrine that protects the employees and in which they can pursue legal action if terminated. The three exceptions are: discrimination, a well-established public policy already in in place, and an implied contract. This means that


1499 words - 6 pages completing the required tasks. Based on the employment at –will doctrine, in United State including Virginia State, the firm is legally allowed to terminate her employment. Even if they specified that an employee would only be terminated “for not doing their job successfully” (NCSL Home, 2012), they would still have legal right. Documentation is very important when an employee is not performing their job functions as agreed upon. The

Employment at Will

2866 words - 12 pages under certain circumstances. As such, employees who are wrongfully discharged may bring legal action against their employer based on violations of employment contract or statutory law. These state and federal statutes collectively are known as the exceptions to the employment at will doctrine that the courts adopted because of the harsh effects on employees. Public-policy exception According to Sentell & Robbins (2008), under the public

Employment at Will - 1879 words

1879 words - 8 pages Employment-At-Will Doctrine Student: Professor: Sliben Dorothy LEG500: Law, Ethics & Corp. Governance Describe what steps you would take to address the following scenario involving skills, competence, and abilities: see appendix A The steps I would take to address the following scenario involving skills, competence, and abilities are: Arranging/scheduling a separate meeting with the supervisor and the employee. Motivate both

Employment at Will - 1167 words

1167 words - 5 pages Employment-at-will “gives employers broad discretion to fire employees ‘for a good reason, a bad reason, or no reason at all,’” (Halbert, J.D. & Ingulli, J.D., L.L.M., 2007, p. 31). Employees of the Loomis Armored Inc., found this out the hard way. This paper will discuss the Gardner v Loomis Armored Inc. case. Do you think an employer goes against public policy when it terminates an at-will employee who violated a company rule in order to go

Consideration for Ethics and Diversity Proposal Choose One or Two Ethical Considerations and One or Two Diversity Considerations on a Company You Will Research or Your Present Place of Employment....

974 words - 4 pages employment laws and regulations and the benefits of a diverse workforce. Importantly, the training program helps reteach the managers how to recruit, hire, train, and promote based on qualifications and not strictly appearance or age. Each manager will receive the initial two-hour training and then attend an annual diversity-training refresher, thereafter. The second step is to redesign the hiring processes. Currently, the restaurant accepts both

Analysis of Three Cbi/Nus Employability Attributes, Why They’re Relevant to the Tourism Sector, Opportunities for Developing Them at University and How They Will Maximise Potential for Future...

1434 words - 6 pages -operate. Also, university is a perfect team working builder before employment as much of the same qualities are needed during university and during work, bonding with others, accepting their differences and becoming a team player as well as a leader to flourish at university and impress a future employer. (CBI, 2011) The second attribute up for analysis is business and customer awareness which is defined as an ability to understand effectively

Related Papers

Employment At Will Essay 1859 Words

1859 words - 8 pages Employment-At-Will Doctrine Strayer University Professor LEG 500 Law, Ethics, and Corporate Governance The Employment-At-Will doctrine continues to be favored by employers and employees in various forms thru out numerous types of companies. The doctrine gives employers and employees the right to terminate terms of their employment “for a good reason, a bad reason, or no reason at all” (Halbert Ingulli, 2012, page 46). There are some

Employment At Will Essay 1431 Words

1431 words - 6 pages Employment-At-Will Doctrine Daryl C. Fingers Professor Anne Dewey-Balzhiser Law, Ethics & Corp. Governance-Legal 500 November 1, 2013 Introduction Employment at will doctrine states employers can terminate an employee for good cause, for bad cause, or cause morally wrong without fear of legal recourse (Halbert, Ingulli, 2012). Every state in the country operates under this law but with exceptions and that’s where the waters get

Employment At Will Essay 2283 Words

2283 words - 10 pages Employment-AT-Will Doctrine LEG 500 – Law, Ethics, and Corporate Government January 29, 2014 What is employment-at-will and whistleblower policy? This paper will provide a better understand of what these policy is and how each could apply to the relationship of employer-employee in the work force. The employment-at-will doctrine avows that, when an employee does not have a written employment contract and the term of employment is of

Employment At Will Essay 2440 Words

2440 words - 10 pages 1) YOUR EMPLOYMENT RELATIONSHIP To know whether your discharge was legal, start with what kind of employment relationship you and your employer had. Highest employees are in at-will employment relationships; union workers have collective bargaining agreements; and public employees may be covered by state laws, local laws, or regulations. To evaluate your employment relationship, you should look at the following materials: (1) any letters that