This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Euthanasia Essay Civil Remedies And Assisted Suicide

1932 words - 8 pages

Civil Remedies and Assisted Suicide

 
      This essay goes into the need for civil remedies to guard against assisted suicide actions by family, guardians, etc. Some states have already enacted such legislation, and others are in the process. This is a simple, safe legal procedure for protecting against the threat ot assisted suicide/euthanasia.

 

On May 2, 1994, a Michigan jury acquitted Jack Kevorkian of charges related to his publicly proclaimed assistance in the suicide of Thomas Hyde. The verdict points up the way in which the pathos of individual cases often leads criminal case juries to react emotionally, failing to give considerate attention to the general effects on ...view middle of the document...

"[2] Other studies confirm this conclusion, which in fact is not limited to circumstances of "terminal illness" or "compassion."[3]

 

While there have been a few successful criminal prosecutions of non-doctors, they have been extremely rare. A 1986 article in the Columbia Law Review concluded:

[A]ll indications are that assistance statutes are rarely, if ever, used. ... [D]espite the thousands of suicides each year, only about fifty news reports regarding some form of prosecution in the past decade for some type of assistance to suicide have been located. ... No post-1930 decision appears to exist in any state reporter of an appeal from a prosecution for the specific offense of assisting or causing a suicide. Surely, many more cases of suicide assistance are occurring than are prosecuted. . . Police and prosecutors appear to be reluctant to bring charges for suicide assistance. A British study found only one-sixth of all reported cases of suicide assistance were prosecuted. ... It seems plain that police and prosecutors are exercising their discretion to turn a blind eye to acts of assistance to suicide, which means that legislative enactments are not being enforced.[4]

 

What happens when criminal prosecutions are actually brought? Leonard Glantz accumulated reports on 20 prosecutions from 1939 through 1983. Only in three of them is there a record of jail sentences for the accused, and in each of those three cases there were unusual factors that cast doubt on how "merciful" were the defendants' motives. A few of the others resulted in suspended sentences, but the great majority resulted either in grand jury refusals to indict or acquittals. Glantz concluded, "[A]s a practical matter, the laws of homicide may not offer much protection to very sick, elderly patients." [5]

 

Why are criminal penalties so easily evaded? Most of those involved in assisting suicide seem more sympathetic characters to a jury than the typical street criminal. They are often doctors or family members and friends of the suicide victim. Even when prosecutors or juries are convinced that what these people have done or are doing is objectively wrong, it is hard for them to regard such people--who often subjectively have convinced themselves they are doing the right thing--as hardened criminals worthy of punishment. Indeed, this is an area in which almost all--including those of us pushing most strongly for laws to protect potential suicide victims from "assistance"--are more interested in preventing the act than in seeking retribution against the actor.

 

Thus, one law review article quotes a local prosecutor as saying "the District Attorney's office [does] not seek out such cases and would prosecute only those in which one of the people involved complained" and another as saying "that the law-enforcement authorities should stay out of them as much as possible." [6] It must be remembered that in our system there is absolute...

Other Essays Like Euthanasia Essay - Civil Remedies and Assisted Suicide

If Human Life Has Intrinsic Value Is Euthanasia Always Immoral?

1806 words - 8 pages The term euthanasia means death without suffering, or a good death. There are four ways to qualify the word euthanasia. Voluntary euthanasia is when a patient makes a conscious decision that his or her life should end, and asks for help in doing so. This is sometimes called assisted suicide. Involuntary euthanasia is when an individual in society makes a positive decision to end the life of someone suffering without consent from the sufferer

Legalizing Euthanasia: a Practical Approach Essay

2357 words - 10 pages ; Anselmi, 2011). The purpose of this essay is to discuss the benefits to patient autonomy and the Medicare budget, by the legalization of physician-assisted suicide and voluntary euthanasia. Legalizing Euthanasia: A Practical Approach Imagine that your beloved pet suffered a stroke and could no longer eat, drink, walk, or care for itself the way it had been able to do previously. Would you have a feeding tube inserted into him and care for his

Euthanasia - to Live and Let Die

3538 words - 15 pages INTRODUCTION Euthanasia is defined as the intentional killing, by act or omission, of a human being for his or her purported benefit. This definition is quite wide-ranging and a number of types of euthanasia and related activities have been defined. These include physician-assisted suicide and involuntary/non-voluntary euthanasia. While participation in the death of another—desired or otherwise—is usually defined in terms of a criminal

Assisted Suicide

736 words - 3 pages Assisted Suicide In ancient Greece and Rome, views toward infanticide, active euthanasia, and suicide were not only tolerated, but accepted. Many ancient Greeks, Romans and Pagan Physicians performed frequent abortions as well as both voluntary and involuntary mercy killings. During these early times, it made more sense to support voluntary death rather than prolonged agony, and physicians complied by giving their patients the poisons they

Euthanasia: The Right To Die

1686 words - 7 pages euthanasia, which is the more controversial type of euthanasia, refers to mercy killings and physician assisted suicide. “Active euthanasia defines the practice where death is caused by direct administration of a lethal substance” (Sayers, 2005). Dr. Jack Kevorkian is a physician well known for his cases of physician assisted suicide. “In his writings and statements, Kevorkian advocates a society that allows euthanasia for the dying, the disabled

Facts and Ethics Behind Euthanasia

2215 words - 9 pages . Suicide, self-deliverance, auto-euthanasia, aid-in-dying, assisted suicide -- call it what you like -- can be justified by the average supporter of the so-called "right to die movement" for the following reasons: The first reason is that an advanced terminal illness is causing unbearable suffering to the individual. This suffering is the most common reason to seek an early end. Second, a grave physical handicap exists that

Capital Punishment and Euthanasia

3227 words - 13 pages literature, there are three types of euthanasia: passive euthanasia defined as the withholding or withdrawing of life-sustaining measures, active euthanasia defined as the conscious medical intervention for the termination of the patient’s life and assisted suicide in which the physician provides a patient with a lethal dose of medication, upon the patient's request, which the patient intends to use to end his or her own life (Mason et al, 2003

Euthanasia 26

975 words - 4 pages alternatives to help disabled or patients approaching death live a pain-free and better life. Family members influencing the patient’s decision into euthanasia for personal gains like wealth inheritance is another issue. There is no way you can be really sure if the decision towards assisted suicide is voluntary or forced by others. Even doctors cannot predict firmly about period of death and whether there is a possibility of remission or

Physcian Assisted Suicide

505 words - 3 pages physician assisted suicide and euthanasia, passive or active, is ongoing. The traditional view of J. Gay-Williams and Phillippa Foot, who make the clear distinction between active and passive euthanasia, is morally irrelevant. What is the difference between letting someone die by withholding medication or giving pain medication to pacify until natural death occurs and giving a terminally ill patient the opportunity to inject a lethal dose of

Re: Re: Topic 2 Dq 1

2679 words - 11 pages at the end of life for years. They manage the needs of patient both independently and collaboratively with other members of the health care team. It is the position of the ANA that participation of nurses in euthanasia or assisted suicide is prohibited as those acts are in contravention of the code of ethics for nurses. Nurses have a duty to provide humane, comprehensive and compassionate care in respect to the rights of patients but maintain the

Physician Assisted Suicide

2561 words - 11 pages revealed for what he is: a romanticized version of Ted Bundy, stacking corpses like cordwood and proud of it.” Pete Waldmeir, Detroit News “He’s a martyr. He’s acted in a great American tradition of civil disobedience.” “It was so clearly not a crime.” Faye Girsh, Hemlock Society Director -compiled from IAETF Update, Jan-March 1999 State Response to Physician Assisted Suicide The states have acted in various ways to the issue of

Related Papers

Ethical And Legal Issues Of Physician Assisted Suicide

1235 words - 5 pages medical sedation, which enables them to practice their freedom of choice to a certain extent. Bibliography Angell, M. (1997). The Supreme Court and physician-assisted suicide: The ultimate right. The New England Journal of Medicine, 336(1): 50–53. doi:10.1056/NEJM199701023360108 Back, A. L., Wallace, J. I., Starks, H. E., & Pearlman, R. A. (1996). Physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia in Washington state: Patient requests and

The Legal And Ethical Dilemma Of Physician Assisted Suicide

3512 words - 15 pages : Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide a Legal and Ethical Dilemma. 1-11. Retrieved from http://commissiononassisteddying.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/Evidence-from-Thomas-Croft-Euthanasia-and-Assisted-Suicide-a-Legal-and-Ethical-Dilemma-.pdf Final Exit Network, Inc. et al. v. State of Georgia, SA11A1960 (Supreme Court of Georgia February 6, 2012). Retrieved from http://www.lexisnexis.com.proxygsu-sho1.galileo.usg.edu/hottopics/lnacademic/?verb=sf&sfi

Patient Assisted Suicide Essay

1225 words - 5 pages arguments against euthanasia say that PAS (patient assisted suicide) will be used in medical cases that are not well-known and will lead to doctors, who utilize euthanasia as an option, running the hospitals of America. Basically, this type of argument is designed to put fear into the lives of sick patients. However, there is really no sufficient evidence that euthanasia or PAS will bring ‘nightmares’ to patients and their families especially if the

Voluntary Euthanasia Paper 1

1004 words - 5 pages Euthanasia should remain illegal in this country. I disagree strongly with this statement for reasons I shall give later in this essay. Euthanasia can be described as a form of assisted suicide. These are the different ways that Euthanasia is classed, voluntary euthanasia is conducted with the consent of the patient and are legal in Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Switzerland, and the U.S. states of Oregon and Washington. Non-voluntary