This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

European Union Institutions Essay

1577 words - 7 pages

‘In theory, the European Commission represents the EU interest, the European Parliament acts as the voice of the people of the EU, and the Council represents the interests of national governments. The reality is quite different.’
Discuss.​

The elementary organizing principles of the European Union have been the representation of different interests and the balance of power between the EU institutions and those particular interests. Emphasized in Monnet’s vision, one of the key tasks of the European project was ‘…to ensure that in their limited field these new institutions were both thoroughly democratic and accountable’. Yet, it is often questionable as to whether this task has been ...view middle of the document...

Arndt Wonka has cast considerable doubt on this process by demonstrating the influence of the appointment procedure, and the power it places in national governments’ and ruling parties’ hands, on Commissioners’ policy preferences. Indeed, it is difficult to see in practical terms how the Commission can be expected to be different from the Council of Ministers: members of both institutions are chosen ultimately by the leaders of their national governments. Moreover, if one government reject the others nominee, it is this government’s right to nominate another candidate. (Yet, in many cases, this rejection will most likely be avoided by other member state – so as to not become the target of such rejection too).


Furthermore, a rational-actor view of the Commission would tend to be suspicious of claims that the Commissioner’s collegial atmosphere allows the institution to assume a life and agenda of its own (and by so represent the interest of the EU), at odds with national governments; this is a particularly valid critique in light of the expansion of the Union, and the move towards a more deliberative and Parliamentarian atmosphere within the Commission. The expansion also opens up the possibility of self-interested national bargaining: it would be folly for a Commissioner from a landlocked country to support proposals on fishing without using their leverage to push for their national agenda at the same time; especially when we consider Wonka’s case for “conceptualizing Commissioners as political rather than technocratic actors.” It is thus doubtful whether the Commission can claim to represent the EU interests by virtue of its “independence” from national self-interest.

Empirically, it is also difficult to find evidence of the Commission’s legitimacy as a true representative of the EU interest. The decline in “popular acceptance of EU governance” can be attributed to recent events vividly traced by Mehde and most viscerally captured by the resignation of the Santer Commission. Further, Tsakatika’s prediction that “enlargement…[would] bring about a further drop in legitimacy” has been vindicated by the strength of Euroskepticism in Poland and the Czech Republic. The rejection of the Constitutional Treaty in 2005 also provided a clear reminder of public suspicion of the legitimacy of the integration project and its institutions. This wears particularly badly on the Commission, which is noted by Chalmers to be susceptible to perception as “a single body with the single idea of promoting European integration.”

A further critique concerns the role of the European Parliament. It is predominantly held that the Parliament represents the voice of the European People. This representation is (questionably) achieved when EU citizens directly elect the Members of the European Parliament (MEP), to stand (as members of national political parties) in seven Europe-wide political groups. Between them, they ought to represent all views on European...

Other Essays Like European Union Institutions

European Union Essay

702 words - 3 pages aim to remove trade barriers between them and form a common market, In1967 The institutions of the three European communities are merged, creating a single commission, a single council of ministers and a European parliament, In 1979 The first direct elections for the European parliament are held, allowing citizens to vote for candidates. In 1993 The Treaty of Maastricht creates the European Union, paving the way for monetary union. In 2002 a

What Is the Real Global Crisis We Face?

903 words - 4 pages is the euro predicament. European leaders must deal with the currency crisis effectively in order to restore faith in the currency and financial markets. If European governments and institutions cannot reach an expeditious agreement on how to prevent the collapse of the euro, a second recession is almost certainly a guarantee. Both the governance structure of the economic union and immediate measures to protect the most vulnerable members of the

The European Union

2426 words - 10 pages Pilato 9The Necessity of a Constitution in the European Union[Abstract: Does the European Union need a Constitution? This paper explores the imperative need for the implementation of a Constitution in the European Union.]Patrick PilatoPoli 211March 14V00811579IntroductionThe concept of adding a Constitution to the European Union and advancing the process of integration has been contemplated for many decades. The European Union is a very large

The European Integration of the Republic of Moldova

5938 words - 24 pages highest purposes of these institutions. The first meeting of the EU-Moldova Cooperation Committee took place on 14 July 1998 and then continued to take place on an annual basis for the evaluation of progress on the implementation of the agreement and for the identification of areas that require the special attention of the both parties or additional assistance from the European Union. Disregarding some problems and delays, the experience of the

Discuss The Expansion Of The European Union Into Eastern Europe And Its Implications For British Companies

2136 words - 9 pages Treaty renamed the European Community the European Union by forming what are known as the three pillars of the EU. They are: European Community, Common Foreign and Security Policy Justice and Home Affairs. (Steven P. M, 2001, The European Union A Critical Guide. 1st published, London: Pluto Press, p.3-5). Joseph (1995) indicates that the first pillar is managed by the institutions of the EU, while the second and third work through inter

An Alysis of the Case "Omega Spielhallen V Bonn"

946 words - 4 pages An analysis of the Omega Spielhallen v Bonn case Omega Spielhallen v Bonn was a case which was presented before the European Court of Justice (ECJ) and which involved a German firm and German authorities. This case constitutes a good illustration of how European law works and of the interaction between State Courts and European institutions. Also, it was a case of prime importance for Human Rights in the Community since the ECJ ruled that

Has the Vision of Jean Monnet Been Realized. Critically Discuss This Statement

2493 words - 10 pages doing so gaining an understanding of his vision, his motivation, his design for change, and how he set about implementing this plan. Lastly we will look at how Europe has changed since 1945, examining the European Union to see if his dream has been achieved. Jean was born in Cognac in 1888, to family of wealthy cognac merchants. His mother was a devout Catholic and his father radical socialist, Jean acquiring many liberal and anticlerical

International Expansion

2274 words - 10 pages everything to start running the business. However, by acquiring an already existing firm, tedious procedures such as brand building, hiring, advertisements and other activities are easily dealt with. I am in support of the idea of acquisition of firms in the European Union. This is due to a number of reasons. One, the different 28 countries have a distinct political and economic partnerships. These partnerships cover almost the entire European

Role of Social Dialogue in Employment Policies of Eu

3366 words - 14 pages Dialogue and the Europeanisation of Trade Unions in the 1990s. Oslo. ARENA. Eberlein, B. K (2002). Theorising the New Modes of European Union Governance, in. Enderlein, H. (2006). Adjusting to EMU. The Impact of Supranational Monetary Policy on Domestic Fiscal and Wage-Setting institutions, in. European Union Politics 7, 113-140. Falkner, G(1998).EU Social Policy in the 1990s. Towards a Corporatist Policy Community, Routledge Research in European

Integration of Muslims in the European Society

2031 words - 9 pages Professor Arroyo European Politics Final Paper 8 May 2013 Integration of Muslims in the European Society One of the most pressing issues facing the European Union and its member states today is how to handle the integration of Muslims into European society. From the time waves of Muslim immigrants were brought to Europe in the 1950’s to perform low-skill labor, the place of the Muslim community within Europe has been hotly contested. Each

Uk Trade Union in 21 Century

4656 words - 19 pages form 0f national institutions and outside trade union officials are not welcomed. Guest and Hoque (1995) attempted to explain why organisations with totally different characteristics and philosophies took a non-union route. They characterise employers as good, bad, ugly and lucky. (a) Good employers are characterised as large companies which are dominant in their sector. They have clear HR strategies, reward packages paying above market rates

Related Papers

The European Union Essay

1255 words - 6 pages and make it easier for international work. Financial Tools and Institutions The primary financial institution of the European Union is the European Centralized Bank. “In accordance with Regulation ECB/2008/32 of 19 December 2008 concerning the balance sheet of the monetary financial institutions sector, the ECB maintains and regularly updates a list of Monetary Financial Institutions” (European Centralized Bank, n.d., para. 7). This list

Differentiation In The European Union Integration Process

2214 words - 9 pages , which is “to continue the process of creating an ever closer union among the peoples of Europe”15 is still the commonly pursued goal of the member states and the institutions of the EU, as it has been written into the treaties and repeatedly interpreted by the European Court of Justice.16 Differentiation in the European Union has become natural to the integration process. Although it is not without the risk of compromising the founding

European Union Essay

834 words - 4 pages join the European Union (EU). Europe’s single currency the euro is officially launched in 1999 and 11 EU Member States adopt it as their official currency, forming what is known as the euro zone. Greece joins the euro zone in 2001. The Treaty of Nice is signed, introducing reforms to the EU’s institutions to prepare for the expansion of the Union with the admission of ten new Member States in 2004. In 2002, the euro becomes a reality on 1 January

Euro In Europe Essay

963 words - 4 pages European Union under its current name in 1993. The latest amendment to the constitutional basis of the EU, the Treaty of Lisbon, came into force in 2009. The EU operates through a system of supranational independent institutions and intergovernmental negotiated decisions by the member states. Important institutions of the EU include the European Commission, the Council of the European Union, the European Council, the Court of Justice of the