Leadership Styles In Western Business Essay

3366 words - 14 pages

Introduction:Leadership is a critical issue and can be understood in different perspectives and different contexts. It would be difficult to give leadership a general definition because many authors have tried without reaching a consensus."Our images of leadership are entirely personal" wrote Georgiades and Macdonell (1998).In terms of management, Robbins and DeCenzo (2005) referred to leadership as influencing others and possessing managerial authority. There are countless definitions of leadership and still no general conclusion.Moreover the western theories of leadership do not cover sufficiently the structures prevalent in Asia and Africa.This work would thus not be focusing on ...view middle of the document...

For example the fact that an approach to leadership in the manufacturing industry in a particular country succeeds does not mean it would succeed in the aviation industry of the same country.According to Mullins (2005) there are two further limitations with this approach• First, there is bound to be some subjective judgement in determining who is regarded as a 'good' or 'successful' leader.• Second, the lists of possible traits tend to be very long and there is not always agreement on the most important.As interest in the trait approach to leadership declined, researchers focused their attention on the leader's actions rather than their attributes, which led to the emergence of the behaviourist theories which took into consideration of that leaders do instead of should do. The behaviour approach also did not answer all questions, as :• There is no clear relationship between behaviour and performance outcomes.• It has failed to find a universal behaviour suitable for all situations.Due to the disillusionment with the fore-mentioned trait theory, the situational approach arose, which suggested that the traits required of a leader differed, according to varying situations. The situational approach, which predominated in the 1950s, held that whether a given person became a leader of a group, had nothing to do with his/her personality, but had everything to do with such factors as the flow of events and circumstances surrounding a group. To put it simply, the leader was a person who was in the right place at the right time. Rather than a great man causing a great event to happen, the situational approach claims that great events are the product of historical forces that are gong to happen whether specific leaders are present or not (Adair, 1984) Unfortunately, this theory still did not answer, why one member of a group emerged as the leader, rather than another, or why one particular leader proved to be a better leader in some situations than another.Fiedler's contingency theory of leadership effectiveness was one theory, which evolved from this interactions approach. It related the effectiveness of the leader, to aspects of the situation in which the group operated, suggesting that factors such as the task structure, the leaders personal relations with the group and his/her power basis, interact to determine what style of leadership would be effective for the situation, i.e. a task-oriented or group-oriented approach.Differences between the West and the East:Current theories of leadership, and leadership rhetoric, in the West place high value also on teamwork, empowerment, performance management, rationality, delegation, listening and learning (Conger, 1989; Ford and Fottler, 1995).The problem is that the amount of hype surrounding such putative features of management implies that it is a hard sell, even in its place of origin. Transformational leadership in the West, including the USA (Kotter, 1990), is more a construct of the...

Other Essays Like Leadership Styles In Western Business

Strategic Management Essay

1078 words - 5 pages management and leadership styles on strategic decisions in differing situations, through examining the competences and styles of successful leaders. Applying management and leadership theories and models to specific situations will enable learners to assess their impact on organisational strategy. The unit will draw on a selection of established principles, including the influence of emotional intelligence on leadership effectiveness. This will

Leadership Styles Essay

1231 words - 5 pages appreciated (Want, 2010). Leadership styles Leaders play a significant role in an organization. The leadership role has a direct influence on stakeholders but what remains unclear are the ways employee’s performances are influenced. That means that leaders have to adapt his or her leadership style according to classifications based on judgments. Businesses are constantly changing, maintain competitiveness, embrace new innovations, and updating


2192 words - 9 pages establish organizational policies that are consistent with this objective of helping others. This leadership style is similar to participatory leadership in the way that it is inclusive of others in decision-making process. There are several types of leadership styles, but as you can they each in some way relate to one another. As an entrepreneur, discuss how you would use resources and tools available through the Small Business Administration and

Participative Leadership

1607 words - 7 pages as innovation stems from teamwork, brainstorming, and trial and error (Maslennikova, 2007). I experience both the strengths and weaknesses of participative leadership in his organization as my organization typically works in teams, but the need for efficiency and speed sometimes dictates the need for an autocratic decision. Participative Leadership: Follower-Centered Leadership According to Maslennikova, leadership styles are either leader

The Reflection of Two Leadership Styles

666 words - 3 pages . References Bjugstad, K., Thach, E. C., Thompson, K. J., & Morris, A. (2006). A fresh look at followership: A model for matching followership and leadership styles. Journal of Behavioral & Applied Management, 7(3), 304–319. Boltax, J. (2010). Leading in Times of Uncertainty. CPAP Practice Management Forum, 6(12), 5-7. Goleman, D. (2000). Leadership that gets results. Harvard Business Review, 78(2), 78-90. Retrieved March 25, 2014, from the Business Source Complete database. .

Factors Influencing Choice of Leadership in Workplace Situations

1144 words - 5 pages Describe the factors that will influence the choice of leadership styles or behaviours in workplace situations. Explain why these leadership styles or behaviours are likely to have a positive or negative effect on individual and group behaviour Leadership styles can be mainly categorized into three main categories * Autocratic - Autocratic leadership is an extreme form of transactional leadership, where leaders have absolute power over

Cross Cultural Analysis

1564 words - 7 pages we will find varity and similarity in case of leadership issues along with other factors. Japan “Business leadership is at the core of Asian economic development”, says HBS professor D. Quinn Mills. The rapid economic development of Asia in recent decades is one of the most important events in history. Compared to western countries Asian countries always lag behind in case of resources, except one. And that was human resource. Japan realized

Traditional vs Cutting Edge Leadership

1994 words - 8 pages the last few decades there has been a shift in its approach; a change in the attitude, function and definition of leadership. This change has made a complete turn around from how most organizations have lead in the past, compared to the newer design that’s been introduced within these same organizations today. These recent changes have been so prevalent within our workforce and in our lives that new terms have emerged while discussing the styles

Leading to the Best of My Ability

600 words - 3 pages Leading to the Best of My Ability Business 610 Leading to the Best of My Ability Leadership is crucial in every business, organizing committee and personal project. Different leadership styles can affect the outcome of performance from workers. The servant-leadership style reflects the characteristics I use in leadership, along with the desire to lead others in a way I would appreciate being led. My style includes being helpful

Organizational Behavior

1975 words - 8 pages ( Chairman and CEO of Infosys). I have given a brief introduction on leadership and given the various types of leadership styles. On literature review I have discussed on various literatures written by various scholars on the leadership styles of the three business leaders that I chose. In addition I have analysed the various literatures and discussed the leadership styles of the chosen business leaders and compared them. Finally I gave a


673 words - 3 pages situational factors that affected the appropriate structure of organizations and the appropriate leadership styles for different situations. Although the contingency perspective purports to apply to all aspects of management, and not just organizing and leading, there has been little development of contingency approaches outside organization theory and leadership theory. The following sections provide brief overviews of the contingency

Related Papers

Leadership In Business Essay

884 words - 4 pages Competency 317.1.5-03-05 Leadership Alan Hollingshead Western Governors University Competency 317.1.5-03-05 Leadership Executive A has led a commercial printing company to success by diversifying their services and creating a tradition of excellence and has been credited as the major contributor to the company’s success. Executive A has a “level 5” leadership style and in executive A’s plan to retire is considering two different leaders

A Survey Research Of Leadership Styles In Libon East Distrcit

641 words - 3 pages In 1939, a group of researchers led by psychologist Kurt Lewin set out to identify different styles of leadership. While further research has identified more specific types of leadership, this early study was very influential and established three major leadership styles: Authoritarian Leadership (Autocratic), Participative Leadership (Democratic) and Delegative Leadership (Laissez-Faire). This survey research is in partial fulfillment of the

3.1 Discuss The Impact That Different Leadership Styles May Have On Motivation In Organizations In Periods Of Change

2257 words - 10 pages Introduction This report will discuss about the effect of different leadership styles may have on motivation of employees during periods of change, comparing the application of different motivation theories within the workplace and the usefulness of motivation theory for mangers. Nevertheless, also this report will explain the nature of group behavior within organizations and the factors may inhibit the development of effective teamwork in

Behaviors Of Effective Leaders Essay

1356 words - 6 pages purpose was to explore psychopathic personality traits that are present in effective leaders in the business and political world. Finally, the purpose of the last article written by van Eeden, Cilliers, and van Deventer (2008) called “Leadership Styles and Associated Personality Traits: Support for the Conceptualization of Transactional and Transformational Leadership” was to determine the personality traits found in transformational