Homosexuality And Misogyny In Frankenstein Essay

2621 words - 11 pages

Homosexuality and Misogyny in Frankenstein

 
    In Mary Shelley's novel, Victor Frankenstein suffers an extreme psychological crisis following his violation of what is considered a fundamental biological principle.  His creation of life undermines the role of women in his life and the role of sexuality, and allows existing misogynist and homosexual tendencies to surface.  Victor represses what he has uncovered about himself, and it merges into a cohesive whole in his psyche that becomes projected on the instrument of revelation, the monster. 

 

Victor's creation allows him to split his sexuality into independent components.  There are three fundamental purposes to sexuality ...view middle of the document...

  When Victor's mother dies, she says to Elizabeth, in Victor's presence, "Elizabeth, my love, you must supply my place to your younger cousins."  (828)  Victor will now marry his mother, rather than his sister.

 

She begins with a gender-neutral title as his cousin, and then takes a gender specific, non-sexual role as his sister.  She then replaces his mother, implying an indirect sexual relationship with Victor, since he is product of his mother's sexuality.  Finally, she enters a sexual relationship with Victor as his future wife.  Her murder then interrupts the progression by preventing the consummation of that relationship.  In the 1831 version this progression of intimacy is strengthened.  Elizabeth, while a small child, is presented to Victor by his mother as a gift.  He takes responsibility for her, and takes pride in her achievements, like a father to a daughter.  The father/daughter relationship is tied to sexual reproduction in the same way as the mother/son relationship.  The progression from daughter to mother implies Victor's exit from her vagina as an infant, and then the next change from mother to wife implies a desire to re-enter her body as part of a sexual relationship.

 

Mary Shelley presents Victor engaging with Elizabeth in all social female roles: wife, mother, and sister.  He is also presented as engaging with her body in all possible variations, creating her body through fatherhood, being formed out of her body as a child, and entering her body as a husband.  She takes all female roles and therefore represents Victor's interaction with all of them.  The incestuous nature of Victor's relationship with her, improving on Oedipus by marrying both his mother and his sister, give us good reason to believe that Victor may find heterosexual relationships distasteful and nauseating.

 

When Victor creates the monster, Victor has a dream in which he holds Elizabeth and kisses her, only to find that she has become his dead mother.  Continuing, the image is of his mother's corpse in its shroud, being eaten by worms. In that moment, Elizabeth and Victor's mother are connected in the kiss, the only sexual interaction Victor has with a woman.  As the communal female figure dies, Victor awakes, and the first thing he sees upon opening his eyes is the monster, lifting the bed-curtains and reaching one hand out towards him, as if to detain him.

 

The monster has entered the room, and bent down to lift the bed-curtains.  This implies bending at the waist for a horizontal torso.  Given his position, and since Victor sees the monster as trying to "detain" him, the monster's hand is presumably extending palm down over Victor's body.  This is significant in that the two classic features of extending a hand in friendship, to a human being or a dog, for that matter, are to place the hand palm up or extend it from below, not the highly threatening gesture of lowering a hand from above.  Since he does not actually...

Other Essays Like Homosexuality And Misogyny In Frankenstein

Frankenstein Essay

698 words - 3 pages "About Mary Shelley." About Mary Shelley. N.p., n.d. Web. 14 Jan. 2013. "Baldick, "The Monster Speaks"" Baldick, "The Monster Speaks" N.p., n.d. Web. 14 Jan. 2013. Baldick, Chris. In Frankenstein’s Shadow: Myth, Monstrosity, and Nineteenth-Century Writing. Oxford, England: Clarendon Press, 1987. Bernard E. Rollin. Frankenstein Syndrome: Ethical and Social Issues in the Genetic Engineering of Animals. Cambridge University Press, 1995. Betty T

Frankenstein Victor and Monster Comparison Essay

758 words - 4 pages Frankenstein In the story Frankenstein, Mary Shelley sways her readers towards a life of neglection towards science. She uses both Frankenstein and the creature as doppelgangers to create tension throughout the story to move plot along. Frankenstein and the monster are clones of each other that Shelley utilizes to demonstrate the vengefulness that science and knowledge has created. Society pushes Frankenstein and the monster to thrive off

Frankenstein-Knowledge and the Desire to Know

1162 words - 5 pages Question 3. Examine some of the ways in which Mary Shelley presents knowledge, and the desire to know, as a problem in Frankenstein. The desire to know, to learn and to educate ones-self was a recurring preoccupation for Romantic writers. What particularly troubles them is the recognition that the traditional grounds of knowledge are far from certain (Swingle 58). Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein is a novel predominantly about knowledge

Frankenstein By Mary Shelly Show metamorphosis in the Book Frankenstein by Mary Shelly

450 words - 2 pages Metamorphosis In "Frankenstein"According to www.Dictionary.com metamorphosis is a transformation, as by magic or sorcery. Frankenstein seems to be using magic or sorcery to bring his creation to life. Also according to www.Dictionary.com change is to be or cause to be different. When Frankenstein's creation was first brought to life he was kind and needing of love from his creator like a newborn child longs for its mother. Throughout the story

Frankenstein: the First Modern Monster Story

1311 words - 6 pages Frankenstein: The First Modern Monster Story When we hear Frankenstein the image that many of us think of today is that of a mindless monster with bolts in his neck who wishes to terrorize anyone who crosses his path. This image is far different from that of the monster in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein. In Shelley’s novel Frankenstein’s monster is smart, caring, and he posses near super human strength and speed. Frankenstein is thought to be

American Psycho

1760 words - 8 pages . Looking cursorily at the realism, for example, it is quickly obvious that Bateman is not supported by the style of the book. The writing is surely darkly comic- a feature made even more apparent in the film. Nevertheless the film is not exempt from accusations of misogyny. The core of the discussion about American Psycho and many other texts related to it lies the question of whether it is truly possible to have a male protagonist and not to

Essay On Shelley's Frankenstein And Milton's Paradise Lost

3270 words - 14 pages Paradise Lost and Frankenstein, the relationships become quite a bit more complex as well delve more deeply into authorial interpretation.  From a feminine perspective, John Milton seems to have provided a text which is filled with his own ideas, though he claims to have written it via the "heavenly muse."  Misogyny is omnipresent in Paradise Lost.  The first female figure we are presented with is Sin, who is the embodiment of all evil at the time of

Frnakenstein

1782 words - 8 pages Which character does the reader feel most sympathy towards: Victor Frankenstein or the creature? Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein belongs to a number of literary genres. It belongs to science fiction as it is a story of a scientist who wants to create life without using the natural process between man and women. The idea of creating a being from dead flesh belongs to gothic horror. Gothic horror is used to create powerful emotions in the reader

Frankenstien and Blade Runner Comparative

1035 words - 5 pages similarly uses imagery and allusions to hint at the consequences humanity will suffer if they attempt to better God through the manipulation of science and the exploitation of nature. Humanity’s rejection of the natural world in favour of the unnatural pursuit of technology advancement to stretch life is a major concern in both Frankenstein and Blade Runner. In Frankenstein, nature is an important aspect of a person’s life and beliefs. Shelley

The True Villain In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

2811 words - 12 pages The True Villain in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein Mary Shelly is best known for her chilling Gothic horror tale "Frankenstein". The story is world famous and is still relevant today. There are two main characters in the novel. There's the young ambitious student playing god which is Victor Frankenstein who's finding the secret of giving life and there's the gentle hearted, gruesome monster who must hide from society

Frankenstein: Deep Down We’re All Afreud

965 words - 4 pages event, whether it was in the past or present. He heavily relies on them to help avoid emotions and sometimes to portray his flawed qualities into his work. Throughout the novel, Frankenstein uses defense mechanisms such as repression and intellectualization to help deal with his daily life and past experiences. Repression is a commonly used defense mechanism and occurs when the individual pushes unpleasant memories or emotions into his or her

Related Papers

Sublime In Frankenstein And Bladerunner Essay

855 words - 4 pages The Sublime in Frankenstein and Blade Runner ‘Sublime’ refers to the effect of nature on the human - the beauty and/or terror of the scene creates a sense of awe in the observer. In Frankenstein, the sublime transcends romanticism and the traditions of gothic literature. Shelley’s vivid descriptions of the natural landscape convey a romantic appreciation of the beauty of nature, but they are mingled with a sense of Gothic terror. While the

Vanity In "The Picture Of Dorian Gray" And "Frankenstein"

417 words - 2 pages "The quality or state of being vain; want of substance to satisfy desire; emptiness; unsubstantialness; unrealness; falsity", is the definition of vanity according to Webster's revised unabridged dictionary. Vanity destroys lives. In the novels "Frankenstein" by Mary Shelley, "The Mayor of Casterbridge" by Thomas Hardy, and "The Picture of Dorian Gray" by Oscar Wilde, one can see the way vanity destroys the lives of a character.In Frankenstein

How Do The Writers Mary Shelley And Robert Louise Stevenson Present The Notion Of The “Monster”, In Frankenstein And Dr Jekyll And Mr Hyde?

783 words - 4 pages How do the writers Mary Shelley and Robert Louise Stevenson present the notion of the “monster”, in Frankenstein and Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde? The authors Mary Shelley and Robert Louise Stevenson have both written their novels “Frankenstein” and “Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde” using the gothic genre. Their novels show in similar and in different ways how monsters can act and behave. Both novels have differences but they are both similar when presenting

Essay On How The Author Of Frankenstein Illustrates The Sublimity Of Nature, Victor's Feelings At Meeting The Monster And How The Author Portrays The Monsters Attitude And Feelings In Volume Ii,...

1057 words - 5 pages Essay on how the author of Frankenstein illustrates the sublimity of nature, Victor's feelings at meeting the monster and how the author portrays the monsters attitude and feelings in Volume II, Chapter IIMary Shelly displays the abnormality and strangeness of the monster in several ways. In her description of Victor's encounter with the monster it is said that the monster advances towards Victor at a "superhuman speed". The word "superhuman