Marxist Theories (Crime And Deviance) Essay

1753 words - 8 pages

Using material from Item A and elsewhere, assess the strength and limitations of Marxist theories in explaining crime and deviance (21 marks)

Marxist theories of crime are based on conflict, as opposed to the functionalist and subcultural explanations of crime, which are based on consensus. They claim that society is divided by capitalism and there is a conflict between the upper-classes and the working-classes. They suggest that social inequality, as a result of capitalism, is the cause of crime. As Item A points out, there are two types of Marxists: the Traditional Marxists and the Neo Marxists. The starting point for Marxist and neo-Marxist approaches is the laws, and how the ways ...view middle of the document...

Chambliss, as mentioned in item A, (1975) argues that laws made to protect property are the cornerstone of the capitalist economy meaning that law protects those who already own which are mainly the upper class. For example: the growth in tea and coffee means they needed the locals to work on the plantations. To do this, they introduced a tax that the locals had to pay and to pay it, they needed to work. Not paying was seen as a punishable criminal offence. This law served the interests of the plantation owners as people needed to work in order to pay the tax.

It is argued that powerless groups, like the working class, are criminalised whereas crimes of the powerful tend to be ignored. Reiman (2001) found that the more likely a crime is to be committed by higher class people, the less likely it is to be treated as a criminal offence. This results in a disproportionate high rate of prosecutions for the types of crimes poor people typically commit eg, theft. Crimes committed by the higher classes, like tax evasions, are treated more forgivingly. This shows that the upper class are treated more forgivingly than the working class. Some Marxists believe that sometimes laws are passed that seem to benefit the working class rather than capitalism however; Frank Pearce (1976) argues that these laws to benefit the upper class. For example, keeping workers fit for work by passing health and safety laws. This creates false consciousness as it projects that capitalism is caring for its workers.

This theory offers a useful explanation of the relationship between crime and capitalist society. It shows the link between law making and enforcement and the interests of the capitalist class (by doing so it also puts into a wider structural context the insights of labeling theory regarding the selective enforcement of the law). It casts doubt on the validity of official statistics on crime. Official statistics are of little use if they simply reflect a policy of selective law enforcement and ruling class control. It has also influenced recent approaches to the study of the crimes of the powerful.

Marxists may argue that capitalism is responsible for all crimes, but crime is still evident in communists societies, thus capitalism may not lead to all crimes. Jones looked at the crime rates of Switzerland and found that they were exceedingly low, despite it being a capitalist society. Left Realists would argue that while white collar crime is inevitably underreported, working class crimes affect people more on a personal and economic level. Marxists, however, ignore this fact. Postmodernists would argue that society is now too fragmented for Marxism to apply anymore
The Corporate Homicide Act (2007) has been developed to deal with corporate crime.

In response to the criticisms of traditional Marxist theory of crime, the Neo Marxist theory was brought about. Sociologists Taylor, Walton and Young, as mentioned in Item A, attempted to produce a ‘fully...

Other Essays Like Marxist Theories (Crime and Deviance)

Crime and Deviance Are the Product of the Labelling Process

1354 words - 6 pages Crime is simply an activity that breaks the criminal law and criminals are the people who behave in this way, whereas deviance is behaviour that does not conform to a society or a group and is defined or created by the social group. The labelling theory takes a very different approach to other theories as it focuses on how and why some people and their actions come to be labelled as criminal or deviant and what effects this has on those who are

Biological and Social Theories of Crime

1244 words - 5 pages Biological and Classical Theories of Crime Dennis Neal University of Phoenix Tracy Williams January 27, 2010 Biological and Classical Theories of Crime The question of what causes people to exhibit criminal behavior is a question that continues to puzzle and intrigue scholars of criminology even after centuries of study. Many theories of crime

Identify and Discuss the Key Features of Both Functionalist and Marxist Theories. [25 Marks]

2777 words - 12 pages Identify and discuss the key features of both Functionalist and Marxist theories. [25 Marks] Functionalist and Marxist are macro sociological theories that give a better understanding of the society. Functionalist theory is referred to as the consensus whilst the Marxist theory is known as the conflict theory. Key features of both theories are going to be identified and discussed. According to Haralambos and Holborn (2008), a theory is a

A critical Marxist analysis of figurational theories justification of pain and injury within boxing

2740 words - 11 pages A critical Marxist analysis of figurational theories justification of pain and injury within boxing. Pain and injury has existed as a part of sports for thousands of years. However it is only recently that sociologist have begun to explore pain and injury from a sociological perspective. Most of the research that has been conducted in the field of pain and injury was primarily concerned with the bio-medical model and viewed pain and

Assess the Value of the Right Realist Approach to Crime and Deviance. (21 Marks)

684 words - 3 pages Assess the value of the right realist approach to crime and deviance. (21 marks) Right realists argue that crime today is a very real and growing problem. Right Realists argue that crime threatens society’s work ethic, social cohesion and destroys communities in society. Unlike other theories, Right realism focuses on the solutions for crime alongside the explanation of what causes crime in society, this approach also criticise labelling and

Sociology

582 words - 3 pages are deviant in first place. Once someone is labelled deviant they follow through. MARXISM 12 MARKS 1.WHAT AREA OF CRIME ARE TRADITIONAL MARXIST INTERESTED IN? crime is inevitable part of capitalists. 2.WHAT TWO THEORIES DO RADICAL/ NEW CRIMINOLOGY BRING TOGETHER? 3.HOW MANY POINTS ARE THERE IN TAYLOR WALTON AND YOUNGS THEORY? 4. WHAT DOES GILROY MEAN BY THE MYTH OF BLACK CRIMINALITY? Every black person is assumed to be deviant or criminal 5.HOW

Biological and Social Deviance

2286 words - 10 pages such as Sheldon’s body type theory, and contrast between the theories mentioned. Finally this essay will examine the differences between the theories and whether the biological explanation or the social constructionist explanation can be better used to explain deviance. Looking at social control can help clarify definitions of what crime and deviance are. Social control refers to both the formal and informal means by which society

Essay Title: Deviance Is Defined Within A Cultural Context. Discuss

917 words - 4 pages problem, also concluding that crime has a social pattern and structure.One notes how in the sub- cultural theories of deviance people who are members of deviant groups conform to the norms of that particular group and these sub- cultural groups are socialised in such a way that is considered deviant to others. Some groups even tend to regard deviant behaviour as a requirement for acceptance. These theories bring out the way in which society and

Explanations of Crime

2041 words - 9 pages be criminalised and how to enforce the law. Marxist approach to crime is based on conflict theory. Unlike the functionalist approach, it does not assume there is consensus over a common core of norms and values. Marxists see deviance in terms if a critique of capitalist society. It questions who defines what crime is and who makes the law. The basis of the argument is that the ruling class, or capitalist class, exploit the working class

Devience Is Socially Defined

1789 words - 8 pages the before , what was done or needs to be done in order to reach wealth. When such actions occur the respect for traditionally accepted means of achieving goals crumble, norms has to weaken and society is no longer able to regulate the methods its members use to obtain success. Merton called this type of deviance innovation- using unconventional means such as street crime to achieve a culturally approved goal-wealth. This being the case it

What Is Functionalism?

1471 words - 6 pages , that everything in society must be functional and serving the functional pre-requisites or else it wouldn't exist. This is true of the apparently destructive appearance of crime and deviance and functionalists have tried to describe its role in terms of benefiting the whole of society.The orthodox functionalist approach focuses on Durkheim's attempts to explain the purpose of crime and deviance. He said that deviance is functional and only becomes

Related Papers

Outline And Assess Marxist Theories Of Crime

984 words - 4 pages Marxist theories of crime are based on conflict, as opposed to the functionalist and subcultural explanations of crime, which are based on consensus. They claim that society is divided by capitalism and there is a conflict between the upper-classes and the working-classes. They suggest that social inequality, as a result of capitalism, is the cause of crime. The starting point for Marxist and neo-Marxist approaches is the laws, and how the ways

Crime And Deviance Essay

2697 words - 11 pages FELONY, MISDEMEANOR OR NONCONFORMITY THAT IS THE QUESTION? In modern day society we often speak of crime and deviance but what are they? Crime could be defined as being an act, by a person or persons of a specific society, which breaks the law of that society. This could be anything from not paying a Television Licence to committing an act of murder. Deviance however is when a person or persons do not conform to the social rules of their

Crime And Deviance Essay

1396 words - 6 pages unacceptability of certain conduct and what deems some behaviour to be classified as deviant or criminal. This essay discusses how society is responsible for the definitions of deviance and criminality. To determine who is doing the defining, and to assist with the understanding of society and social behaviours, sociological theories can be applied. One such theory, symbolic interactionism, can be applied to gain insight and explain how social

Functionalist Explanations To Crime And Deviance

1339 words - 6 pages Assess functionalist theories of crime and deviance. Functionalism is a social structural and social control theory. It believes that it is society that causes the individual to commit crime. Social control theory looks at why people do not commit crime as it says that people are controlled by the primary and secondary agents of social control, such as the family or religion, and so should not commit crime. Functionalism is also a Right Wing