Felony Disenfranchisement In The United States

2775 words - 12 pages

Felony Disenfranchisement: A Stain on Democracy

Maggie Hall
POLS 413
Dr. Michael Murphy


Fundamental to the democracy which the United States of America appears to pride itself on is the right to vote.  An engrained principle of democracy, enfranchisement- the admittance to citizenship particularly through voting- is permanently altered in some states.  Is a government truly democratic if it permanently disenfranchises its citizens?  Are those who are disenfranchised less ‘citizen-like’ because of their inability to cast a ballot?  In this essay, I will argue that felon disenfranchisement in the United ...view middle of the document...

Disenfranchisement is traced back to medieval times when infamous criminals could suffer a ‘civil death’ whereby they essentially become dead in the eyes of the law.  The convicted could not participate in any aspect of the legal system including property ownership or involvement in juries (Chin 2012).  In America today, a similar ‘civil death’ occurs with felon disenfranchisement; an ex-convict appears to have broken a ‘civil contract’ and in certain states is therefore no longer permitted to participate in civil life.  Felonies inhibiting the right to vote can include first time offenses ranging from cheque fraud to murder.  It is estimated that “3.9 million Americans, or 1 in 50 adults, had either currently or permanently lost their right to vote as a result of a felony conviction” (Roberts 2004:1292).  Because of the operation of American judicial systems, “state law governs removal of the right to vote, even if the conviction is for a federal, rather than a state offence” (FELLNER GET REAL CITATION). There are nine states which subjugate ex convicts to permanent felon disenfranchisement, three of which- Alabama, Mississippi and Tennessee only after certain offences, and two which disenfranchise after a second offence- Arizona and Nevada. An additional three states disenfranchise ex-convicts for up to five years after certain offences (The Sentencing Project 2012).

Felony Disenfranchisement’s Effect on Citizenship
After committing a felony crime, a person is no less a citizen of America than they were before committing the crime. “Citizens who commit crimes cannot be forced to leave the country or legally declared noncitizens” (MANZA AND UGGEN 2006: 186), so why then is a right that is held so pertinent in the responsibilities of citizenship stripped after an illegal act? Committing a social wrong does not mean that one is any less American, or any less able to participate in legal life.

Additionally, there are many decisions passed through politics about incarceration, punishment, parole, and the like each year. By affecting citizenship through felon disenfranchisement, many states do not permit the people who these decisions would affect be a voice in deciding if they should be passed. The laws and policies relating to ex-convicts will, in some states, never get the opinion of the ex-convict himself. Judith Shklar explains that “disenfranchised Americans…have asked…that citizenship be equally distributed, so that their standing might also be recognized and their interests be defended” (1991: 30). Here we can see discontinuity; if state governments were to pass legislation on public transportation, for example, those employed or affected by the use of public transportation would have the option to vote for or against that piece of legislation. Ex-convicts do not have that luxery, in that in certain states, they become subject to laws that they were in no way permitted to voice a ballot-related opinion on. The...

Other Essays Like Felony Disenfranchisement in the United States

Drug Trafficking Methods in the United States

1333 words - 6 pages Drug Trafficking‭ ‬Methods‭ ‬in the United States ‭ ‬In‭ ‬2009,‭ ‬the United States Customs and Border Control seized over‭ ‬1,626‭ ‬tons of illegal drugs.‭ “‬The United States Customs and Border Control‭ (‬CPB‭)‬,‭ ‬is one of the Department of Homeland Security‭’‬s largest and most complex components,‭ ‬with a priority mission of keeping‭ ‬terrorists and their weapons out of the U.S.‭ ‬It also has‭ ‬a responsibility for securing and

Health Care Issues in the United States

783 words - 4 pages Health Care Issues in the United States HSA 500 Health Services Organization Management January 22, 2012 1. Explain how health is affected by behaviors, economics, and social structure. Health is affected by economic and social problems that are facing the United States today. Health insurance and medical care is still rising and impacting several Americans. However, the United States is becoming the worst health care systems in the

Hispanic Americans Rise in the United States

1613 words - 7 pages Hispanic Americans rise in the United States January 2013 The history of the United States houses many different cultures, ethnic groups and immigrants yet of these Hispanic Americans have thus far been known to be the quickest growing minority until recently. People who speak or are of Spanish, Latino or Hispanic decent are identified as Hispanic Americans in the United States being that they come generally from the Latin America region

Diversity in the United States of America

1107 words - 5 pages Diversity has been the foundation of the United States. Diversity is not limited to race, gender, or religion; it includes age and disabilities as well. I have never thought of those as aspects of diversity. I do see them in that light since taking this course and I now realize the extent of the differences in the population of America. Without that variety our country would not be as magnificent as it is. I, myself, am about as American as I

Energy Sustainability in the United States

1923 words - 8 pages Energy Sustainability in the United States When a switch is flipped, or a power button depressed, results are expected. Many daily activities rely on electricity. Without energy, drastic changes to human life would have to be hastily made. The electricity that is wired to our houses is taken for granted and the majority of discussions about conserving energy are stemmed from the arrival of the electric bill. People need an increased desire to

Research: Racial Differences In Household Wealth In The United States

1460 words - 6 pages , 2006). Lay explanations on perspective views relating to what constitute wealth have been neglected in today’s research. This study compares the nature and psychology behind racial groups’ definition of wealth within the United States Coast Guard. Using survey data collected, descriptive and multivariate procedures, an analysis of service members’ views on wealth undertaken. The United States is the wealthiest nation on earth and exhibits

The Chinese Facing Discrimination In The United States

1081 words - 5 pages Life was tough in China during the mid 19th century. People did not have enough food or money, and cities were overpopulated. Young Chinese men heard about opportunities for work in the United States such as farming, gold mining and railroad work. They believed it would be a great place to start over again. Young Chinese men came to this country with great hopes of making money, and sending it back to their families, and eventually returning to

Bilingual Education in the School Systems of the United States

1401 words - 6 pages Over half of the world’s population today is bilingual, meaning that it is able to use two languages with equal fluency, and sixty-six percent of children are raised to speak more than one language. At the same time, only 6.3 percent of children in the United States are being raised this way. In an effort to keep up with the times, many school systems throughout the world practice bilingual education, or teaching two languages simultaneously

How to Solve the Healthcare Issue in the United States

670 words - 3 pages How Can We Solve Health Care Problems? Health care is an immensely difficult problem in our society. Every industrialized country except the United States has national health care for all of its citizens. There are currently 46 million American citizens who have no health care coverage. So, this means that when these people are sick or have a toothache, it will cost them a lot more money than it will cost those of us who have health care

The History of Domestic Violence in the United States

613 words - 3 pages Historically, legal and social traditions in the United States have permitted and supported the abuse of women and children by the male head of household. This historical phenomenon helps explain why women are the primary victims of domestic violence. In this country, civil rights and legal responsibilities were first granted to free, property-owning men. Wives, children, and slaves were considered "chattel" or personal property of male

What Does Representative Democracy Really Mean in the United States?

853 words - 4 pages What does Representative Democracy really mean in the United States? by Christian Gallardo Democracy has been traditionally defined as government by the people. However, here in the U.S. we know by democracy, what is known as representative democracy. In this model, the people transfer, through voting, their sovereignty to some “Representatives”. This model has been used over time to justify the exercises power of a social minority over

Related Papers

Terrorism In The United States Essay

1254 words - 6 pages Terrorism in the United States Terrorism is like a plague. It has haunted the world as well as the United States for years. It is only currently, in light of what has happened to New York and Washington, been threatened by a nation. This newly found hatred for terrorism is not just from a government, it is from the governed as well. It is not as strait forward as one may think. There are many definitions of terrorism. The definition of

Prohibition In The United States Essay

1525 words - 7 pages through loopholes in the 18th Amendment, speakeasies, doctor’s prescriptions, and bootlegging. Bootleg alcohol was one of the main reasons organized crimes began (Organized Crime and Prohibition 1). Bootlegging was when alcohol was brought into the country illegally from outside the borders. Although, sometimes the illegal alcohol was obtained within the United States (Sifakis 725). Organized crime can be defined as unlawful activity for

Laws In The United States Essay

741 words - 3 pages Laws in the United States The United States has various laws in place, which are anticipated to foster fair, balanced, and competitive business practices. These laws are placed as control measures to help safeguard fair business practices. With anti-trust laws in place we are then warranted a since of security from unfair and anti-competitive business practices, unreasonable trade, and price discrimination. As though anything new that is

Bullying In The United States Essay

4524 words - 19 pages Bullying in the United States Introduction My main interest in this topic is how much bullying certainly can psychologically affect a student’s emotional developmental stage as well as affect students academically in school. While reading and annotating these articles I am hoping to see some impressive statistics about the research that other people had done about the affects of bullying in school. I also am really hoping to see some