This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Launching Military Coup Is Justified Essay

1680 words - 7 pages

Debates
This House believes launching a military coup against a democratic government can be justified
Coups are a regular occurrence around the world. The most recent happened in May 2014 when the Thai army overthrew the government of Yingluck Shinawatra. From 1945 to 2006 there were 261 coups of all descriptions.1 A coup can be defined simply as “a sudden, violent, and illegal seizure of power from a governmment”.2 This can mean that the seizure of power is by the people after a protest as in Ukraine but much more often this is done by someone with military or police forces at their disposal. It is such cases which will be looked at here.
This debate will only be looking at democratic ...view middle of the document...

nikolaymarinov.com/wp-content/files/GoemansMarinovCoup.pdf, p.2
2'coup', Oxford Dictionaries, http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/coup
3Thyne, Clayton L., and Powell, Jonathan M., 'Coup d’état or Coup d'Autocracy? How Coups Impact Democratization, 1950–2008', Foreign Policy Analysis, 16 April 2014, http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/fpa.12046/abstract
 
Read more
Discuss this
 
* Points For
* Points Against
Necessary to restore peace to the country
Point
The clearest, and most common, reason for the military stepping in is to restore peace to the country. When the stakes are so high, power through control of government, the ability to distribute resources, it is something well worth fighting for. The result can be that democracies become unstable and violent with election campaigns particular flashpoints. The runup to the Thai elections in 2014 shortly before the coup left 10 dead and 600 injured1 with no sign of stability returning after the flawed elections General Prayuth Chan-ocha the head of the army said the coup was necessary “in order for the country to return to normality quickly, and for society to love and be at peace again.”2 When there violence creating violence it is the military's role to step in the prevent such instability.
1Wilkinson, Laura, 'Thailand elections: Violent clashes in Bangkok over disputed poll', The Independent, 2 February 2014, http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/thailand-elections-violent-clashes-in-bangkok-over-disputed-poll-9101656.html
2Hodal, Kate, 'Coup needed for Thailand 'to love and be at peace again' – army chief', The Guardian, 23 May 2014, http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/may/22/military-coup-thailand-peace-general-prayuth-chan-ocha
 
Improve this
 
Counterpoint
In a country that is so polarised that there is violence at elections the chances are the military is not neutral. In Thailand the royalists had been calling for military intervention because they know it is unlikely they will win an election. A coup cannot therefore be considered to be likely to end violence; Egypt is a case in point as there have been more than 3,200 deaths in the 7 months after the coup against President Morsi.1
1'More than 3,200 Egyptians killed since coup', Middle East Monitor, 9 April 2014, https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/news/africa/10798-more-than-3200-egyptians-killed-since-coup
 
Improve this
 
A technocratic government is needed to prevent corruption
Point
Democracy does not mean that a country is not corrupt, or that the political leadership is not corrupt. There are many countries where democratic elections stand side by side with a large amount of corruption; Afghanistan, Libya and Iraq countries that have recently had elections following western intervention are ranked 175, 172, and 171 out of 177 on the corruption perceptions index. Even countries with long established democracies can be perceived as being corrupt, India is 94th.1 If...

Other Essays Like Launching Military Coup Is Justified

Iraq-Kuwait War Essay

2287 words - 10 pages not to intervene. Thus Iraq’s official reasonexplains why Iraq invaded Kuwait.Saddam’s leadership: The egoistic Saddam Hussein envisioned himself as the leader of the Arabworld. Kuwait’s defiance was seen as a personal attack on him. This induced Saddam Hussein toinvade Kuwait. Saddam was also facing pressure from the populace and military. He feared areligious uprising and a military Coup détat if the situation in Iraq did not improve. Thus

An Essay On The History And Present Western And American Intervention In The Middle East

9086 words - 37 pages Since the Second World War, the United States has been the dominant world power in the Middle East. Every political campaign or military intervention has been carried out to ensure the control of the world's most valuable energy source. Despite new discoveries of oil reserves in Central Asia, the Middle East still has two-thirds of the world's oil reserves, and its oil is still the cheapest to pump and produce. The U.S. has relied on repressive

Military Dictatorship May Be Necessary To Save Pakistan From Islamic Fundamentalism

1152 words - 5 pages In 1999, General Pervez Musharraf overthrew Pakistan's civilian government in a coup. While he has been criticized by some both within and outside of Pakistan for failing to restore democracy in that country, David Tahir Mehmood argues in the following viewpoint that Musharraf should instead be praised for taking actions against Islamic militants in Pakistan. He compares Musharraf to Mustapha Kemal (Ataturk), who as military dictator of Turkey

Prospect Theory and Democracy in Haiti

2504 words - 11 pages I. The Introduction: On September 30, 1991 a military coup in Haiti overthrew the newly elected President, Jean-Bertrand Aristide. The United States had just agreed to a policy of upholding democracy when the military junta and General Raoul Cedras overthrew Aristide. The U.S. was unable to accept the new heads of power and both the Bush and Clinton Administrations attempted to force these illegitimate leaders out of office so that Aristide

The Soviet Tragedy

1349 words - 6 pages . The different perspective of some Russian liberal historians is that October’s Revolution was not a proletarian revolution but a coup d´état carried out by the Bolshevik Party and influenced by the devastation of the First World War. This revolution was a brutal interruption on the country’s to achieve a constitutional democracy was the beginning of the totalitarianism in Soviet Union in the sense that Lenin’s Party dictatorship led to

Cuban Missile Crisis

1424 words - 6 pages Castro, after he nationalized businesses, which were all American owned. He, however left their Naval Base as is. The US broke off relations.Then in 1961 the CIA launched the Bay of Pigs operation, it involved training exiles to land and create a Coup d'etat and overthrow Castro. Castro learnt of this and was ready for it and the operation failed. Castro felt threaten and felt a second invasion was inevitableThe USA can be blamed for the causes of

Diet Analysis

1065 words - 5 pages Mexican-American War The Mexican-American War was fought between the United States and Mexico between 1846 and 1848, and it was marked the first American military battle to be fought on foreign soil. The Mexican American War was mainly driven by the idea of “Manifest Destiny”; the belief that the Americans had a God-given right, based on racial superiority, to spread across the Pacific Ocean (Chavez 2). The motives that were

Philippines Case Study

541 words - 3 pages mirrored the economy in terms of the significant positive change than has occurred over the last 50 years. In the mid-80’s the country had many obstacle to overcome “ national debt, government corruption, coup attempts, disasters, a persistent communist insurgency, and a military conflict with Moro separatists) as it returned to a democratic government. Since then we have seen a fairly unstable government with significant corruption up until

Spanish Civil War

2183 words - 9 pages those two popular and rival were creating a huge impact on the situation in Spain and becoming one of the main causes for the war. The final cause of the war was not any type of idealism, but a certain Francisco Franco and the coup d’état of 1936 where the nationalists rose against the republicans and started the civil war. Francisco Franco was born in Spain, grew up studying in Toledo and started his life in the military by fighting in the

Napoleon Bonaparte: Friend or Enemy to the French?

1308 words - 6 pages The main controversy over Napoleon is if he was a friend or enemy to the French people. Napoleon's prosecutors said that he destroyed the civil liberties of the French people. They also think that he started unnecessary wars of aggression. Another argument is that he ruled above the law like a absolute monarch. People on the defending side of Napoleon say that he saved France from a near anarchic situation in France. He extended the French

Indo-Pak Relations

4886 words - 20 pages have fought three major wars, one undeclared war and have been involved in numerous armed skirmishes and military standoffs. The Kashmir dispute is the main center-point of all of these conflicts with the exception of the Indo-Pakistan War of 1971, which resulted in the secession of East Pakistan (now Bangladesh). . And instead of bringing peace and prosperity to der vast majority of population both the states feel threatened and insecure by

Related Papers

Coups In Africa Essay

1714 words - 7 pages social divisions, partly from pre-colonial times, fueled the resentments between different groups or are deliberately used to fuel them. Due to power monopoly Nigeria has since witnessed transitions from democratic rule to military rule by force in a coup. Military force was justified in that the leaders sought to "maintain control" when democracy created a chaotic and dysfunctional society. Nigeria has also been overrun by corruption due largely in

Us Involvement In The Goulart Coup D'etat

3359 words - 14 pages coming into power and indeed it did put military aid on standby, however the US did not fully immerse itself in the coup. This is possibly because of the Vietnam War; during the time leading up to the Goulart coupe the US government was occupied in preventing communism from taking over Vietnam and dealing with Vietnamese leader Deim. Furthermore, Washington perhaps realized that the Brazilians were on the verge of overthrowing Goulart and thus

Personal Narrative Fear Of Technology Essay

1004 words - 5 pages auditory experience. In other words, I fear the microwave. While I imagined the old one might pack up and leave on us, I imagine the new one, which is a cold, steely black color quite unlike the soft beige and orange of the old Litton model, will someday stage a coup of the house, expanding its reign of terror further, to the basement to our washer and dryer, to the family room to take over the TV such that we would only able to tune in Emeril and

Explain Why The Cold War Came To An End

624 words - 3 pages powerful people in the Communist Party feared the collapse of the Soviet Union and so attempted to remove Gorbachev from power. Gorbachev was imprisoned on house arrest in his holiday home and so Gorbachev could do nothing and had to stand by and listen to the military attempt to seize control of the Russian parliament through a radio. Due to mass protests and the acts of President Yeltsin, the coup failed. However, although the coup failed when