This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Indigenous Law Essay

3728 words - 15 pages

PART A: Question 4 Survival of Society
Following Mabo (No 2) the Native Title Act 1993 (NTA) gave hope to aboriginal communities around Australia. The Yorta Yorta People were the first Aboriginal community to make a claim to the government in an attempt to regain the land that was rightfully theirs. However, in Yorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v Victoria the High Court found that the native title rights of the Yorta Yorta People could not be recognised as the community had failed to maintain a continuous acknowledgement and observance of traditional laws and customs from the time of British sovereignty. In reaching this ...view middle of the document...

It is only those normative rules that are "traditional" laws and customs.
Secondly, and no less importantly, the reference to rights or interests…requires that the normative system under which the rights and interests are possessed (the traditional laws and customs) is a system that has had a continuous existence and vitality since sovereignty.
A) Origin in pre sovereignty society
The majority of the High Court held that because the aboriginal rights and interests over land and water owe their existence to traditional laws and customs, this ‘infers the existence of a normative system other than the common law.’ That is to say, native title rights and interests originate from an indigenous normative system. Upon British sovereignty an intersection between two normative systems occurred between the common law and the indigenous system. Because there can be ‘no parallel law making system after the assertion of sovereignty it follows that the only rights or interests…which will be recognized…are those that find their origin in pre-sovereignty law and custom.’ As summarized by Gleeson CJ, Gummow and Hayne,
“Traditional” in this context must be understood to refer to the body of law and customs acknowledged and observed by the ancestors of the claimants at the time of sovereignty.
Otherwise the term traditional would have no present meaning in the statutory definition.
Continuous existence of society
In order for native title rights and interests to achieve recognition and protection the normative system must have had a continuous existence and vitality. Indigenous societies must have continued to acknowledge and observe the traditional laws and customs since sovereignty. The court qualified that the continuity must be ‘substantially uninterrupted’. The Court explains that this qualification was made for two purposes; to recognize that proof of continuous acknowledgement and observation of oral traditions is extremely difficult, and to acknowledge that due to European settlement it is inevitable that ‘the structure and practices of those societies…will have undergone great change since European settlement.’
It therefore follows that the High Court allowed for an element of change within the traditional laws and customs. The content of the laws and customs does not have to be identical, as long as their origins derive from a pre-sovereignty normative system. It is the normative system, not the content, which must have a continuous existence. Accordingly, Gleeson CJ, Gummow and Hayne JJ stated that adaption of traditional laws and customs is not ‘necessarily’ fatal to a native title claim. The key question is whether the law and custom can still be seen as traditional.
However, the court faced difficulties in the application of this liberal view, and ‘it becomes reasonably clear that the joint judges contemplated little accommodation of adaptation and interruption’. The question still remains ‘How, if at all, is account to be taken of the...

Other Essays Like Indigenous Law

Term Paper on History of Education in Nigeria

3470 words - 14 pages existed for a long time as human beings started living in societies of Africa and this education is referred to indigenous African education. The purpose of education in the traditional African society was to set afoot a man with functional skills that would help him live peacefully among others and contributes his quota to the overall development of himself and his community. Fafunwa (1974) observed, “Society used to accord priority to the

Social Injustice in Australia Essay

545 words - 3 pages forward by the gov. the Government has put through many campaigns such as racial hatred legislation in 1992 (the Racial Discrimination Legislation Amendment Bill 1992), and later reintroduced it in an amended form (the Racial Hatred Bill 1994). The Government committed $5 million for the first of what was described as a two-year campaign, stating that the other $5 million would be for campaign's effectiveness. The Indigenous Law Centre (formerly the

Montana 1948 - Racism

655 words - 3 pages Hayden sons, are the only two white people in the novel free from prejudice against indigenous people. This may have been because they come from different states and have moved into Montana. David shares his mother’s ideals, seeing only Right and Wrong, not European and Indian. Through these characters, and also through Marie Little Soldier and Ronnie Tall Bear, the novel presents images of hope, moving forward towards social justice. The novel shows a community that is changing and people in conflict over the issue of racism. The reader, like David Hayden, becomes sceptical of human nature, history and the law, because the novel has dramatised racism in many forms.

Bangladesh and 15th Amendment

2943 words - 12 pages The 15th amendment, CG, indigenous people, and related issues→ M. Serajul Islam  The 15th amendment was inevitable because of the abolition of the 5th and 7th amendments by the Court. However, the Parliamentary Committee that was set up to deal with the Court's rulings extended its terms of reference beyond the rulings and delved into issues and areas that had already divided the nation, for instance the issue of the caretaker government

Early Aboriginal Lifestyles And Clans

1667 words - 7 pages elders and ways of identification.LawsMarcia Langton is in my opinion undoubtedly correct when she states that the indigenous laws come from the Dreaming. She said:"The Aboriginal ancestors travelled the country during the Dreaming, the creative period from the time immemorial. They established the code of life which today is called The Dreaming or The Law."Langton, 1997, page 36The Law was continued and taught through the generations through

Common Law Concepts

1813 words - 8 pages CONCEPT 1 – COMPENSATION AS A WAY TO REDUCE NUISANCE (Hogan & Edwards, 2003) states the idea of compensation in Common Law is to protect the environment as it amplifies the need for organisations and individuals within a society to prevent nuisance. Furthermore, compensation concept has raised conflict between environmental concerns and restricts the property holder’s rights to fully utilize their resources. Nevertheless, the idea of

Re: Discussion on Religion

3659 words - 15 pages Instructor Name: Professor Alicia Plant Reference Cite for the book: Fisher, M. P. (2014). Living religions (9th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson. Week 1 Discussion for World Religions – REL212 "Understanding Religions and Indigenous Sacred Ways" Please respond to the following: Define indigenous religion, and describe at least one aspect of indigenous religions that exists in a similar form in a traditional mainstream religion

Critique of Kenyan Tv Industry

970 words - 4 pages of political representations to the owners and threats to sue through courts of law. The third category of the media in Kenya are the more venerable group indigenous magazines and weeklies such as the Weekly Review, Finance, The Nairobi Law Monthly, Parents, and Step. This category depends on the good will of the government of the day as their capital base is weak. They have less circulation confined mainly to most urban centers and consequently

State, with Reasons, Whether This Quotation Is Consistent with the Use of the Doctrine of Binding Precedent in Australian Courts

1273 words - 6 pages existing precedents set by British common law and highlighted how existing laws are not in the best interests of our society. Justice Brennan, a sitting judge on the case, discussed the notion that although Australian law is influenced by precedent, it is not strictly bound by this doctrine: ‘Australian law is not only the historical successor of, but is an organic development from, the law of England. Although our law is the prisoner of its

I Hate This

665 words - 3 pages % Christian, and 10% indigenous beliefs, the population also boasts more than 250 ethnic groups. The most influential are the Hausa, Fulani, Yoruba, Igbo, and Ijaw groups. The populace continues to experience longstanding tensions between ethnic and religious groups. English is the official language of Nigeria. The country also suffers from an abnormally high rate of HIV/AIDS infection, ranking 2nd in the world in that category. In addition

Racism - Issues Within The Australian Culture

2397 words - 10 pages and things good, true, worthy and reasoned. They are encoded in models of child development, in the common law, in aesthetics and national histories, the literature we study and read for pleasure. The recent National Inquiry into the Stolen Children (1997) is a powerful example of the ways such narrow and ill-informed assumptions can have disastrous consequences when enacted by welfare or legal authorities. Almost all non-indigenous officials

Related Papers

Scl1502 Assignment Two Semester 1 2013

1190 words - 5 pages ) and Introduction to Law (ILW 1501) you were introduced to indigenous law as part of South African Law. Write a short essay (1-1.5 pages) in which you explain what indigenous law is and what its role is in South African Law generally. You MUST consult sources other than the study guides and reference them properly. ANSWER The purpose of this short essay is to explain what indigenous law is and outline its role in South African Law

The Sufferings Of A Stolen Generation

2108 words - 9 pages , their families, their culture and their identity taken away from them, and they have unfairly suffered ever since. Word count: 1,476 Reference list: Armitage, A 1995, Comparing the policy of Aboriginal assimilation: Australia, Canada, and New Zealand, UBC Press, Vancouver Atkinson, R 2005, ‘Denial and loss: the removal of Indigenous Australian children from their families and culture’, Queensland University of Technology Law and Justice

Justicein The Australian Leagal System For Aboriginal And Torres Strait Islanders

840 words - 4 pages Equality and justice for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders (ATSI) is today an integral part the fabric of Australian culture, however that has not always been the case. For many years after Australia was settled by the British and it was declared ‘ Terra Nullius’ all its citizens have been subject to a system of laws based upon British common law. This has been an ongoing source of conflict as the indigenous communities had, and to an

Legal Work Prelim Term 1 (Not Complete)

978 words - 4 pages Oral Law: Oral Law is law that is not written down but is spoken Kinship : The act or fact of being in a relationship. Terra Nullius: Land owned by no one. Native Title: Native title is land given to the indigenous community by the government. Who is Eddie Marbo: Dispute Resolution If the law is broken or a dispute arises family and community is involved in resolution. * Discussions are held at ceremonial times * Elders