This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

French Canadian English Canadian Hostiliy Essay

5674 words - 23 pages

The war between France and England ended decades ago; but the conflict between the French and English speaking settlers in Canada could still be felt as a result of many events and issues.
Confederation was never enthusiastically embraced in Quebec as it evidently was in Ontario. Since, by Confederation, Quebec only had about 40% of the population of the United Province of Canada, to share equally in the government put it in an advantageous position; this was so much so that it was Upper Canada that now complained about the Union and its most important political leader of the time, George Brown, claimed that the province had become ‘French dominated’. ...view middle of the document...

It is the realization of all of these possible losses that made many Quebecers hesitate about Confederation and generated quite a bit of apprehension and opposition. When the vote was taken in the Legislative Assembly of the United Province of Canada on the Confederation project, about 40% of the members from Quebec voted against it. Nearly half of the newspapers of the province were opposed to Confederation. This not only reflects the great reluctance of Quebecers for Confederation but also supports the idea that the majority rallied behind Confederation, albeit without enthusiasm.
What brought Quebec to support Confederation?
Five main reasons explain why the majority in Quebec eventually supported Confederation:
Political realism: Even the most reluctant Quebecer must have realized by 1864 that the United Province of Canada had become ungovernable. Sectionalism was a constant problem (what language to use? How much confessionals should there be in schools? Should we resort to conscription to protect our territory against the threat of the United States? Where should the capital be? Does each section have a fair share of the civil service and of government expenditures?), the Province was embroiled in a hopeless political deadlock, it was impossible to establish a government that lasted any significant amount of time (we count thirteen governments in a period of eight years at some point), and Rep by Pop was unacceptable in the context of the Union. This state of affairs could not continue indefinitely and, if it remained unresolved by the lack of agreement between Upper and Lower Canada, it was feared that Britain would intervene to resolve the problems. If England intervened, as had been done in 1840-41, it was evident that the solution it would impose might not be favourable to Quebec. Political wisdom, common sense, dictated that Quebecers cooperate in making changes and attempt, in the process, to safeguard vital interests.
The support of powerful elites: Political realism was especially displayed by the power elites of the time (political, economical and clerical). They understood the problems outlined above and they wished to apply pragmatic solutions. The period of Confederation was not yet a particularly democratic time, as we would understand or apply democracy today, but one where elites considered issues and made the necessary accommodations. And when the elites agreed, and made the accommodations, the people were expected to follow; they were rarely consulted and their views mattered very little unless the elites disagreed. There is no doubt that Confederation was going to be good for business, that the political elites of French Canada (people like George Etienne Cartier) thought that Confederation would impact positively on the survival of French Canada and on their own career and, thus, should be supported. The...

Other Essays Like French Canadian -English Canadian Hostiliy

it280 week 1 Essay

1391 words - 6 pages Call Canadian Module Call Mexican Module Call English Module Call Japanese Module Call French Module Call Exit Module Call Output Module Input module Declare Currency Type as integer Display “Welcome to Foreign Currency Converter” Display “Please select a type of currency (Enter 1 – 6)” Display “1 Canadian Dollars” Display “2 Mexican Pesos” Display “3 English Pounds” Display “4 Japanese Yenâ

English & French Relations Essay

1141 words - 5 pages Quebec is a large part of Canada's history. It was one of the first provinces to join the confederation in 1867 . With its population of 6.7 million Quebec is the home to nearly 25 percent of Canada's population . Québec has the majority of French-speaking Canadians in Canada. French and English relations have declined in the past century. There are many factors that caused this damage but several events in Canadian history largely

The Saint-Gabriel Museum

2013 words - 9 pages with was spoken by the majority of Canadians. The Saint-Gabriel Museum argues that there are more than 2000 curse words in French Canadian vocabulary. The other reason the Sacres are a part of the identity of the Quebecers is because they are part of their Roman Catholic roots. English Canadians had their Anglo-Protestant traditions did not identify with this minority. J.S. Tassie states, “French-Canadian society has been essentially theocratic in

Hie 208 4-1-1

1032 words - 5 pages , the King government had to use conscription and force military service. Conscription divided Canada along language and cultural lines – French versus English Canada. Once again, conscription had little impact on the war as World War II ended less than a year later and worsened relations between English-French Canada. The military of World War I had failed to grasp technology fast enough before battle and this was

Genuine Meaning of Being Canadian

1563 words - 7 pages ENG3U1b 25 February 2013 The Genuine Meaning of Being Canadian What does it really mean to be Canadian? People have numerous statements to define themselves "Canadian". Many individuals would recognise themselves as Canadian citizens simply because they were born in Canada. In fact, it is sometimes the occasion that even people from different races may tell you that they are "just" or "100%" Canadian, when you ask their background. On the

Wilfrid Laurier

1863 words - 8 pages being recommended by their local politician (Stewart 40). During Laurier’s reign, Canada was constantly changing and Wilfrid Laurier ensured that it was changing for the better. In the relations between English and French Canadians, Laurier tried to have diversity accepted as a characteristic of Canadian culture (Désilets). His amazing public speaking skills were able to convince people of the rightness of his ideas (Désilets). Wilfrid Laurier

The Uncertain Future of Quebec Culture

1424 words - 6 pages at other parts of Canada that have roughly the same policy. The Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) has a fixed quota at 60% of television content must be Canadian, for English Canada, but this does not cause a rise in the production of Canadian content. (Donaldson, 1970) Tremblay is clearly picking and choosing the facts and interpreting them in his own way. Later in the article, he even admits that if American

Social Studies Rebellion Essay

863 words - 4 pages Open protest, conflicting interests, lives changed forever. This is a rebellion. You’re willing to fight the authorities to be heard. Armed rebellion is only justifiable if nothing else works. The Rebellions of Upper and Lower Canada, Red River Rebellion, and Northwest Rebellion are all part of Canadian history. They show us that people can go against the government which usually results in a large loss of life, but more importantly change

Canadian History and Defining Moments

1526 words - 7 pages design, leaving no hope for the program to be reinstated. Canadian scientists had no where to work except in the U.S. The Canadian scientists that migrated to the U.S. for work, naturally we drawn to N.A.S.A. where their skills and talents could be put to the challenge. In conclusion, Canada has a very unique and interesting history, from the French and English cultures, to the rich Aboriginal history. Among this long, and unique

Reconciliation Quebec

882 words - 4 pages 1995 referendum. The Québécois have been forced to choose whether they are more loyal to Canada or Quebec. Québécois are very proud of their French inheritance so when Anglophones moved in to Québec and started using English more instead of French the Québécois felt like they were losing their culture and tradition. The Québécois decided to start a revolution. This was called The Quiet Revolution and it began in 1971 with the reforms enacted by

Law And The Government Trashing The Incumbent : Lesson From Canada

2512 words - 11 pages Trashing the incumbent: Lesson from CanadaIN 1984, Prime Minister Brian Mulroney was swept to power in the biggest landslide in Canadian history. But unpopular economic policies and his failure to resolve a dispute with French speaking Quebec undermined his political popularity and support, which eventually turned him into one of Canada's most unpopular leaders ever. Son of a poor Irish immigrant in the northern Quebec, Mulroney announced he

Related Papers

Trudeau's Efforts At Achieving Canadian Unity (East/West, French/English)

1157 words - 5 pages Throughout Canadian history, the idea of national unity has been challenged numerous times, mainly by conflicts between English and French Canadians. In the past half-century, however, the issue of Western alienation from federal politics has developed into a significant obstacle to Canadian unity. While the government of Pierre Elliott Trudeau was in power, its main focus was on resolving these conflicts to bring about a true sense of national

Federalism And The French Canadian Pierre Trudeau

1577 words - 7 pages incompetence. Needless to say, this won him few friends from Quebec's nationalist community. Nevertheless, it is these ideas that are the basis for his 1968 compilation of essays, Federalism and the French Canadian. It provides a fascinating glimpse behind the public image of Trudeau and thirty years later shows just where he came from and what ideals and beliefs drove him.A recurring theme running through the essays in the book is an us-versus

The Canadian Identity Essay

1105 words - 5 pages “village”. There has been three main founders of this country we call Canada today, namely the Aboriginal, British and French. The aboriginal were believed to have migrated from Asia thousands of years ago before any settlement of the Europeans. Their history forms a great big part of the Canadian identity together with their achievements in the agriculture and arts and their rights being well protected under the Canadian constitution. The English

Currency Conversion Essay

673 words - 3 pages = TRUE Convert_Currency Display Results End If End If Until Continue = FALSE End Main Module Display_Menu Declare Boolean Valid_Entry Display “Welcome to Eric’s Foreign Currency Converter” Display “Please select from the following” Display “1 Canadian Dollars” Display “2 Mexican Pesos” Display “3 English Pounds” Display “4 Japanese Yen” Display “5 French Francs” Display “6 Quit” Repeat Input Foreign_Currency_Type