This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Macbeth What Was Beyond His Control?

1247 words - 5 pages

GIVE A VERY BRIEF ACCOUNT OF WHAT MACBETH'S TREAGEDY IS AND THEN GO ON TO SAY TO WHAT EXTENT THIS TRAGEDY IS HIS OWN FAULT AND HOW FAR HE IS AFFECTED BY CIRCUMSTANCES BEYOND HIS CONTROL.

“Macbeth” by William Shakespeare is the story of a brave, honourable soldier who ruins his life due to his own greed for power, respect and wealth. The story starts with Macbeth as the king’s favourite soldier, a very respectful, honourable man. Macbeth then is told by the witches his life will change for the better – “All hail, Macbeth, that shalt be King hereafter!”. In a desperate effort to obtain this promised position of King, Macbeth takes his fate in his own hands. He kills, lies and ...view middle of the document...

Macbeth decided to leave it to fate first, then changed his mind, to kill Duncan. The fact he changed his mind is the first example of how his personality changed throughout the play. Macbeth returns to the witches at the beginning of Act 4, desperate for new information – “Howe’er you come to know it – answer me”. This shows he places much faith in the witches, which is his choice, therefore their words are not beyond his control.

Lady Macbeth’s reaction to the news of the witches, which she received in a letter, was outwith Macbeth’s control. Her love for Macbeth and her ambitions for his happiness were what caused her decision that Duncan should be killed. However, Lady Macbeth realises in Act 3 that “nought’s had, all’s spent” – they have what they want but are not enjoying it. I think that after Lady Macbeth’s decision in scene 5 of Act 1, Macbeth had his own choice to make. He decided to listen and to follow Lady Macbeth’s instructions, even though he needed further encouraging. I believe that agreeing with Lady Macbeth was not his only choice.

Macbeth is an impressionable man, as can be judged by his first reaction to the witches. While Banquo laughed at the witches’ predictions, Macbeth takes them very seriously and wonders how he can become Thane of Cawdor if the Thane is still alive. Being a soldier, Macbeth has learnt to only trust himself, and I believe that the incident with the first Thane of Cawdor lying to his country only escalates Macbeth’s urge to only trust himself, and not fate, therefore leading him to believe he will only be king if he takes fate into his own hands.

Macbeth is very honest and faithful at the beginning of the play – “for brave Macbeth-well he deserves that name”. As exhibited at the end of Act 1, he is worrying much about what Lady Macbeth expects him to do about Duncan – “but this blow might be the be-all and end-all”. When he objects to her plan, his loyalty and love to her is the reason that Lady Macbeth is able to persuade him. At the beginning of Act 2 his apprehensions of Duncan’s murder are still haunting Macbeth, as he envisions daggers similar to those with which he must kill Duncan – “Is this a dagger which I see before me, the handle toward my hand?”. This conscience is one of the main elements of Macbeth’s personality which has allowed him to become part of this tragedy; perhaps if he had been less...

Other Essays Like Macbeth - What Was Beyond His Control?

Superstition In William Shakespeare's Macbeth Essay

1676 words - 7 pages banner and turning into the villain, he no longer attempts to stifle the guilt in his conscience, but instead seems to accept the murder as an inevitable act beyond his control, saying, "I go, and it is done. The bell invites me" this type of language is used to signify the pivotal point when Macbeth surrenders himself to the witches and their supernatural powers. At this point there is little doubt in the audiences eyes

Analysis Of Macbeth By William Shakespeare

1083 words - 5 pages with the murder. Macbeth is a flawed character, his frailty is greed and ambition and he becomes the victim of circumstances beyond his control. A. Quiller. Couch’s opinion Shakespeare has made Macbeth proceed to his crime “under some fake hallucination.” The initial image of Macbeth as brave and courageous is deceptive for it is his weakness, recognized by Lady Macbeth “yet I do fear thy nature/ it is too full o’ the milk

Evil Character of Lady Macbeth

1253 words - 6 pages spirits in thine ear\". (I,V, 26) The play starts when Macbeth sees the witches and gets told that he will become King. They recount to Macbeth three prophecies. That Macbeth will be Thane of Cawdor, Thane of Glamis and King. These prophecies introduce Macbeth to ideas of greatness. As a result, I think the witches foretell the future, they can add temptation, and influence Macbeth, but they do not control his destiny. He immediately writes a

Who Is Macbeth?

1209 words - 5 pages Macbeth is a man; therefore he is the character most capable of violence. Is this what Shakespeare says? Shakespeare illustrates how not just Macbeth, but other male and female characters, can be violent. Violence is a subjective term. Perhaps physical violence is what Macbeth is capable of due to his impulsive need towards “finishing the job”. However, the Witches and Lady Macbeth contributed to his demise as well. This could be seen as

Macbeth, Men Are Responsible for Their Fate

657 words - 3 pages very own cousin. This is evident to show that Lady Macbeth is the dominate figure in the relationship and has total control of what happens to her and her husband. Men are sole individuals responsible for their fate. In Macbeth, Shakespeare has expressed this through Macbeth showing his flaws that acted upon his fate. Macbeth shows his ambition and desire to gain a hierarchic status in which influenced my multiple companions that has endorsed his personality to change therefore acting upon Macbeths fate.

Macbeth. a Dead Butcher and His Fiend Like Queen

1809 words - 8 pages his wife. This shows that their relationship was very confusing, there seems to be two sides. When Macbeth is normal he is controlled by his wife but when he shows his evil side, he starts to take control. The “butcher” side of him starts to creep out again but this time completely out of his own will, with no encouragement from anyone else accept his own ambitions. He tells his wife to: "Be innocent of the knowledge, dearest chuck

Macbeth: Act II, Scene II

1845 words - 8 pages Lady Macbeth's character completely on her own and waiting. She is straining to hear anything, as she wants to hear if Macbeth has done the deed and hesitant of it because he was so unsure about it before. As she thinks that something has gone wrong tension is created because we wonder what will happen next. Will they be caught or not? The audience will want to know what happened so they will become involved in the play and will

Macbeth Essay

1345 words - 6 pages predicting the fate of Macbeth. This gives the audience a clue to what the future holds for Macbeth. "When the battles lost and won" (1.1, 4) was said by the second witch. It says that every battle is lost by one side and won by another. Macbeth's fate is that he will win the battle, but will lose his time of victory for the battle of his soul. Webster defines witches as, “one that is credited with usually malignant supernatural powersâ

The Supernatural in Macbeth

1846 words - 8 pages three witches meet and give many clues as to who they are or what they have control over, “…we three meet again in thunder, lighting or in rain?….When the battle’s lost and won….That will be ere the set of sun….There to meet with Macbeth.” This scene sets the atmosphere for the rest of the play. If this scene was not there it would be difficult for the audience to understand how later scenes are linked or how these three

Macbeth Themes

1297 words - 6 pages it’. CHARACTER ANALYSIS: MacBeth Predictions by the witches Banquo’s Ghost Invisible Dagger Burnam Wood Lady MacBeth Sleep Walking – Blood on Hands Killing Herself MacDuff C-Section King Duncan’s Attendants When they get framed for the death of King Duncan King Duncan King Duncan is what a king should be. MacBeth is what a king should not be Banquo His ghost is seen by MacBeth Witches Predictions/Prophecies aren’t

The Secret Diary Of Lady Macbeth

1600 words - 7 pages shame Macbeth into control by trying the cowardice trick. I said, "I would shame to wear a heart so white". All we needed to do was to wash our hands and we would be clear of this deed, "what's done cannot be undone". Macbeth stood in dismay even though someone was knocking at the castle gates. He stood in the corridor in his nightgown jumping at every knock. I pushed him to move, thinking "to bed, to bed, to bed", but it was no use. I was sure we were going to fail; he regretted what he had just done. I must try my very best. It is time for me to "screw my courage to the sticking place", we cannot fail now!

Related Papers

At The End Of Macbeth, Malcolm Refers To Macbeth And Lady Macbeth As 'this Dead Butcher...And His Fiend Like Queen.' To What Extent Do You Agree With This Judgement?

1445 words - 6 pages Macbeth is too honest and caring to commit such a deed so she evokes the spirits to help her which would then help her make Macbeth do what she wants, get the throne. She blackmails Macbeth by saying that if he truly loved her then he would do it and she questions his manhood and masculinity. Lady Macbeth suggests that the killing initiates Macbeth into manhood.Although originally Lady Macbeth was the backbone of her and Macbeth's relationship, and

Gender Roles In Macbeth Essay

1279 words - 6 pages murder Duncan, it triggers a switch in his head to start killing more innocent people, making him a merciless killer. All of the traits he has is what Lady Macbeth wanted from the start. She wanted to be evil, cruel and have no fear in killing people. Macbeth turning into a monster was also part of his own fault because he is too easily controlled by Lady Macbeth, letting her do whatever she wants with him indirectly. His submissive behavior makes

Loss In Macbeth Essay

994 words - 4 pages comparison to when others are killed, which never seemed to bother Macbeth. This could show to us that Macbeth was always on the verge to his ruthlessness, but the killing of King Duncan was the final push that allowed Macbeth to break. Macbeth never felt the same guilt when he dealt an order to kill Banquo, this displays a loss beyond repair, his innocence his non-existent and his identity has completely changed, he isn’t the same man as the start

At The Beginning Of The Play Macbeth Writes To His Wife As Dearest Greatness’ How Does There Relationship Change During The Play?

755 words - 4 pages relationship later then changes. Also, at the beginning of the play, Lady Macbeth was in most control. She convinced Macbeth to carry out the murder of the king. Whereas later on in the play, it shows how Lady Macbeth had been in control to Macbeth being in control. From then on Macbeth makes up his own mind leaving his wife in the dark about his plans. In Act 3 scene 2, Lady Macbeth is the one trying to make Macbeth forget the past and leave everything