Extending Core Science: Human Cloning Essay

3092 words - 13 pages

2010

Extending Core Science
ECLSC3012
F.A.O. Seán Doyle

Part A

Outdoor Learning

Outdoor learning provides great opportunities for students to become motivated to learning. It can offer a contrast to the usual indoor classroom learning environment. Outdoor experiences can help students to become stimulated sparking off fascination, and breakthroughs in their personal learning, (IOL, 2010).

It is suggested by Salford City Council (2003) that, ‘educational trips and visits provide a valuable opportunity for young people to participate in positive experiences, which are not available to them in the classroom, or youth centre. These trips and visits can enable young ...view middle of the document...

This suggests that these pupils will have some knowledge of cloning.

Most KS2 pupils are aware of cloning and some of the issues around it due to media coverage. Over recent years there have been many breakthroughs in animal cloning, the biggest one being the first successful mammal cloning of ‘Dolly the sheep’ in 1997. Since then smaller clones have been created. Seven years after the death of ‘Dolly the sheep’ the scientist who cloned her, has now cloned her again as quadruplets, these clones are the exact genetic replicas as ‘Dolly’. Pupils will now be aware of this through the media and may ask questions about this (Highfield, 2010). Pupils could discuss the fact that Dolly died some years ago and is now living as quadruplets.

Cloning can seem to be a relative new discovery, but since the early 20th century, it has been applied to botany, when talking about plants, (UNESCO, 2004). While many plants clone themselves naturally to reproduce, people can clone plants simply by taking a cutting of the plant and re-planting it, (CSIRO, No Date). So why are there issues in animal and human cloning?

Some of the ethical issues surrounding this topic sprouted from the successful cloning of Dolly the sheep, as this provoked the possibility that very soon, human cloning could be possible. This has motivated the debate of ‘should humans be able to play God?’

Cloning violates some religious beliefs of how human reproductions (Sc2) should occur. Some religious organisations believe that human cloning is wrong. This is mainly because they believe that God made man and if human cloning comes about, God will no longer be doing this. Christians believe in particular that if human cloning happens, man will be able to state what features they want and therefore design the “perfect” human, this also reminds Christians of Hitler and Nazi Germany, and his cruelty in trying to make the perfect race (Phillips, 2009).

After the cloning of Dolly the sheep, the Cloning Act 2000 came in to place stating that it would be illegal to use cloning for reproductive purposes in humans. The Cloning Act defines this as ‘the implantation of an embryo created by any means other than fertilisation’ (Janson-Smith, 2002)

Where Cloning Fits in to the KS2 Curriculum

As pupils will be learning about cloning (Sc2) later in the Key Stage 3 curriculum this could be used as a bridging project. This would give pupils background knowledge of cloning as it is suggested by Moses (1990), that students learn better when they have a basic knowledge of the topic before learning more about it. This project would also ensure a successful transition from primary to secondary schools. Cloning would fit in to the Key Stage 2 curriculum while or after looking at reproduction of plants and animals, as this may give a different ‘option’ to reproduction.

Approaches for out of classroom learning

One approach that could be used when studying this topic is...

Other Essays Like Extending Core Science: Human Cloning

Human Cloning the Human Race Would Be Better Off in the Long Run If the Best of Us Were Copied…???

1089 words - 5 pages Human Cloning The human race would be better off in the long run if the best of us were copied…??? Introduction The ethics of human cloning has become a great issue in the past few years. The advocates for both sides of the issue have many reasons to clone or not to clone. Cloning will first be defined. Followed by that, a discussion of the opinions that support cloning will be presented and then the same against cloning. And finally

To Clone Or Not To Clone

866 words - 4 pages true and is taking place with human cloning at this very moment. If you don't act fast this crowning achievement of medical science could be lost forever. This procedure will be both a contribution to science and a betterment of the human race. Human cloning will provide unlimited benefits to our species and should be legal.The cloning of humans could be the greatest achievement of medical science; it could lead the way to the solution to some of

Cloning

541 words - 3 pages Cloning: Frontiers of Genetic Engineering David Jefferis Crabtree Publishing Company, New YorkISBN 0-7787-0048-8 This book is an excellent resource into how cloning came about, what’s been done with it, and what may come in the future. This book is written for people who have a basic understanding of science. If you have that this book is an easy read. The format of the book is laid out step-by-step of how cloning came to be all the way

human cloning

417 words - 2 pages Scientists are either very close at being able to clone human beings or scientists have already done it. Human cloning has already become illegal or restricted in a variety of degrees in several countries. The film the island shows how the science can go terribly wrong.Human life should be left to nature for several reasons. First, they make clones for their satisfaction and for commercial purposes. Human organ transplants are used from clones

Human Cloning

855 words - 4 pages Science fiction authors have for many years instilled in us the fantastic idea of great armies of cloned men and women, fighting mindless battles for the betterment of human kind. Perfect beings created under the microscope of fantasy to accelerate the evolutionary process, a brave new world, of disease free and identical people. But is there truly an application for human cloning in our 21st century society? Some scientists argue that one

Problems With Embryonic Stem-Cell Research

1565 words - 7 pages a liver cell remains a liver cell (Kumar 1-2). Although this concept sounds promising, the idea of applying embryonic stem cells in an attempt to cure major diseases has many flaws and there are many hurdles that science must overcome before embryonic stem cells could be of any use in medicine. Scientists obtain embryonic stem cells by harvesting them from human embryos. The procedure after harvesting consists of cultivating the harvested

Natural Selection vs Human Intervention

614 words - 3 pages “Evolution by natural selection is now replaced by evolution through human intervention.” Evolution has been one of the big topics on the science part of the world. Through years, there has been many debates on not the idea of evolution but by which process(es) it undergoes. There is the natural and artificial selections. I take I have enough knowledge to distinguish both sides of the argument and to take my stand which would be somewhere right

Revolutions in Genetic Technology-an Abstract

1363 words - 6 pages we had to take up the study of genetics or the gene structure of the human body. The perfect cure still eludes us but we have managed to make some really great progresses in the field such as recombinant DNA technology, cloning, assisted reproduction and gene profiling. RECOMBINANT DNA TECHNOLOGY Recombinant DNA (rDNA) molecules are DNA sequences that result from the use of laboratory methods to bring together genetic material from multiple

Designer Foods

668 words - 3 pages Designer Foods or Franken Foods) is the possible future elimination of shortages of food by increase production. "Modern Science has devised revolutionary breeding techniques." Reader’s (190). In a issue of Nature, the Roslin Institute and the PPL Therapeutic PLC announced the cloning of Dolly, a lamb cloned from DNA of a adult sheep mammary gland cell. (The news media first announced the story on February 22, 1997).” (NCGR-GPI). In order to

Anthonique Writer

619 words - 3 pages representation of technology on the population .Most of the special effects concentrate on the action scenes that are only slightly related with science fiction aspects. A notable feature is the holographic grid that is part of the illusion that the population are living in a complex on the sea and that there is an island. 6) How do you feel about cloning? * I definitely don’t sanction cloning, when clones are created they develop their own

The Life of a Clone: Never Let Me Go - the Island

4125 words - 17 pages favoured object to try new methods of cloning, but scientists often forget that they, too, have feelings and are able to feel pain. Works Cited a) Monographs : 1. Haran, Joan, Jenny Kitzinger, Maureen McNeil & Kate O’Riordan (2008), Human Cloning in the Media – From Science Fiction to Science Practice, Oxon: Routledge 2. Harris, John (1998), Clones, Genes and Immortality, Oxford: Oxford University Press b) Primary sources

Related Papers

Cloning Course Project Essay

573 words - 3 pages . When comparing the clone to the original, do they think similar and act similar? Or are they just connected but have differences and are more like identical twins? The science involved is very intriguing but does the human race really have a right to create and destroy beings as we see fit? Researchers feel that cloning could act almost as the cure that people are hoping for however, I feel that science is starting to over-step their bounds

Cloning Is Unethical Essay

828 words - 4 pages sparked a curiosity for cloning all over the world, however, mankind must answer a question, should cloning be allowed? To answer this question some issues need to be explored. Is cloning morally correct, is it a reliable way to produce life, and should human experimentation be allowed? Scientists have no problem with the ethical issues cloning poses, as they claim the technological benefits of cloning clearly outweigh the possible social

Cloning Right Or Wrong? Essay

1491 words - 6 pages rather than protect mankind. As such, cloning embryonic human life under any circumstance crosses an ethical line, takes an irrevocable step, from which science can never turn back." Many people think that it is against God’s will to clone animals and that is the huge problem with cloning. In Colossians 1:16 is states “We were created by God for his purpose.” Religion is one of the biggest problems when it comes to cloning starting many religion

Ethical Issue On Human Cloning Essay

532 words - 3 pages ETHICAL ISSUE ON HUMAN CLONING In our contemporary world science has so developed that it has almost taken the place of God, something’s that are exclusively the reserve of God has been ventured into by science, one of such issues is CLONING, the latest bio-technological development that deals with the cloning of human being. This development has generated a lot of controversy. In this work attempt would be made to expose the ethical issues