How Adequate Is Mill’s Conception Of Happiness? How Good Are His Arguments To Show That “Higher” Pleasures Are Intrinsically More Desirable Than “Lower” Ones? Is This Distinction Consistent With The Thesis That Pleasure

2110 words - 9 pages

How adequate is Mill’s conception of happiness? How good are his arguments to show that “higher” pleasures are intrinsically more desirable than “lower” ones? Is this distinction consistent with the thesis that pleasure is the only thing of value?

In “Utilitarianism” Mill argues that ‘higher’ pleasures are intrinsically more valuable than ‘lower’ pleasures, citing the invariable preference of men who have access to both available (pp.140). I am inclined to disagree, particularly with regards to his assertion that ‘higher’ pleasures have such a “superiority of quality”(pp.139), so as to render any quantity of ‘lower’ pleasures “in comparison, of small account”- this non-cardinal view of ...view middle of the document...

But does this mean that ‘higher’ pleasures are intrinsically better? Not necessarily. It is a non sequitur argument- the conclusion doesn’t necessarily follow from the premise. After all, even if they were just as enjoyable as ‘lower’ ones, we may still choose to be the intelligent man in Mill’s example. There are numerous arguments for this:
1. We may simply prefer a diversity of pleasures. The intelligent man has access to physical pleasures as well as those of the higher faculties. Even if both are equally enjoyable, it is reasonable to prefer the possibility of both in exchange for a slightly lower level of ‘contentment’.
2. Tellingly, in one of a series of comparisons used to highlight our intuitive respect and desire for a consciousness that has can employ the higher faculties, Mill compares “Socrates”, and a “fool” (pp.140). The fact that Mill even knows of Socrates, more than 2,000 years after his death suggests one reason why we may wish to chose the intelligent man over the fool- society as a whole respects these men and women, and they leave a far greater impact on history. Apart from the ‘higher’ pleasures available to the intelligent, there are other reasons that may lead us to choose their lifestyle, such as historic recognition.
3. There is nothing in this argument to suggest that ‘higher’ pleasures are better in kind- that our preference for them is not simply a matter of degree. Higher pleasures may be more pleasurable than ‘lower’ ones, but this is not necessarily enough to render considerations of duration or intensity “of small account” (pp.139).
Of course, we may be inclined to agree with Mill despite these objections- they do not prove him wrong, merely weaken his argument. In Mill’s favour is the seemingly fundamental difference between human and animal pleasures, and ‘higher’ and ‘lower’ pleasures as an extension of this. He draws our attention to this with his assertion that we would prefer to be a “human being unsatisfied than a pig satisfied” (pp.140). This seems similar to earlier comparisons, but there is an important distinction. Mill highlights that anyone who doesn’t believe there are intrinsically more desirable higher pleasures is forced to concede it would be better to live as a beast. ‘Higher’ pleasures are an embodiment of our higher faculties and I believe that our enjoyment of these is an important marker of what makes us human. Which animal enjoys solving mathematics? Thus, as far as the distinction between human and animal pleasures, Mill’s claim seems reasonable.
Another strength of Mill’s argument is his choice of words surrounding the ‘lower’ pleasures. We are told of a “satisfied” pig, and a “content” fool (pp.139-140). These sound like oxymoron, but also remind us of the much higher capacity for enjoyment of more intelligent people. A fool is easily contented, for he can easily exhaust the pleasure sources available to him. For the intelligent man or woman, the myriad of options available...

Other Essays Like How Adequate Is Mill’s Conception of Happiness? How Good Are His Arguments to Show That “Higher” Pleasures Are Intrinsically More Desirable Than “Lower” Ones? Is This Distinction Consistent with the Thesis That Pleasure

How Successful Are Descartes Arguments For The Real Distinction Between Mind And Body? Upon Which Would You Place Most Weight?

2530 words - 11 pages answer, for how are they to know the reason?I am unsure as to whether the mind is divisible for if the mind is the brain then there could be a section that deals with emotions and so could be separated from the mind as a hole. This would mean that emoting isn't merely a function of the mind but a section of it.How successful are Descartes arguments for the real distinction between mind and body?From doubt - this argument is not at all successful

How Accurate Is It To Say That The Yorkists Remained A Serious Threat To Henry Vii’S Security Throughout His Reign?

1593 words - 7 pages also a factor which is on Henrys side when maintaining his royal security. In 1506 Philip of Hapsburg had to land in an English port, Henry then managed to press him to deliver Suffolk to the tower. This shows again where Henry manages to maintain his security from a once serious Yorkist threat. Despite the fact there may seem more reasons the Yorkists were a serious threat to Henrys reign, there were important factors that disagree with this view

Arguments in Support of the Claim That It Is Not Wrong to Eat Animals

1837 words - 8 pages -called “Obama Levy” that apply to assets in risk-taking operations and with more than $50 billion in assets as well. It could act as a fund of the cost of bailing out failing banks. However, this tax could reduce the growth rate of a firm and they may become unwilling to expand their businesses that affect economic growth. Rating agencies have also already reported the Obama levy-caused worsening of American banks ratings. (Kreindel, 2006) The tax

‘of Mice and Men’ Serves as a Reminder That Dreaming Is Futile. How Far Do You Agree with This Representation of the Text and Its Key Themes?

1562 words - 7 pages ‘Of Mice and Men’ serves as a reminder that dreaming is futile. How far do you agree with this representation of the text and its key themes? To first answer the question we need to define a key element, what are dreams? When we dream we contemplate the possibility of doing something or indulging in fantasies about something greatly desired. Yet they are necessary to keep the levels of hope high in people to stand for what they believe in

This Is A Project Is On Earthquakes In Canada. What They Are, How They Are Formed, How To Act Before,During And After An Earthquake

1907 words - 8 pages winter. The reason for this is thathumid air is rare in the winter in Canada, and to have a tornado produced cold dry air must collide with hothumid air. Also eighty percent of tornadoes that occur in Canada strike between twelve noon and twelvemidnight.Canada's Ten Most Disastrous TornadoesThe following chart shows the most disastrous tornadoes ever reported in Canada. All these tornadoeshave occurred where on average at least one tornado per year

Bypass Suggests That the Journey Is More Important Than the Destination

961 words - 4 pages an installment into Young’s journey along the Hume. In doing this is draws the story back to the basics; it reiterates the concept of the Hume as the physical structure on which both Young and McGirr’s treks took place, providing the story with a lineal structure that makes more impact when compartmentalized as it keeps the idea of the journey fluent throughout each chapter rather than isolating the destination as the desired point of interest

Most People Are Taught That Loyalty Is a Virtue. but Loyalty-Whether to One's Friends, to One's School or Place of Employment, or to Any Institution-Is All Too Often a Destructive Rather Than a...

617 words - 3 pages cultivates our responsibility as a certain social member and unities us into a certain group. Since loyalty may have negative effect if one follows the loyalty without rational consideration, the assertion of John Corvino, associate professor of Philosophy at Wayne State University, may help clarify the conflicts between different loyalties. He proposes that loyalty is only a virtue to the extent that the object of loyalty is good. The statement should help us to decide who we should be loyal to and how we should practice our loyalty.

The Underlying Theme of Othello Is Reputation and It Is This That Culminates in the Play’s Tragedy. to What Extent Do You Agree with This Claim?

1172 words - 5 pages charisma which makes it compellingly easy for others to confide in him and to appreciatively take his advice. This is on of the main constituents of Othello's downfall and consequently the tragedy of the play. On line 258-261 Cassio is talking with Iago about the recent events of a fight that broke out between Cassio and Montano. Cassio explains to Iago how he feels about his impetuous fight and how he has lost his reputation: ‘Reputation, reputation

In Order to Write a Persuasive Essay, You Need to Come Up with a Few Arguments in Favor of Your Point. Here Are Some Potential Arguments for This Idea: It Makes the Children Feel Equally Loved by Both...

1252 words - 6 pages task to do, but love. Work at house, taking care of the baby and household, is much more stressful then the job outside. In addition, everyone is busy; it is just the matter of how you manage your time, and what if mother unfortunately passes away, who will take care of our children? How could you support to take care of them when you and they are almost stranger? If father don’t have time for his children, it will reduce the family happiness. To

What Is The Current State Of McGregor's Theory X And Y In Industry? Do Most Employees Fall Within X? Y? Are There Any Other Theories That Offer Alternative Arguments About The Nature O Employees?

869 words - 4 pages What is the current state of McGregor's theory X and Y in industry? Do most employees fall within X? Y? Are there any other theories that offer alternative arguments about the nature o employees? What does your company do to address both Xers and Yers?I believe that Theory Y is the most predominately used method of management. This theory has gone through a few transformations since McGregor first wrote about his X and Y theories in the early 60

Charities Are Outmoded Institutions That Have No Contribution to Make to Modern Society. What Is Needed Are Social Enterprises. Discuss

3452 words - 14 pages Charities are outmoded institutions that have no contribution to make to modern society. What is needed are social enterprises. Discuss. Introduction In this essay I will start by looking at definitions of both “Charities” and “Social Enterprises” before going on to look at a short history of the development of the voluntary sector in the UK. I will then move on to examine the arguments suggesting that charities have become outmoded and the

Related Papers

How Convincing Is The Thesis For The Identification Of Happiness With Pleasure?

549 words - 3 pages , it means I am getting happier.” His idea is that happiness is identical with only occurent pleasures. I agree with Davis in this point, of course the place of pleasure cannot be denied in happiness. However I don’t agree with the part that it is totally “identical” with happiness. I believe happiness is more complex than that and it consists more elements other than simply pleasure. According to Daniel Haybron, there are two types of

How Far Do You Agree That Shakespeare’s Portrayal Of Gender Relations Is More Sinister Than Comic?

1668 words - 7 pages resistance of her youth and made defeat of her’ (4/1/45-46). This is pitifully sad, as it implies that Leonato does not mind if Claudio had forcibly taken Hero’s virginity but is more concerned with being embarrassed in front of the congregation. Therefore gender relations in the comedy are initially represented as unsettling rather than comic. Furthermore, perhaps the most overt example of the volatile relationship between male and females

Some Unions Feel That The Organization Does Not Compensate Its Members Fairly, Or That The Organizational Working Conditions Are Less Than Desirable. Conversely, Some Employers Feel That Unions...

715 words - 3 pages short essay (two-to three- pages) taking one side or the other on the issue you select. You want to state very clearly the reasons you are taking the position you take, but you don’t have to defend it thoroughly (that’s what Part III is for). Part II: Anti-thesis Part II is the anti-thesis. Write a critical analysis in reply (two-to three- pages) to your essay in Part I by imagining that you oppose what the writer of Part I has stated. Careful

Argumentative Paper About Women And How They Are Claimed To Be A Weaker Sex Than That Of Males

1202 words - 5 pages From professional sports to children's toys, women are portrayed as the weaker sex. The media and pop culture has allowed this to happen. Women are shown as dumb, beautiful, and totally dependent. Although women are shown like this, most women in the real world are intelligent, nice, independent, and not as beautiful as a supermodel. Women have fought long and hard to get rid of the demeaning connotations that go along with being female; yet