How Convincing Is The Thesis For The Identification Of Happiness With Pleasure?

549 words - 3 pages

13.05.2013

Systematic Survey of ETHR111:
How convincing is the thesis for the identification of happiness with pleasure?
In my systematic survey, I am going to analyze if the thesis for the identification of happiness with pleasure is convincing. In doing this, I am going to use Wayne Davis’ and Daniel Hybron’s views and ideas about happiness and pleasure. In order to investigate the convincing proof of pleasure thesis on happiness, we first have to understand their conceptions and explanations of pleasure and happiness individually.
According to Wayne Davis, pleasure and happiness come from the same state of mind or mental state. Davis separates happiness into two; occurent and dispositional. Occurent ones are the “episodes” of happiness; they are segments of happiness which are happening just for the moment. ...view middle of the document...

The pleasure comes from the idea that we are doing something considered as “good” by the society. According to him, non-epistemic pleasure which comes from the action, which comes from an episode, doesn’t bring happiness.
According to Davis, every relational pleasure is equivalent with a relational happiness. Davis has this thesis of “The happier I am, it means that I am having pleasure, and if I am having pleasure, it means I am getting happier.” His idea is that happiness is identical with only occurent pleasures.
I agree with Davis in this point, of course the place of pleasure cannot be denied in happiness. However I don’t agree with the part that it is totally “identical” with happiness. I believe happiness is more complex than that and it consists more elements other than simply pleasure.
According to Daniel Haybron, there are two types of happiness; psychological and prudential. Psychological happiness is related with hedonism and it is purely psychological whereas prudential happiness is related with Greek eudaimonia and it is a particular condition in life, state of affairs, flourishing.
Haybron suggests that happiness is more than an episodic and backward-looking phenomenon, as hedonism suggests. He explains that it is more like a psychological disposition that influences our hedonic experiences. He disassociates pleasure from happiness. Even though I believe that happiness is not truly identical to pleasure, I also don’t believe that pleasure can completely be eliminated from happiness, I think that it is a main part of happiness.
In my systematic survey, I focused on Wayne Davis and Daniel Haybron; who both explained pleasure’s role on happiness but only from two different aspects. When Davis identified happiness with pleasure, Haybron made a disassociation of pleasure from happiness. I don’t completely believe in both of them, however I believe even if it is not completely identical, being happy needs pleasure.

Other Essays Like How Convincing Is the Thesis for the Identification of Happiness with Pleasure?

Senior Thesis - How to Improve the Environment

5946 words - 24 pages ) As air pollution increases, people with this disease experience an increase in symptoms and heart attacks become more common for those that are exposed to heavy pollution. (EHHI) Recycling We have all heard about recycling for years, but what is it really helping and how is it helping the environment? Recycling is the process of reusing materials to prevent wasting materials that can be useful. Recycling provides a fresh substance of a used

God Is The Key To Happiness

1068 words - 5 pages the morning: let?s pray for John as he is having some hard time in the hospital right now. Every single person in our class was shocked because of John. No body could believe that such an amazing life can turn to a disaster. John, the happiest person on the earth, who said that he does not need anything in his life got in trouble with a deadly disease which could cause death in few months, he got in trouble with blood cancer in his early life

Metaphors Used in the Conceptualisation of Happiness

2050 words - 9 pages happiness -Happiness is Vitality/Energy/Activity- The main emphasis of the vitality metaphor is that the happy person is energetic, active; he or she is “full of life.” Linguistic expressions: /Her eyes were alive with joy. /We were dancing with joy. /He was singing for joy. /I’m feeling spry./ I felt vivacious. Asp.of SD-the energy of vitality, Asp. of TD-the energy that accompanies happiness Asp.of SD-the energy that comes Asp

"Breaker Morant builds a convincing argument that it is those at the top of the war hierarchy that are truly guilty, and not the lowly soldiers who carry out orders." Discuss

574 words - 3 pages Bushvelt carabineer's were in juxtaposed by the situation of the British high class officers, and the guilt that they truly posses. War has been familiarized by people all around the world, and it is well known that soldiers follow orders from higher class officers. It is military custom for a soldier to carry out ones duty. We see this all throughout the film of Breaker Morant, their daily casual proceedings, and the flashbacks, how the soldiers

Thesis in Factors Affecting the Study Habbit of the Students

2747 words - 11 pages information and communication technologies have created a "global village," in which people can communicate with others across the world as if they were living next door. For this reason, ICT is often studied in the context of how modern communication technologies affect society. Tech Factor:  1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Updated: January 4, 2010 Webopedia.com Sign Up    |    Sign In    ------------------------------------------------- Top of Form

1.How Big Is the Market for Curled Metal Pads

595 words - 3 pages drive the same amount of miles. Therefore, if the price is $1,000 per set of pads and 6 pads are required per set, the price per pad would be $166.67. For Fazio, where 5 curled metal pads were in a set, and the set was worth $2,000, the price per pad would be $400. Considering a market size estimate of 174,000 to 234,000 pads per year, at a price ranging between $166.67 a pad and $400 per pad, sales would range between $29,000,580 and $39,000,780

Critically Evaluate the Theoretical Perspectives of the Psychology of Happiness

1283 words - 6 pages The dictionary describes happiness as a “state of well-being characterized by emotions ranging from contentment to intense joy”. However different people will receive “intense joy” from different things - happiness is subjective . The ability to create a formula for happiness has been attempted throughout history, to no avail. From Greek philosopher Epicurus and his notion of sensations create pleasure, up to Maslow (1943) and his

Thesis About the Study Habits

2559 words - 11 pages , it’s also easier to become distracted from work when using technology, an affliction known as DAD (divided attention disorder). With the temptation to check bank balances, speak to someone on a smart phone or download a song available at the click of a button, many students have trouble finishing essays or doing some important reading. Sponsored Links Modern technology is the use of machines to make life better. For example, the improvement of

Tragic Fall Of Icarus--Compares The Myth And How It Relates To "Musee Des Beaux Arts," Landscape With The Fall Of Icarus," And "Waiting For Icarus."

1337 words - 6 pages poems "Musee des Beaux Arts" by W. H. Auden, "Landscape with the Fall of Icarus" by W. C. Williams, and "Waiting for Icarus" by Muriel Rukeyser. Even though the three poems talk about Icarus's fall, each covers it in a different way. "Musee des Beaux Arts" and "Landscape with the Fall of Icarus" describes how human suffering occurs at as a personal burden that only affects the influenced individual. In addition, they both basically let us know

The Misery Behind the Happiness

617 words - 3 pages It has been years since I wrote anything at all, although people do see mewriting odd pieces of music. But this time I am writing about my past, the pastthat seems so far away and forgotten. I know that this account is hardly goingto interest anyone, but I do need to share my feelings with someone, or in thiscase, with something. People see me as a berserk creature talking garrulouslyof her past that probably never existed. And that is the

How Accurate Is It to Say That the Spread of Revolutionary Beliefs Was the Main Reason for the Fall of the Qing Dynasty 1911-12?

1344 words - 6 pages How accurate is it to say that the spread of revolutionary beliefs was the main reason for the fall of the Qing dynasty 1911-12? This essay will be looking at how much of a contribution the spread of revolutionary beliefs in China had in the fall of the Qing Dynasty. In order to determine the importance of this I will therefore also be looking at other factors such as, foreign interference, double tenth and the inability to change. I believe it

Related Papers

How Adequate Is Mill’s Conception Of Happiness? How Good Are His Arguments To Show That “Higher” Pleasures Are Intrinsically More Desirable Than “Lower” Ones? Is This Distinction Consistent With The...

2110 words - 9 pages How adequate is Mill’s conception of happiness? How good are his arguments to show that “higher” pleasures are intrinsically more desirable than “lower” ones? Is this distinction consistent with the thesis that pleasure is the only thing of value? In “Utilitarianism” Mill argues that ‘higher’ pleasures are intrinsically more valuable than ‘lower’ pleasures, citing the invariable preference of men who have access to both available (pp.140). I

How Convincing Is The Design Argument As An Argument For The Existence Of God?

1591 words - 7 pages How convincing is the design argument as an argument for the existence of God? In this essay I will attempt to prove that the design argument does little to tell us anything about the existence of God. I will examine the strength the analogy used in the argument as well as primary objections such as the notion of intent and evolution. Upon my findings I will conclude as to weather I am convinced that teleology provides sufficient grounds for

Association Of Drugs With Pleasure Essay

397 words - 2 pages condition. . .Many associate drug use with risk taking, if he could find some risky yet healthy behavior such as sky diving or mountain climbing, those new risks could take the place of the drugs.Using the example of my friend there are several ways to change his response to his continued drug use. These friends of his naturally and automatically triggered a response in him, and that response was enjoyment and happiness. This is a somewhat similar

The Pursuit Of Happiness Essay

2094 words - 9 pages The Pursuit of Happiness Should people leave their countries? This is a question that all of us need to concentrate on in our society to answer it. A young man who had a fight with his father decides to leave home to be independent. A person who fails in love goes to another country to start his life over again. Even some for inexplicable reasons want to live abroad to pursue their dreams. There are many other stories all around the world that