This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Fact Or Fiction: A Critique Of The Man Eating Myth: Anthropophagy And Anthropology

1935 words - 8 pages

Fact or Fiction:
A Critique of the Man-Eating Myth: Anthropophagy and Anthropology

The Man-Eating Myth: Anthropophagy and Anthropology by William Arens (1979) examines the evidence or lack thereof in determining what constitutes cannibalism or anthropophagy. Throughout history anthropologists as well as other “explorers” have encountered numerous peoples throughout the world. During their fieldwork they have gathered data which suggest the practice of cannibalism within the communities. There have been countless documents which have substantiated the claim of cannibalism in distant countries. This data has been accepted as fact but in actuality these assumptions contain more fiction ...view middle of the document...

”(p.9) First person evidence is the only credible way of substantiating or refuting the argument of cannibalism. Hearsay is only circumstantial in finding the truth on the subject. Arens’ experience with the tribal people in Tanzania added more depth to the anthropophagy debate. While in the field, Arens notice the Tanzanian people referring to him as Mchinja-chinja. Curious of the meaning, Arens asked his guide what the meaning was. Arens was told the meaning of Mchinja-chinja was blood-sucker. “… I learned early on that the majority of the inhabitants either had suspicions or were convinced that I consumed human blood.”(p.12) This evidence gives rise to the assumption people do not require ample evidence to conclude that a person or a group of people foreign to themselves is or was a cannibal. “… their belief in this common variation on the cannibalism theme without a shred of concrete evidence.”(p.13)
The reason this generalization is prevalent is because everyone is an “other” to someone. “In contrast to this critical position, the idea that Africans, Polynesians, New Guineans, American Indians are or were man-eaters until contact with the benefits of European influence is assumed to be in the realm of demonstrated fact.”(p.19) The theory of “others” is associated heavily with anthropology because it helps justify the agenda of “explorers”. Being an “other” helps substantiate the assumptions made by travelers arriving in distant lands. The explorers encounter new lands inhabited by people who possess things of value. The easiest way to relinquish them of their possessions is to prove they do not deserve them. Being barbaric and uncivilized was reason enough to strip a people of their belongings, to conquer and assimilate them to western civilization. This mindset causes the accepted documentation to be skewed and inaccurate; creating a pattern of savagery for future generations to reference.
An example of this is seen in Hans Staden’s story of his journey. Hans Staden, a 16th century seaman, supposedly spent a little less than a year as a captive in America. During his stay Staden was captive as well as a guest. He recalled the tribal people whom inhabited his location as being cannibalistic. Staden spoke of an extremely detailed display of savagery. Staden explained how the captives were in cages and he heard women taunting him, saying “they would eat him”. He was brought, bound, to a spot designated by the painted females were they again taunted him. He then speaks of seeing a victim who is set next to a fire, and then killed by a warrior. The women then begin to collect the body and the village begins to celebrate. “I was present and have seen all this with my own eyes.”(p.23)
The Staden example shows the stylized depiction associated with tribal people. Cannibalism was and is a fascination that has weaved itself into history, although no solid proof has ever been found. Staden’s account has no validity...

Other Essays Like Fact or Fiction: a Critique of the Man-Eating Myth: Anthropophagy and Anthropology

Theories of a Myth Essay

887 words - 4 pages both good and bad. Hercules steals from a god in one myth, but in others he is a hero and rewarded for his actions. The myth which Hercules steals, he is punished not by others, but by his own guilt. The fact that no one, besides himself, shows any kind of consequence for his stealing shows the division of good and evil within oneself as their conscious (Jung & Kerenyi, 1963). Different cultures around the world have unexplainable fears and

Adhd a Disorder, a Condition, or Myth

747 words - 3 pages 9/30/2013 A disorder, condition, or myth? Bryan Crites | Psy200 | ADHD Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder | Psy200 | ADHD Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder | After reading the paper “Sit Still and Pay Attention, Children with ADHD” given to us in class, I continued to

The Myth of Dracula

2629 words - 11 pages , just like almost every vampire in almost every myth America has ever heard (Angel site, 2004). But could such a creature truly exist? Although the vampire myth is present in many societies around the world through the centuries, there is a basis in science and fact, for this legend. To start off with, one of the most popular modern vampire stories, written in 1897, was Bram Stoker’s Dracula. To this day, it sets the bar for the modern

The Myth Of Rescue

1152 words - 5 pages that the allies could have bombed Auschwitz or the railway lines leading up to it. He says that bombing Auschwitz would have killed lots of Jews without necessarily destroying the gas chambers. And if railways lines were destroyed, others were always available for use. Now I'm going to say what I think about Rubinstein's points. In favour of him I think he made a very thoughtful point when he described the circumstances that Britain was in

The Myth Of Meat

2139 words - 9 pages omnivores do survive. A meat-based diet is, all-around, hazardous. A vegetarian (or mostly vegetarian) diet seems best to promote health and well-being. It is debated the length of time in which humans have consumed meat. Some archaeologists, based on excavations of fire-pits on the British Isles, suggest that at the very least Britons have been eating meat for the length of their occupation. However, it is unknown how much meat was consumed

The Worldview Of A Man

2194 words - 9 pages that entails. The first area of of what makes a worldview is philosophy. Philosophy is the portion of one’s worldview that provides details of how one defines truth and the methods of how one comes to that conclusion. Philosophy is powerful and often underrated. Though it has the power to override the other schools of thought in terms of whether or not someone will believe something, the common man has the propensity to either ignore or attempt

Utopia: a Philosophic and Political Work of Fiction

2175 words - 9 pages Comment on the travel-book apparatus of Utopia. What role does this play in advancing More’s thinking of the book? Utopia: a philosophic and political work of fiction The discovery of South and North America was an exciting time for all of humanity. At least, it was for those who were aware of its discovery. Those that knew details of the voyages and the new found countries, did by either being on such a voyage, or they read reports by

Consider One or More of the Ways in Which Irish Fiction Addresses the Subject of Violence

2413 words - 10 pages Ireland seem to get stuck around 1972. The subgenre of the ‘Troubles Thriller’, for example, tends towards melodrama and a sort of voyeuristic violence in which stock characters and images are recycled in more or less disabling ways (Smyth, 1997: 114) However, whilst the Troubles will always remain a large part of Ireland’s history, contemporary Irish fiction has gradually began to move away from what is labelled the ‘Trouble’s Thriller’ and a

A Poststructuralist Critique of Neorealist Conceptualizations of the State and Anarchy

5626 words - 23 pages era, I think, particularly post 9/11 that it has experienced somewhat of a comeback[3]. Whilst neorealism is not without its merits, indeed, it is both important and fundamental within policy circles,[4] I believe that in the globalised world in which we live, it leaves us in a position where we are unable to explain or understand much of the world’s conflict. In-fact, perhaps somewhat pessimistically for the neorealist, the world reveals

“What Are the Challenges That Face a Psychotherapist Working with Self-Harm or Eating Disorders?”

3276 words - 14 pages “What are the challenges that face a psychotherapist working with Self-Harm or Eating disorders?” Word count; 3046 Introduction – In this piece of work, I intend to include a description and definition of self-harm. As I believe that the term self-harm is deceptively simple I also intend on describing some of the aspects of self-harm with regards to the definition that I will be working from. Please note that the definition I will be

A Critique of Articles

519 words - 3 pages The two articles in question are Peter A.Brown’s “Restoring Perspective: $1000 for the prom is immoral” and Mitchell Farnum’s “ Color me Pro-choice”. First, let us discuss Brown’s article “Restoring Perspective”. I have never heard of Peter A.Brown before and if this is the kind of stuff he churns out, then I’ll say “Thank you God” if I never have to read another word of Brown’s composition’s in my life. If somebody thinks that’s a little

Related Papers

Fibromyalgia: Fact Or Fiction Essay

2414 words - 10 pages Fibromyalgia: Fact or Fiction Although fibromyalgia is not new and progress is being made to understand this disease the actual cause of it is still speculation. There have been many theories but nothing that has been proven. Most believe “fibromyalgia is initiated or triggered by a physical trauma such as a car accident, surgery, death of a loved one or some physiological and emotional stressors” (Envita). It is speculated that the abnormal

Sewer Alligators: Fact Or Fiction Essay

1053 words - 5 pages Sewer Alligators: Fact or Fiction? Ever imagine what it would feel if one of our darkest fears comes true. There are stories that are told around the world to scare us. It is up to each and every person who will hear it, if they would believe it or not. A story that is told throughout the years with different variations depending on the teller is classified as an urban legend. Different variations can be caused by tellers changed the plot of

Global Warmin Fact Or Fiction Essay

1050 words - 5 pages warming III. Global warming Impacts A. Global warming impacts on infrastructure B. Water quality affects people and ecosystems IV. List four things that can be done to help with global warming Running head: PROFESSION BUSINESS WRITING 3 Global Warming Fact or Fiction Introduction Global warming has changed this world drastically over the past decade. Vice President Al Gore, set

Critique Of Anthropology Essay

655 words - 3 pages Article Critique: “The Scope of Anthropological Contributions to Human Rights Investigations” In the 2005 article The Scope of Anthropological Contributions to Human Rights Investigations, by Steadman and Haglund examines the participation of anthropologists in international human rights investigations between 1990 and 1999 by surveying four of the most active organizations, including the Argentine Forensic Anthropology Team (EAAF