Inmate Labor Essay

854 words - 4 pages

The utilization of prison labor for the purpose of clearing urban blight and renovating abandoned homes in Detroit would be cost effective and could rapidly change the face of Detroit for the better. However there are those that would undoubtedly oppose the use of inmate workers no matter how noble the cause. But who could be against the the demolition of dilapidated structures that cover Detroit’s neighborhoods? Who would oppose the use of inmate workers in helping to turn around this once great city? I shall explore the opposition to the use of prisoner labor in general and shall explore possible local stakeholders that may oppose the use of a inmate work force in Detroit as well. I ...view middle of the document...

(www.” So the inmates are able to assist needy families while also learning valuable skills in construction they can easily utilize once they are free from incarceration. This is not slavery but quite the opposite the state and the inmates are making the most of a an unfavorable situation. If these inmates were left in there cells it is true they would work less. But I find it difficult to believe that most would rather be behind bars instead of out in the community assisting people from the very communities they once belonged to.
According to the National Institute of Corrections “. jails and communities must jointly own and address the issue of local reentry (of offenders) (NIC TJC, 2008)”. Inmates that invest there time in bettering there community are more likely to be more accepted back into that community and more likely to strive to find employment
So does utilizing inmate labor to assist in the destruction and or building of new homes in Detroit amount to slavery ? Simply put the answer is' no' The 13 th amendment of the Constitution states “Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.”
So if the law of the land allows this why is prison labor not being used more widely in cash strapped Detroit and in other cities near or in bankruptcy? Besides the Civil rights advocates, the politician...

Other Essays Like Inmate Labor

The Principle Purpose of Kate Richards O’Hare's Writing from Crime and Criminals

565 words - 3 pages the misuse of prisoners as objects for profit. Crime and Criminals serves to pinpoint the corruption of the penal institution, judicial system, and the “under the table” profiteering between manufacturing corporations and the Department of Justice when using the prisoners for dirt-cheap labor.             Each inmate was asked to complete a job, however if they didn't finish their job they were dealt terrible punishments. The harshest of

Final Project Essay

1525 words - 7 pages duty of a correctional review specialist is to provide information to administrative staff; responsible for ensuring that the Inmate Grievance Resolution Program operates within the confines of its Directive; provides direct supervision to grievance staff in the assigned jail facility handling inmate grievance complaints by an inmate about the substance or application of any written or unwritten policy, regulation, rule or procedure of DOC or any of

Criminal Justice

1517 words - 7 pages other prison. Federal prisons have over gone a tremendous change over the last couple hundred years. Early punishment was often public humiliation, “slave” work sentences and/or corporal punishment. It was not until the Quakers, a deeply religious group, believed that a criminal should be dealt with in a more humane fashion and given labor. By 1786, convicts were providing honest labor while wearing the “ball and chain” and brightly colored

Prison Comparison

1401 words - 6 pages conditions were cleaner, healthier and body contamination was avoided by separating inmates from each other as much as possible preferably in isolation and to create habits by enforcing strict rules. Prisoners work at productive labor, no sitting around as they did in old jails and prisons. The secular institution was a place where the inmate expressed regret, a religious meeting needed for expressing contrition for sin, including and a place of

Prison Systems

1086 words - 5 pages opposing the death penalty except for serious crimes such as murder. From the mid 18th century to be imprisoned meant hard labor for those who committed petty crimes. By 1777 John Howard (namesake of the Howard League) chastises the prison system as being filthy, barbaric, and disorganized. (Howard League, 2006) The Great Penitentiary Rivalry involved the state of Pennsylvania and the state of New York. And, each state believed that the


915 words - 4 pages both secular and spiritual, a type of place that would have humane punishment instead of the abusive and labor-heavy environment that you would find over in foreign countries, primarily in the western hemisphere. Over in the west, they used the aspect of physical punishment to expedite the sentences of criminals with serious charges against them, rather than wait for them to appear in front of a judge. Their philosophy in confinement involved

Criminal Justice

919 words - 4 pages outlawed torture and corporal punishment. Americans brought about two main developments. The first was the Pennsylvania System which included the Walnut street Jail. This type of system housed one inmate per cell. They also did not allow for group work or living. The next system was the Auburn system which was started by the Auburn prison in New York. This system is known for its congregate system. The prisoners were all in the same areas for

Penitentiary Ideal and Models of American Prison

929 words - 4 pages inmates, humane living conditions from bedding to health care, strict daily routines, and available religious contemplation. It was considered a less pure model than the Philadelphia system because of the inmate interactions not being limited. Prisoners are together, side by side, during work, meals, and prayer only returning to solitary confinement in their cells at night. However just because they were among other inmates strict rules of silence

Corrections Trend Evaluation

1569 words - 7 pages reach a maximum capacity population. Another current and future issue of concern for prisons and prison administrators stemming from overcrowding is prison violence. Prison researcher Stephen C. Light found that when conditions such as overcrowding worsen. Inmate misconduct often increases (Gaines & Miller, 2008, pp. 340).Prisoners often use violence as a way to show power or to control other inmates. Prison violence is a means of

Prisons in America

2658 words - 11 pages conditions 1. Typical prison cell a. Cell size b. Prisoner’s assigned to each cell 2. Inmate labor a. Prisoner jobs b. Hourly rate B. Security system conditions 1. Levels of security a. Minimum b. Medium c. Maximum 2. Differences between levels of security a. “Lockdown” b. Security Housing Units c. Private prisons Pinzon 11 C. Disciplinary actions against inmates 1. Different types of infractions a. Minor-major infractions b. Examples of

The Other Dead Factory

2087 words - 9 pages . “Gulag,” the Russian word for prison or camp, is actually an acronym for Glavnoe Upravlenie Lagerei (GULAG). “Gulag has also come to signify not only the administration of the concentration camps, but also the system of Soviet slave labor itself, in all its forms and varieties: labor camps, punishment camps, criminal and political camps, women’s camps, children’s camps, transit camps.” But isn’t “concentration camp” is a term usually

Related Papers

In Both The Uk And The Us, The Prison System Is Being Increasingly Contracted Out To The Private Sector, Often Public Corporations. (The Largest Of These Is The Corrections Corporation Of America, A...

2059 words - 9 pages   new   trend,   as   it   happened   from   the   Reconstruction-­‐era   till   1920,  targeting  minorities  such  as  Afro  Americans  convicting  and  forcing  them  to   forced   labor (Hinkes-Jones 2013).   A   similar   event   is   happening   today   with   the   prison   system,   whose   2.3   million-­‐inmate   populations

Do The Time, Pay The Crime

802 words - 4 pages earned money for the on-going errors that inmates keep repeating? Does that make sense? In the United States alone there is approx 2.4 million people incarcerated. 2.4 million inmates! That’s almost 7% of Canada’s population. Prisons cost taxpayers more than $32 billion a year. An American study done in 2010, demonstrated that every year an inmate spends behind bars costs taxpayers anywhere from $30,000.00 to $168,000.00! So an individual

The Prison System Essay

1236 words - 5 pages version of the silence and labor system. Two systems emerged to form the debate of which version was more effective in running a prison: that used by Pennsylvania and that used by New York. The Pennsylvania system utilized the idea that silence was a virtue in an intense way. Separate confinement spared each inmate from the influence of others and prisoners worked, slept, and ate alone in their cells. The New York system focused on obedience and

Which Warden Presented The Most Realistic Vision Of How Sing Sing Should Operate? Was This Also The Best Vision? Why?

1113 words - 5 pages -democracy under him. A little bit of pressure was always useful at those times, but under his control there was too much pressure on inmates. Besides, he had completed the entire prison with inmate labor. Inmate activities thus made Sing Sing a money-making opportunity but Lynds' cruel and unjust punishments influenced the care of the prisoners negatively. Consequently, his totalitarian conduct decreased the productivity inevitably.Lynds' strict regime