Expanded Comparison Of Leadership Articles Essay

1711 words - 7 pages

This is a comparison of three articles and all the components which are required for a research study. It is a qualitative assessment conducted to measure the validity of research articles, and is accomplished by comparing, contrasting and synthesizing the information. Article one; is a study of existing paradigms which studies the leadership known as transformational. It is suggested in this article that public organizations are not as bureaucratic as people stereotype them. It is further noted that the performance measures which are in place support higher levels of the leadership known as transformational in spite of their hierarchical structures (Wright, 2010). Article two; explores ...view middle of the document...

Conversely; when an organization refrains from the practice of reward for performance, transformational leadership is higher (Wright, 2010). In article two the study sets out to prove that personnel who are managed with a transformational leadership style, will be more committed to the organization, and will have more job satisfaction than those employees who are managed with a leadership style known as transactional. Customer satisfaction is directly related to the attitude of the personnel (Emery C. R., 2007). The study in article three examines two questions: The first is the parental practices of both parents and the differential role they play and how this relates to conflicts between parents, and behavioral issues with children. The next question is how passive genotype–environment correlation plays a role in interactions between parents and the potential problems with behaviors children might exhibit (Harold, 2013).
Literature Review
Article one explores the different cultures in the organization and relates these to transformational leadership behaviors. This is very similar to article two which examines the differences between transformational and transactional leadership styles and how they relate to organizational commitment and employee satisfaction. These two studies examine the effects of organizational leadership on employee satisfaction. A healthy work environment is conducive to better attitudes in workers which in turn results in happy customers. Article three however is a totally different type of study. In this study the author measures the effect of the other parental practices; specifically inter-parental conflict and hostile parenting and how this relates to negative child outcomes and children's externalizing problems. This study consists of two analyses, one which examines the role of mother-to-child and the other father-to-child, with the variables being hostility, inter-parental conflict, and children’s externalizing behavior problems. The analyses which were conducted utilized four primary sets of subjects across genetically related and genetically unrelated parent-child groupings. These were compared to establish an association to the various conflicts. Although the authors in articles one and two had very similar objectives the only authors referenced in both were Bass, Burns, Conger, Howell, and Porter. There were no common authors from articles one and two referenced in article three or vice versa.
Populations Sample
In article one the sample population consisted of 1,322 high-level public administrators in municipalities exceeding 50,000 residents (Wright, 2010). In the second study the people that participated were over 77 branch managers from three banking organizations and some 47store managers a national food chain (Emery C. R., 2007). The third study’s sample had 361 sets of adopted children and adoptive mothers and fathers. All of these participants came from adoption agencies located in...

Other Essays Like Expanded Comparison Of Leadership Articles

Behaviors of Effective Leaders Essay

1356 words - 6 pages effective leader. In addition, behaviors of an effective leader can be categorized into three themes of personality traits, personal leadership styles, and leader self-identity. While not all behaviors are conducive to effective leadership, all the above themes are vital to the development of successful leaders of the past, present and future. The shared themes were synthesized from three articles all of which discussed the effective leader

Leadership - Mallya vs Branson Essay

2889 words - 12 pages people appears to be more fitted towards an autocratic style of management theory. There are lots of similarities between Richard Branson and Vijay Mallya, both of them are charismatic leader and have demonstrated similar characteristics and behaviours as identified in the trait theory of an effective leaders. Nonetheless, in comparison to Mallay’s UB; Virgin Group has expanded quite significantly – an independent research held by HPI has shown

Final Assessment

596 words - 3 pages topics: • presentation and discussion of academic and anecdotal resource materials • deconstruction of current homeland security or public safety leadership • identification of acceptable and effective professional homeland security or public safety leadership principles • collation of data from personal leadership self-assessment assignments • comparison and contrast of self-assessment data, to include applicability, with best practices and identified leadership principles • presentation and discussion of future personal leadership development and opportunity

British Airways

613 words - 3 pages understanding organisational behaviour The main objective of my report will be firstly to demonstrate the contribution of behavioural science theory in comparison to scientific theories. In the light of these concepts I will go on to link theories to the problem (employee unrests/strikes) to my organization- British Airways. I will look at the scenario from the following perspectives: 1) Leadership and Management The first part of the paragraph

Transformational Leaders Vs Charismatic Leaders

1626 words - 7 pages better good of the group is Barack Obama. Obama is highly dedicated to making USA a united country where everybody is happy with one another, independent but still walk on the path that leads to a better future for their country. (Obama Leadership Styles) Charismatic leaders, in comparison, seek to weaken their followers and make them subservient. They take pride in having these kinds of followers. This is proven in the article by Mooney when she

Critical Thinking

3433 words - 14 pages to what is at hand at the moment. This is very helpful in improving efficiency to a big extend and it motivates and improves persistance to get the desired result. CRITICAL AND REFLECTIVE THOUGHT The two articles Authenticity paradox and Self Leadership High Road has given me a great deal o understanding about the leadership qualities, the qualities a leader should posses, the dificulties of being a good leader, the self conflict within a

Super Leadership And Creativity Potential

857 words - 4 pages -leadership (Sims & Manz, 1996). It is asserted that one can lead in a better way if able to develop and use individuals’ skills and capabilities at workplace (Manz & Sims, Self Management as a subsitue for leadership:A social learning perspective, 1980). As advocated by (Manz C. , Self-leadership: toward an expanded theory of self-influence processes in organizations, 1986) and (Manz & Neck, 2004) as organizational members are trained and

Business Management

2210 words - 9 pages . Leadership Quarterly, 7(3), 323 - 352. Managementstudyguide.com. (2012). House’s Path Goal Theory. Retrieved from Management Study Guide: http://managementstudyguide.com/houses-path-goal-theory.htm Silva, S. (2009, April 6). Motivation Theories - Understanding the Expectancy and Equity Theories of Motivation. Retrieved from Articlesbase - Free Online Articles Dictionary: http://www.articlesbase.com/human-resources-articles/motivation-theories

Air India - Mismanagement

2539 words - 11 pages 1. Understand the relationship between strategic management and leadership 1.1 Air India comes directly under the Ministry of Civil Aviation, Government of India. The Board of directors and CMD have to work under the guidance of bureaucrats and politicians. What in your opinion have been the influence and effect of such a leadership and the strategic management and decisions taken on Air India over a period

Leadership

3583 words - 15 pages training. There are a number of books, articles, and research papers written on how we define leadership in the public sector, as well as how it affects the organization. Some leaders are born into the role, such as royalty, where there have been some notable successes and failures. Other leaders become leaders simply because other people choose to follow them. Researchers have been studying the definition of leadership for many years with

Hong Kong And Venezuela

1618 words - 7 pages ://www.hku.hk/hkcer/articles/v57/walker The economic freedom between Hong Kong and China provides an interesting comparison. In rating government jurisdiction and use of markets, China is rated dramatically lower than Hong Kong (Figure 8). However, ratings in monetary policy are not that different, but use of alternative currencies in Hong Kong remains far more open. In terms of international exchange and financial markets, Hong Kong also rates

Related Papers

Comparison Matrix Paper

1339 words - 6 pages factors” sheds light on the direct and buffering effects of three contextual factors in work environments---constructive leadership, perceived organizational support, and organizational anti-bullying initiatives and the relationship to bullying. The three articles are necessary to the discussion of workplace bullying. Each is different but effective in its message. Research Questions Comparison Research questions are arguably the beginning and

Comparison Matrix Paper

1692 words - 7 pages the socialization process (Weidman 2001) and understanding of their role, as they see them, will greatly assist in providing more successful socialization experience for doctoral students is to compare three empirical articles on the topic of leadership. . Comparison of Sample Population The questionnaire was sent to 83 active Ph.D. students enrolled in two departments in a major public research university that is a member of the

Comp Paper

1614 words - 7 pages Expanded Comparison Matrix | |Article 1 |Article 2 |Article 3 | |Title/Author(s) |Transformational Leadership in the Public Sector: Does Structure |The Effect Of Transactional and Transformational |The Reality of Web-Based Interaction in an

Strategic Management Essay

1078 words - 5 pages skills: different methods of developing leaders through formal learning, self-help and developmental activities eg training courses, job rotation, seminars, executive coaching, mentoring, companies’ own universities, developmental assessment centres, action learning, self-directed learning, reading articles, partnership with key academics; changing methodology in leadership development programmes; benefits of self-help activities eg learning