Give A Critical Account Of Freud’s Understanding Of Religion

1006 words - 5 pages

Give a critical account of Freud’s understanding of religion.
To answer the set question I will explore Freud’s Totem and Taboo looking at his theory of the primal horde and Oedipus complex and his theory on religion as an illusion. Also looking at Freud’s theory that religion is unhealthy psychologically. To conclude I will explore his relationship with Jung and the affect his criticism of Freud’s theory had on their professional collaboration.
Freud’s interpretation of the totem as representing the father of the tribe returns again to Freud’s problems with his own father. He approaches his Totem and Taboo theory from entirely a patriarchal stance ignoring the fact that his case ...view middle of the document...

His theory is one sided and focused only on male dominance, he is ignorant to the female role and the effect that it had on tribe thus neglecting vital evidence.
Connolly (1999, 177) recognises that the Oedipus complex may be a factor in the development of some individuals and an understanding of it may be helpful when seeking to make sense of their beliefs and behaviours, but as a primary factor underlying all forms of religion it must be rejected.
Freud believed that religion originated in man’s feeling of helplessness (Storr, 1989, 110). He saw religion as a weakness and a crutch and a symptom of not being fully developed psychologically. Believing that obsessional rituals were ways of protecting the ego from the emergence of phantasies, thoughts or sexual impulses which the individual repressed (Storr, 1989, 111). He concluded that a patient who compulsively washed his hands felt guilt about masturbation. In his conclusion Freud fails to understand the reason for the ritual of cleansing within religious practice instead depending solely on his own theory. Monotheistic religion was viewed as attracting obsessional and compulsive neurosis.
Freud’s obsession with his sexual theory seems to have clouded his judgement on religious experience. His reluctance to consider that religion is beneficial to the psychological well-being of its believers severely damages his theories. The fact that Freud himself had obsessive tendencies and as he admitted could be obstinate ties in with his reluctance to accept criticism from any quarter especially that of his protégé Jung.
Jung’s theory on religion and his claim that Freud’s denouncement of religion was the cause of his sexual theory would end their relationship. Jung criticised Freud’s approach and his lack of understanding or even attempting to understand a person’s feeling as a result of religious experience. For Jung, then, it is not the presence of religion which is a symptom of neurosis but its absence. (Palmer, 1997, 92). Freud saw religion as a...

Other Essays Like Give A Critical Account Of Freud’S Understanding Of Religion

Assess the Usefulness of Functionalist Theories in Understanding Religion Today

657 words - 3 pages explain religion to teach us how to conform by teaching us morals and norms; doing this we learn social control and order. This theory and way of looking at religion gives us a good understanding of religion, therefore when looking at Durkheim’s theories of religion they are reasonably useful. A second theorist is Parsons; Parsons emphasised the role of religion in providing the core values of any culture, along with the social norms which

Assess the of Functionalist Theories in Understanding Religion Today

1223 words - 5 pages Assess the of Functionalist theories in understanding religion today Functionalists have put forward their perspective on religion and how it benefits both society and the individual starting with how religion brings people together harmoniously, creating social cohesion and a sense of belonging as people believe in the same thing and all abide by the same rules. Religion creates and maintains a value consensus whilst giving society social

Balance of Payment, Current Account, Capital Account

1001 words - 5 pages year. It represents a summation of country's current demand and supply of the claims on foreign currencies and of foreign claims on its currency. These transactions include payments for the country's exports and imports of goods, services, financial capital, and financial transfers. Current account:The difference between a nation’s savings and its investment. The current account is an important indicator about an economy's health. It is defined

Managment of Account Receivable

4263 words - 18 pages retaining customers. The following modern payment methods are available and provide the benefits of added customer service, reducing remittance processing costs and improving cash flow through faster debtor turnover. Direct debit - involves authorisation for the transfer of funds from the purchaser’s bank account; this approach has the advantage of reduced processing costs, however it can present security exposures. Integrated Voice Response - a

Evaluate the Extent to Which Freud’s Theory of Psychosexual Development Can Help Us to Understand a Client’s Presenting Issue?

2999 words - 12 pages Evaluate the extent to which Freud’s theory of psychosexual development can help us to understand a client’s presenting issue? (Word count 2,749 excluding bibliography, references) Sigmund Freud’s theory of psychosexual development is based on the idea that parents play a pivotal role in the sexual and aggressive drives that form in the early years of their child’s development. Freud (Freud & Philips 2006) proposed that psychological

A Written Account Of Laboratory Work: Body Temperature

1716 words - 7 pages Body Temperature represents the balance of heat produced and heat lost. In order for optimum functioning, the body needs to maintain a core temperature within the ranges of 36.1 to 37.8 degrees Celsius (Marieb, 2000). The purpose of this laboratory report is firstlty to describe the normal physiology of temperature control. The assignment will then focus on an experiment that was carried out in order to determine the effect that ingestion of hot

Analysis of a Critical Situation

967 words - 4 pages Analysis of a Critical Regulatory Issue in Health Care Alfreda Bostick HCS/430 December 5, 2011 Lori Lewellen Analysis of a Critical Regulatory Issue in Health Care There are many types of critical regulatory issues that trouble the medical field. Never has anything been more important that the critical regulatory issue been more important than dealing with life or death. When a situation of this nature arises, a person must follow his

Reflective Account of Sfe Role

722 words - 3 pages The Introductory Reflective Account requires you to describe what you do in your work role, how you do it and why.  * the type of organisation you are working in * the range and purpose of services provided by your organisation * your organisation's aims and objectives * the range of customers, clients or service users who make use of the services * the range of activities you are involved in on a regular basis Briefly

A Critical Review of Progression in Mathematics

3416 words - 14 pages and future lessons. Summative Assessment “This is carried out to collect data about the pupils about their understanding of a unit of work and to be able to benchmark them against their class and nationally”. (Black et al., 2005) These usually take the form of tests, such as end of term or end of year tests. The grade boundaries of these tests usually give students a National Curriculum level at KS3 or a GCSE grade at KS4. There are

Critical Analysis of "To Kill a Mockingbird"

1752 words - 8 pages Task 2: Critical Analysis Ngien Sing Jier For this semester, we are analysing a novel entitled ‘To Kill a Mockingbird’ written by Harper Lee. I find this novel very meaningful and interesting to read as well. After reading and analysing the novel a few times along with the teachings of my lecturer, I can differentiate the story told from different perspectives, parts when Scout was young and parts when she was an adult. It is about the life

A Critical Review of Strategy as Revolution

1407 words - 6 pages A Critical Review of STRATEGY AS REVOLUTION Introduction Hamel strategic revolution seems to be the value of re-cognition. In the "Strategy is revolution", Hamel said that "Let us face the reality of it: the world is about to reach the asymptotic limit of the development." For enterprises, "or else it will hand over to the next challenger who has a revolutionary or innovation spirit, or on their company's strategic approach to a revolution

Related Papers

Assess Freud’s Contribution To The Sociological Understanding Of ‘The Self’

3811 words - 16 pages . Capitalism and consumerism have transformed cultures and developed new ‘selves’. The term ‘century of the self’ has often been associated with modern times. What has Bernays contributed to a sociological understanding of the self and how could Freud’s theory account for some of society’s ills we face today such as mental illnesses (e.g. depression) and excessive amounts of violence (e.g. murder)? Lastly, I will draw a comparison between Freud and Elias

Give An Account Of Derrida On Forgiveness And The Unforgivable

2447 words - 10 pages 1While Derrida is perhaps best known among literary theorists and Continental philosophers, the importance of his work to the question of religion has received growing critical attention. Derrida's writings on religion address and question many of the fundamental concepts that inform the three Abrahamic religions and their cultures. Derrida's writings attempt to rethink the logic of religious difference and elucidate its significance for

Evaluate Freud’s Theory Of Psychosexual Development

2550 words - 11 pages “Evaluate the extent to which Freud’s theory of psycho-sexual development can help us to understand a client’s presenting issue”. To being this assignment I will explain the different stages of psycho sexual development. Identifying some of the defense mechanisms that are used by adults in their daily lives. Views by other psychologists, on the contributing factors, that are also considered to be accountable for human behavior. Freud (1856

“A Critical Assesment Of Religion Today In The Philippines: Reality And Challenges; Weaknesses And Oppurtunities”

822 words - 4 pages RONIE BOTONA RESEARCH AND METHODOLOGY I Professor: Fr. Dave Capucao “A CRITICAL ASSESMENT OF RELIGION TODAY IN THE PHILIPPINES: REALITY AND CHALLENGES; WEAKNESSES AND OPPURTUNITIES” Religion is humanity’s way to be in connection with the divine. It can be traced centuries ago. In the Philippines, religion existed already during pre-colonialization. However it was only during the colonialization period that religion becomes a power to