This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Hyman Minsky And The Financial Instability Hypothesis

1935 words - 8 pages

Hyman Minsky and the Financial Instability Hypothesis

Luz A comas

Strayer University

Professor: Michael Hamuicka

Financial Management – FIN 534



The current turmoil on the Stock Market has taken a lot of people by surprise. One person who, were he alive today, wouldn’t be the least bit surprised, is Hyman Minsky, who predicted that events like this would be a regular feature of a deregulated financial system. He developed what he called “The Financial Instability Hypothesis”, and anyone who wants to understand today’s events needs to know about it.
The following is just an introduction to Minsky's ideas. Minsky’s research focused on ...view middle of the document...

Disagreeing with many mainstream economists, he argued that these swings, and the booms and busts that can accompany them, are inevitable in a free market economy, unless government steps in to control them, through regulation, central bank action and other tools. He opposed the deregulation that characterized the long 18 years of Greenspan era. No wonder we are hearing a lot of talks about regulations recently. (Introduction to Minsky Theory. 2008)
Minsky broke down the process from stability to instability into three types of debt phases: hedge, speculative, Ponzi.
Hedge phase describes that buyer’s cash flows cover interest and principal payments for borrowers who obtains a debt to buy an asset. This way, the debt is self-liquidating, fully hedged, so it is a stabilizing factor in this economic phase.
Speculative phase is a step further on the risk side. In this phase, cash flows cover only interest payments, but not enough to amortize the principal. Obviously, this is less stabilizing since borrowers (or in this case on its way to be speculators) are betting on: interest rate is not going up, and the value of the collateral will not decline. The longer an economy is stable, the more incentive to speculate, and the more speculative borrowers become.
Ponzi phase is the last phase toward the end of the bubble. In this phase, cash flows cover neither interest rate nor principal, and it all depends on rising asset prices to keep the borrowers afloat. In the mortgage market, it becomes option-ARM, a negative amortization loan, or subprime with no ability of paying back, and all the mortgage backed securities (MBS). In other fixed income market, it becomes collateralized debt obligations (CDO), SIV, leveraged loans which private equity firms use for their leveraged buyouts, relying on their acquired business to maintain historical high revenue growth and profit margin.
Different than speculative phase, this whole phase is hinged on asset price (or operating profit margin for private equity firms) to go up. They can’t just stay flat or not decline, they have to go up, otherwise their investments will get wiped out. They are also betting on future buyers will buy these overvalued assets from them, assuming more new buyers will buy the same assets at even higher price from future buyers. It is an escalation of buying high and selling even higher.
In these three step process, the tendency of markets becomes more risky as they become seemingly more stable. The longer the markets seem to be stable, or appear more secure the more risky and unstable they become. The false hope of security leads investors to extrapolate stability into the distant future.
In the Ponzi phase, the rising asset prices become a self-fulfilling prophecy. As more people enter the market and become speculators, they drive up the value of the collateral. In turn, they can borrow more to buy more assets to drive up...

Other Essays Like Hyman Minsky and the Financial Instability Hypothesis

The Missing Link Connection Organization and Financial Performance

4994 words - 20 pages The Missing Link Connecting Organizational and Financial Performance February 2007 Confidential Working Paper  Copyright 2007 McKinsey & Company Aaron De Smet Rodgers Palmer William Schaninger 2 Contents 3 3 7 8 8 9 11 12 Introduction Strong organizations have better financial results Achieving top-quartile organizational performance Focus on a few practices Target distinctiveness in four to five practices Create your blend for

Government Policy, Moral Hazard And The Endless Financial Crisis

1962 words - 8 pages Loan Crisis of the 1980’s and 90’s. Smaller institutions go bankrupt and are acquired by the big banks making them even bigger (the total would decline from 3,234 to 1,645). In 1998, the Fed rescues Long-Term Capital Management, a highly leveraged investment bank that gambled and lost during a worldwide decline in commodity prices. Normally financial institutions are risk-averse because failure means bankruptcy. But now risk taking is

What Were the Cause of the Financial Crisis of 2008 and 2009”

1126 words - 5 pages Rafael Puerari FIN 358 Professor Kingshott Midterm “What were the cause of the financial crisis of 2008 and 2009” The 2008 financial crisis led to a sharp increase in mortgage foreclosures primarily subprime leading to a collapse in several mortgage lenders. Recurrent foreclosures and the harms of subprime mortgages were caused by loose lending practices, housing bubble, low interest rates and extreme risk taking. Additionally, expert

Comparison Of Financial Statements For The Sony Corporation And The Google Corporation

1038 words - 5 pages Prof. William C. AudenACC 403Principles of AccountingSubmitted by: Jason K. HauckMODULE 1 CASEIn the following pages I will be discussing several topics to include: the importance of the GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principles), as well as comparing current assets and liabilities to non-current items. I will also review the financial statements for the Sony Corporation and the Google Corporation, locating the balance sheets, income

Impact of the Asian Financial Crisis in 1997 and Effect to Latin America

1898 words - 8 pages Impact of the Asian Financial Crisis in 1997 and effect to Latin America Name: Institution: Date: Abstract In 1997, the Asian Financial Crisis spread rapidly all over the Asia and affected almost all the economies in the world. Prior to the Asian Financial Crisis, the Asian countries such as Thailand, Malaysia, South Korea, Indonesia, Hong Kong and Singapore experienced a remarkable growth in the economy that was considered the highest in

Boards of Directors’ Composition and Financial Performance: the Columbia Sportswear Case

4807 words - 20 pages Corporate Governance Aikaterini Dimitriou 1030771 Boards of Directors’ Composition and Financial Performance: The Columbia Sportswear Case Aikaterini Dimitriou 1030771 Contents I. Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 2 II. Theoretical Background

Your Company Is in Financial Trouble and Is in the Process of Reorganizing

607 words - 3 pages Your company is in financial trouble and is in the process of reorganizing. Your manager wants to know how you will report on restructuring the debt. Use the following information to help with this assignment. • Part A ASSETS CURRENT ASSETS Cash and cash equivalents $ 108,340 Trade accounts receivable, net of allowances 2,866,260 Other receivables 62,150 Operating supplies, at lower of average cost or market 58,630 Prepaid

Discuss The Relationship Between Accounting Choices Made By Management And The Values Reported In Financial Statements And The Possible Reasons Why Those Choices Are Made

2485 words - 10 pages IntroductionThe Age (17 May, 1988) reported that the true picture of Wormald's financial state was revealed by the accountants, Arthur Young. After a request by the National Companies and Securities Commission (NCSC) Arthur Young prepared a revised report, increasing the original loss of $54.8 million to a loss of $255.9 million. This, of course, raises the question of why there was a difference between the reports prepared by the Wormald

The Fundamental Accounting Concepts And The Role Of Financial Accounting In Aiding The Decision Making Processes Of Four Different Non-Management Stakeholder Groups

2455 words - 10 pages IntroductionReliable, relevant financial statements present the best information about a company's economic history, current financial health, and prospect for the future (Johnson, 2004). The preparation and presentation of financial statements require the use of certain rules to ensure truth, fairness, and consistency.Accounting employs a number of concepts. They underlie all traditional accounting in commercial organizations and are generally

To What Extent Was Market Maturity the Cause of Caterpillar Restructuring? Critically Examine the Extent the New Strategy Transformed Market, Productive and Financial Performance

2481 words - 10 pages To what extent was market maturity the cause of Caterpillar’s restructuring? Critically examine the extent the new strategy transformed market, productive and financial performance. During the late 1980s and the early 1990s Caterpillar Inc. (CAT), a $30 billion colossal in the earth-moving equipment (EME), engines and power systems, underwent a significant restructure. This was because in 1982 CAT posted its first annual lost of its 50-years

The students who study science should be given more financial support than those who study other subjects like language and business. Do You agree?

337 words - 2 pages short - sighted. What they ignore is how critical a role other professionals play in our life, and furthermore there is much more to society than just that.One the other hand, it is indeed true to say that other professionals also contribute as much as scientists to social development. For example, banking and financial institutions are vital to funding development and research projects. Can we imagine a society where businesses do not exist to

Related Papers

Compare The Efficient Markets Hypothesis With Other Theories Of Pricing In Financial Markets

2317 words - 10 pages EFFICIENT MARKETS HYPOTHESIS AND OTHER THEORIES OF PRICING IN FINANCIAL MARKETS Name Course Title/Code Instructor’s Name Date Efficient Markets Hypothesis and other theories of pricing in financial markets Efficient market hypothesis (EMH) is a theory that emerged in the 1960s. It states that it is difficult to predict the market since the price has been set and reflect the current market conditions. It is a disputed and controversial theory

How Accurate Is It To Suggest That Treaty Of Versailles Was Mainly Responsible For The Political And Economic Instability In Germany In The Years 1919 1923?

1384 words - 6 pages , which sparked further frustration within society as Germans were branded with the ‘war guilt clause’, accepting full responsibility for the conflict. Overall, we can see that the Treaty of Versailles laid the long-term flaws in the new Weimer Republic that led to political and economic instability in the years 1919-23. The issue of domestic policy also played a major role in the political and economic instability; by 1922 the new Weimer

Bhp Billiton And The Financial Crisis

2441 words - 10 pages . (PAR, 2009 pp 5) The market for petroleum and indeed the mining industry as a whole was unsure what effect the global financial crisis would have and what action affected parties would take during the period. Regardless of the changes, such a large and important company as BHP would have to study the potential changes and start, if necessary, reformatting their financial planning/strategies and other control processes. These would have to be

Economic Principles And The Financial Services

1321 words - 6 pages Economic Principles and the Financial Services Unit Standard 14517 Summative assessment 3 Question 1 1.1 Diagram of Four Phases of Business Cycle Four Phases of Business Cycle Business Cycle (or Trade Cycle) is divided into the following four phases :- 1. Prosperity Phase : Expansion or Boom or Upswing of economy. 2. Recession Phase : from prosperity to recession (upper turning point). 3. Depression Phase