Ethical Case For Reinstating The Draft

2893 words - 12 pages

Our first President eloquently stated the rationale for national service:
"... it must be laid down as a primary position and the basis of our (democratic) system, that every citizen who enjoys the protection of a free Government owes not only a proportion of his property, but even his personal service to the defense of it.”

George Washington’s statement makes explicit the social contract inherent in US citizenry: to enjoy our nation’s freedoms requires we as citizen’s to bear personal responsibility for defending them. And yet, today, while our nation continues to fight war on several fronts and must regularly contemplate new military interventions and increased domestic ...view middle of the document...

" --Thomas Paine: The American Crisis, No. 4,1777
Many countries in the world have compulsory service. Such democratic countries as Austria, Brazil, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Israel, Mexico, Norway, Russia, South Korea, Sweden, Switzerland and Turkey are among them. Compulsory military service is normally for 18-year-olds, and lasts between 1 and 3 years.

And there are usually many types of service that can be performed, ranging from combat roles to intelligence and logistic work. Different genders are frequently given different responsibilities. In Israel, for example, males usually perform 3 years of combat/security service, while females perform two years of non-combat service. Many nations grapple with the question of mandatory military service, including the United States. Proponents believe it increases the strength of the military, strengthens the character of youth, and increases the collective conscience of a nation and the restraint of leaders when considering military action. Opponents consider it an affront to individual liberties, a risk in breeding militarism and the dominance of the state, and simply unnecessary when voluntary armies can be sufficient. These and other pros and cons and quotations are documented below.
Compulsory national service is not a new concept; it is rooted in government policies of the late 1700s. A draft changes the nature of national service because only a sub-set of citizens must serve.

At two key points in American history, the draft was highly divisive and resulted in massive protests: the Civil War and Vietnam. President Nixon and Congress abolished the draft in 1973.

Reinstituting the draft would require an act of Congress

Political and moral motives[edit]

Further information: Social contract, Social solidarity, and Active citizenship
Jean Jacques Rousseau argued vehemently against professional armies, feeling it was the right and privilege of every citizen to participate to the defense of the whole society and a mark of moral decline to leave this business to professionals. He based this view on the development of the Roman republic, which came to an end at the same time as the Roman army changed from a conscript to professional force.[124] Similarly, Aristotle linked the division of armed service among the populace intimately with the political order of the state.[125] Niccolò Machiavelli argued strongly for conscription, seeing the professional armies as the cause of the failure of societal unity in Italy.
Other proponents, such as William James, consider both mandatory military and national service as ways of instilling maturity in young adults.[126] Some proponents, such as Jonathan Alter and Mickey Kaus, support a draft in order to reinforce social equality, create social consciousness, break down class divisions and for young adults to immerse themselves in public enterprise.[127][128][129]
1.  
2. Jump up ^ Rousseau, J-J. Social Contract. Chapter...

Other Essays Like Ethical Case for Reinstating the Draft

Ethical Medical Case Study Call the Wife? or Not to Call the Wife?

1307 words - 6 pages Ethical Medical Case Study Call the wife? Or not to call the wife? Mr. Cooper is 53 years old. He has his own business and works a lot. He enjoys the work and has become quite successful. He’s been smoking, on and off, for more than 20 years. He realizes it’s a bad habit and understands the damage it can do but he hasn’t been able to quit. Recently, he has become fatigued easily and sometimes has chest pains when he’s got a lot on his

Which Chinese ethical system would be best for the United States?

335 words - 2 pages China's isolated culture caused it to form many unique ethical systems. Three of the most popular are Confucianism, Daoism, and Legalism. Each has its own concepts and values on how to keep order throughout the dynasty. In America today only one of these ethical systems would keep peace and order and that system is Legalism.There are many reasons why Legalism would be the best Chinese ethical system for the United States. First, Legalism is the

“Using the Case Study at the End of the Module Assess the Client’s Issues and Describe Your Treatment Plan. What Ethical Issues Might Arise?”

2381 words - 10 pages come automatically and are not painful (Hadley and Straudacher 1996). This would in turn lead to a better life or weight loss in order to maintain a healthy weight and lifestyle. In view of this, this essay will assess Miss E’s issues as presented in the case study. I will describe a treatment plan with an attached initial screed and any ethical issues that may arise. Hypnotherapy is a popular therapy for weight loss. (Chrysalis 2010

A Study on the Interpretation of an Article Entitled“Case Studies of Ethics Scandals: Effects on Ethical Perceptions of Finance Studies”

4305 words - 18 pages that teach what you should do. Instead, they need to embrace feedback from colleagues and advisors in order to understand the values inside you that would determine what you would do in a sticky situation." That's why my colleague, Dr. Carol Orsborn, co-author of "Trust Inc.," developed our Values Based Leadership Workshop for PR professionals to include role-playing scenarios based on common ethical dilemmas arising from workplace case

Long-Chain Polyunsaturated Fatty Acids: the Case for and Against the Supplementation of Infant Formula

1176 words - 5 pages LONG-CHAIN POLYUNSATURATED FATTY ACIDS: THE CASE FOR AND AGAINST THE SUPPLEMENTATION OF INFANT FORMULA The following paper investigates the role of long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids (LCPUFAs) and its effects on infants to determine whether or not there is beneficial to supplement LCPUFAs in infant products. A brief introduction to the topic is provided and the key concepts defined, after which thorough analysis of a variety of studies is

Voip.Biz, Inc. Deciding on the Next Steps for a Voip Supplier Case Study

974 words - 4 pages VoIP.biz, Inc.: Deciding on the Next Steps For a VoIP Supplier Case Study VoIP.biz, Inc.: Deciding on the Next Steps For a VoIP Supplier Case Study VoIP.biz, Inc.: Deciding on the Next Steps For a VoIP Supplier Case Study Introduction Traditional telephone systems are a thing of the past. In today’s business world, VoIP or Voice Over Internet Protocol is the next generation of the future. There are many benefits of switching to VoIP systems

Ound, Spirituality and Healing for the Family Experiencing Terminal Cancer: a Case Study of the Application of Mantras

5851 words - 24 pages UNIVERSITY OF CALGARY FACULTY OF NURSING SPRING SESSION 2008 NURSING 607.57 ASSIGNMENT # 3 SCHOLARLY PAPER title: sound, spirituality and Healing for the family experiencing terminal cancer: a case study of the application of mantras Submitted by: Rosato, Mr. Giuseppe Date of Submission: July 18th, 2008 Submitted to: Dr. Carole-Lynne Le Navenec sound, spirituality and Healing for the family experiencing terminal cancer: a

An Evaluation On The Socio Economic Characteristics Of Solar Lighting Users To Determine The Market Segment For Solar Products As A Basis For Expansion: The Case Of Card Bdsfi Experience, Philippines

1897 words - 8 pages ). For the median, the raw data were arranged from smallest to highest and the middle was taken. In this case, number 24 is the median, which is 34. Mode is defined as the result having the most number of frequencies; in this case, the mode is 33. c. Marital Status Pictogram 2. Marital Status of Solar Users, December 2011 Masbate and Oriental Mindoro Single Married Widow Separated Each picture represents 2 persons Majority of those who are

“Using the Case Study Provided Develop a Treatment Plan for This Client. Justify Your Assessment and Proposed Actions in Terms of the Relationship Models and Concepts Introduced in the Module.”

3108 words - 13 pages incorporate the other person back into future sessions but the needs of one may out weigh the needs of the couple for a time, at least for diagnostic purposes. In the case of Mr. G we will see how an able bodied man was taken ill, and the journey that took him from being fit and healthy to wheelchair bound and lethargic causing him distress in his current relationship. Six years ago Mr G was diagnosed with a progressive neurological condition that has

Make a Case to the Ceo for or Against Investment in This New Operating System (as Opposed to Sticking with Your Current Operating System Platform) Clearly Argue Why You Would Recommend Installing This...

969 words - 4 pages Abstract Make a case to the CEO for or against investment in this new operating system (as opposed to sticking with your current operating system platform) clearly argue why you would recommend installing this new system or not? There are many questions that must be answered before you purchase a new operating system (OS). Foremost is the cost of the upgrade to the Vista OS. Will it make the company work more efficient, or improve

Smoke, Cough, & Die: The Case For A Federal Ban On Cigarettes

2441 words - 10 pages Smoking is something that millions of Americans do every day and companies profit millions of dollars every year through the sales of cigarettes, but at what cost? Five dollars a pack for a cancered lung and a heart attack. A deadly addiction comparable to heroin or cocaine, cigarettes are the only product that efficiently kills more than five million people year -- one million in the Americas-- and is still legal. The damage that it causes does

Related Papers

Ethical Issue Analysis For The Ethical Treatment Of Animals

880 words - 4 pages Ethical Treatment of Animals Amber Marie Keldie Soc120 Dr. Monica Jones. September 30th 2012 Ethical Issue Analysis for the Ethical Treatment of Animals Summary: Of all the agricultural land in the US, 87% is used to raise animals for food. These animals are fed more than 80 percent of the corn and 95 percent of the oats the US produces. Meat animals of the world alone consume food equal to caloric needs of 9 billion people- more than

The Case For Change Essay

1278 words - 6 pages The Case for Change at Modern Appliances | Employee Engagement at Modern Appliances Inc. | The Case for Change | | In order to build an increased spectrum of customer service, an internal strategy to modify Modern Appliances’ employee engagement was needed. Within an employee centered culture, employees are utilized for their overall value input for increased exposure and profit. This case study will focus on the methods and strategy

The Case For Reparation Essay

606 words - 3 pages Name: Huyen Bui Instructor: K.C Harrison Course: PSTL 1525W Date: 09/22/14 The Case for Reparation As I read the article “ The Case for Reparations” by Ta-Nehisi Coates, he writes about black people during 20th Century in America. He uses other people’s opinion to support his own argument. There’s some examples that show how Coates use of the “ They say/ I say” technique to respond his own argument, whether

The Case For Stealth Innovation Essay

625 words - 3 pages LIBRARY RESEARCH ASSIGNMENT Article review: The Case for Stealth Innovation – By Paddy Miller and Thomas Wedell-Wedellsborg AUGUST 22, 2015 VARUN SRIDHAR Library Research Assignment Varun Sridhar For organizations to survive and continue its constructive role, it needs ideas that are fresh and has got to have a new perspective to get new ideas based on field research and otherwise to ensure and understand the dynamics and