Human Dignity Essay

2766 words - 12 pages

The Use of Human Dignity in Death Penalty Cases: An International perspective
An examination of cases from several jurisdictions that address the legality of the death penalty reveals various uses of the notion of human dignity.
In 1972, in Furman v. Georgia, the United States Supreme Court declared all existing death penalty statutes at the time unconstitutional as a violation of the Eighth Amendment prohibiting "cruel and unusual punishment". There was no majority opinion, and each of the five majority members wrote a separate opinion. While three of them based their decision on the arbitrary and discriminatory application of the death penalty in the U.S., Justices Brennan and Marshall ...view middle of the document...

A majority of the Supreme Court set out obligatory guidelines for the legislatures to follow in order to craft a constitutional capital punishment sentencing scheme. It then decided that Georgia's sentencing scheme met these criteria, and the death penalty was therefore ruled constitutional. The majority ruled that in order to respect the dignity of a man underlying the Eight Amendment, the punishment of criminals should not be excessive. But there was no clear definition of dignity. This time Justices Brennan and Marshall, who reiterated their belief in Furman that the death penalty was unconstitutional, were the only two dissenters. Brennan wrote a decidedly brief opinion that contained his view on Furman, which is that: "the primary moral principle that the State, even as it punishes, must treat its citizens in a manner consistent with their intrinsic worth as human beings – a punishment must not be so severe as to be degrading to human dignity".
In 1980, in Bachan Singh v. Punjab, the Supreme Court of India was required to rule on the matter of the constitutionality of death penalty to a convicted murderer. This was despite the fact that the Indian Constitution allows the state to deprive a person's life, as long as it is established by law. Four of the five justices rejected the petition and declared that death penalty is constitutional if it abides by certain standards and is used reasonably. The majority relied in part on the principle of judicial discretion in not judging capital punishment to be unconstitutional per se. The lone dissenter, Justice Bhagwati, expressed a diverging opinion. From the beginning of his verdict he explains the source of the divergence: "Mine is unfortunately a solitary dissent… by my deep and abiding faith in the dignity of man and worth of the human person and passionate conviction about the true spiritual nature and dimension of man". In his view, the Indian Constitution respects the dignity and worth of the individual and protects them from degradation. Therefore, he determined that capital punishment, which he defines as a legally sanctioned "barbaric act" of taking a man's life, is unconstitutional.
It is clear that Bhagwati adopted the same approach as Brennan. In fact, both the majority and the minority in the Indian court referred at length to Gregg and Furman. While the majority uses these cases as evidence that even the U.S. reinstated capital punishment to a substantial degree, Bhagwati used it to side with Gregg's dissenters.

In 1995, in the case of Mbushuu v. Republic, the Tanzanian Court of Appeal upheld the constitutionality of the death penalty. That was despite the fact that the Court found the capital punishment to be contradictory to Article 13(b)(d) and (e) of the Tanzanian Constitution – the right to life and the prohibition of inhuman, cruel, and degrading punishment. The Court approvingly cited Brennan in Furman, and therefore declared that the death penalty is a violation of the...

Other Essays Like Human Dignity

An Evaluation of Singer Essay

1352 words - 6 pages of the presumption argument. He traces “distinctive human dignity” back to Renaissance humanists and asserts the following: Once we ask why it should be that all humans—including infants, mental defectives, psychopaths, Hitler, Stalin, and the rest—have some kind of dignity or worth that no elephant, pig, or chimpanzee can ever achieve, we see that this question is as difficult to answer as our original request for some relevant fact that

Rerum Novarum Essay

1305 words - 6 pages while the role of the church was to speak out on matters regarding social issues and teach acceptable social principles while ensuring social harmony is maintained. The Pope restated the church’s teaching concerning the significance of private property rights. However, he acknowledged that the free market operation forces have to be accompanied by moral considerations. Dignity of Workers as human beings Every human being is created in the

Human Cloning And The Value Of Human Life

1284 words - 6 pages centrality of the human person in law is effectively expressed by the classical aphorism: "Hominum cause omne ius constitutum est". This means that law is such if and to the extent to which it is based on man in his truth. Who does not see that this basic principle of every just legal system is being seriously threatened by reductive conceptions of man's essence and dignity? These concepts have given rise to the legalization of serious violations of

Killing Is Never Justifies

1612 words - 7 pages committed society's most heinous crimes, including rape and murder. Ultimately, Capital punishment is wrong due to the likelihood of error, the unjust racial allocation, and the violation of constitutional rights. However, many people believe that capital punishment is morally correct and preserves human dignity. Primarily, until human judgment is proved to be infallible, capital punishment will always carry a likelihood of error along with it. As

Nursing Reflection

3234 words - 13 pages task-oriented (Calnan et al, 2005). The dignity of Mr Len must be respected and protected as a person who is born free, equal in dignity and has basic human right (Amnesty international, 1999).Health service will need to recognise the specific needs of older people in caring for them, demonstrating respect for Mr Len autonomy, privacy during Mr Len care and avoiding poor practice that will deify Mr Moses dignity, such as: allowing him to remain

Pleasures in Terms of Morality and Physicality Stuart Mill

936 words - 4 pages present in every human being and it leans on physical pleasures, as Mill supports, some pleasures which make the human dignity explicit are more important than material pleasures. Man’s effort to have himself becomes more significant than to have basic pleasures. In this sense, in Mill’s theory, artistic, cultural and religious activities get ahead of effort to satisfy physical pleasures. Thus, man should be considered as a moral being. Contrary

human cloning

417 words - 2 pages clients pay lots of money and get internal organs for their health from the clones. They are really expansive when you want to make clones. I think we don't need to make clones by paying lots of money. Human life is worth more than money. I think human clones can't assess the value of money, because they are same as human.Last, clones are human too. They are not just products. They can have feeling like human do. They have dignity, so we have to

The Concepts of Nonmaleficence

1436 words - 6 pages person can say they Have dignity. Dignity is also linked to “following and upholding the ethics you Live by”. Dignity in justice involves things such as people like Rosa Parks when she refused to get up for a white person because at the time it was the “normal” thing to do. Dignity plays a huge role in making people better, nicer, doing what is right and doing what should be done if it is right. Human rights are another aspect on

An Alysis of the Case "Omega Spielhallen V Bonn"

946 words - 4 pages German Federal Court. The main argument of this Court was that the game was an affront to human dignity as guaranteed by the first Article of the German Constitution. However, it decided to refer a question to the European Court of Justice, because the prohibition of 'laserdome' was not compaticle with fundamental freedoms guaranteed by the EC Treaty, such as the freedom to provide services and the free movement of goods. This issue was raised

Arthur Miller's Definition Of A "TRAGIC HERO" In Death Of A Salesman

954 words - 4 pages challenge of his dignity, his image of his rightful status".In that definition of the tragic flaw lies a sense of optimism, an adjective not usually given to tragedies. Arthur Miller feels that they should be considered optimistic in that a tragedy "reinforces the onlooker's brightest opinions of the human animal". His essay is the perfect accompaniment to one of his greatest works. Truly, Willy Loman is a tragic hero despite Aristotle's

Aspects of Caring

902 words - 4 pages trust is not only a matter of competence. The nurse must also make the care of patients his first concern, treating them as individuals and respecting their dignity. The RCN (2008) believes dignity to be at the heart of good nursing care. Dignity may be promoted or diminished by many factors, including the attitude and behavior of the nurse. When dignity is preserved, people feel “ in control, valued, confident, comfortable and able to make

Related Papers

Learning Human Dignity And Rights Through Cinema

1098 words - 5 pages Learning Human Dignity and Rights Through Cinema Human dignity forms the basis of human rights, as it signifies the intrinsic worth that lies in every human being. Human rights would mean that a person possesses the worthiness of respect on all levels of treatments concerning sex, age, status, religion, ethnicity, and even political values. As a member of Western society, one finds it easy to overlook such matters as many live

Implication Of Human Dignity Essay

1086 words - 5 pages the line of the human shoot.” (1975) The three positions on the relation of Christianity and world religions, namely exclusivism, inclusivism (or fulfillment) and pluralism was developed in response to religious plurality. The exclusivist position has been the governing status of the Catholic churches as a whole beyond much of its chronicles, up until the Enlightenment. This position is the intellectual faculties of God's most

Political Science Principles Of Research Research Classification Essay Analyse : Wierenga, A. (2011) “Transitions, Local Culture And Human Dignity: Rural Young Men In A Changing World” Journal Of...

1228 words - 5 pages concurrent cultural practices with transitioning into an urban environment.Reference ListCostello, P. (2004, 05 11). Australian Government. Retrieved 08 20, 2012, from Budget Stratergy and Outlook 2004-05:, K. F. Collecting Qualitative Data. In K. F. Punch, Introduction to Social Research - Quantative and Qualitative Approaches. London: Sage Publicatioin.Wierenga, A. (2011). Transitions, local culture and human dignity- Rural young men in a changing world. Journal of Sociology , 47 (4), 371-386.

Relativism And Morality Essay

1156 words - 5 pages connects our overall existence as a whole. Once our humanity is chipped away at by another we can see where the wrong doing lays. The preservation of life and the freedom to live life is what is most wrong to take away. Essentially a moral norm is things that our universal human morality should prevent that rob others of life, dignity, survival, and one’s own will. The targeting of one culture for mass murder is universally wrong for robs others