Legal Theory Essay

2577 words - 11 pages

Both legal theory and theories of the state stand at a crossroads today. The modern state has transformed quite radically from its traditional image. According to Habermas’ account, in traditional societies, “the law made by the ruler remained subordinate to the Christian natural law administered by the Church”. The social integration was a result of bonding convictions which came from the mythical narratives and ritual practices. However, in the postmodern situation with all its complex interrogations of Universalist claims and a predominantly secular society such as ours, “the normative order is maintained without such metasocial guarantees”. Such a situation leads to a specific question: ...view middle of the document...

This replacement of natural law with the enacted/positive law tends to circumscribe freedom and simultaneously give it unhindered play.
[1]
This serves as the entry point to Agamben’s notion of “bare life” (a life that has no significance beyond the fact of its existence) whose politicization decides the “humanity of living man”. In a state of exception, the realm of bare life coincides with the political realm so much so that the distinction between exclusion and inclusion, outside and inside, bios and zoe ceases to exist. This serves to expose that the law truly “has no existence in itself, but rather has its being in the very life of men”. The law and fact becomes totally indistinguishable. Moreover, Agamben states that, the “threshold on which violence passes over into law and law passes over into violence” is the place of sovereignty. So the sovereign is, at the same time, “outside and inside the juridical order and also the one who decides the exception”. This, according to Agamben, is the ultimate paradox of sovereignty. The place of the sovereign, as Agamben has suggested, is a place where the outside is brought inside the community. Homo sacer, the one who is "captured in the sovereign's ban", the one who may be killed without committing homicide but not sacrificed, can be compared to the sovereign in the sense that he also is outside the normal juridical order. Thus, Agamben argues that the “political space is constituted through a double exclusion. The political sphere, the place of sovereignty and the referent of the sovereign's decision, is created in its separation from the divine and the juridical”.
Agamben's most explicit argument about overcoming state sovereignty is human capacity to think potentiality which alone can render sovereignty inoperative. Dissatisfied with all theories of constituent power as they relate power to law and fail to sever the connection between constituting and constituted power, Agamben becomes intrigued by Antonio Negri's effort to reconceive constituent power as the power of potentiality. In other words, Agamben emphasizes the shift from a "strictly political concept" to a "category of ontology," the shift, that is, from "political philosophy to first philosophy". Only once a "new and coherent ontology of potentiality," Agamben argues, "has replaced the ontology founded on the primacy of actuality" will a "political theory freed from the aporias of sovereignty" become conceivable.
Agamben argues that in contemporary politics, the state of exception identified by Schmitt in which the law is suspended by the sovereign, has in fact become the rule. And he identifies this condition with that of abandonment, in which the law is in force but has no content or substantive meaning—it is “in force without significance.” The structure of the exception then becomes directly analogous to the structure of the ban identified by Jean-Luc Nancy in his essay “Abandoned Being”, since in both the cases “the law only...

Other Essays Like Legal Theory

Anti- Buylling Essay

667 words - 3 pages contract may be ineffective. The contract theory is the legal concept that a binding agreement exist between two or more parties if a reasonable person would judge that an offer has been made and accepted. It dispense with the subjective notion of intention “meeting of minds” of the parties advocated under the older subjective theory of contract as being too hazy (Objective Theory of Contract,1999).The contract applies to this scenario because

Theoretical Concepts In Companies Essay

1151 words - 5 pages nevertheless whether it is legal or not. For example, is a stockholders decide to close a successful deal and the manager know is it a wrong decision, hi/she cannot to anything because of lack of responsibilities. “Stockholder theory could point out that employees (including managers), suppliers, and customers negotiate for and autonomously accept wage and benefit packages, purchasing arrangements, and sales contracts, respectively.” (1

Theories of Personality Introduction

1941 words - 8 pages . principles of learning that make up a theory. c. guidelines for living a principled life. d. legal entities for raising revenue. ______9. What is the relationship among theory, hypothesis, and observation? a. Observations are practical tools; theories and hypotheses are impractical. b. Theories generate hypotheses that lead to observations that may alter the original theory. c. Hypotheses

Advertisement Ip3

732 words - 3 pages of Contract Law & Legal Definition (n.d.). Retrieved April 13, 2013 from http://definitions.uslegal.com/o/objective-theory-of-contract/ Financial Web – Contracts (n.d.). Retrieved April 13, 2013 from http://www.finweb.com/loans/contracts.html#axzz2QLo0z8UU

Emphasizing the Role of the State: the Legality of Same-Sex Marriage

966 words - 4 pages Emphasizing the Role of the State: The Legality of Same-Sex Marriage The social contract theory holds that humans living in the state of nature surrendered their personal freedom to their government in order to promote the safety and wellbeing of all. The social contract gives rights to both citizens and their government. Just as the rights of citizens are limited by legal constraints, the doctrine of the separation of church and state is one

Nozick vs Rawls

1702 words - 7 pages than freedom, also need sufficient resources. Furthermore, would an unregulated market really protect individuals? Especially in a society where the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. Is that just? Another problem is that it is unclear whether property rights are ‘natural’ or are a function of the institutions (social, legal, political, economic) of particular societies?9 Rawls A Theory of Justice (1971) proposes his theory which

Rule of Recogniton

748 words - 3 pages basis of his description of the legal system; but he must then accept that this leaves open and unanswered what constitutes the actual nature of the rule of recognition. Thus different societies may have different rules of recognition; the problem then is that such an expression as the rule of recognition needs to have some limitations imposed upon it, otherwise it cannot serve the role it plays in Hart’s theory. Hart is giving an account

The Standard Formula Of An Article In Applied Ethics

803 words - 4 pages Ethics Article “On the Moral and Legal Status of Abortion” by Mary Anne Warren 1. Introduction to the case the author wishes to analyze Warren provides a brief survey of the abortion debate and identifies some problems with current anti-abortion lines of argument. She particularly focuses on the distinction between the genetic and moral senses of the term “human being.” 2. Proposal of a theory (or principle) which can be used to analyze the case

Answers to Test 1

1544 words - 7 pages . James is an employee whose job it is to proofread legal documents. He is paid by the number of documents that he proofs. He discovers that he is paid substantially more than his colleagues, even though their jobs and performances are very similar. What is likely to be his reaction to this discovery according to equity theory? -c) The quality of documents he proofreads will increase 66. Gloria thinks that she is paid less than other workers in

Contracts

601 words - 3 pages A contract is an agreement between parties, with terms and conditions that describe the agreement, that constitutes a legal obligation. Contracts provide the means for individuals and businesses to sell and otherwise transfer property, services, and other rights. The four elements of a valid contract are agreement, consideration, contractual capacity, and lawful object, in order for a contract to be

Business Syllabus

2871 words - 12 pages 2: Section A – The Market: the transfer of goods or the rendering of 4 services for cash or on credit terms. Section B – The Workplace: the legal relationship between 4 employers and employees. Section C – The Family: the family relationship arising from 5 marriage or cohabitation. Section D – The Criminal Offender: the essential nature of criminal 5 liability and the study

Related Papers

Mapping Legal Theory Essay

952 words - 4 pages The theory of artifactualism and its perspectives Artifactualism is a theory of law that develops upon the insights of legal realism and positivism, natural law and criticizes these theories at the same time. In a similar sense with the natural law, the theory of artifactualism recognizes the impossibility of conceiving of law without any reference to the social values that are reflected in, as well as enforced by law. The theory however

Theories And Theorists Essay

960 words - 4 pages they serve. While Friedman came up with the stakeholder and shareholder’s theory, Archie Caroll came up with the theory of social responsibility classifying the responsibilities of a business as being economic, ethical, legal and discretionary. In his theory, Caroll agrees with Friedman in that businesses should make profits, however, he also recognizes the fact that it is the responsibility of all businesses to be legally responsible. In

The Future Of Crime Theory Essay

893 words - 4 pages is reflective of causation, reduction, and punishment. Differential coercion theory considers degrees of coercion and consistency that affects any legal or illegal outcome. Differential coercion applies to acute street, exploratory, or professional criminals. “Integration at both the inter-personal and macro-social levels reveals how differential levels of coercion and consistency appear in micro processes of social control and at the macro level

Business Contracts Essay

1143 words - 5 pages ; refraining from doing something right; or anything of value (Small Business, 2010). However, the consideration of the contract cannot be something that was promised in the past (Ollek, n.d.). It must be a new promise or a new exchange for the offer to be made valid (Ollek, n.d.). Now that we know the four elements of a valid contract lets discuss what the objective theory of a contract is. According to US Legal (2011) the objective theory of a