Lyotard And The Postmodern Condition Essay

1019 words - 5 pages

Jean-François Lyotard was a French philosopher and literary theorist. He was a key figure in the development of postmodernist philosophy. Beyond helping to define postmodernism, Lyotard also analyzed the effect of postmodernism on the human condition. The Postmodern Condition is one of Lyotard’s seminal works on the impact of postmodernism on the modern world. The focus of the work is the current transition of societies from an industrial to a postindustrial framework. How does this shift revise the means and methods of productions and the products created? How does the alteration of legitimation from Enlightenment/Newtonian criteria for legitimation to postmodern ones affect the ...view middle of the document...

e. experiments are narratives waiting to be told), Lyotard warns against belief in totalizing "metanarratives". There were two main metanarratives referred to as legitimizing science before post-modernism; one, that science is legitimized as a tool for the liberation of humanity, and two, that science is to define a speculative unity for all of knowledge-a totalizing philosophy of the universe, so to speak.

Since science has gone from a representational to a non-representational practice, these two justifications (especially the second) are no longer valid. Since science is no longer seen as something capable of revealing some objective reality (which post-modernists say is impossible), what could take their place as legitimation? Besides a consideration of the effects of this societal evolution on the people and power structures residing within society, The Postmodern Condition is a thinly veiled polemic against Jürgen Habermas and the theory he suggested as a replacement for the old legitimation of metanarratives.

Jürgen Habermas was a German sociologist and philosopher. He agreed with Lyotard that the metanarratives of the Enlightenment were no longer useful as legitimation for science and knowledge. But he felt that with this change, society was rearranging into a new social form, a society based on communication as legitimation. This new form of community would use rational discourse and consent of the community as methods of legitimation. For any given situation, the community affected would test the validity claims of the norms in question. They would come to a conclusion that in that particular situation, the norms were right. Lyotard believed that this theory was erroneous. He felt that reliance on the ideal of consensus as a criterion for truth to be particularly specious, even going so far as to call it “terrorist”. This reliance on the ideal of consensus was just another “totalizing” philosophy.

But then what could stand in for legitimation in the postmodern world. Lyotard salvages the legitimization of science by redefining it (of course lol) in terms of linguistics and the act of the performative. The justification for science then becomes not as a means of...

Other Essays Like Lyotard And The Postmodern Condition

A Rock N' Roll Ulysses Essay

4163 words - 17 pages postmodern invention and artifact. Many theorists assume postmodernism was initiated at the conclusion of World War II, after the introduction of the atomic bomb by the United States to the rest of world. Just as "the bomb" erased one hundred thousand living "narratives" with one plausibly fictive hot flash of light that was indeed real, postmodernism claims that "'history' and 'reality' [are] no longer possible, since both have been

Modernism Vs Postmodernism Essay

2531 words - 11 pages political context within which art characterised as postmodern has developed. It seems reasonable, therefore, to start by attempting to clarify the critical positions represented by Greenberg and Burgin. Greenberg, in 'Modernist Painting' (1961) and other writings, sets the development of modem art, specifically painting, in the context of the ideas of the Enlightenment philosopher Kant, who 'used logic to establish the limits of logic' (Art in

Evaluate the View That the World Is Becoming More Secular

1639 words - 7 pages may pray for help if we are suffering from an illness for which scientific medicine has no cure. Postmodernists like Lyotard argue that religion have lost their power to influence how people think about, interpret and explain the world in postmodern societies. People are now taking more control over their own lives and are less willing to be told what to believe religious authorities. Sociologist Hervieu-Leger also agrees with the idea

My Personal World View

1035 words - 5 pages achieving perfection and going to live with God. References Faith, Religion, & Spirituality. (n.d.). Retrieved from Postmodern worldview -- How postmodernism changes the rules. (n.d.). Retrieved from Seaward, B. L. (2013). Health of the human spirit


1128 words - 5 pages modernistic. Thus, Sartre promotes the use of socialism to deconstruct colonialist perceptions of truth. 3. Debordist situation and the posttextual paradigm of narrative The primary theme of Abian’s[6] model of socialism is a dialectic whole. The subject is interpolated into a capitalist narrative that includes narrativity as a reality. It could be said that Lyotard suggests the use of precultural capitalist theory to attack class. â

Globalization and the Art Market

628 words - 3 pages adding the suffix ‘-ization,’ the term globalization means that the process of globality is still under the development towards a new condition of postmodern globality; that globality has not yet been reached. Globalization equivalents to cross-outskirt trade of worth, including monetary action. Merchandise and administrations change hands crosswise over area and ocean and individuals profit. The relationships between the global and the local art

British Novel

837 words - 4 pages Clemens). The 20th century is divided into two phases of literature--modern literature (1900-1945) and contemporary literature (1945 to the present), also referred to as postmodern. The characters in modern and contemporary novels questioned the existence of God, the supremacy of the human reason, and the nature of reality. Novels from this era reflected great events such as The Great Depression, World War II, Hiroshima, the cold war and communism

Sun Poisoning - Analysis

1041 words - 5 pages . Notably the narration and the characterization have postmodern traits. It is very common for postmodern texts to utilize an unconventional narrative form. The narrator in Sun Poisoning is a 2nd person narrator, which is rarely seen in literary work. The effect of this is that it feels as if someone is bossing you around and constantly telling you what to do and feel. This is really how the life of the protagonist works. She doesn’t have much of a

Assess the View That Science Has Replaced Religion as the Main Ideological Influence in Society Today

1388 words - 6 pages system is the dominant one, an arguments such as secularisation can be criticised to such an extent (i.e. many parts of the world cannot be described as secular) that we cannot assume this is proof of science being dominant. Instead, I would like to draw our attention to Lyotard, a postmodernist, and his work on language games, through which we can clearly see a distinction between scientific and religious ideology. Lyotard argued that in pre

American Gangster

915 words - 4 pages major part in postmodern films. Raiders of the Lost Ark, produced by Steven Spielberg, whose name was associated with “blockbuster”, is an example of a postmodern film. In the introduction of the film the soundtrack is very thrilling and suspenseful. The music and sound effect prepares the audience for an adventure throughout the movie. An example of the movie paying close attention to the sound effects is when the men whip their whip lashes

The Problem of God in the Human Mind

1206 words - 5 pages (believing) are ultimately two traditions to nurture the passion of life. He sees our awe in the presence of beauty and our fundamental need to worship, as the core of the human condition. Caputo argues that in the postmodern era the human nature tends to intellectualize the complexity of things, pay closer attention to details, and to the sensitivity to differences because of the assumptions we inherit, the languages of human communication, and the

Related Papers

Postmodernism Essay

2067 words - 9 pages IntroductionAccording to the postmodern theorist Jean-François Lyotard, the term represents a culmination of the process of modernity and enlightenment thought, toward speedy cultural change, to a state where constant change is the status quo, leaving the notion of progress contradictory. Postmodernism, thus, relies on concrete experience over abstract principles, always cognizant that the end result of one's experience will necessarily

Pouring Postmodernism Into The Computer Essay

1348 words - 6 pages Pouring Postmodernism into the Computer "I can't define it, but I know it when I see it," has become a standard reply to questions that are hard to answer, now serving as the definition of more than just pornography. Postmodernism seems to at times share this elusive definition. To paraphrase Lyotard, its refusal to take solace in and unified form and conventions are partly responsible for its apparently shapeless definition. Paraphrasing

A Philosophical Enquiry Into The Origin Of Our Ideas Of The Sublime And Beautiful: Edmund Burke

1611 words - 7 pages [Trans. Juan Antonio Méndez,] (2008) A. Machado Libros, Madrid. -Jean-François Lyotard, The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge, (1984) [Trans. Geoffrey Bennington and Brian Massumi] University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis -Jean-François Lyotard The Postmodern Explained: Correspondence, 1982–1985. (1933) [Trans. Don Barry] University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis. -Roxana Popelka Sosa Sánchez Postmodernity and its influence on Visual Arts (2009) Arte Individuo y Sociedad, 21: 89-98, Madrid -Robert Davis Art and enlightenment: aesthetic theory after Adorno (1991) University of Nebraska Press, Lincoln

Significant Texts In Any Period Arise From Particular Ways Of Thinking And Possess An Enduring Relevance

2269 words - 10 pages structures. Through the subversion of the Christian metanarrative, Beckett’s play revolutionised Absurdist theatre to become almost an anti-theatre piece that comments on humanity’s intensified questioning of life- its meaning, or lack there of. French philosopher, Jean-François Lyotard identifies Post-structuralism as a product of Postmodern skepticism that refuses to accept the totalizing nature of metanarratives and there heavy reliance on a