This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Ethical Perspectives Of Friedman, Drucker And Murphy

2412 words - 10 pages

The purpose of this week’s assignment was to read three peer reviewed/scholarly journals and compare and contrast each author’s ethical perspective. The articles were: What is Business Ethics by Peter F. Drucker, 1981, The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits by Milton Friedman, 1970 and The Relevance of Responsibility to Ethical Business Decisions by Patrick E. Murphy, 2010.

Ethical Perspectives of Friedman, Drucker and Murphy
Peter F. Drucker is known as the man who invented management. Drucker wrote many books on management and influenced the way business and industry thinks about management.
“Peter F. Drucker ...view middle of the document...

26) .
Casuistry is not or cannot be the solution to the business ethics dilemma. It cannot be the solution, as the business executive rationalizes why a certain action is unethical for other individuals, but not unethical for himself. Unfortunately, in today’s business society, this mindset is the norm and not the exception. Drucker dismisses casuistry due to extortion and how many societies use extortion to employ their older government employees and business executives who have been displaced due to age or younger, brighter, fresher employees taking their jobs.
“The Ethics of Prudence do not spell out what right behavior is. They assume that what is wrong behavior is clear enough-and if there is any doubt, it is questionable and to be avoided. Prudence makes it an ethical duty for the leader to exemplify the precepts of ethics in his own behavior” (Drucker, p.27).
Ethics of Prudence cannot be the answer to the business ethics dilemma. Who is to say
what is right behavior? Society informs us what the norm is, but since we are raised in different households by different parents, everybody’s idea of right behavior is not the same. If everybody had the same sense of right and wrong, there would be no need for the judicial system or prisons. Also, there would not be the discussion for business ethics. Drucker identifies the reason for ethics of prudence not being the absolute answer as business ethics denying authority and ethics of prudence takes for granted authority exists. At the end of his paper he states: “…it is a society that must stress the Ethics of Prudence and self-development” (p.36).
“Confucian ethics elegantly sidesteps the trap into which the Casuists fell; it is a universal ethics, in which the same rules and imperative of behavior hold for every individual. There is no social responsibility overriding individual conscience, no cost benefit calculation, no greater good or higher measure than the individual and his behavior, and altogether no casuistry. In the Confucian ethics, the rules are the same for all….” (Drucker, p.30).
Drucker subscribes to the Confucian ethics and does not foresee the need for a separate
business ethics apart from personal ethics. Drucker recommends the adoption of the five key concepts of Confucian ethics:
“-clear definition of the fundamental relationships;
-universal and general rules of conduct-that is, rules that are binding on any one person
or organization, according to its rules, function, and relationships;
-focus on right behavior rather than on avoiding wrongdoing, and on behavior rather
than on motives or intentions; and finally,
-an effective organization ethic, indeed an organization ethic that deserves to be seriously considered as ethics, will have to define right behavior as the behavior which optimizes each party’s benefits and thus makes the relationship harmonious, constructive, and mutually...

Other Essays Like Ethical Perspectives Of Friedman, Drucker And Murphy

The Legal and Ethical Dilemma of Physician Assisted Suicide

3512 words - 15 pages The Legal and Ethical Dilemma of Physician Assisted Suicide: An Analysis: People v Kevorkian Angelia Prince Shorter University The Legal and Ethical Dilemma of Physician Assisted Suicide: An Analysis: People v Kevorkian This research was aimed at providing an analysis of the ethical and legal dilemma surrounding physician assisted suicides. The subject of physician-assisted suicide has raised many thought provoking and

Legal and Ethical Issues of a Medical Error Case

1063 words - 5 pages Legal and Ethical Issues of a Medical Error Case In the case study "Understanding the Causes and Costs of Medication Errors”, a Denver hospital acknowledged that a medication error had led to the death of a day-old infant, born in 1996 to a mother with a prior history of syphilis. Because the patient’s parents spoke only Spanish, communication was difficult. This factor, coupled with the fact that the hospitals’ physicians, nurses, and

Ethical and Legal Issues of Physician-Assisted Suicide

1235 words - 5 pages , the proponents argue that individual conviction and the right to end one’s life is more important than looking for the objective truth. Ethical Considerations Most of the controversy surrounding PAS exists because there are two conflicting viewpoints that depend on the ethics used to interpret the act of assisted suicide. On one hand, it is possible to prohibit PAS, and that approach to solving the issue would adhere to deontological ethics

Legal And Ethical Analysis Of Pat Parker & Associates

2517 words - 11 pages the author, and therefore, the copyright holder.Since Pat Parker was not an employee of the Dale Jackson for Attorney General Campaign, the law would require there be a specific agreement between the two parties stating specifically that the work was a WFH. And since the evidence showed that no such agreement existed, therefore Pat Parker can legally sell the Terry Pain research paper to the Trial Lawyers.ETHICAL CASE ANALYSISI. ISSUESThe ethical

"An Interdisciplinary Approach To The Study Of The Life Of Siddhartha Gautama, Focusing On His Moral And Ethical Context In Terms Of Actions, Influence And Response"

1532 words - 7 pages To obtain a clearer statement of the significant issues that fashioned the moral and ethical values of the Buddha, the responder has to enquire beyond the spiritual context, and examine the historical. In this sense, the historian should not dismiss myth and legend as "historically implausible" due to the fact that the ethical values of these texts emphasize the motivational forces behind the actions of the figure. In the case of Siddhartha

“Using the Case Study at the End of the Module Assess the Client’s Issues and Describe Your Treatment Plan. What Ethical Issues Might Arise?”

2381 words - 10 pages come automatically and are not painful (Hadley and Straudacher 1996). This would in turn lead to a better life or weight loss in order to maintain a healthy weight and lifestyle. In view of this, this essay will assess Miss E’s issues as presented in the case study. I will describe a treatment plan with an attached initial screed and any ethical issues that may arise. Hypnotherapy is a popular therapy for weight loss. (Chrysalis 2010

Legal and Ethical Implications of Classroom Management

1308 words - 6 pages Fabulous First Grade Case Study: Thinking Outside The Box to Manage Disruptions Mary Gajnos First Grade Teacher Keller Elementary Green Bay, Wisconsin December 10, 2013 This is a case study of one of my first graders who began the year with what one would call quite a reputation for disrupting the class. In this study I will try to show how I had to reflect, change, and implement other strategies/methods in order for him to coexist in

The Different Perspectives Of Being Caught In Ovid’S Myth: Diana And Actaeon

966 words - 4 pages In Ovid’s Metamorphoses the myth of “Diana and Actaeon” is written using descriptive diction and symbolism. The symbolism creates ambiguity leading to many possible interpretations of the myth. One symbolic line is that shows the fear expressed by Actaeon and Diana is: “so deeply blushed Diana, caught unclothed” (Ovid, III, 188). Both Diana and Actaeon become caught figuratively and literally in the myth. Caught prey reacts instinctively and

Consideration for Ethics and Diversity Proposal Choose One or Two Ethical Considerations and One or Two Diversity Considerations on a Company You Will Research or Your Present Place of Employment....

974 words - 4 pages appeals to a diverse customer base. Broadening customer base often brings more revenue. Variety of Viewpoints: A more diverse workforce brings more diverse ideas and experiences to the table. Diverse ideas can lead to an increase in creativity, innovation, and productivity. Ethical Consideration Currently, we are a company with a high-turnover rate, in an industry with a high-turnover rate. Over time application of our promotion policies

“What Is "Business Ethics"?” Peter F. Drucker

2335 words - 10 pages those behaviors that optimizes the benefits for each party. In other words, take a look in the mirror and you should see a person you respect and the person you want to be every day. “The Relevance of Responsibility to Ethical Business Decisions” Patrick E. Murphy This article focuses on responsibility as a fundamental principle of business ethics. Responsibility is being in a position of being accountable to someone or to something. With

Business Ethics - an Oxymoron

954 words - 4 pages or unreasonable demands on others, etc. Is “ethical leadership” an oxymoron? I believe that "ethics" should be a part of all management courses. Yes, there are grey areas depending on different perspectives, but there are also areas of "black" and "white". There is more to ethics than drafting and implementing codes of ethics for others to observe. Leaders should lead by example and refrain from adopting an approach which conflicts with

Related Papers

Ethical And Legal Environment Of Organizations

2246 words - 9 pages Loria Young Ethical and Legal Environment of Organizations (MOD 45) Abstract This paper will depict a discussion on the case studies found in week one of Ethical and Legal Environment. The information found in week one is a combination of how we look at business ethics, systems of ethical reasoning, and our goals of values in management. Ethical decision making in the business environment plays an important role in our everyday work

Timeliness And Ethical Aspects Of Va Claims

801 words - 4 pages Timeliness and Ethical Aspects of VA Claims Introduction This is a necessary and important resource offered to the veterans, (VA hospital care, monetary compensation monthly, and educational benefits) who serve our country, but at the same time, a service that gets widely abused and millions of dollars of fraud, waste and abuse is happening. The establishment of the Veterans Administration came in 1930 when Congress authorized the

Examine Religious And Secular Perspectives On The Nature Of Human Life

1176 words - 5 pages this universe. Also human beings can live ethical and fulfilling lives without religious beliefs and instead human beings derive their moral code from the lessons of history, personal experience, and thought, this view gives us much more independence. Aristotle said that “man is by nature a political animal” and he denied that “Forms” could be separated in a higher realm of being, and located them in the world, rather than alongside it

Information Technology And The Rise Of Ethical Issues

720 words - 3 pages Information Technology and the Rise of Ethical Issues The purpose of this research is to identify what are the advances in information technology that resulted in new ethical issues necessitating the creation of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), 1991, and the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA), 1998. To start examining the ethical issues of each act it was necessary to understand the meaning of the act and who the act