Men And Women Should Not Serving Together In Military Units

2021 words - 9 pages

Amanda Libbie Kelebit

Lecturer Miss Indra Mohini

English 104

3rd August 2009

Men and Women Serving Together in Military Units:
Men and women should not serving together in military units

Physical differences, leadership and sexual assault are the factors contribute to the issue regarding men and women serving together in military units. The statement regarding men and women serving together in military units is meant that two different entities work as one in armed forces. The main point at the mean time is about the factors of men and women involve together in military units. Some would support this statement; some would rather on the opposition side. Men and women were ...view middle of the document...

34). The Renaissance man is also literally well-rounded: he should be agile and strong, with "shapely" limbs (Castiglione, p. 30, line 26). Renaissance women must also fulfil specific requirements. Though they should develop their bodies as well as their minds, Renaissance women should not undertake strenuous activities, as even dancing too energetically can impede her "womanly sweetness," (Castiglione, p. 35, line 192). Neither men nor women should take sport--or anything else--too seriously because being well-rounded is more important than being a specialist. In simpler term, Castiglione stated that men and women have his or her own roles in the world.

The main question is that whether men and women that have physical differences can serve together in military units. As a general, men have better physical strength compared to women, whereas women are prone to injury. “Army doctors found that eight times as many women as men were being discharged during basic training [...]. Differences in strength, bone mass, stride length and lower body bone structure caused women to suffer disproportionately from Achilles tendon problems, knee, back and leg pain, and fractures of the tibia, foot, and hip.” (Qtd. in Army- GIBT 4). Prof. Charles Moskos, a respected military sociologist and member of the Congressional Commission, wrote in the panel’s Final Report:

“I am particularly perturbed by the high physical injury rate of women trainees compared to men. Likewise, I am put off by the double-talk in training standards that often obscures physical strength differences between men and women. The extraordinarily high dropout rate of women in IET cannot be overlooked (nor should the fact that females are more than twice as likely to be non-deployable than are male service members). The bottom line must be what improves military readiness.” (2).

Apart from that, women were plainly viewed to be less productive than men in most situations especially in military units. “This might have been due to lack of physical strength, lack of initiative, family responsibilities, more sick days, etc., and jobs were correspondingly divided into those suitable for each sex, such as light work for women and heavy for men.” (T. Petersen, V. Snartland and E.M.M. Milgrom 16)

But this does not mean that women cannot serve in military, it just that the field that these women serve maybe not as broad as men in military units. “[E]stablished boundaries: “Women may be assigned to all units except those with a high probability of engaging in ground combat, direct exposure to enemy fire, or direct physical contact with the enemy.” (Vogel). Women should be allowed to play a full role in military units in spite of being discriminate by the world view. “The erasure of distinctions between the sexes is not only the most striking issue of our time, it may be the most profound the race has ever confronted.” (U.S. News and World Report). In April 1993, President...

Other Essays Like Men and Women Should Not Serving Together in Military Units

Portrayal of Men and Women in Indian Television Advertising

5294 words - 22 pages less likely to depict women as sex objects (Nam 1998; Ford, Kramer, Honeycutt and Casey 1998). This was interpreted in the light of the fact that Asian societies are grounded in a traditional culture where the exhibition of the female body is not encouraged. A second significant difference was that, unlike in Western advertising, women were not necessarily associated with low priced products and were as likely as men to appear in ads for high

Breast Cancer: the Fight in Men and Women

1736 words - 7 pages leading cause of death in the United States today. Breast cancer is the most common of all cancers that consumes the lives of many women each year. However, breast cancer is also a problem that attacks men as well. Breast cancer is considered a rare occurrence in men, but it is a growing problem that should be recognized. Because breast cancer is a disease that is more common in women, it is silently overlooked and rarely talked about in men

Relationship Between Men And Women In Pre 1914 Short Stories

2501 words - 11 pages Relationship Between Men and Women in Pre 1914 Short Stories For this prose study I will examine 3 short pre 1914 stories, the stories I will comment on about relationship will be 'Tony Kytes', 'Seeing a Beauty Queen Home' and 'News of the Engagement.' I will first start with Tony Kytes. In the story 'Tony Kytes', the relationship is very dramatic and confusing, as Tony does not know what girl he wants to be with

Communicaton Between Women and Men

546 words - 3 pages female counterparts. Socialization factors play a very important part is this communication scheme, however, in my personal perspective, I do see women and men very similar, however, they have different ways of expressing themselves. Men and women have to take the time to learn about the differences and learn to respect them. As our text explained the young man could only listen once he covered his eyes. It’s not that he did not want to

Brain And Behavior Of Men And Women

1908 words - 8 pages If we were to examine a high school calculus classroom or the staff at an engineering program of a college or university, chances are that the male to female ratio would be significantly skewed. Why are women and men so different in their choices and behavior? The brunt of popular opinion focuses on the environmental cues that lead to our distinct behaviors. But is there also an innate biological basis to the choices and differing abilities

The Differences Between Men and Women

574 words - 3 pages and ability, we can notice certain differences in some of men organs. For instance, the structure of the chest in men is quite flat. Men’s hands are quite thick. And their's pelvises are not wide. Also, one of the most physical differences between men and women is the skin. A man's skin is quit rough. In addition, emotion can be distinguished between men and women. It is an important factor in men's and women's lives. However, it is less

The Fit Between Technology and Structure as a Predictor of Performance in Nursing Sub-Units

2010 words - 9 pages . Empirical Study 4: Fry and Scolum (1984) studied 35 police units and discovered the significance of interaction between search behaviour and specialization was significant for workgroup performance but other interactions studied were not. [Analysis] This study was based on an examination of 27 nursing subunits in 3 hospitals through a questionnaire survey addressing the relevant technologies and structures on a five point scale. The

Haemodialysis And The Dental Units Of Acanthamoeba Species In Alexandria, Egypt

1062 words - 5 pages Acanthamoeba belongs to a group of free-living, opportunistic amoebae that can be isolated from different environmental sources including water, air and soil. They can be pathogenic or serve as carriers of other pathogenic organisms. The aim of the present study is to evaluate haemodialysis and dental units in Alexandria for the possible contamination of their hydraulic systems with Acanthamoeba species. The lack of previous studies in this

Should People Move in or Stay Together Before They Get Married

1800 words - 8 pages Should people move in and stay together before they get married. What is the pros and cons of it? This is a common and important question. Cohabitation -- living together without the commitment of marriage -- is on the rise. And it's a good idea to examine your fears and ask questions before making this important step. Although increasing numbers of individuals report less social stigma about cohabitation, many of the people who I've counseled

To What Extent Do Male and Female Literary Characters Accurately Reflect the Role of Men and Women in Society?

866 words - 4 pages To what extent do male and female literary characters accurately reflect the role of men and women in society? A lasting piece of literature is a work that accurately reflects the role of the people during certain time period eloquently. This is best perpetuated in the short novel Kitchen written by Banana Yoshimoto and the play The Importance of Being Ernest by Oscar Wilde. While the main characters Mikage in the novella and Gwendolyn in

Students Should Be Required to Take Courses in Many Fields and Not Concentrate on One Area

567 words - 3 pages “STUDENTS SHOULD BE REQUIRED TO TAKE COURSES IN MANY FIELDS, AND NOT CONCENTRATE IN ONE AREA.” The current education system is nothing but a machine that churns out a set of highly specialized educated professionals who have nothing to do with the world at large except for the parts that pertain to their areas of study. And hence these professionals are mostly insulated from other areas of education, which prevents them

Related Papers

Women And Men Are Born Not Raised

1908 words - 8 pages thought to be necessary for child care, such as nurturance and warmth, are typical of women and not men. Because most people's activities are determined by their societal roles, stereotypes about gender, even though they may be based on a theory of sex role socialization, they are still often grounded in the theory of Biological Determinism. Adverse to the theory of Biological Determinism is the standpoint of many Social Determinists. Social

Divorce And Women In The Military

5926 words - 24 pages (Hillman, 2009). Approximately two times as many women (63%) report an encounter of at least one unethical, gender-related event as compared to men (34%). In spite of equivalent compensation and equivalent ranks in the military, 13% of women and 2% of men report they have experienced sexual prejudice (Lipari, Cook, Rock, & Matos, 2008). In addition, data confirms that women in the military are not considered as equals by their male

Stereotyping Men And Women In Mass Media

841 words - 4 pages After watching television and flipping though ads and articles in several magazines, the stereotyping of men and women is so apparent but at the same time society is so blind to it. In society parents teach their children gender role at a very early age. Gender role refers to the attitudes, behavior, and activities that are socially defined as appropriate for each sex learned through the socialization process (Lips, 1993). Males are

Men And Women Essay

1319 words - 6 pages squad surrounding Smith by the end of the video, all seem to be women purposely portrayed to be appealing to men. The third video commercial I viewed started off caressing you with warm sounds of your mother saying to you, “Beauty is skin deep”, and “It’s what’s underneath that count”. But then suddenly cuts in with, “This is not what your mom had in mind”, showing clips of full-figured women in very attractive lingerie that seem to have plenty