This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

How Can I Be Moral If I Don't Believe In God?

1399 words - 6 pages

HOW CAN I BE MORAL IF I DON'T BELIEVE IN GOD?

Let's just get this out in the open now: I do not have any faith or belief in any personal deity--one that dispenses grace, goodness, and/or miracles according to its 'will'. I do not acknowledge any ‘supernatural’ agent or agency that intentionally intervenes in human affairs (like say, one that chooses sides in a war), or selectively answers peoples' prayers. I do not and can not abide any willful deity that plays with tornados and trailer parks. I do not support or espouse any formal, organized religious notion or expression of any such 'god'.
I acknowledge only a creative principle at work in the Universe. I also acknowledge a ...view middle of the document...

To the pious, to be without religious belief, is to be 'immoral'. Science itself is held up as an example of an activity devoid of god, and therefore devoid of morality. This viewpoint is illustrated best by a discussion I had with a Christian acquaintance many years ago. At some point in our conversation, perhaps in exasperation, I confessed that I did not believe in any 'god', as previously described. He took a moment to digest this information, and then asked me in all sincerity:
"Well, how can you be moral if you don't believe in God?"
His question, I believed, was not meant as an exclusively Christian question. To my acquaintance, it seemed that any religion's god would be preferable to no god at all. Only this belief made me morally redeemable in his eyes. Despite feeling a bit insulted by this naïve interrogative, my acquaintance had in fact touched upon a significant issue in my 'existential quest'. For, it was indeed a question that I had been quietly asking myself since that day I walked out of church when I was seventeen years old.
What follows then, after much time to reflect, is my response to this question:
The answer, my theistic comrade, lies within the very religion you embrace. In the gospel of Matthew, the person calling himself 'The Son of Man' enjoins his followers to 'do unto others as you would have them do unto you'. Biblical scholars sometimes refer to this as the 'law of reciprocity'. Common folk know it as The Golden Rule. Whichever, it embodies the fundamental basis of moral conduct: reciprocal beneficence. Without any reference to 'god', the golden rule instructs us to treat others the way we wish to be treated, that is, in kind. A young child easily understands the meaning of this law: don't poke Tommy in the eye, or steal his toys, because you wouldn't want Tommy to do this to you. It is a remarkably objective, humanistic dictate.
A religious scholar might point out that the Law of Reciprocity as expressed by Jesus is merely an expanded recapitulation of the second commandment: love thy neighbor as thyself, and that the first commands us to worship (i.e., 'love') the one God. True, and yes, of course, we should expect a ‘high priest' (in this case, Moses) of any religion to put his god out there first, demanding absolute faithfulness, otherwise, they’re ‘out of business’, so to speak. But the second commandment is none the less a separate commandment and it stands on its own.
I will ask at this point, apart from the belief in god itself, what moral behavior is not covered by this reciprocal rule? Is god--any god--required for the understanding and practice of reciprocal beneficence?
A religious moralist, might protest this by asserting the origin of this reciprocity rule to be the Christian religion--a belief system preached by Jesus of Nazareth, whom some called the Christ. Such a person might question the validity of embracing the message, but denying/rejecting the...

Other Essays Like How Can I Be Moral If I Don't Believe in God?

This I Believe Essay

551 words - 3 pages This I Believe Essay I remember back to the very first day of middle school. Everyone was scared and looking around to see if they knew someone in their home room. When I looked around I realized no one in the class was from my elementary school. Back then I was really shy and didn’t speak a lot. This guy came up to me and asked if I wanted to be friends. I said yes of course. We didn’t make many friends because we were both shy but we did

This I Believe Essay

726 words - 3 pages view, the happiest place is where I am at a specific moment in time. If tomorrow I find myself herding cattle with the Massai tribes of Kenya, then in my opinion that savanna will surely be the happiest place on earth at that moment. What’s the point of living in the greatest country ever if you are not happy? I believe that if we all decide to adopt a “citizen of the world” mentality, we would learn from each other without losing our own

I Believe in the Potential of Children

643 words - 3 pages I Believe in the Potential of Children “Anybody, any kid can learn if he or she has the desire to do it… The teacher plays an important role in education—we all remember the first teacher who really touched our lives, or gave us some encouragement, or at least appreciated our best. The teacher gives us the desire to learn, the desire to be Somebody…The teacher has to have the energy of the hottest volcano, the memory of an elephant, and

I Don't Know

1775 words - 8 pages I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't Know I Don't

This I Believe About Tr

563 words - 3 pages idolize and see actors and sports figures as the most important figures in our society? Now keep in mind, I am not talking about trends. I am talking about misconceptions. There is a misconception about TR because people do not know what we do or even who we are. I think if I pointed my life towards TR as a career, my goal would be to make people see what I do as very important. I mean, if you don’t believe in something, or the product in which

If I Won Lottery

570 words - 3 pages "I've won the first prize!" I couldn't explained how I feel that moment. I couldn't believe what I have seen. With my hands shivering, I passed the newspaper to my wife."It's true! The first prize is exactly 8888!" I burst into uncontrollable laughter. The first prize! I wasn't dreaming. One million ringgit was in my hand! This would not happened if I didn't spend hundred ringgit in buying lottery yesterday. How lucky I was! Undoubtedly , I

If I Was You

972 words - 4 pages happy? According to Aristotle the can be happy and lead a happy life. If a man adheres to virtues ad pleasures there is no reason for him not to attain happiness. Aristotle also makes a point about “moral virtues”: not lying, not taking a persons life, and other morally right things. Being morally virtuous is a way of leading a happy life. By not stealing, or killing, or lying; one can be content in knowing he is good thus bringing happiness. But

I Don't Have One Yet

837 words - 4 pages they wanted? I would think yes. But, at the time it didn’t seem to be a top priority. We had the fear of communism. Countries becoming involved in wars that were going to be fought with nuclear weapons and the CIA. What did we know about that? Not much. So, we did what we thought was best. Whose to say if our priorities were right and Latin America’s were wrong. We were living different lives. Our concerns were global we had to keep and

If I Won the Lottery

922 words - 4 pages . I would definitely tell my boss what I think of him and quit, but it would be important to me to continue to hold a job—only I’d be my own boss. My greatest pleasure is to make people feel beautiful and good about themselves because I believe if someone likes the way he or she looks, then that will change a person’s attitude about life in general. Therefore, I’d open my own spa and call it “A Little Bit of Heaven.” Some of the services would

If I Were a Mayor

1195 words - 5 pages .  Together, we can contribute to our community.                 If it were to cost $0.20 per watt, and every building used 1,000 watts, it would be $200 per building.  There are about 300 businesses in Plymouth, so it would cost about $60,000.  Although the cost seems high, it would surely reduce electricity prices.  Our new volunteer clean-up crew would clean up the parks and streets, making people want to visit.  The windmills would produce more

If i was a crayon

390 words - 2 pages his attention away from us and onto the TV. Towards the end of the night the mother would come in and act like a scavenger searching for any lost or hidden crayons under the couch. Sometimes the little boy would play with us after being yelled at and be show much fervent towards us and rub our sharp heads against the paper making us very dull and unusable. I?ve lost many cronies that way and they?ve had a nice, little plummet into the garbage can

Related Papers

I Believe In Adventure Essay

813 words - 4 pages snake. When I bring them out the kids usually say how cool they are and ask if “ Can I have one” . I love being able to teach people what I’ve learned. I have had so many adventures in my life that I have many great memories. I wonder if I didn’t have all these adventures would I be who I am today. I have my whole life ahead of me that I plan filling with adventures. I plan on sharing what I’ve learned and living life to its fullest.

Why Should I Be Moral? Essay

1476 words - 6 pages Why Should I Be Moral?      The question of morality proves to be a complex interrogatory. Should I be moral? If I should be, then why? Why is morality important to society? An assumption can be made that morals derive from a purely religious perspective or the Golden Rule approach. We are told that it is right to be moral. This is an ineffective answer, since it does not apply to someone outside the moral circle

I Believe In Carpe Diem Essay

670 words - 3 pages in lieu of 9. With this experience, I found myself wanting to do everything. I wanted carpe diem, to make every day my own and live how I wanted. I wanted to go out with friends and do hobbies I loved; to enrich myself. I did not want to let that moment define me, I wanted to come back stronger. I believe I did. One day, I will leave my body and never come back. However, it wasn’t that day and it won’t be anytime soon. All I really want is to be happy, and when death comes, I want to die happy. Carpe diem is living how you want to live, and if it’s your time, you’ll have no objections.

How Would I Imagine God Essay

1070 words - 5 pages like a mouse after all. As for his weight, I see God with a little bit of fat on him. It would be a bit like a grandfather with a round stomach. I just don't see him being skinny, the way I do Jesus. He would also walk athletically, and gracefully. He would walk very slowly, but you would know that if he wanted to he could outrun a cheetah. He is of course, master of the universe. As for his clothing, in my mind, God wears a simple white robe