This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

How And Why Milgram's Research On Obedience Contributed To Our Understanding Of Human Behaviour

1107 words - 5 pages

Part 1 Interpreting a table

Table (adapted from Milgram, 1974, cited by DSE141 assessment booklet, p11) puts together prediction of average voltage at which 'teachers' would disobey experimenter to continue and percentage of 'teachers' using the maximum shock level -by psychiatrists, students and middle class adults and the results of the original study and its three variations:
• 'teacher' being in the same room as 'learner',
• 'teacher holding hands of learner on shock plate,
• 'teacher' choosing shock level.

The results shows that:
• the mean of voltage used before the participants would withdrawn that was predicted by three groups was about 133.
• the figure from the ...view middle of the document...

• Volunteers were invited individually to laboratory, took part in drawing to decide who will be 'teacher' and 'learner'. It was set up – participants were to play a role of a teacher. Learner was played by a nice and friendly looking accountant.
• Teacher and learner were sat in different rooms, could communicate through the sound system.
• Learner was supposed to learn pair of words.
• For every mistake made teacher was supposed to administer electric shocks, increasing the voltage (from 15 to 435) with subsequent mistakes.
• Teacher was given sample shock of 45v which was not pleasant but did not hurt.
• On the beginning all went well, but after some point the learner started to make mistakes and teacher administering electric shocks. Soon moans and cries of learner started to be heard.
• When and if teacher wanted to stop the experimenter was 'pressing' him to continue by saying i.e. 'Please, continue.'

Results:
• All of teachers administered up to 300v
• Only 5 participants stopped there.
• 65% went all the way using maximum voltage

Ethics:
Milgram was strongly criticised for the stress and anxiety to participants. One of opposing psychologists was Diana Baumrinds. (Banyard, 2010) According to her Milgram violated the Nuremberg Ethics Code:
• experiment should had been stopped because of high level of distress to participants
• the value of the results was questioned
• participants has no real right to withdrawn form the study - when they tried they were pushed by experimenter to continue.
Milgram argued that:
• he could not predict the results
• participants were interviewed afterwards, debriefed fully and reconciled with the 'learner' – that was new thing.
• were checked by psychiatrist if they were OK, and most of them were happy that they took part in the research.
• the study was about obedience so it was necessary for experimenter to give orders to continue.
In the result the storm about study showed clearly why the ethics are important.

Outside the laboratory?
There was a question if the experiment would work in real life situation.
It was tested by Charles Hofling in 1966 – the nurses in the hospital were asked by a dummy doctor over the phone to administer drug in dosage twice the daily allowance and he would sign authorisation later. 21 out of 22 nurses obeyed! (Banyard, 2010)

After the study
Milgram research was a shock to the world. It was started to understand what has happen in the past, but its results pointed out...

Other Essays Like How and Why Milgram's Research on Obedience Contributed to Our Understanding of Human Behaviour

Evaluate the Contribution Psychological Research Has Made Towards Our Understanding of How Children from Birth to Five Learn and Develop Competencies in the Processes of Observation, Problem Solving,...

3252 words - 14 pages Evaluate the contribution psychological research has made towards our understanding of how children from birth to five learn and develop competencies in the processes of observation, problem solving, exploration, experimentation and prediction, thinking and decision making. Introduction The aim of this essay is to evaluate the developmental theories of ‘Problem Solving, Reasoning and Numeracy’ (PSRN) and an ‘Exploration and Investigation

Understanding and Supporting Behaviour Essay

1873 words - 8 pages theories and how these help understand individual's behaviour Humanistic Theory- is an approach to psychology which emphasizes empathy and the positive, good part of human behaviour, promoted human rights and equality, focuses on ways of improving individual's self-esteem/image/actualization and those elements that feel worthwhile. Maslow, a represent of humanistic theory emphasizes the importance of focusing on own personality, own life

Explain the Relationship Between Discipline and Obedience from the Montessori Perspective. Explain How Discipline and Obedience Are Linked to the Development of the Will

1927 words - 8 pages There are various theories explaining the development of discipline and obedience in early childhood. Montessori perspective establishes a link between these two concepts and how their maturation is dependent on the maturation of the will of the child. This essay will attempt to explain the relationship between discipline and obedience in the developmental stages of a child. Attention will be paid to how the environment helps the child in his

How Has the Role of Women in Society Changed from the 1950's and What Has Contributed to This Change?

1363 words - 6 pages roles; they would also be of how women kept making the changes more radical. The main method of investigation is to research the reaction of society and the incredible expectations set on by men. B. Summary of Evidence * Women were expected to marry right after high school or college * If women weren’t married by their early twenties or thirties they were considered an ‘Old Maid’. * Image was created that women wo9uld be

How Public Policy, Demographics and Classic Sociological Concepts Have Shaped Our Understanding of Educational Attainment

2345 words - 10 pages Assignment Briefing: Assess how public policy, demographics and classic sociological concepts have shaped our understanding of educational attainment. With supporting evidence, I will identify the major demographic factors which affect educational achievement. I will discuss the relevance of self fulfilling prophecy, labelling theory, the hidden curriculum and counter school sub-cultures. I will also outline recent educational ideas such as

How have changes in technology contributed to the globalization of markets and production? Would the globalization of markets and production have been possible without technological changes?

522 words - 3 pages changing in technology would lead to an influence on globalization of markets and globalization of production.The widely use in microprocessors and telecommunications increasing the amount of information being transferred, but lower its cost. This is very helpful in merging markets. The opportunities for companies to expend businesses are raised, due to plummeting in global communication cost. Updated data can be collected, and monitoring overseas

The Anatomical Similarities of Mice and Humans, and Why Mice Are Useful in Human Research

2579 words - 11 pages their size, other than that, they are nearly identical. Research on mice, rats, and guinea pigs has contributed greatly to our understanding of biological processes in humans and has helped to save millions of human lives. Mice and Rats are the most common used mammals because they are readily available, they are small and don’t take up much space in the lab, they are bought at a very low cost and in large bulk, they are easy to handle, and they

How Has Technology Contributed to Change in the Everyday Life of Australians in the 1950s

898 words - 4 pages Essay Technology has contributed to change in the everyday life of Australians in the 1950s by inventing new types of transport. In the 1950s Australia made their first motor car, aircraft became faster and was able to carry more passengers and diesel locomotive trains became available in Australia instead of steam trains. Changes in Australia's transport technology can mean there will be more deaths caused by transport and more traffic on the

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere, Assess the Contribution of Marxism to Our Understanding of the Role of Education

1545 words - 7 pages inequalities through the generations by ensuring that most working-class pupils experience educational failure. Education also legitimates this inequality, persuading the working class to accept educational and social inequalities. Other Marxists have also pointed to the existence of a hidden curriculum in schools. Using material from Item A and elsewhere, assess the contribution of Marxism to our understanding of the role of education. (20 marks) Marx

understanding behaviour of soldiers during war

905 words - 4 pages How Milgram’s work is relevant to understanding behaviour of soldiers during war. Summary This report will use the work of Milgram to demonstrate an understanding of the implications of obedience. Briefly touch on some of the events throughout the Second World War in a military context today, and the relevance now. Show the implications of adhering to commands from figures of authority and the risks this could pose or potentially cause

Using Material from Item a and Elsewhere, Asses the Contribution of Functionalism to Our Understanding of the Role of Education

618 words - 3 pages their talents. Education also sifts and sorts individuals, allocating them their future occupational roles on the basis of their ability and effort and enabling the talented to become upwardly mobile. The structure and processes of education systems are related to the general process of socialisation. All sociologists agree with this, but sociologists have many different views about how societies are structured. They have many different views

Related Papers

Stanley Milgram’s Research On Obedience And His Contribution To Our Understanding Of Human Behaviour

850 words - 4 pages This report aims to illustrate how Stanley Milgram’s research into obedience to authority has influenced our understanding of human behaviour today. Background In 1961 the psychologist Stanley Milgram (1933-1984) began research on obedience to authority. Influenced by the cruelties committed in the second world war he wished to discover what made ordinary people commit evil deeds (Banyard, 2010). Milgram took forty male volunteers who

Compare And Contrast The Contributions Of Taylor And Ford To Our Understanding Of Organizational Behaviour At Work

2510 words - 11 pages who ensures that things are done right, efficiently and one who is held responsible for these duties. I would say that Taylor has contributed more to our understanding of organisational behaviour than Ford, as Ford more developed on the ideas of Taylor, but it is fair to say that both have had a fair contribution to our understanding of organisational behaviour, whether it be in a way for us to follow or for us to amend. Bibliography 1

Analyse And Assess The Contribution Of Feminist Research To Our Understanding Of Society

1978 words - 8 pages social fact. Moral codes are external to individuals they also are constraining over individuals because they influence our behaviour. Morality is essential for understanding social order. Durkheim argued that human happiness, social order and social solidarity could only be achieved by regulation of human desires to within attainable limits. In Durkheim's book, 'Division of labour in society' he showed how small scale societies developed to a modern

The Influence Of Other People On Human Behaviour And Performance

1686 words - 7 pages The influence of other people on human behaviour and performance In this essay we shall examine and assess the influence of other people on human behaviour and performance. When using the term “other people” we are generally referring to people who have an impact on our lives such as family members, teachers, friends and peers, we shall examine there influence drawing on examples from chapters 1 and 6 of Investigating Psychology. We will