This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

How Managers Become Leaders Essay

551 words - 3 pages

Article Structure
The foundation of the article “How Managers Become Leaders: The Seven Seismic Shifts of Perspective and Responsibility” is that the transition from manager to executive requires “learning new skills and cultivating new mindsets” (Watkins, 2012). To support this, the author interviewed more than 40 executives, ranging from managers, senior human resource professionals, and individuals who recently transitioned to senior leader positions for the first time. The information gathered from these sources assisted Watkins in molding the Seven Seismic Shifts: Specialist to Generalist; Analyst to Integrator; Tactician to Strategist; Bricklayer to Architect; Problem Solver to Agenda Setter; Warrior to Diplomat; and, Supporting Cast Member to Lead Role. In conclusion, the author asserts that the shifts amount to switching from analytical ...view middle of the document...

The author does not share the questions asked of the interviewees or the scale used to make final determinations and analysis. However, the author’s framework of seven shifts represents the idea that executives or leaders have to take on a more strategic and big picture role in their organizations.
Access Article Evidence
The author is a single provider for the information provided in the article. The author’s qualifications lead you to determine that he is an expert in the field of executive and leadership transition. The information collected and analyzed by Watkins is a primary source and can be considered fact. Limiting the scope of interviewees and not providing the questions or raw data captured, questions the reliability and assumptions made by the author. I believe the conclusions the author makes are sound and embody what you would expect to see in an article like this one.
Analyze the Article’s Logic
The author used causation as the reasoning to come to his conclusion. “What I found is that to make the transition successfully, executives must navigate a tricky set of changes in their leadership focus and skills” (Watkins, 2012). This statement supports the conclusion that leaders must shift their mind-set and these navigations are easier with preparation and training. The author was able to show, through the story of Harold, the cause that seven shifts can make in effective executive leadership.
Evaluate the Argument of the Article
The argument in this article is strong and accurate. The author’s use of storytelling and data collection from interviewees supported his argument. Watkins was able to support his conclusion in a clear manner. Although the absence of the specific questions asked and matrix caused me to pause, I support his argument that in order to successfully transition from an effective manager to executive one needs to shift a series of mind-sets.
Watkins, M. (2012). How Managers Become Leaders. Harvard Business Review, June 2012, 65-72.

Other Essays Like How Managers Become Leaders

Leadership And Management Essay

961 words - 4 pages achieve a organizational goal. This paper will discuss the difference between management and leadership, the roles of leaders and managers, and the managers in creating and maintaining a healthy culture. This paper will also explain how the four functions of management support creating and maintaining a healthy organizational culture.Managers have subordinates and the power over others. This is a formal authority given to them by the organization

Management and Leadership at Frito Lay

1903 words - 8 pages Businesses in today’s competitive world, demand leaders and managers to be a well rounded person and possess the necessary skills in order to attain organizational goals. It is essential to managers and leaders to have good communication skills in order to communicate to employees effectively, relay information correctly, and to keep business running smoothly as possible. Effective managers must be able to lead

leaders and organizational culture

1967 words - 8 pages Abstract In this paper I will use my life experiences to discuss Kohl’s Department Store and examine the roles and responsibilities of the leaders in the company. I will also differentiate between leaders and managers. I will describe the roles that the organizational managers and leaders play in creating and maintaining a healthy organizational culture. I will also explain how the four functions of management support the creation and

Eco561 Week1

726 words - 3 pages , the effectiveness of this approach can be identified through analyzing how managers solve issues and survive with job conflicts. However, this method of leadership is not designed for all types of personalities as it requires leaders to have specific behaviors to contribute to the success of an organization. References Yulk, Gary. (2010). Leadership in organizations: the nature of leadership. Retrieved from University of Phoenix, LDR/531 website:

Managment and Leadership

1757 words - 8 pages (Smith, 2010). Whereas, the leadership team focuses upon implementing training, tools, and procedures that would allow the production team to accomplish daily requirements which lead to the completion of the organizational goals. Management or managers will focus upon “systems and structures” (Bateman and Snell, 2009). This puts the manager at looking at the budgets and production outputs versus the leaders who focus on the people (Prussakov

Leaders: Born and Made

542 words - 3 pages achieve results, and to make decisions. These essential traits, ones that any leader must possess, are the foundation for the making of an effective leader. Not a single leader was ever born with all the necessary skills to be an effective leader. Leadership is an apprentice trade, and most leaders learn more than 80% on the job. To become effective leaders must do one important thing; take responsibility and seek self-improvement. The most

Leaders as Coaches

1794 words - 8 pages accountability easier than leaders by being more patient. Disadvantages might be; • Too much emotional relation sometimes causes conflicts in organization. For example, sometimes small discussions between workers getting worse and cause bigger problems than it supposed to be. • If relations between managers and sub-workers become so close and this causes lack of discipline in the organization • Their emotional part might be misused by their

Management And Leadership

1130 words - 5 pages components are necessary for the success in a progressively complex and unpredictable business atmosphere. Strong leadership with weak management is worse, than weak leadership and strong management. The key is two harness the two and combine strong leadership and strong management to create a harmonic balance with both.ManagersThere are subtle differences between Managers and Leaders. Successful executives learn to use management skills at the

Cmi Leadership

2579 words - 11 pages subsequently is able to practise accountability, holding themselves and others accountable along with responsibility for results. How managers and leaders motivate their people to work or follow them is one of the main differences. By definition managers have subordinates and have a transactional style. The manager telling them what to do and with reward staff will do as asked. Where as leaders have followers, and following is

Management And Leadership

946 words - 4 pages will go on to explain how the leading function of management supports the creation and maintenance of a healthy organizational culture within AT&T. Finally, I will conclude with my recommendations that both managers and leaders can use to create and maintain a healthy organizational culture within AT&T. The responsibilities of the managers within AT&T are to monitor employees’ performance, provide feedback during progress reviews, and


3583 words - 15 pages training. There are a number of books, articles, and research papers written on how we define leadership in the public sector, as well as how it affects the organization. Some leaders are born into the role, such as royalty, where there have been some notable successes and failures. Other leaders become leaders simply because other people choose to follow them. Researchers have been studying the definition of leadership for many years with

Related Papers

Managment Essay

605 words - 3 pages Today, we had a very interesting lession in our business edge class. Most of the people misunderstand the concept of difference between Manager and a Leader. So we had a lession called “Managers and Leaders are they different?” . From that, it is very clear that these two concepts are totally different and after listening and reading the article, now I am in a better position to differentiate these two. While listening to all the presentation

Managers Are Not Always Leaders Essay

1241 words - 5 pages and implement change. They may recognize that there is a problem and that change needs to happen, but may not know how to make it work. Leaders are the brains behind the change. They are the innovators and they are the able to motivate others to see the need for change. Although a leader may not agree with a needed change, they create the vision to make it happen and do what it takes to accomplish it. Managers wait for results, analyze processes

Chapter 1, Fulfillemnt Essay

2213 words - 9 pages Question 1: 1a) Explain the difference between effective leaders and effective managers. Can someone be effective at both managing and leading? Illustrate your answer with reference to: i. Current thinking in leadership and management ii. Leaders / managers you have experienced 1b) What are your own strengths and weaknesses as a manager and a leader and how do you balance the demands of both these roles? What impact do your own

Ethics In Management Essay

1881 words - 8 pages an understanding of how management style is impacted.Working at HUD there are many managers and leaders; the differences are visible. In my office most of the leaders (we call them team leads), cope with the changes of the office while the managers cope with the difficult decisions and the implementation of regulations and laws regarding policies for the different HUD programs.Managers and Leaders are two different jobs; however, they both