This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is China Neo Mercantilist Nation Essay

698 words - 3 pages

China's not breaking the rules. It's playing a different game.
Posted By Clyde Prestowitz Friday, February 17, 2012 - 4:24 PM Share
In their Oval Office meeting earlier this week, President Obama predictably warned China's visiting president-in-waiting Xi Jinping that China must play by the rules in international trade. It sounded right and fair and slightly tough as it was carefully crafted to do by top White House political advisers, and the president may even believe it. But he shouldn't have said it.
Put aside for the moment the indelicacy of implicitly calling the soon to be president of the a country that is the world's second most powerful and that highly values "face" (pride,dignity) a cheater. I mean, can you imagine the reaction here if Xi had lectured Obama on playing by the rules? But I digress.
There are three problems. The phrase "all must play by the same rules" implies that all are playing the same game, but in actuality they are not. In many ...view middle of the document...

This is a totally false premise that immediately gets the discussions off in irrelevant directions. The global economy is, in fact, sharply divided between those who are playing the free trade game and those who are playing some form of mercantilism. Of course, there is a spectrum of attitudes and policies, but roughly speaking the Anglo/American countries, North America, and parts of Europe are playing free trade. Most of Asia, much of South America, the Middle East, Germany and parts of Europe are playing neo-mercantilism. It's like watching tennis players trying to play a game with football players. It doesn't work, and insisting on playing by the rules doesn't help, because both sets of teams are playing by the rules -- of their game. 
In any case, there are a lot fewer clear cut rules than most people think. For example, probably the biggest single factor in the off-shoring of large chunks of U.S. based production and millions of jobs abroad has been the packages of financial investment incentives offered by China and others to global companies to encourage them to relocate production. More jobs have been lost to these packages than to currency manipulation. But you can't complain about rules violations because there are no rules to cover these investment incentives. At the federal level, American doesn't offer such incentives but there is not WTO or IMF or other rule against it. Nor is the United States proposing any rules in this area.
Take the case of currency manipulation. China is surely manipulating its currency, but so have and do many other countries. Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, and others all used currency manipulation is a major element of their export led miracle growth strategies. Some of these countries still to engage in currency manipulation and recently others such as Brazil and Switzerland have gotten into the game. Germany enjoys an undervalued currency because of its incorporation in the Euro. So here is a case where rule violation has been so prevalent that the violation is, in a way, the rule. So if something is to be done about it, that something will have to be a lot more powerful than a call for everyone to "play by the same rules."
We first need to get everyone playing the same game, and that is more likely to turn out to be football than tennis.

Other Essays Like Is China Neo Mercantilist Nation

History of Korea China and Japan

1744 words - 7 pages with internal and external conflicts. Although China and Korea weren’t total failures, the Land of the Rising sun overshadowed them. China’s first experience with western imperialism is seen in the 1830’s when they had conflict with the spread of opium and the dwindling of silver within the country. China wished to stop both these events so when they confiscated supplies of opium from British traders, the British government used its newly

Businss Plan In China Essay

5302 words - 22 pages the establishment of the nation-wide enterprise and individual credit reporting arrangement (China Monetary Policy Report Q2, 2003).Chapter 4 Industrial AnalysisFigure 1 - The Five Factors or Forces Affecting Competition in an IndustryBased on a diagram appearing on page 4 of Competitive Strategy by Michael Porter. Free Press (1980).Five Competitive Forces4.1Potential EntrantsIt is unlikely to attract new competitors who will bring in substantial

Critically Evaluate Post War Realist Explanation of International Politics with Reference to Power

2541 words - 11 pages Relations. However, it is a highly controversial theory due to the fact there are no clear definitions of realism. Thus, there have been various definitions of realism, even though for the purpose of this assignment I will be limited to a few. According to Beer and Hariman[3], realism is the traditional, historical theory of international relations, reformulated in recent years as neo-realism. It includes important narratives, among which are

Arts2813 Annotated Bibliography

1083 words - 5 pages International Security Annotated Bibliography Joshua Liew z3464397 Annotated Bibliography Case Study: East China Sea Dispute Manicom, J. (2014). Bridging Troubled Waters: China, Japan, and maritime order in the East China Sea. Washington DC: Georgetown University Press. Manicom’s book questions the assumption that conflict is inevitable with

The Man of Steel and the Dragon: Australia’s Relationship with China During the Howard Era Proposal

5500 words - 22 pages Australian minerals and ore, and Australia was able to focus on common interests in its bilateral relationships with each nation. With China’s continuing rise is importance for Australia, the ANU’s Roy McDowall’s The Strategic Depiction of China in Howard Government Policy from 1996-2006 (2009) argues that for over fifty years China has been one of the primary threats to Australia’s defence and security, but successive Australian governments have

Debate Notes

690 words - 3 pages way to have an even trade with any other nation, always will be disproportional -There is no date in which paying back is due -The US is mainly concerned because China has 1.1 trillion bonds in the US Economy but that’s more of a political problem seeing them as a threat rather than an economic problem however Japan has 1.04 trillion invested in the US Economy and anyone could invest in the economy so China really is not the real threat


2571 words - 11 pages Globalisation, of course, is therefore a manifestation of a neo-liberal economic ideology.  Globalization is a process of interaction and integration among the people, companies, and governments of different nations, a process driven by international trade and investment and aided by information technology. This process has effects on the environment, on culture, on political systems, on economic development and prosperity, and on human

Hutu and Tutsi

2720 words - 11 pages started to massacre Tutsis in Rwanda. Almost 927,000 Tutsis were killed in 100 days. UN and all other countries in the world did nothing. 2. Q: It is impossible to objectively define nation. Why? Because in the objective definition of nation, nation is group people who speak the same language, have same religion, share the same history. But what about the countries like Swiss that have multiple language? So it cannot be

International Politics

1392 words - 6 pages . That action may have shifted international politics towards unilateralism and weakened the role of multilateral institutions. Realism is well alive again as its characteristics of survival and security of its own nation state becomes the ultimate goal for the US (Rosefielde, Mills 2007). Furthermore, the emergence of China as a great power in the Far East in the 21st century has also revived realism in international politics. China has seen its


913 words - 4 pages havoc on Tibet's fragile environment through extensive deforestation and open dumping of nuclear waste. Tibet's most sacred lake, Yamdrok Tso, is currently being drained for a Chinese hydroelectric power plant. This problem has not been dealt with for nearly 60 years. The United Nations has failed to punish China for any of its human rights abuses. Major corporations from around the world continue to do business with China. Last year

West's Effect on the World

2756 words - 12 pages The West’s Affect on the World Every nation is always in contention with one another. For every civilization that triumphs, others must suffer. For a majority of human history the strongest nations were comprised into a group known as the West. The west is home to the ideologies of democracy, capitalism, and consumerism. The idea of democracy has been forced upon many nations in the world by the Western states. Democracy however has

Related Papers

Chapter 5 Global Business Today Essay

929 words - 4 pages these costs? What? Having a free trade regime will create job loss in some industries. One thing the government could do is provide retraining programs. On the other hand jobs are lost every day and they don’t get government help to find a new job. 5. Reread the Country Focus on “Is China a Neo-Mercantilist Nation?” a) Do you think China is pursuing an economic policy that can be characterized as neo-Mercantilist? b) What should

Power And Wealth Are Intricately Linked

3253 words - 14 pages , Eric Schlosser wrote in his book, Fast Food Nation, “The McDonald’s Corporation has become a powerful symbol of America’s service economy, which is now responsible for 90 percent of the country’s new jobs.” (Saul 2011) Korn (2012) suggests that Multinational Corporations are increasingly exerting their power and clout in the legislative and regulatory spheres, resulting in a new and alarming world power structure. The pursuit of power and wealth

Can Regionalism Be A Principal For A Stable World Order?

3289 words - 14 pages state and a potential global village? The apparent breakdown of the traditional role of the nation-state, if many ever really existed, gives the impression that world order is changing - regionalism and return to neo-medieval structure could provide an answer. This essay will examine whether regionalism can be a principal for a stable world order and how it will interact with globalisation and nationalism. Firstly a definition of regionalism is

China. The Period Of Disunion And The Sui Dynasty

744 words - 3 pages enlightenment, and immortality, the Neo-Confucianists used metaphysics as a guide for developing a rationalist ethical philosophy. The Yuan Dynasty The Yuan Dynasty was a ruling dynasty founded by the Mongol leader Kublai Khan, who ruled most of present-day China, all of modern Mongolia and its surrounding areas, lasting officially from 1271 to 1368. It is considered both as a division of the Mongol Empire and as an imperial dynasty of China. In