Explain The Relationship Between Discipline And Obedience From The Montessori Perspective. Explain How Discipline And Obedience Are Linked To The Development Of The Will

1927 words - 8 pages

There are various theories explaining the development of discipline and obedience in early childhood. Montessori perspective establishes a link between these two concepts and how their maturation is dependent on the maturation of the will of the child. This essay will attempt to explain the relationship between discipline and obedience in the developmental stages of a child. Attention will be paid to how the environment helps the child in his development through the stages according to Montessori.

According to Oxford dictionary, ‘to discipline is to train to obey rules and code of conduct, using punishment to correct disobedience’. In the traditional sense of discipline much emphasis ...view middle of the document...

‘The basic error is to suppose that a person’s will must necessarily be broken before it can obey, meaning before it can accept and follow another person’s directions’ (Montessori, p 235). From the definitions above it is clear that the development of the will of the child precedes obedience and the child relies on this maturation of the will to develop his internal discipline.

Discipline and obedience in a Montessori perspective can be discussed in an atmosphere of freedom. Children are active learners in the right environment. Thus a favourable environment which is ‘ the sum total of the objects which a child can freely choose and use as he pleases, that is to say, according to his needs and tendencies’ (Montessori 2007, P 65)bolsters the child’s inner need to explore and investigate, supports a child natural’s quest to learn and grow. This freedom not only allows the child to progress in his or her own pace; it also fosters the child’s inner discipline.

A child’s freedom as explained to him from the beginning of his life in a Montessori class is liberating. The child has freedom to (inter alia) choose activities, repeat activities, movement, speech and rest. As this child chooses activities according to his own interest and repeats these activities he learns to know himself better and he finds his inner discipline and calmness through increased concentration and a sense of independence. Through self- discipline, the child is in better control of himself and he is able to sublimate his own will for that of others. In this regard, Montessori asserts that ‘an individual is disciplined when he is the master of himself and when he can, as a consequence, control himself when he must follow a rule of life’ (Montessori 2007b, P 51).

A teacher’s role is central in the prepared environment. The teacher is the custodian of the environment to ensure order is maintained and through careful selection of activities, the child can expect some level of consistency and predictability. These factors are important in supporting the child’s sensitivity to order. ‘Order is one of the needs of life, which when it is satisfied, produces a real happiness.’ (Montessori 1966, P52). Secondly, the Montessori Teacher sets the ground rules for the prepared environment. These ground rules help the child’s understanding of what is acceptable and what is not and guide the child’s emerging will toward socially acceptable behaviour.

Ordinarily, an individual is unable to obey an instruction unless he has the ability. A child grows in his ability to grow as his will matures. The maturation of child from birth to age six, in Absorbent Mind plane of development (Montessori, 2007a) culminates in the full control of a child’s own will. From birth to age three, the child is controlled by his inner drive towards independence, referred to as the ‘Horme ’(Montessori, 2007a).
It marks the beginning of the personality creation, when the child absorbs and...

Other Essays Like Explain the Relationship Between Discipline and Obedience from the Montessori Perspective. Explain How Discipline and Obedience Are Linked to the Development of the Will

Analyze And Explain The Work Of One Christian’S Agency Working For World Development

2195 words - 9 pages fact that Tearfund’s volunteers are the various Christian churches from different countries working together to bring equality and bring justice emphasizes how much Tearfund follows and treasures the Christian teachings. One of their future goals is to create a worldwide association of 100,000 churches of various countries all on one mission to exterminate poverty. An example of Tearfund working with local churches of the community they are

Explain the Sequence and Rate of Each Aspect of Development That Would Normally Be Expected in Children and Young People from Birth – 19 Years

857 words - 4 pages Explain the sequence and rate of each aspect of development that would normally be expected in children and young people from birth – 19 years Birth – 1 month: Sleeps 20 hours a day Crying – main form of communication – fosters early interaction. Begins to have distinct facial expressions. Moves around more. Focuses both eyes together. Can detect smells. Sensitive to touch. Uses reflexes. Focuses on source of sound. 2 – 3 months

(P3) Explain the Influences of Two Predictable and Two Unpredictable Major Life Events on the Development of an Individual

640 words - 3 pages that comes with it. If someone has the support from family members and the community then they may be able to deal with the emotional and psychological effects. Parenthood Parenthood can be a very stressful time and some people may develop conditions like postnatal depression. 7 in 10 mothers will develop this condition the psychological and emotional side effects are: they will feel worthless and hopeless, have anxiety/panic attacks, their

“Residential Segregation Shapes the Social Life of Cities and People’s Sense of Who They Are”  Explain How Different Types of Evidence Used in Dd102 Support This Claim. 

1536 words - 7 pages “Residential Segregation Shapes the Social Life of Cities and People’s Sense of Who They Are”  Explain how different types of evidence used in DD102 support this claim.    Residential segregation is the physical separation of two or more groups into different neighbourhoods, or a form of segregation that "sorts population groups into various neighbourhood contexts and shapes the living environment at the neighbourhood level”. (Wikipedia

Explain the Difference Between Bentham's Act Utilitarianism and Mill's Rule Utilitarianism (25)

910 words - 4 pages Explain the differences between Bentham’s and Mill’s Utilitarianism (25): Utilitarianism is a consequentialist ethical theory as the consequence of an action or rule is the main principle to judge whether an action is right or wrong. Act Utilitarianism is a teleological theory which was designed by Bentham, states that the act which produces the most pleasure was the most desirable act. Rule Utilitarianism is a deontological theory which was

Evaluate the List of 13 Benefits of Training and Development, Pp. 291 – 292. Select the 4 That You Assess as Having the Highest Value to Employees and the Organization. Explain the Reason(S) for Each...

932 words - 4 pages adopt to help them to maintain desired behaviors or to recognize symptoms that indicate variance from a desired path. A very high value can also be find in benefit number 9. Leadership training seems to enhance the attitudes and performance of followers. Specifically, it seems to have a positive effect on the motivation, values, and self –efficacy of followers. This means, if the managers/leaders in my company are well-trained this will also

Are Uniforms a Good Way to Improve Student Discipline and Motivation?

2115 words - 9 pages available to support either proposition. Are they in fact beneficial in improving discipline and motivation_ I believe so, and the experience at South Houston suggests that I am right! The staff reported a considerable decrease in violence and indiscipline, and an average across the board increase of two grades in academic performance by the end of the year within which a uniform policy was introduced. Could it just be co-incidence? It seems

P2- Explain the Potential Effects of Five Different Life Factors on the Development of an Individual

2170 words - 9 pages . Socio Economic Economic status will affect the development of an individual and their family. Children from low economic status generally have a low academic score and have a higher chance of dropping out of school. This is similar to their parents who also have are less educated and less equipped schools. Therefore have fewer learning resources at home. There are also physical and psychological effects that link to an individuals economic

P2: Explain the Potential Effects of Five Different Life Factors on the Development of an Individual

741 words - 3 pages P2: Explain the potential effects of five different life factors on the development of an individual. Genetic factors The individual I have chosen has such disease as asthma. What is asthma? Asthma is the most common disease of childhood and is strongly genetic in origin. Since asthma has a genetic origin and is a disease you are born with, passed down from generation to generation. People with asthma have inflamed airways which are super

Explain How Children and Young Peoples Developments Are Influenced

1288 words - 6 pages : Id – The id is someone's animal instinct, responsible for their needs to satisfy basic desires. Supergo – This represents someone's ideal of what sort of person they would like to be. This is based on the demands from their parents and society. Ego – The ego is the force that regulates between id and the supergo. It tries to resolve conflicts so that the id is satisfied within the limits of what the Supergo will allow. Some of Freud's methods are still in placed till today. For instance, we highly value 'Talking therapies' to help people deal with feelings and traumatic events that stem from their childhood.

Explain How to Monitor Children and Young People's Development Using Different Methods

520 words - 3 pages Task 6 EXPLAIN HOW TO MONITOR CHILDREN AND YOUNG PEOPLE’S DEVELOPMENT USING DIFFERENT METHODS. Accurate observations and assessments are essential to effective educational practice. We observe that we can recognise children’s and young people’s skills abilities and identify their needs. This will make planning for their future development much more specific to the individual need. Observation is more than just watching; You are also notify

Related Papers

Unit 1 1.1 Explain The Sequence And Rate Of Each Aspect Of Development From Birth 19years

5095 words - 21 pages . 2.3 Explain how theories of development and frameworks to support development influence current practice. Theories of development that influence current practice are:- Cognitive- Jean Piaget’s theory of cognitive development started off from his observations of his own children at play he then went on to observe other children and used these observations as the basis for his theory of cognitive development. From Piaget’s observations he

Explain The Sequence And Rate Of Each Aspect Of Development From Birth 19 Years

5317 words - 22 pages the same step. 4-7 years – From the ages of 4-7 the child’s physical development is improving much less rapidly. The main development is in their fine motor skills, which they will be learning, as they join pre-school, then school. They will develop the ability to pour liquids, do threading and will be able to use scissors. The child will be able to improve their drawing skills and will be starting to learn how to write in school. By 6-7 years

Explain What The Concept Of The 'will' Is To Arthur Schopenhauer

971 words - 4 pages animals with not thought for consequences or outcomes, but it separates causality from action. The Will is the raw force that causes humans to clash into each other in daily interaction, (Stanford.edu). It is why we do everything, it encompasses hope, fear, repulsion, attraction, etc. It is our subconscious motivation for everything we do. The people and places and objects and scenery that make up our world are part of our individuated intellect

Compare And Contrast The Attitudes To Travelling To Paris In Text 1 And Text 2 And Explain The Expectations Of Paris That Are Conveyed In The Texts

695 words - 3 pages Compare and Contrast the Attitudes to Travelling to Paris in Text 1 and Text 2 and Explain the Expectations of Paris that are Conveyed in the Texts. Text 1, 'Stories are Waiting in Paris' is multimodal text of a transcript for a Eurostar advert. A multimodal text relies on more than one medium, meaning that you not only have to read but listen and watch. This makes it more powerful as it appeals to your different senses, for example the sound