Imf And World Bank Challenge Nation State

1439 words - 6 pages

To what extent do organizations like the IMF, WTO, and World Bank challenge the nation state’s ability to shape domestic economic and social policy?

The World Trade Organization welcomed with open arms Russia in 2012. This would open up trade possibilities for many countries in Asia, Europe and even the US. Some US companies, like Caterpillar, are already exporting a substantial amount to Russia. However, many in Congress do not want to grant Russia permanent normal trade status because of the way Russia has handled many political situations. As Andrew Kramer brought out in his NY Times article, “Congress has balked at the Obama administration’s request to grant Russia permanent normal ...view middle of the document...

That will hurt the bottom line of companies here in the US and thus hurt US workers and the economy. So there will be much discussion about what status to grant Russia which shows that the WTO policies on its members to treat all other members the same will shape the national policy of the United States government on this matter.
In a general way the United States is dependent on the IMF, and thus that organization will influence US economic policy. There are a few reasons why the International Monetary Fund makes it easier for the United States to do business globally, and I will look at one. Because of globalization, the US economy is tied up closely to the growth of the world economy. The IMF can lend to developing countries and thus stabilize their ability to engage in trade with the US. In fact, as brought out in the report by C. Randall Henning, US trade (exports plus imports) with countries that have borrowed from the IMF totals more than $400 billion per year. Keeping foreign trade open by lending to countries that struggle economically or that face a crisis which hurts their economy, limits the potential for a collapse of currencies and growth that could hurt the US economy. So by supporting the IMF and developing policies that make it easier to support the IMF, especially financially, the US government may feel it is doing what is necessary to help local job growth and strengthen the country financially.
There is also the argument that the United States would have to tailor its policies to please other member countries of the IMF, therefore compromising its ability to make independent decisions that would be beneficial for itself. The counter to that is by having more nations involved and making multilateral decisions, there are more resources to handle a crisis and more countries to shoulder the burden of responsibility. Also, the US has the major influence over the IMF and has veto power over decisions of the Fund, so the United States could keep the decisions of the IMF in line with its own economic policy preferences. Once again, it seems belonging to the IMF does have an effect on policy decisions of the US, but this could be a compromise which is the best decision for the health of the United States economy. So obviously it is in the best interest of the US to make sure the IMF can continue to support these smaller countries.
The IMF has also come under scrutiny because of the conditions under which it will provide assistance to countries, and allow countries to be a member. The organization uses this conditionality to impose economic policies that it thinks are best for the country. So in the United States, the Federal Reserve Bank not only has to fight inflation but also create policies that would stimulate job growth and the economy. This is usually based on what the team of economists used by the IMF thinks is best as an economic policy, not necessarily what is best for the country. It seems that the Fund’s economists...

Other Essays Like Imf and World Bank Challenge Nation State

Brics Bank Essay

921 words - 4 pages form a development bank and a pool of currency swaps at their sixth annual summit in Fortaleza, Brazil. The July 15-16 summit marked a new beginning in the global economic order because for the first time in post-War history there was a collective, institutionalised effort from major economies to challenge the hegemony of the West-focused World Bank and International Monetary Fund (IMF). The New Development Bank (NDB) of Brics, which will start

Somalian Economy in 1990 Essay

5160 words - 21 pages market system.[17] This observation requires further examination of the role the IMF and World Bank, and their structural adjustment program, had on Somalia’s economic decline. This essay does not oppose that western, economic policies of the Washington-consensus are solely sensible for the crisis in Somalia. Rather, IMF and World Bank policies were one factor that contributed to the economic problems and collapse of the Somali state

International Monetary Fund IMF

1645 words - 7 pages Balance of Payments Problems. A policy program supported by IMF financing is designed by the national authorities in close cooperation with the IMF, and continued financial support is conditional on effective implementation of this program. ==►The IMF is also actively working to reduce poverty in countries around the globe, independently and in collaboration with the World Bank and other organizations. ==►The IMF provides financial support

How Latin America Could Get Out of Imf's Control

3460 words - 14 pages fund and lending organization established on 26 September 2009 by Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay, Uruguay, Ecuador, Bolivia and Venezuela with an initial capital of US$20 billion. The Bank is intended as an alternative to borrowing from the IMF and the World Bank. Hugo Chávez has promised to withdraw from the IMF and encourages other member states to do so as well. Latin America's dependence on the IMF fell dramatically between 2005 and 2008, with

Un and Ngos Make to Solve the Problems of Population and Wealth Facing Humankind in the 20th Century

652 words - 3 pages After the Second World War, the world’s population growth became faster. The problem is serious especially in the third world countries. These countries need to face overcrowding, food and resource shortage. And the distribution of wealth is uneven. So the United Nation and other international organizations make to solve the problems. Due to the population growth, the living standard of the poor countries becomes worse. UN form IMF and World

Democratic Republic of Congo

984 words - 4 pages World Bank and IMF are lending institutions that provide funding to developing countries. These developing countries are to use this funding to support projects and/or policies that are designed to fight poverty and other economic concerns. Developing countries such as, Democratic Republic of Congo(DRC) are plagued with poverty, health concerns and lack many of the basic necessities to live. Many question whether the support from these

The International Monetary Fund's Model

1834 words - 8 pages Who are the IMF? The International Monetary Fund( IMF) is comprised of 188 member states for increasing global cooperation on monetary matters, ensure financial stability, facilitate international trade, support sustainable economic growth and high employment and working to reduce poverty all over the world. Although, the IMF is one of the specialized agencies of United Nations, they have their own charter, management structure and financial

IMF- International Monetary And Financial Committee

5134 words - 21 pages that they would need. When the IMF was established in 1944 by a United Nations conference held at Bretton Woods, New Hampshire, the Allied Powers of World War II also established a U.S. dollar-based international monetary system. Under the agreement of Bretton Woods, the IMF and the World Bank began to monitor the economics of world market.History and Purpose of the IMFThe IMF was conceived for economic cooperation designed to avoid a repetition

Imf and Stand by Arrangements

1850 words - 8 pages Taliban ideology. Pakistan does not need injections of temporary macroeconomic calm, but durable support for production-led growth. And that is possible only by focusing the much-ignored social sector. A stable democratic and economically sound Pakistan is in the interest of the world today. Therefore, IMF, WB, Asian Development Bank or donor agencies instead of extending new loans to Pakistan, should think about canceling the by-lateral and multilateral external debts of Pakistan, enabling it economically powerful enough to eliminate religious fundamentalism and fanaticism. Contact: cadtm.pakistan@gmail.com

Bretton Woods Agreement

2449 words - 10 pages ). The agreement aimed to rebuild after WWII through a series of currency stabilisation programs and infrastructure loans to war torn nations. By 1946 the system was in full operation through the newly established International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD/World Bank) and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) 2 which were both established under the Bretton Woods Agreement (Wiggin, 2006, para. 3). There were several main features

Bretton Woods Agreement

2441 words - 10 pages stabilisation programs and infrastructure loans to war torn nations. By 1946 the system was in full operation through the newly established International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD/World Bank) and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) which were both established under the Bretton Woods Agreement (Wiggin, 2006, para. 3). 2 There were several main features of the Bretton Woods Agreement including, an adjustable pegged

Related Papers

Imf And World Bank Responsible For Economic Genocde

1053 words - 5 pages IMF and World Bank responsible for economic genocide. Ahmed Raza This article talks about how global organizations such as the IMF and the World Bank, which were created to bring people and countries out of poverty have in contrast have made the situation for those nations and their people worse. The article firstly gives a brief description about what the IMF and the World Bank are and what their role initial role was and how it has changed

Rsst1 Nation, State, And Nation State Essay

2519 words - 11 pages responsibility of providing for the national defense, protection of borders, regulation of international commerce, and federal law enforcement. The United States of America, arguably, more than any other nation has a huge in influence and plays a great role in world affairs. The interaction of the United State with other nations and international organizations falls under the broad title of foreign affairs. The guiding principles and goals of the United

Mexico And The World Bank: Rebuilding A Country

1829 words - 8 pages decentralization in mind, by placing greater weight of state-level policies and programs. The Bank is currently investing in several programs that combat many of the goals listed on the CAS agenda. The Bank just approved a $202 million project to protect the environment, a $400 million loan for rural investment, and a $64.6 million project to improve financial services to the poor. Mexico has a long way to go, but with the help and financial support of institutions such as the World Bank, it can hopefully develop into a strong and independent nation that is able to avidly compete in world markets.

The Nation State, Core And Periphery: A Brief Sketch Of Imperialism

2354 words - 10 pages world. A leading organ of this conflict was the respective national-bourgeoisie’s nation-state. Some Neo-Marxists have argued that given the ostensive decline of the nation-state, imperial sovereignty is increasingly being replaced by a new form of sovereignty and economic organization which transcends the nation as a unit of political and economic organization. These two issues; the persistence of unequal relations between the core and