Explain The Difference Between Bentham's Act Utilitarianism And Mill's Rule Utilitarianism (25)

910 words - 4 pages

Explain the differences between Bentham’s and Mill’s Utilitarianism (25):

Utilitarianism is a consequentialist ethical theory as the consequence of an action or rule is the main principle to judge whether an action is right or wrong. Act Utilitarianism is a teleological theory which was designed by Bentham, states that the act which produces the most pleasure was the most desirable act. Rule Utilitarianism is a deontological theory which was designed by Mill, states that that the act which produces the best act is the most desirable act - – “The greatest happiness for the greatest number”. The principle of utility states that actions are right if they promote pleasure but are wrong if ...view middle of the document...

Bentham believed that circumstances should be taken into account in estimating the value of a pleasure or pain considered with reference to a single person and on its own. For instance, there was a crime committed and the police are holding two suspects in custody but the police know it was not them but could not find the real criminal. Nevertheless they want to close the case quickly. They have two choices – to choose one suspect and charge them with the crime or continue searching for the criminal. Bentham would say that the police should choose one of the suspects and charge them with the crime because that is that would bring the police the most pleasure. Mills, on the other hand, would disagree. He believed that a society’s ‘well-being’ was the most important rather than an individual’s wants/desires. Mill stated that the most important condition for happiness is liberty. People should be free to do as they choose as long as they do not cause harm to others (Harm Principle). Act Utilitarianism focused on the individual’s happiness whereas Rule Utilitarianism emphases on everyone’s happiness.
Furthermore, Bentham argued that the best way to judge whether an action was right was to use the Hedonic Calculus. An action should be judged on the 7 criterias - its purity, remoteness, richness, intensity, certainty and duration. He took the view that following the Hedonic Calculus would benefit the individual and would lead itself to that individual’s greatest happiness. Conversely, Mill reasoned that a set of general rules that everyone should follow to bring about the greatest good for that community. For example, in the UK everyone must drive the left hand side of the road. This rule helps to stop chaos on the roads. In all situations...

Other Essays Like Explain the Difference Between Bentham's Act Utilitarianism and Mill's Rule Utilitarianism (25)

Compare and Contrast Kantianism and Utilitarianism

1137 words - 5 pages whether or not one should tell a lie depends on the consequences. Suppose I’m a doctor who have just examined a patient who did not know yet that he has an incurable terminal illness. If I follow utilitarianism, I will lie about his situation, knowing that the truth will immediately cause more pain. Thus, I would prefer to lie and tell the patient, "Hang in there, you'll recover soon enough." At this point the difference between the two starts getting

Utilitarian Act and Rule Essay

962 words - 4 pages number of people and the ends must justify the means, in order to be considered morally just by means of the Utilitarian calculator. Within utilitarianism there are two main groups, Act Utilitarian and Rule Utilitarian. An act utilitarian would say that each individual situation is unique and must be judged on its own merit. I believe that an act utilitarian would likely say that though the act of X in this case isn’t encouraged, that in this

The Difference Between Bullying And Harassment

2359 words - 10 pages broken without consequences. Although schools have a set of rules, they are rarely enforced and some don’t even do anything on when something occurs off campus. Cyber bullying is no different from verbal and physical bullying it has the same effects, it hurts innocent individuals and it should have the same consequences. Cyber bullying the majority of the time, occurs between the ages of 13-18. Most teens feel that by not telling someone that this

The Difference Between the Cash Flow and the Profit

932 words - 4 pages income minus expenses. However, transactions of income and expenses take place not only on a cash basis but also on a credit basis. Accounting, therefore, has to be used to adjust the timing difference in recording transactions to reflect the whole genuine picture. An important principle that is particularly relevant to the interpretation of the distinction between the cash position and the profit is the matching principle. The matching

Orwell's 1984: Similarities and Difference Between Oceania and the Usa

1689 words - 7 pages Similarities and Difference between Oceania and the United States This paper will discuss the similarities and differences between the Oceanic society of Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four and the society of the United States. First I will talk about the similarities and then I will finish off with the differences, all of which will be based on factual information that I have gathered both, from the book and the mainstream media. Then I

The Difference Between Obeying Orders and Obeying the Law

560 words - 3 pages I do believe that to a certain extent there is a difference between obeying orders and obeying a law. To obey the law one must abide by the same rules as everybody else. On the other hand, to obey an order is distinguished by one’s role. For example, everyone must obey the law that one is not allowed to consume an alcoholic beverage under the age of 21. If one is the age of 21 or older and enjoys an alcoholic beverage, then he or she is

The Difference Between Associate Degree and Baccalaureate Degree in Nursing

1049 words - 5 pages The Difference Between Associate Degree and Baccalaureate Degree in Nursing Increasing clinical understanding and the rising complexities in the health care technologies today requires that professional nurses be educated and competent to the baccalaureate level. Nurses with their RN can be educated to the level of associates degree or to baccalaureate degree. According to the Grand Canyon University Baccalaureate Curriculum Model, the

Difference Between Resultant and Equilibrant

716 words - 3 pages | | | | |that connects them), the transfer | | | | |of information between the | | | | |hemispheres ceases, and the

1.2 Summarise the Difference Between Formative and Summative Assessment

833 words - 4 pages 1.2 Summarise the difference between formative and summative assessment Assessments within a school is the process of gathering data/evidence on a student’s learning. This can be in the form of observations, tests and exams. The two most common types of assessments used within a school are formative and summative. Both of these assessments measure a student’s learning but in different ways. Formative Assessment – Supporting learning The

Difference Between Juvenile and Criminal

922 words - 4 pages Difference between Juvenile and Criminal Justice System David E. Foster Kaplan College – Las Vegas Campus CJ 150 Professor Laura Fletcher December 5, 2013 Difference between Juvenile and Criminal Justice System How would it feel if our children were being treated like adults in the criminal justice system; getting sentenced for life without parole, or maybe have your child sentenced to death as a teenager. Well thanks to our

Mussolini’s Consolidation of Power Between 1922 and 25

1239 words - 5 pages Mussolini’s Consolidation of Power Between 1922 and 25 “ It seems that Mussolini from the outset was determined to retain power in his hand; but he was uncertain of the method to be employed towards the other political parties and their leaders, towards the press, and towards parliament” (F.L. Carsten, an academic historian and specialist on European Fascism, The Rise of Fascism, (1967) In 1922 Mussolini had

Related Papers

Is Rule Utilitarianism Preferable To Act Utilitarianism Essay

2081 words - 9 pages would not be morally permissible because it is true that general adherence to the rule 'do not kill innocents' produces more value that non-adherence and to do so would be breaking a rule, thus acting immorally. Our intuition that killing the innocent in the situation provided would be morally wrong can be explained by our ability to distinguish between 'death' and 'murder' or 'killing' where act-utilitarianism does not. By not killing the innocent

Explain Both The General Principles Of Utilitarianism And The Distinctive Features Of Rule Utilitarianism. (30 Marks)

964 words - 4 pages Explain both the general principles of utilitarianism and the distinctive features of rule utilitarianism. (30 marks) In the following essay in order to illustrate the general principles of Utilitarianism; I will first introduce the general principles of Utilitarianism as a theory used by many, then secondly I will explain the principles of rule utilitarianism by Mill. Finally I sum up both the principles and rule of utilitarianism

The Link Between Utilitarianism And Democracy

361 words - 2 pages candidates for the Presidency, and 10 people take part in the elections, then, if 4 people vote for Jack and 6 for Jill, Jill will be elected President.Although many people regard the two ideas as completely unrelated and independent concepts, it is not difficult to see the parallelism between them. For example, much like utilitarianism, democracy is a majority rule theorem. Also, when either of these philosophical ideas are put into practice upon

Explain How Bentham’s Version Of Utilitarianism May Be Used To Decide On The Right Course Of Action. (25 Marks)

856 words - 4 pages Explain how Bentham’s version of Utilitarianism may be used to decide on the right course of action. (25 marks) Utilitarianism is a teleological theory. It states that something is morally right if it produces pleasure and it’s morally wrong if it produce pain. The principle of Utility refers to the greatest amount of pleasure or happiness for the greatest number of people. According to Bentham, most moral acts are those that maximise