‘International Law Is Not Imposed On States – There Is No International Legislature.’ (Wallace, R.M. (2005) International Law, 5th Ed, Sweet & Maxwell)

2388 words - 10 pages

i. ‘International Law is not imposed on States – there is no international legislature.’
(Wallace, R.M. (2005) International Law, 5th ed, Sweet & Maxwell)

When looking at this statement it is important for one to consider the concept of International Law and how this idea differs from the domestic legal order. Ascertaining the law on any given point within the domestic legal system is not usually a difficult process. In the US, for example, one will look to see as to whether a certain legal matter is covered within their codified constitution and through law reports view how similar matters were interpreted by the judiciary. However, when this method is compared with that of ...view middle of the document...

(Adapted from Malcolm. M. Shaw, 2003, Chapter 3). Nonetheless what does become clear, when one looks at custom as a source of international law, is that it does impact on sovereign states with the International Court of Justice (ICJ) acting as the judicial arm of international law. The statement which this paper is based on argues that international law is not imposed on states, however, when one looks at the Right of Passage over Indian Territory case, Portugal claimed a right of passage over Indian territory but India claimed that no local custom could be established between the two states, however the ICJ declared that there had in the past existed a right of passage and due to it being a constant and uniform practice it was accepted as customary law. What this case shows then is that international law is in some circumstances imposed on sovereign states.

Another source of international law which impacts on sovereign states are treaties and, unlike custom, these are a more modern and deliberate method. For the purpose of this paper one will look at the law-making treaties, which are intended to have universal or general relevance, as opposed to bilateral treaties which are between few states. The reasoning for this is because it bears more international relevance because more states are involved. Article 38 refers to ‘international conventions, which establish rules expressly recognised by the contradicting states’, these conventions or treaties are express agreements which are agreed by states and bear a close resemblance to contracts in that these agreements once signed are binding on states. The sheer amount of international treaties has increased dramatically over the past century and it could be argued that this increase is due to the growing need for ratification of the concept of international law. Some treaties require the participation of a large number of parties in order o produce rules which can be binding on all, these treaties are a prescribed set of rules to be followed and an example of this could be the Genocide Convention. This particular type of treaty is a compulsory agreement which even if not signed by some parties is still binding due to it then becoming not only a treaty but a customary act. Therefore, although it can be difficult to ratify international law it can be imposed on states in some circumstances.

A further source of international law is the general principles of law which arises when there is no statute nor judicial precedent which covers a certain legal point. What this method does is deduce a rule which is best relevant to the point by using already existing rules or directly from the general principles of law. This has further relevance in international law due to there being no method of legislating new situations. However, what this principle does is bridge a gap that could appear international law thereby solving a possible problem. This can therefore impact on states because even if a certain...

Other Essays Like ‘International Law Is Not Imposed on States – There Is No International Legislature.’ (Wallace, R.M. (2005) International Law, 5th Ed, Sweet & Maxwell)

Public International Law: International Courts and Enforcement

2718 words - 11 pages century. In 1625, Hugo Grotius [referred to by most people as father of international law] followed with the first systematic treatise on international law, de iure belli ac pacis, which dealt with the laws of war and peace. One important aspect of Grotius's treatment of international law is that he no longer bases it exclusively upon Natural Law, but also accepts that states among themselves can also create binding rules of law (ius voluntarium

Sources of International Trade Law Essay

1944 words - 8 pages that apply in the domestic jurisdiction, especially when there is no separate body of law in a country for dealing with international trade transactions. Also, it is going to analyse the relevant parts of municipal law that can apply to the governance of international trade transactions. The questions that this essay is going to analyse are: What are the sources of international trade law? What are the alternatives available for countries to deal


3038 words - 13 pages have been one of the classical methods of regulating ________ trade a. International b. National c. Domestic d. None of the above 5. The world trade organization (WTO) was established on 1st January a. 1996 b. 1995 c. 1997 d. None of the above IIBM Institute of Business Management 1 Examination Paper of Marketing Management 6. Export documentation is a very important area in _______ management a. International b. Import c. Export d. None


532 words - 3 pages International marketing is the use of advertising standards in more than one nation, by organizations abroad or beyond national borders. It is an act of considering international tastes and trends in order to market a particular product globally. International marketing is an expansionary version of a locally produced marketing plan which takes into account marketing identification, targeting, and decisions internationally. It is essential for

Bus 378 International Commercial Law and International Business Transactions

2903 words - 12 pages , there are cases where jurisdictions have recognized the tribunal’s priority to rule on its own jurisdiction (also known as negative effects of the competence principle). This is considered as a lis pendens rule. Hauberg (2014) states In international civil and commercial disputes in the EU, courts in different Member States may have jurisdiction to hear the same case. Such jurisdiction may be based on purely national rules or may be based on the

International Humanitarian Law and Protection of Women

1894 words - 8 pages €œhonour” when referring to the special protection conferred by international humanitarian law on women against attacks like “rape, enforced prostitution, or any form of indecent assault”. The question of honour-a term which is also used in other articles of the Geneva Conventions and not only in those pertaining to women-demands more examination than can be done in such a general article, covering so many aspects of women and war. However

Asylum Protection in Diplomatic and International Law Perspective

637 words - 3 pages political threat, and permission to enter the state territory as confirmation to the asylum seeker request. In International law, every people possess right to seek asylum and take it in another country as the asylum seeker request, this right is stipulated in Universal Declaration of Human Rights Article no 13 . The right to seek asylum protection can’t be segregated with the authority of states to give the permission in order provide necessary

International Business Law and Its Enviornment! Chapter 1 .2 Question

798 words - 4 pages international business law is a system of rules that check and supervision an international business. 6. I think the corporation accountable to their host country, consumers, and investors. My ideas about set up an accountability system to ensure compliance with codes of conduct and other ethical and social responsibility standards for business are the system should be based on the existent international business law; According to practical

International Finance

4512 words - 19 pages . Drabek, Z. (2013). Regulation of foreign investment challenges to international harmonization. Singapore: World Scientific Publishing Company. Haley, U. (2001). Multinational corporations in political environments ethics, values and strategies. River Edge, N.J.: World Scientific. Hill, C. (2005). International business: Competing in the global marketplace (5th ed.). Boston: McGraw-Hill/Irwin. Luo, Y. (2001). Strategy, structure, and performance

International Marketing

3465 words - 14 pages INTERNATIONAL MARKETING International marketing is simply the application of marketing principles to more than one country. However, there is a crossover between what is commonly expressed as international marketing and global marketing, which is a similar term. For the purposes of this lesson on international marketing and those that follow it, international marketing and global marketing are interchangeable. Trade is increasingly global in

International Trade

3259 words - 14 pages Chicago is reflected around the world. If stocks on the New York Stock Exchange plummet in value, the effects are not limited only to the United States; news are quickly transmitted worldwide, and stock prices all over the world might be affected. If factory workers in Taiwan go on strike, prices of Taiwanese toys may be forced up in Europe, Asia and North America. Interdependence means that countries have to work together and rely on each

Related Papers

International Law Essay

1854 words - 8 pages . * The contract of sale makes it clear which law will apply in the case of dispute United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) manages sale of goods contracts. Undroit Principles of International Commercial Contracts (Unidroit Principles) governs all types of commercial contracts (Mo 2013). In Australia, when there is no inconsistency existing between the rules and the provisions of the CISG, or any other

International Law Essay

1144 words - 5 pages . Conclusion The simulation shows how challenging it can be to partake in international business relationships and how even the best lay contracts will not always cover every last issue that can arise. The simulation showed just how complex working around crisis can be and how not every legal business decision involves business and legal rights first but rather the need to make choices for the best of people ad for the greater good than what is legally right for either side to do. This can be a challenging grey area that has no clear winners but is vital for the image and survival of a company.

Application Of International Law Essay

1166 words - 5 pages Application of International Law By Dawn M. Engel Argosy University Business Law and Corporate Ethics Dan Adams May 28, 2014 In the United States, Calvin Coolidge signed the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) into law in 1925, to be effective on January 1, 1926. (Wikipedia, 2014). “International commercial arbitration in Russia is governed by another statute: Law No. 5338-1 . . . It follows the UNCITRAL Model Law almost verbatim.” (Nikiforov

International Law Nibm Answers Essay

3022 words - 13 pages offence on account of any act or omission which did not constitute a penal offence, under national or international law, at the time when it was committed. Nor shall a heavier penalty be imposed than the one that was applicable at the time the penal offence was committed Article 12. No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honor and reputation. Everyone has the right