Marriage A Tradition Or An Institution

1221 words - 5 pages

The issue at hand is simple, is marriage between a man and a woman a tradition that has become an institution. Should same sex marriage be legal, and should the government recognize it as a legal marriage? We have equality in our society for many things, but the foundation of a marriage unites a man and a woman as one with the children in order to create the traditional family. This unity has become a tradition that Americans continue to uphold as the very foundation of a marriage.
The institution of marriage brings a man and a woman together as one another. The author creates some premises which offer support to their conclusion that marriage laws need to stay the same in order ...view middle of the document...

The original argument is the supporting of a traditional marriage. The first premise is: Marriage, in the traditional sense, has always been between a man and a woman. The second premise is: We should not change the law regarding traditional marriage because few others choose to live a certain way. The third premise is that the institution of marriage has already been weakened by adult’s desires preceding the needs of their children. The conclusion: Traditional marriage should stay the way it was intended to be, between a man and a woman. This argument is an inductive argument, which is weak, but valid. An inductive argument according to the book is “offer conclusions that, one way or another, introduce information that is not contained in the premises” (Mosser, 2011, 3.2). There is nothing to uphold this claim, and the premise does not hold up the original argument. This argument is not a strong argument, as it holds the opinions and emotions in an effort to uphold its foundation. The emotional basis in which this argument uses is not one of logic at all nor does it take everyone into consideration, there are hints of it trying to, but in all reality the article contradicts itself. These arguments state that the need for redefining the traditional marriage is not there, and that society should not change the normalcy of it because changing them would weaken the tradition. “The government isn’t in the business of affirming our loves. Rather it leaves consenting adults free to live and love as they choose” (Anderson, R. T. 2013). Our government’s way of politely saying they really do not care one bit who anyone chooses to love, but they will not recognize it in any legal aspect of the law.
In creating a counter-argument, I will discuss each premise with its conflicting views. The counter argument will show that the original statement regarding same sex-marriage should not be legalized is a very week argument, which leaves much up for discussion. Even though the premises may support the conclusion, they do not convince the reader to share the same beliefs. In this specific case, there are two sides to this tradition of marriage.
The issue in the counter-argument is should same sex-marriage be legalized. The first premise stated is that same-sex marriage is not illegal, and that same-sex couples can qualify for certain benefits that heterosexual couples are receiving. In light of this statement I recall the case of Edith Windsor, in 2010 she sued the federal government, challenging that they refund her on the taxes she was forced to pay...

Other Essays Like Marriage a Tradition or an Institution

Creating An Independent Citizen Or Forming A Predictable Pattern Of Behavior

1992 words - 8 pages by describing the origins of such a system. The concept was based on Prussian culture and first tried on the territory of modern Germany. The main purpose of compulsory schooling at that time was to produce an ordinary citizen without any outstanding intellectual abilities or leadership skills: “But what shocks is that we should so eagerly have adopted one of the very worst aspects of Prussian culture: an educational system deliberately

The Bombing Of Hiroshima And Nagasaki, Japan: A Necessary Evil Or An Unnecessary Act?

1346 words - 6 pages necessary to bring an end to World War II as has been claimed? No, it was not. For months, many of Japan’s cities had suffered a never-ending attack of weapons raining down on them by American military forces. In March of 1945, the city of Tokyo was attacked and 16 square miles of the city was destroyed (Weber). As a result, over 100,000 people were killed and a million were left homeless with nowhere to go, nothing to eat and nothing left of

Does Pakistani Society Regard Women as an Angel in the House or a Source of All Evils

1152 words - 5 pages Conclusion Perspective of society: A perspective of any society depends upon the thinking people of that particular society. How much intellectual are they? How much sensible are they? And how much educated are they? All these have an impact on building a perspective of any society towards any object or incident or scenario. Women as an angel or sources of evils: All characters of women i.e. daughter, sister, mother, wife, mother in law etc

Choose Either a Rural or an Urban Area and Describe How You Analysed and Presented the Results of Your Fieldwork and Research Into Rebranding Schemes

725 words - 3 pages Named Area – Newcastle For my geography fieldwork I was required to take a trip to Newcastle to assess whether or not the rebranding schemes were successful. Within this trip we concluded many things and gathered numerous results, which ranged massively. After the investigation I was ordered to analyse and present the results of my findings in different ways. The first way that I analysed and presented my results was by placing the

Same Sex Marriage

1113 words - 5 pages designed to protect the well-being of the children, gay people do not need marriage because they never have children from prior relationships, and a man should not be able to marry whomever a woman can marry, a woman should not be able to marry whomever a man can marry. Also children of married gay couples might suffer bulling and teasing in school. Although you have some that would say marriage is an institution that is very sacred and personal

Same Sex Marriage

1284 words - 6 pages . As of July 17, 2013, same sex marriage has been legalized in 13 US states and the District of Columbia. 35 states have same sex marriage bans through either bans or constitutional amendments (Gay Marriage). People argue that altering the “traditional definition of marriage” will further weaken a threatened institution and that legalizing same sex marriage may lead to bigamous and inter species marriages (Gay Marriage). Same sex marriage has

Religion Essay

1207 words - 5 pages an object, narrative or tradition. The only connection in symbolism between Christianity and Islam is in the symbolism of marriage. In Christianity, the story of Adam and Eve symbolises the idea that men and women were made to live together in families. In Islam, they have a story much like that of Adam and Eve, that can be found in their holy text the Qur’an, about Adam and Hawwa , that symbolises for them that a man and woman are meant to

Same Sex Marriage

1230 words - 5 pages believe that there is a difference between same sex and traditional marriages regarding validity or moral implications. One could argue that the bond between man and woman is valid, since biologically they are able to have a child. Love is a phenomenon, which is purely human. Therefore, if two individuals of the same sex love each other, why can they not celebrate this love through marriage? Natural science should not be an argument against this

Gay Marriage 3

999 words - 4 pages limit the opportunities and access to resources by socially disadvantaged groups Same-sex marriage (also called gay marriage) is a legally or socially recognized marriage between two persons of the same biological sex or social gender. The conflicts arise over whether same-sex couples should be allowed to enter into marriage. The oppose argument of gay marriage are: 1. Marriage is an institution between one man and one woman. Gay and lesbians

Traditional Marrige vs Same Sex Marriage

1040 words - 5 pages kinship. It is an institution in which interpersonal relationships, usually intimate and sexual, are acknowledged in a variety of ways, depending on culture or subculture in which it is found. (Merriam, 1967) Such a union, often formalized by way of a wedding ceremony, may also be called matrimony. I will build a foundation of my personal principals and moral values on traditional marriage opposed to modern (same sex) marriage, and their

Gay marriages

2022 words - 9 pages heterosexual male and heterosexual female and nothing else. Or maybe gays just cast a queer image on a straight institution? Some politicians, who have gay children themselves, may actually succumb to the knowledge and empathy and suggest that love and commitment are universal and should not be confined to a single category of sexual orientation. Gay marriages will in no way, shape, form or fashion weaken the institution of marriage. A ?normal

Related Papers

Using Material From 1b And Elsewhere, Assess The View That Marriage Remains A Patriarchal Institution. (24 Marks)

1062 words - 5 pages to examine the essay. Murdock argues that the sheer practicality of the nuclear family is a way of meeting four needs whereas Parsons says the family may meet more needs too for example political or religious functions. Also, the overall patterns and changes in the families and households over time according to factors such as the geographical workforce and the social workforce. Functionalists visualise society as a system made up of

Cross Dressing: A Curse Or An Inspiration?

2773 words - 12 pages before. This paper is an appreciation on the question of the acceptance of such beings on earth now or is it dilemma-tic pitfalls of human mankind in which most are sufferings since a long haul. Keywords: Cross dresser, transvestitism, sexual diversity, Religions, Society, Gender 1. Introduction Cross dresser or transvestism is apparently increasing in years and changing the society of today. Several literature based studies on this topic has

Most People Are Taught That Loyalty Is A Virtue. But Loyalty Whether To One's Friends, To One's School Or Place Of Employment, Or To Any Institution Is All Too Often A Destructive Rather Than A...

617 words - 3 pages Loyalty, defined as faithfulness or a devotion to a person, group, country, or cause according to Wikipedia, is viewed by most people as a virtue, including me. Though I concede that loyalty does not bring about positive outcomes all the time, yet I cannot agree with the speaker's claim that loyalty is all too often a destructive rather than a positive force. As far as I'm concerned, due to the blindness to universal morals, loyalty may be

Reasons For A Change In An Organisations Product Or Service

1015 words - 5 pages Organizations will change the goods or services they provide, more often than others. This can be for many reasons such as social trends, competition, advances in technology and occasionally from accusations from pressure groups. Social trends give a broad indication of the society in that particular country, by analyzing previous economic data. Social trends will have an effect on the services or products that organizations provide, for