This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Killing Is Never Justifies Essay

1612 words - 7 pages

Killing Is Never Justified

Capital punishment, by definition, is the legal killing of an individual. Now, how someone could be killed legally when murder is universally recognized as a violent and serious crime. It is irrevocable, meaning that once an inhabitant of death row pays the ultimate price. The death penalty is corporal punishment in its most severe form and is considered to be the ultimate form of retribution for those who have committed society's most heinous crimes, including rape and murder. Ultimately, Capital punishment is wrong due to the likelihood of error, the unjust racial allocation, and the violation of constitutional rights. However, many people believe that capital ...view middle of the document...

Subsequently, according to the Atlanta Weekly newspaper,
In Georgia in 1975, Earl Charles was convicted of murder and sentenced to death. A surviving victim of the crime erroneously identified Charles as the gunman; her testimony was supported by a jail-house informant who claimed he heard Charles confess. Incontrovertible alibi evidence, showing that Charles was in Florida at the very time of the crime, eventually establishes his innocence–but not until he had spent more than three years under his death sentence. His release owed largely to his mother’s unflagging efforts (Atlanta Weekly, May 30, 1982).

This man served three years under death row before his innocence was proved and he could become a normal citizen once again. Three years of his life has been wasted due to the fact that he had been framed. Deciding to execute him just one day short of three years, then the court would have put Earl Charles to death for a crime in which he did not commit.
Secondly, capital punishment is inflicted disproportionately on the poor and minority groups. Fifty years ago, Nobel Prize winner, Gunnar Myrdal, reported that, “the South makes the widest application of the death penalty, and Negro criminals come in much more than their share of executions.” Confirmation of these statistics is not just relative to the South, either. “Between 1930 and 1990, 4,016 persons were executed in the United States. Of these, 2,129 (or 53 percent) were black. During these years African-Americans were about twelve percent of the nation’s population” (Bedau 6). According to author D.J. Herda, Racial discrimination was on the grounds of which the Supreme Court relied in Furman vs. Georgia ruling the death penalty unconstitutional. Death row has always been disproportionately black in population in its history in relation to its population percentage. At the time Furman was convicted of murder, about six-hundred inmate’s addresses read Death Row. Of those convicted inmates, several were teenagers, over twenty were women, and a disproportionate many were black. Amidst this discrimination and injustice, no one had ever before confronted this issue on the grounds of injustice towards the poor and oppressed of the nation (Herda 13).
Undoubtedly, the choices of human lives are left to the discretion of imperfect human beings.
The history of capital punishment in American society clearly shows the desire to mitigate the harshness of this penalty by narrowing its scope. Discretion, whether authorized by statues or by their silence, has been the main vehicle to this end. But when discretion is used, as it has always been, to mark for death the poor, the friendless, the uneducated, the members of racial minorities, and the despised, then discretion becomes injustice. (Bedau 7).

Human nature uses temptation to attract the condemnation of people who are considered unclean. Chances are that a rich white man with a family and children at home is not going to be convicted, while a...

Other Essays Like Killing Is Never Justifies

Brutus' Motivation in Julius Caesar Essay

1087 words - 5 pages face of men, / The sufferance of souls, the time’s abuse¬— / If these be motives weak, then break off betimes / And every man hence to his idle bed’ ” (II.i.125-128). Brutus tells them all of the important reasons for killing Caesar are ones that they do not understand. He proceeds as if he is the only one who understands the underlying motives for assassination, and tells them that they are doing it for all the wrong reasons. Thus

Genocide in Darfur Essay

1376 words - 6 pages supplied with better equipment. Recently, fighting has intensified in the region and spilled into neighboring Chad; refugees are fleeing to the Central African Republic, which is embroiled in its own internal conflict. A regional catastrophe is brewing that could be worse even than the past three years of killing. Bashir recently accused aid workers of exaggerating Darfur's crisis to preserve their jobs. (washingtonpost,2008). The Human Rights

Free Will; Do We Have It or Not

1218 words - 5 pages was not squeamish about killing animals. But I had never shot an elephant and never wanted to. Somehow it always seems worse to kill a large animal." This shows that he really didn't want to shoot the animal. It was only out of pressure and to gain respect. He was put on the spot because the natives of the country viewed white men as being cruel and they were looking on expecting him to shoot. He felt pressured it's almost like he was forced into

Ambition Macbeth Persuasive Speech

1212 words - 5 pages Where our desire is got without content. 'Tis safer to be that which we destroy Than by destruction dwell in doubtful joy. After Duncans assasination the self-awareness of moral perversion is still present. Prior to Banquo’s assassination he justifies and nullifies this by convincing himself he’s too far up the river of blood to turn back. This marks the tipping point of his ambition. By this point, Macbeth is

The Improbability Of God

1499 words - 6 pages at the top of God’s system of priorities…This determination to believe when the proof is not provided and when the questions are not answered is central to our relationship with the Lord. He will never do anything to destroy the need for faith.” (When God Doesn’t Make Sense, pp. 17-18.) Hence, the absence of extraordinary evidence for God’s existence, one is justified in believing that a being does not exist. Throughout my philosophical

The Crucible

1055 words - 5 pages can never turn from. Abigail becomes so delusional in thinking that her relationship with Proctor could be a reality that she decides there is a necessity in killing Elizabeth. She decides she can do this by framing Elizabeth to taking part in witchcraft and then charging her in court which prompts an investigation. Even though her charade gets completely out of hand, she cannot find it in her heart to stop convicting people of signing with the

Death of a Salesman Analysis

637 words - 3 pages Injustice, either social or personal, is a common theme in literature. Choose a novel or a play in which injustice is important. Write an essay in which you clearly define the nature of the injustice and discuss the techniques the author employs to elicit sympathy for its victim or victims. Do not merely summarize the plot. Use evidence from the text to support your answer. Poignant, Tragic, Arthur Miller’s play “Death of a Salesman” discusses

Philosophy

1453 words - 6 pages them. Destiny is not in our hands and we can’t predict anything that could happen in the next one or two seconds, so where is the logic then in predicting that by someone killing himself in a certain situation the outcome of that, after a few seconds, will be guaranteed. Nothing in life besides death, is guaranteed. • The third argument is quite philosophical actually. It justifies suicide if the outcome can lead to maximum happiness. How

Federal Death Penalty Law

3153 words - 13 pages defendant is found guilty of intentionally killing the victim. Finally, if the case presents several aggravating factors that feature in the statutory list, the defendant is eligible for a death sentence (U.S. Department of Justice 3). The aggravating factors that necessitate a death penalty include the defendant having a prior record of criminal activities, which involve violent offenses. In addition, if the defendant has committed multiple

Julius Caesar - Study Questions

4021 words - 17 pages does Brutus object to Cicero joining the conspiracy? 5. He says Cicero will never follow what someone else began. 6. Why does Brutus oppose killing Mark Antony? 6. Their cause would seem too bloody, and they would be considered murderers. He thinks Antony is not dangerous. 7. How does Decius plan to get Caesar to the Capitol? 7. He says he will use flattery. 8. What advice does Brutus give the conspirators as they leave his house? 8. He

Justification Hamlet; S Deeds

798 words - 4 pages Hamlet to seek revenge, beause if he doesn't this means Hamlet did not love his father. Hamlet feels he has a moral justification for revenge because of the circumstances of the murder (brother kills brother and marries his wife). The murder of old Hamlet is the cataclyst for all the subsequent actions. Taking this into mind we can argue that without that one action Hamlet would never have sought revenge having as result that all the other actions

Related Papers

Atomic Bomb 1 Essay

902 words - 4 pages Lily Q. 3.11.12 The dropping of the atomic bomb over two major Japanese cities was and is a highly controversial topic. Some didn’t approve because it would mean the killing of hundreds of thousands of innocent civilians. Others fully supported it because they felt it was a necessary factor in getting Japan to surrender. This essay will strive to find and uncover both these areas. The author provides many good reasons

Utilitarian Act And Rule Essay

962 words - 4 pages pleasure and decrease pain, must provide the greatest good for the greatest number of people, and the result must be that the end justifies the means. In the case of the sailors lost at sea, the question is whether or not they morally justified in killing and eating the youngest member of the crew. Here, X (the cannibalism of another rational being) must be proven to increase pleasure and decrease pain, provide the greatest good for the greatest

A Review Of John Doones' The Flea

533 words - 3 pages bloods within the flea "Where we almost, yea more than married are."Even when his pickup line fails and the lady is about to smash the flea, John justifies the fleas' life "And cloistered in these living walls of jet. Though use make you apt to kill me, Let not to that, self murder added be, and sacrilege, three sins in killing three." I can see Donne begging for that fleas' life as the lady is about to smash it and then when she does Donne stated

View Of War In All My Sons

833 words - 4 pages justifies his actions for he thinks he has a responsibility to his family over the community. To Keller, “Nothin’s bigger than that…I’m his father and he’s my son, and if there’s something bigger than that I’ll put a bullet in my head!” (3.77). Miller uses this to criticize the kind of narrow-minded point of view Keller has. The entire play of All My Sons is a criticism of the American Dream. Joe Keller, is an ordinary American