How Far Do You Agree That Shakespeare’s Portrayal Of Gender Relations Is More Sinister Than Comic?

1668 words - 7 pages


How far do you agree that Shakespeare’s portrayal of gender relations is more sinister than comic?
Shakespeare’s depiction of gender relations in ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ distinguishes male and female stereotypes during the Elizabethan era of 1599. Shakespeare accomplishes this through the contrasting couples of Benedick and Beatrice and Hero and Claudio. The relationship between fathers and daughters is likewise used to demonstrate the sinister and slightly comedic relations between men and women.
To a great extent, modern audiences would find the objectification of women very much ominous, especially in the case of Hero. ...view middle of the document...

Therefore gender relations in the comedy are initially represented as unsettling rather than comic.
Furthermore, perhaps the most overt example of the volatile relationship between male and females is the denouncement of Hero. When Claudio accuses Hero at the altar for unfaithfulness and sexual promiscuity, he is supported by Don Pedro. The degrading line ‘but the sign and semblance of her honour. Behold like a maid she blushes here’ (4/1/32-33) perpetuates the sinister idea that Claudio thinks Hero’s outer beauty is concealing corruption within. The phrase ‘like a maid she blushes’ is the sign of her honour but Claudio sees it as evil guilt. The endorsement that Claudio receives from Don Pedro and Leonato presents how men will believe each other over any woman, even their own daughter. Here Shakespeare appears to be contradicting the view of Aristotle who wrote ‘comedy does not involve pain and destruction.’ 1Yet in ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ the sinister relations between men and women cause pain to many of its female characters. Leonato wishes for Hero’s death and says ‘Death is the fairest cover for her shame’ (4/1/114). He would rather Hero die than not marry as a virgin and regrets ever conceiving her. The tragedy of the scene would thus validate the argument that gender relations are portrayed as more sinister than comedic.
Additionally, Shakespeare entails that women must sacrifice their integrity if they are to marry or find love. When Beatrice is presented as witty and outgoing, she is immediately discouraged by her uncle. Leonato tells her ‘So by being too curst, God will send you no horns’ (2/1/22) which interprets to audiences that by Beatrice acting independently, she will not find a husband. During the masked ball scene Beatrice says ‘Here’s no place for you maids Heavens...where the bachelors sit’ (2/1/40-42) which is stating a tradition in a patriarchal society where women have to remain virgins until marriage while men can indulge themselves in sexual activity. This clearly presents males as the dominant gender during the Elizabethan era and women must accept their rule or risk being shunned. Shakespeare enriches this idea throughout the comedy using controlling male figures, which are more committed to their male ideal of honour than respecting women. The expectation of females in the comedy is obedience, modesty and beauty which is why Hero is presented as the ‘ideal’ woman because she fits this description and Don John calls her ‘Leonato’s Hero, your Hero, every man’s Hero’ (3/2/92). As Jean E Howard convincingly argues that ‘Hero, the blank sheet upon which men write whore or goddess, as their fears or desires dictate’ represents how men have egotistical attitudes to reassemble so use female characters like Hero or Margaret to achieve this. 2Beatrice, feisty at the beginning of the comedy, conforms to society by the end, perhaps because she realises that she is living in a...

Other Essays Like How far do you agree that Shakespeare’s portrayal of gender relations is more sinister than comic?

How Far Do You Agree That the Catholic Church Significantly Hindered Italian Unity in the Years to 1870?

821 words - 4 pages How far do you agree that the Catholic Church significantly hindered Italian unity in the years to 1870? The Catholic Church was a major power in Italy during the time of unification. Some people say that they hindered the process of Italian Unity and some say they didn’t. In this essay I will be explain points which back up and go against the statement that the church significantly hindered the process of Italian unity. To a very far extent

How Far Do You Agree That Hitler's Policies Were A Success For German People During The 1930s?

886 words - 4 pages opposition to prevent them from influencing others. Fear of being sent to concentration camps or of being denounced by the SS or Gestapo kept silent many of those who did not support the Nazis.Hence, I agree to a large extent that his policies were successful. With the success of the four year plan, inflation slowed, people could feel secure about saving again, unemployment decreased to 0.5 million in 1938 and wages rose. Hence, this is the most

How Far Do You Agree That William Duke of Normandy’s Military Skills Were the Main Reason for His Success in Securing the English Throne in 1066?

909 words - 4 pages historians speculate that Harold’s army may have thought that if they surrendered then they would live, however the reality was a little different. William’s army still slaughtered many of Harold’s army. The fact that Harold had been killed, although how he died is still being speculated, meant that his army crumbled without him to lead them which led to William having an easy job of killing Harold’s army and taking the English throne for himself

How Far Do You Agree That the Brutality of the Bolsheviks Was the Main Reason Why They Remained in Power in the Years 1917-24?

834 words - 4 pages fall. This meant that the people of Russia did not support the Whites, so the only side left to support was the Reds (Bolsheviks) increasing their popularity and in turn their power over Russia. To conclude this was another main reason why the Bolsheviks remained in power. Putting in order of significance to the Bolsheviks remaining in power the Sovnarkom is a little more important and higher over the lack of support for the Whites. To conclude to a large extent the Bolsheviks remained in power because of their brutality. To a small extent it was due to other factors.

How Far Do You Believe That Romeo and Juliet's Love Is Genuine?

1373 words - 6 pages How far do you believe that Romeo and Juliet’s love is genuine? Romeo and Juliet’s feelings for each other can be seen as genuine at different stages in the play. Their love for each can be very strong at times and not so strong at other times. An example of this strong love for Juliet is when they first saw each other at the Capulet’s party. It can be said that this was love at first sight and it was the strongest love that Romeo felt for

“the Puritans Were Never a Serious Threat to Elizabeth” How Far Do You Agree?

1148 words - 5 pages highlights an almost aggressive reaction to the Queen’s laws. Peter Wentworth, being nobility and a member of parliament had some influence, more than that of the general public who were disputing the Queen’s laws. Her own nobility turning against her is a sign of danger, proving the situation to be rather serious. However, Elizabeth was willing to treat all future Puritan threats extremely harshly in order to stamp it out before it became more dangerous

How Far Do You Agree That the Impact of the Second World War Was the Main Reason Why the Position of African-Americans Improved in the Years 1945-55?

1923 words - 8 pages have a clear impact on the position of African-Americans, it had a more subtle gain. It showed how the confidence of black people had increased and it showed that is was possible to challenge segregation. A final factor was the Sweatt v. Painter case of 1950. It was the NAACP’s first challenge to segregation in education. HemanSweatt was a black student who wanted to study Law in Texas. However, the Texan education system was segregated and

How Far Do You Agree with the View That the Origins of the Cold War in 1945 and 1946 Owed Much to Ideological Differences and Little to Personalities and Conflicting National Interests

1045 words - 5 pages How far do you agree with the view that the origins of the Cold War in 1945 and 1946 owed much to ideological differences and little to personalities and conflicting national interests? (TOTAL 40 MARKS) Use sources 7 and 8 to your own knowledge The origins of the Cold War in 1945 and 1946 were due to a number of factors, and whether it was mainly due to ideological differences or personalities and conflicting national interests is still a

“the Women Characters Are Merely Decorative Figures of Seemingly Fragile Beauty” – How Far and in What Ways Do You Agree with This View of the Great Gatsby

1336 words - 6 pages everything. In other words beneath the silliness and the giggles, she is just sick of life. However the majority of the time Daisy behaved carelessly. She is a very flighty character. We see this when it says “How gorgeous. Let’s go back tomorrow’ then added irrelevantly ‘you ought to see the baby”. This shows us that she just talks and never stops. She doesn’t stick to any ideas. This could also be seen to display her underlying sadness. It is as

Hitler Became Chancellor in June 1933 Because He Was Leader of the Most Popular Party in Germany? How Far Do You Agree?

718 words - 3 pages To begin, I believe that despite that the Nazi party was indeed the most popular party in Germany it was not the sole reason for Hitler becoming chancellor in June 1933. The Nazi's had the highest number of seats and votes in both elections in 1932 and this is conclusive evidence that the Nazi's were the most popular party in Germany at the time. However, the Nazi's only became popular like this because of the Wall Street Crash and Great

Do You Agree or Disagree That with the Following Statement? It’s More Important for the Government to Spend Money to Build Art Museums and Music Performance Center Than to Build Recreational...

567 words - 3 pages Do you agree or disagree that with the following statement? It’s more important for the government to spend money to build art museums and music performance center than to build recreational facilities (such as swimming pool, playgrounds). Art museums, concert halls and recreational facilities are indispensable to any civilized society. When it comes to the issue of the arrangement of a government’s budget, some people suggest that the

Related Papers

Between 1953 61 Us Soviet Relations Were Based On Confrontation Rather Than Co Existence. How Far Do You Agree With This View?

1666 words - 7 pages foreign policy and the Soviet Union differed to that of Truman, who had been president before him. Eisenhower was believed to be more hard-line than Truman, being highly critical of Truman’s foreign policy as he did not take a strong enough stance against communism. Eisenhower’s ‘New Look’ policy suggested that the communists were pursuing expansionist policies and outlined the idea of ‘massive retaliation’, which threatened nuclear force in

‘Of Mice And Men’ Serves As A Reminder That Dreaming Is Futile. How Far Do You Agree With This Representation Of The Text And Its Key Themes?

1562 words - 7 pages ‘Of Mice and Men’ serves as a reminder that dreaming is futile. How far do you agree with this representation of the text and its key themes? To first answer the question we need to define a key element, what are dreams? When we dream we contemplate the possibility of doing something or indulging in fantasies about something greatly desired. Yet they are necessary to keep the levels of hope high in people to stand for what they believe in

How Far Do You Agree That The Most Important Cause Of The Revolution In February 1917 Was The Great War

1334 words - 6 pages AS History How far do you agree that the most important cause of the revolution in February 1917 was the Great War? The February revolution which occurred in 1917 was the result of several causes, one of which being World War 1; in my opinion, it was the most important trigger. The Great War was the cause of Russia becoming financially dependent on Britain and France, decreasing the prestige the Tsar once held. Russia was unable to sustain its

How Far Do You Agree That The Actions Of The Ussr Were Primarily Responsible For The Division Of Germany In 1949?

609 words - 3 pages How far do you agree that the actions of the USSR were primarily responsible for the division of Germany in 1949? Actions of the USSR contributing towards division Stalin’s determination to create a buffer zone and attitude towards Germany * Stalin wanted to protect the USSR from future conflicts with Germany * Stalin had gained influence in many eastern European countries as the Russian armies advanced for Germany. * Stalin’s