Free Market Vs Planned Economy Essay

1311 words - 6 pages

Question
Compare & contrast a market economy and a planned economy in terms of the following; provision of public goods, production and consumption of merit and demerit goods, consumer sovereignty and equity in income distribution. (30marks).

A market economy is an economic system where the factors of production, are privately owned, consumers and producers are motivated by self interest, the level of competition in the markets is very high and resources are allocated through the price mechanism. The definition is supported by Lipsey (1992) who also state that decisions about resources allocation are made without any central direction but instead as a result of innumerable ...view middle of the document...

However in a planned economy there is provision of such goods because the government makes all decisions on what is produced. Hall () mentioned that public goods cannot be provided privately because of their non diminishability and non –excludability that is consumers take a free ride since no one can be excluded from consuming them so it is almost impossible for a private firm to get anyone to pay for a public good. In a planned economy the state can finance the provision of public goods like defence and police service, by means of taxation and sometimes borrowing, local authorities provide street lighting and flood control can be provided by giving contracts to private sector firms.

Production and consumption of merit and demerit goods
According to Lipsey (1992), merit goods are those goods that the government compels or encourages people to consume, mainly because individuals are said to be unaware of the true benefits from consuming them. He also added that demerits goods are those goods which the state forbids people to consume mainly because individual are said to be unaware of the true harm they would suffer by consuming them. The best known examples of merit goods are health, education systems, insurance, inoculation and seat belts. The provision of merit goods in a free market economy tent to be under provided because spending on merit goods by the consumer would be determined by the private benefits derived from them. Like in United State of America where the free market is practised, the public health system compromised, people are advised to buy health insurance. The poor might not be able to afford this and some people might simply decide not to bother if they feel particularly health. In cases of seat belts consumers may fail to recognise their true private benefits hence less demand and less supply in a free economy. The demerit goods include cigarettes, alcohol and illegal drugs. These are over consumed in a market system because consumers may be unaware of the true cost of consuming them which includes negative externalities.
However in a planned economy there is an increase in the production and consumption of merit goods because the government considers them to be highly desirable for the welfare of the citizens. In this economic system the government has central authority to make decisions on the commodities to be produced hence emphasis will be placed on the production of merit goods and consumption of demerits will be reduced. The state can increase the production of merit goods by providing free state education and national health services. Contracts for services like refuse collection can be given to private sector firms. The government can also encourage the consumption of merit goods by providing information about the benefits of inoculation and passing legislation requiring vehicles to take and pass the vid tests. In the command economy production and consumption of demerit goods is reduced with the purpose of...

Other Essays Like Free Market vs Planned Economy

Bond Math Essay

696 words - 3 pages return on the Copiers, Inc. Bond when it was issued. Rating | AAA |   | AA |   | A |   | BBB | Beta | 0.19 | | 0.20 | | 0.21 | | 0.22 | Source: Fama, Gene and Ken French, 1993, "Common Risk Factors in the Returns on Bonds and Stocks", on Bonds and Stocks, “Journal of Financial Economics, 33, 3-56, Table 4 | Expected Return Rate = (Risk Free Return) + (Beta) * (Expected Market Return – Risk Free Return) Risk Free Return: Treasury

Economic Systems Essay

618 words - 3 pages well. The more the producers are able to provide goods and services, the greater their incomes will be. The goods and services produced thus will be of a quality that the consumer wants and not of some distant quality. Individual workers are free to choose the jobs they want. However, goods and services go to those with the most dollars. Businesses may be able to control the market for a good/service. Mixed System A mixed economy (also called a

Microecononics

707 words - 3 pages compensates people based on the work that they are able to do, and does not accord all work the same value, serious income disparities quickly arise. (ii) Lower Employment Rates: In many socialist economic systems, the desire for equality and the lower efficiency that comes from a planned economy has at least one positive side: high, or even universal, levels of employment. (iii) Overproduction: free-market economies tend to suffer from overproduction

Managerial Economics

516 words - 3 pages method in which to organize economic activity and far preferable to having the economy directed by a central planning authority, such as a governmental body. Under the market economy, buyers and sellers are free to enter transactions and seek those that bring them the greatest benefit. Government * Although most economists prefer market economies to centrally planned, or government-directed, systems, they recognize that government has an

Market Economy

1857 words - 8 pages report will cover why there can never be a truly ‘free market’ economy, where there is absolutely no government intervention. Market Economy In a market economy, the majority of a nation’s land, factories, and other economic resources are privately owned, either by individuals or businesses (Wild, Wild & Han 2010:151). It is also an economy in which prices of goods and services are freely set based on the laws of supply and demand which are

States-Markets Relations

2590 words - 11 pages because of lack of democratic institutions and unability to transform of a strictly state controlled market to an open one. In these days, they are still attemps to adopt more protective economic system as well as continuation of transformation to free market economy. As an example for late developer, China has had before Marxist Economy (controlled by Communist Party), it had a centrally planned market in which everything is controlled by state

Keynes vs Classical

694 words - 3 pages Classical vs. Keynes The Classical and Keynesian approaches are similar because they are both theories which try to explain the economy and try to decide the best strategy to take during a time of recession and inflation. While they are alike because they are both economic theories, the content of both of these theories is very different. Either one has been deemed as the “perfect” solution, but we can learn a lot from these models, and try to

Master in Management

1822 words - 8 pages . (Scale economies) Market vs. Structural Approaches   Antitrust represents a political and social philosophy, and interpretations of the support for that philosophy vary considerably. Market (competitive) view -- current laws should be enforced to allow the economic system to operate closely to the free market norm. Market Enthusiasts    The most dangerous sort of market power is that which emerges from

The Financial Analysis for Davide Jones

1517 words - 7 pages FY2005 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 22 $m 8 GP % to Sales Outlook FY06 market conditions as expected Cycling high 1Q05 sales growth of 7.7% enhanced by Olympics and Interest Free Sales for 1Q06 forecast at -3% to -4%, with non big ticket categories flat Anticipate 2Q06 will see a modest improvement with flat sales growth for Christmas quarter Further strengthening of sales growth in 2H06 Confident that Company’s business model will deliver 5%-10% PAT

Global Business Cultural Analysis-Sweden

5422 words - 22 pages planned for, then the business can focus primarily on the advantages that lead to success. Competitiveness of the Swedish nation. According to Kettles (2012), in Sweden's position in the Global Economy, "economy market shares have been eroding, especially in the first half of the last decade but this seems largely a reflection of trade being substituted by foreign direct investment". The article goes on to say how the trade profile of Sweden has

The U.S. Weight Loss Market: 2014 Status Report & Forecast

816 words - 4 pages (who qualifies), CVS drugstore chain enters market with mini-clinic program, threat posed by Walmart, weight loss & fitness apps – how big a threat?, new diet books, reasons why market growth is slow – how diet companies can execute better, customize programs, form new retail partnerships, and more. The U.S. weight loss market has entered a new phase of flat to low growth, constrained mainly by a weak economy and a shift to do-it-yourself plans

Related Papers

The Planned Economy Vs. The Free Market Economy

392 words - 2 pages The Planned Economy which is the economy that the government "organises" is very different from the Free Market Economy where the private sector is in charge and owns firms etc...The planned economy is better in the sense that people are less stressed due to not having to worry about their next meal or other, due to the government supplying their basic needs like housing, medical care, food, clothes, education, a job, so nobody is unemployed yet

To What Extent Do You Agree That A Free Market Economy Is The Only Approach To Bringing About Economic Growth

2716 words - 11 pages centrally planned governments. (Economy Watch, 2010) However, despite the excellent provision of public and merit goods, command economies tend to fail and become inefficient due to the sheer scale of planning and available information. (Amadeo, 2012) Where the free market uses signalling between producers and consumers through demand and supply, it is difficult for a centrally planned economy to read such signals when there is no competition and the

Hayek Vs Keynes: How Much Influence Should Governments Have In The Economy?

2143 words - 9 pages masterminds’ differing views, its first important to show what is meant when I refer to ‘central planning’. By central planning, I do not mean a centrally-planned economy akin to that of Communism, whereby the state allocates the entirety of the resources on its own. By central-planners I am referring to the part of the government that act to counter some of the free-market forces that can often cause such social issues as inequality. It is fairly

Assigment Essay

2173 words - 9 pages Introduction Economic system is defined as the basic arrangements made by societies to solve the economic problem. There are three economic systems that classification by degree of government control. The three economic systems are Command Economy System (Socialism). A system where the government, rather than the free market, determines what goods should be produced, how much should be produced and the price at which the goods will be offered