Ethical Issues Related To Fetal Tissue Research

1996 words - 8 pages

Ethical Issues Related to Fetal Tissue Research

The use of fetal tissue in biomedical research has been a hot topic for debate in social and political forums ever sense the landmark decision in the 1973 case of Roe vs. Wade (Beller & Weir 182). The decision of the Supreme Court to give women the right to abort a fetus without having a medical reason for doing so, sparked controversy which has affected any medical procedure or research dealing with fetuses (Bellar &Weir 182). Supporters of fetal tissue research believe it has too much potential to provide cures for many of the diseases and medical problems that plague today’s society for it to be halted. Opponents of this type ...view middle of the document...

During the late 60’s and early 70’s this research was viewed as a new and exciting field of medicine and many important medical advances were made. But after the ruling in Roe vs. Wade fetal tissue research was brought under the scrutiny of pro-life advocates, seeking to protect the rights of unborn children (Maynard-Moody 13). This development eventually led to a political movement that cut government funding for fetal tissue research and placed tight restrictions on the sell of fetal tissue and compensation for women who chose to donate fetuses to science after an abortion (Howell & Sale 458).

Pro-life advocates were able to muster strong political support by exposing some of the grotesque results of experiments that had taken place during the late 60’s and early 70’s (Maynard-Moody 15). In one of the experiments fetuses were decapitated and hooked to special equipment that monitored the effects of starvation on the brain of the fetus (Maynard-Moody 14). When experiments such as this one were exposed to the public, fetal tissue research became highly controversial. This political movement was made even stronger by the fact that until 1993, when Clinton took office, all of the presidents were considered to be pro-lifers (Steinbock 170). Previous presidents had placed tight restrictions on the research and cut government funding, President Bush even went so far as to place a ban on research involving the use of fetal tissue from abortions (an act which was rescinded by Clinton in 1993)(Steinbock 170-71).

Supporters of fetal tissue research believe not using the tissue is an immoral act because it denies medical treatment to patients who could benefit from it, and it wastes a valuable resource that could be put to practical use (O’Neil 149). “It is socially and morally reprehensible to destroy cadaver tissue which can be used towards perhaps saving millions of lives”(Steinbock 184). Many people believe that if the government bans fetal tissue research on moral grounds then it must be willing to step up and take responsibility for the millions of people who die from diseases such as Parkinson’s, diabetes, and Alzheimer’s every year. All of these people may have benefited from research conducted on fetal tissue (Steinbock 184). Advocates for research believe that even if one doesn’t approve of the practice of abortion, he or she should at least be willing to salvage some kind of good from the situation (Maynard-Moody 108).

Opponents of the use of aborted fetal tissue in research argue that allowing the tissue to be used will cause an erosion in the value placed on human life and will open the door to unspeakable atrocities. Many have compared the research conducted on fetuses to some of the experiments that German scientists conducted on prisoners in concentration camps during World War II (Stinbock 182). These people believe that this research is a slippery slope and once we start down its path, it will undoubtedly lead to evil.

Other Essays Like Ethical Issues Related to Fetal Tissue Research

Legal and Ethical Issues: Confidentiality, Privilege, Reporting and Duty to Warn

1366 words - 6 pages Legal and Ethical Issues: Confidentiality, Privilege, Reporting and Duty to Warn Liberty University Abstract Any persons working in the social work, counseling or any helping profession will be faced with different incidents where they will be dealing with confidentiality, privilege, reporting and duty to warn. The research done, will allow readers to have a first hand look at different hypothetical and even factual events that have

Discuss the Issues Related to Genetic Diversity: Mutations, Sexual Reproduction, Migration, and Population Size

858 words - 4 pages Title: What I see as the biggest challenges in young adults today. General Purpose: To investigate the challenges faced by the young adults in the society today.  Specific Purpose: To determine the link between parenting, economic crisis and societal vices and how they pose as a challenge to the young adults today.  Central idea: To investigate the issues faced by young adults today. Introduction: It is essential to realize that time frames

Consideration for Ethics and Diversity Proposal Choose One or Two Ethical Considerations and One or Two Diversity Considerations on a Company You Will Research or Your Present Place of Employment....

974 words - 4 pages A Business Proposal to Make Ethical and Diversity Considerations to Improve the Strategic HRM Planning Process. Prepared for Jane Doe HR Director ABC Restaurant & Pub Prepared by XXXXX Personnel Director ABC Restaurant & Pub December 24, 2012 ABC’s Restaurant & Pub Ethical and Diversity Considerations to Improve the Strategic HRM Planning Process. I have gathered information over the last five weeks about

Planned Parenthood: the Next Great Debate

1362 words - 6 pages perfect, there are still many good things about this bill. The sale of fetal tissue is a big issue within the abortion ‘community,’ so to speak, and is an issue that needs to addressed immediately. Often times, fetal tissue is sold in a professional and legal manner, and is eventually used in medical research. The terms in which fetal tissue has been sold by organizations such as Planned Parenthood have been agreed upon by the women who chose to

Stem Cell Research

3717 words - 15 pages announced that they had successfully cultured human stem cells. The first team, led by a Dr. John D. Gearhart of John Hopkins University, conducted experiments on human fetal tissue, and succeed in isolating and maintaining stem cells, which continued to divide and retain their unspecialized qualities (John D. Gearhart, 2010). Dr. James A. Thomson led the second team at the University of Wisconsin. Dr. Thomson started his research on primates in

Stem Cell Research

1332 words - 6 pages 2003 the National Institutes of Health budget for stem cell research increased $25 million (Kass). The only ban on stem cell research currently is for federal funding of destructive embryo research. This ban was also passed by Clinton, not Bush, but Bush does support it saying, “I oppose using federal funds to perform fetal tissue research from induced abortions”(Mainer).      In the past elections, more breakthroughs have been made. In


2287 words - 10 pages knowledge about congenital heart disease in the 1970’s, and in the 1980’s the transplantation of fetal tissue into adults to help with serious conditions like, diabetes or Parkinson’s (Gold, 2004). While there has always been concern and controversy over the use of human embryonic cells, today the debate is ethical. This ethical debate lies within the destruction of human embryos in order to use them for medical research. This paper will talk about how

Stem Cell Research

1514 words - 7 pages ago, yet this kind of stem cell thinking already provides new perspectives in medical science and could usher in new therapies. Today, political, religious, and ethical issues surround embryonic stem cell and patient-specific pluripotent stem cell research and are center stage in the attempts by governments to ban these fields for discovery and potential therapies. These interventions require physicians and physician-scientists to determine for

Stem Cells - 1

1035 words - 5 pages embryonic stem cell research may have the prospective to put an end to many diseases it still isn’t right to kill another potential human being in the process. At the same time we can still use other types of stem cells for procedures that don’t pose any ethical controversy that will have positive outcomes. This still allows for stem cell research to continue and procedures to occur without any ethical issues. Stem cell research can be very useful

Uterine What

2925 words - 12 pages repair a ureterocele? . Yvonne is faced with making a decision on behalf of her infant that would involve surgical treatment. There are inherent risks with surgery, regardless of age. Research the condition malignant hyperthermia, the most common cause of death related to general anesthesia. Case copyright © by the National Center for Case Study Teaching in Science. Originally published April ,  at Please see our usage guidelines, which outline our policy concerning permissible reproduction of this work. “Uretero What?” by Lorentzen & Kousa Page 

Utero What

2925 words - 12 pages abnormality. Although the procedure poses some risk—about one percent of miscarriages are related to the procedure—I would recommend it so that we can better understand the fetal anomaly.” Yvonne agrees to the amniocentesis, but is in utter shock. The words “genetic disorder,” “hydronephrosis,” and “fetal anomaly” echo in her head as she waits for Dr. Costa to finish the day’s patients and perform the procedure. Within an hour or so, it is

Related Papers

The Debate Over Fetal Tissue Research

2643 words - 11 pages research into a cure or treatment for AIDS. By transplanting fetal cells into mice without immune systems, human immune systems can be developed. These mice are then used as models to test new treatments. Ethical Issues From all of the previous information, it is obvious that the use of fetal tissue is beneficial. But many ethical and moral questions arise from those who question its humanity. Pro-life groups, those who are opposed to abortion

Ethical Issues Research Paper

2559 words - 11 pages Ethical Issues Research Paper Sherrill Jones AJS/532 Cristina Payne August 3, 2015 Ethical Issues Research Paper In the field of criminal justice, ethics is an integral part of the organization. The public relies on its police agencies to provide protection and maintain order in the community. It is also about a matter of trust the community places with its law enforcement agencies with regards to ethical behavior. This

Trends And Issues Related To Technology Integration

2823 words - 12 pages groups influence action. The importance of technology in learning should never be disregarded, and it should be available to all students. Trends And Issues Related To Technology Integration The use of computers in school classrooms has evolved throughout the years, and has become revolutionary in changing the way we teach and learn. Our classrooms should no longer be confined to four walls and a few teachers who are considered to be

Social, Cultural And Psychological Issues Related To The Ageing Population

2273 words - 10 pages significant issue. The older adult may experience slower processing speeds, memory loss and mental disorders such as depression. (Berk, 2009). These examples of mental deterioration are related to the process of aging and form the basis of the psychological issues linked with the increase in the aged population. PSYCHOLOGICAL ISSUES RELATED TO THE INCREASE IN THE AGED POPULATION With the increase in the aging population and the extended life