Ethic Case Study

1326 words - 6 pages


Ethic Case Study

BSB111 Business Law and Ethics

Naufal Budi


Word Count: 1220

Part A
1. Shop: The fruit and vegetable shop that is operated by Samantha is one of the major stakeholders in the business. Beth has been stealing food from the shop and there is a risk that can jeopardise the shop because it is already struggling to keep up.
2. Nathan: If Nathan doesn’t tell Samantha about Beth, there is a chance that Samantha will know about this in the future and if Samantha identified that Nathan knows about Beth he can be in a great risk of being fired. On the other hand, if Nathan does tell Samantha ...view middle of the document...

According to Low (2014, p. 389) “by following a maxim it becomes a universal law”. According to universal acceptability it can be define that the employees that are working in Samantha’s shop can take any goods or products from the shop just for their own benefits without paying or informing their owner. Should the employees tend to have this behaviour continuously, the economy and the customers of the shop would be greatly impacted and the employees would be blamed for illegal or if not unethical behaviour. Thus, according to the universal acceptability the maxim would be a failure and would be impermissible.
The next step of the categorical imperative is to apply the “respect” formulation. It is surely unethical for Nathan to not tell about the situation to his boss. It would be disrespectful if the employee’s behaviour is to take the products from the business without informing the boss beforehand. In this regard, it is believed that Beth is not respecting her boss despite having other circumstances.
Virtue Ethics
According to Fisher & Lovell (2013, p. 104). “Virtue ethics ensures that the individual is likely to make the right choice in any ethically complex situation.” It is identified that the appropriate virtue for this situation according to the table of Aristotle’s Moral virtues is ‘Self-control’ (Fished & Lovell, 2013, p, 105). Beth has been stealing foods from Samantha’s shop therefore this makes Beth deficient concerning to this matter.
Self-control is defined between two vices, which are indifference and greed (Fisher & Lovell, 2013, p. 105). Beth has stolen foods from Samantha just for her daughter benefits which make the vice excess to be ‘greed’. Thus this makes it unethical for Nathan to not tell that Beth has been stealing foods from the shop to Samantha.
Recommendations to Resolve Ethical Dilemma
It is in your own characteristics that you should decide. On this situation, it is hard to decide just solely on your perspective because no matter what happens there will be major consequences that will impact your life in the future from this situation. Regarding just solely based on Virtue and Kantian ethics alone, it is recommended for you to tell Samantha about the situation because it has the least consequences and more rewarding point of view. At this point of time, your duties are to work under your supervisor/manager which is Samantha. It is for you to comply with your duty and obligation to obey her because you are working under her. Obeying to your supervisor/manager may have negative consequences to your subordinates such as Beth but you are ethically required to comply with your supervisor.
On the other hand, utilitarianism can be applied in this case if you have a strong relationship with Beth. In other words, if you are close friends with her and should you break this relationship it will hurt you at the...

Other Essays Like Ethic Case Study

Ethic Issues Essay

579 words - 3 pages Jordan Gentry Brother Fisher ECEN 398R October 30, 2015 Henry’s Daughters: Ethic Issues 1.  Prioritize the examples of ethical issues you found from most critical to least critical.  Include some explanation to justify your choices. There were a wide range of ethical issues that were brought out in this video clip. Many of them I didn’t recognize nor don’t remember but I did see a few examples of sexual harassment, decisions based on

Business Ethic Essay

3035 words - 13 pages moral comprehensive understanding of the problem, and then to carry on the analysis. Making companies in the society, the government, and people’s hearts set up a better image, which is beneficial to the development of the company and have more income. Hope this report from every Angle analysis Toyota company pedal events, brake event. Let the Toyota Company remember the lesson. And effectively solve it. 1.0What is business ethic? Have a lot

Ethic in Organisation

822 words - 4 pages Business Ethics: What happens when business operates without ethics In Ethics, The Heart of Leadership, Al Gini argues that ethics are an integral part of business. He employs multiple arguments to back up his claim. One such argument is that “work is how we spend our lives, and the lessons we learn there, good or bad, play a part in the development of our moral perspective and the manner in which we formulate and adjudicate ethical choices” (p

Ethic and Marality

758 words - 4 pages Hector Padilla Prof. Amar Almasude ENG 240 Essay on Ethics & Morality There are a lot of situation in which ethical perspectives are in difference to another person's opinion on a similar subject matter. Ethics is a theory used to make moral decisions. It does not rely on religion, society or culture; it only depends on the individuals themselves (Merriam-Webter, 1981). Each person has established themselves looking over his/her asking

A New Work Ethic

917 words - 4 pages after 90 percent of those who worked for me. I am no longer a restaurant manager due to the lack of respect and lack of urgency as well as work ethic in the food service industry. A recent experience in a retail store was tow employees engaged in a conversation. My wife and I approached and the employee started to grab my items and begin to check me out. I had a question for the employee, so I hadn’t taken my hands off of the merchandise and

Philosophy on Ethic

994 words - 4 pages The central question in this philosophy curse is to define what the good life is. So how I will know whether or not I have lived a good life? Both Plato and Aristotle said that the good life is total virtue. Plato reasons that a person will exhibit total virtue when his desires have been extinguished, while Aristotle believes the perfection will bring forth the virtue in men. Both Plato and Aristotle agree that education is the means to learn

Humanity and Ethic Worksheet

1024 words - 5 pages their lives and the support system of a village; mother, father, grandparents, teachers, friends and prayers. Jesus is the answer to all our problems. Parents need to take their children to church, bible study, Sunday school. There they will receive a foundation in Christ. They will learn if there is not anyone else there to turn to Jesus will always be there. Children need to know that they are loved not only by their family but God also. References Grose, T (2013): The Psychological of Mass Shootings

How Personal Can Ethic Get

1725 words - 7 pages that management could handle the situation without further intervention from me. Knowing that top management is committed to the ethical behavior of all employees and managers is enough for me to know that I would be doing the right thing in this situation. SUMMARY To conclude, this case study is one that many people face on a daily basis. Valerie’s case is on that requires her to look within herself to make sure that her own moral fiber does

The Rowe Approach to Work Ethic

1181 words - 5 pages Written Assignment #2 Daniel Rossey MGMT 417 Human Resources Management Potomac College July 25, 2013 Instructor Michael Donovan Abstract In this paper I will talk about how ROWE approach to work ethic works at some places and not at others. I will also discuss why it doesn’t work for some industries. I will touch on the fact that it might not work as well for retail employees as it does for managers. The second half of this

Importance of Adapting Corporate Culture and Ethic in Indonesia for the Multinational Companies

2237 words - 9 pages Fade Achnaf (25364561) Assignment 1 International marketing Importance of Adapting Corporate Culture and Ethic in Indonesia for The Multinational Companies Culture is a subjective matters because it is unique for every person, Fatehi (2008) state that culture are people’s system of knowledge and standard of perceive , behave and act. Culture keep evolving and getting bigger from time to time. Corporate culture impact behavior of employee

The Army Profession and the American Culture

1301 words - 6 pages Profession and Ethic (CAPE) located at West Point, New York (Center for the Army, n.d.). CAPE is the think tank that creates and posts videos, recommended books, study cases for group discussions, interactive movies, posters, press releases, broachers, and publishes quarterly information papers to teach soldiers about the fundamentals of the Army Profession. The Army Profession is the Soldiers Creed, NCO Creed, Army Values, Warrior Ethos, and another

Related Papers

Business Ethic Essay

1440 words - 6 pages 1. Identify the nuggets from the two-day sessions of Business Ethics class and explain how would you apply those nuggets in your work place. ANSWER: Nuggets from the lecture Ethics defined as the study of right or wrong and as broadly as the general inquiry into what is good. Ethics examines the right or wrong within the context of moral duty. Business ethics is a form of applied ethic in business activity that examines ethical principle

A New Work Ethic Essay

809 words - 4 pages A New Work Ethic 1 Running head: A NEW WORK ETHIC A New Work Ethic Business Ethics January 24, 2011 A New Work Ethic 2 As I read the case study “A New Work Ethic,” I began to noticed strong similarities of my own experiences and the work environment explored by the human resource manager James Sheehy. What he had uncovered happened to be very shocking. He described this new generation of workers as

Ethic Case Byp1 6 Essay

1111 words - 5 pages Wiley Plus: Ethical Case - BYP1-6 Marjorie Williams ACC/349 January 11. 2016 Leonard Glendale Wiley Plus: Ethical Case - BYP1-6 | | In the Wiley Plus, BYP1-6, the following ethical case is displayed: “Wayne Terrago, the controller for Robbin Industries, was reviewing production cost reports for the year. One amount in these reports continued to bother him—advertising. During the year, the company had instituted

Ethic Groups Essay

938 words - 4 pages Ethnic groups in the population of interest: Wenzhounese: Over the last decade, newer Chinese immigrants to France have largely originated from Northeast China (Dongbei). Their population as of 2010 was about 15,000. Women largely outnumber men among this Chinese community and often leave China for France in hopes of establishing new lives Dongbei: Over the last decade, newer Chinese immigrants to France have largely originated fromÂ