This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Morality And God Essay

1914 words - 8 pages

Morality and God

The belief that morality requires God remains a widely held moral maxim. In particular, it serves as the basic assumption of the Christian fundamentalist's social theory. Fundamentalists claim that all of society's troubles - everything from AIDS to out-of-wedlock pregnancies - are the result of a breakdown in morality and that this breakdown is due to a decline in the belief of God. This paper will look at different examples of how a god could be a bad thing and show that humans can create rules and morals all on their own. It will also touch upon the fact that doing good for the wrong reasons can also be a bad thing for the person.
The belief that morality requires ...view middle of the document...

Thou shalt torture innocent children in your spare time. ..." The reason that this is possible is that killing, raping, stealing, and torturing were not wrong before God made them so. Since God is free to establish whatever set of moral principles he chooses, he could just as well have chosen this set as any other.
However it is absurd to think that such needless killing, raping, stealing, and torturing could be morally permissible. Moreover, to believe that God could have commanded these things is to destroy whatever grounds one might have for praising or worshiping him. And if in accord with the definition of tyrants, justice consists in that which is pleasing to the most powerful? Besides it seems that every act of willing supposes some reason for the willing and this reason, of course, must precede the act.
Leibniz's position is that, if things are neither right nor wrong independently of God's will, then God cannot choose one thing over another because it is right. Thus, if he does choose one over another, his choice must be arbitrary. But a being whose decisions are arbitrary is not a being worthy of worship.
The fact that Leibniz rejects the Divine Command Theory is significant, for he is one of the most committed theists in the Western intellectual tradition. He argues at great length that there must be an all-powerful, all-knowing, and all-good God and consequently that this must be the best of all possible worlds, for such a God could create nothing less. What Leibniz demonstrates is that, far from being disrespectful or heretical, the view that morality is independent of God is an eminently sensible and loyal one for a theist to hold.
To avoid the charge of absurdity, a Divine Command theorist might try to deny that the situation described above is possible. He might argue, for example, that God would never condone such killing, raping, stealing, and torturing, for God is all good. But to make such a claim is to render the theory vacuous. The Divine Command Theory is a theory of the nature of morality. It tells us what makes something good by offering a definition of morality. But if goodness is a defining attribute of God, then God cannot be used to define goodness. If being all-good is an essential property of God, then all the Divine Command Theory tells us is that good actions would be willed by a supremely good being. While this is certainly true, it is unenlightening. For it does not tell us what makes something good and hence does not increase our understanding of the nature of morality.
A Divine Command theorist might try to avoid this circularity by denying that goodness is a defining attribute of God. But this would take him from the frying pan into the fire, for if goodness is not an essential property of God, then there is no guarantee that what he wills will be good. Even if God is all-powerful and all-knowing, it does not follow that he is all-good, for, as the story of Satan is supposed to teach us, one can be...

Other Essays Like Morality And God

Christian Worldview Essay

548 words - 3 pages died for our sins (John 3:16). 4. Question of Morality God is the basis for morality, we must develop good character within ourselves. We must know truth from lies, and know that we have a loving God to worship and live for (John 1:5). God created us to be moral human beans, and share the same character as he does. We

The Natural Law Theory Essay

1231 words - 5 pages law and the divine law God created them from a law much superior than the rest, one which only God himself has the knowledge of, the eternal law. Humans actively participate in the eternal law of God by using reason in conformity with the Natural Law to discern what is good and evil(Magee 1). Of these laws the natural law is the most vital, the natural law uses nature as a guide to morality and humanity, to decipher the right from the wrong

What Is a Christian Worldview

901 words - 4 pages ." Aaron remained silent". Luke 4:8 "Jesus answered, "It is written: 'Worship the Lord your God and serve him only.'" Morality - Romans 5:12-14 tell us that Man has fallen short of the glory of God. The very glory that He was intended for. Though we have a sinful nature and are inclined to sin, there remains a standard by which we know right and wrong. The ultimate standard is God Himself. God revealed Himself as Jesus Christ teaching men

Naturalism, Realism and the Existence of God

863 words - 4 pages material, so all beings are simply stimulus-response machines and there is no room for freedom, shame or human dignity (Leffel, 1994). In contrast to naturalism, realism is the belief that says morality is based solely on what God is thought to have commanded people to do. Reinhold Niebhur, known as the father of Christian Realism, laid out what he called “indeterminate possibilities”. He said that because God is alive in everyone, people

Morality and Religion

862 words - 4 pages morality and religion is that if our morals come from a divine being, what happens when the divine being changes his mind? If all of a sudden, God said that raping and murdering children was the moral thing to do, would it be? In the Bible, all of God's morals carry consequences that will occur if they are not followed, typically involving eternal suffering. Those who claim that religion is the only source of morality are indirectly saying that

Living in Community

651 words - 3 pages , This is to be expected, because God does not call together groups of people who are naturally adapted to one another. He calls people who are very different in their origins, customs, and ways of thinking and he asks them to live together because they believe Jesus Christ. Therefore, when we realize it, we must seek common points while reserving difference. (Page 99-100) In my opinion, religion plays an undoubted role in community life. There

A Short Christian Theology

960 words - 4 pages way. And I believe a perfect, non-contingent, self-existing, personal God is the only logical answer for this. I also recognize that there is a moral law, and that speaks to a moral law-giver, and I see in that the need for a non-contingent being, who explains everything we see and know of. If God does not exist, how then do we make moral pronouncements of any kind? Where does that morality come from? There are basically four fundamental

Hinduism Worldview

603 words - 3 pages Hinduism Worldview 1. The Question of Origin. The beliefs of a Hindu can be very confusing with the question of origin because they believe in so many different God’s and there are so many different sects. What unifies the sects though is the worship of Braham. It would be my guess that they believe that Brahma, the creator God, Is what brought them into existence. 2. The Question of Identity. To a Hindu all forms of living beings are a

Worldview Assignment

821 words - 4 pages worldview, it’s all about having a personal intimate relationship with God through Jesus Christ (Weider and Gutierrez, 2011). In John 17:3, he shows how important it is to find salvation. The greatest verse that I believe shows how detrimental salvation is, is in Mathew 19:25-26, where he clearly states that with God anything is possible. 4. The Question of Morality or Ethics asks the questions of “What is the meaning behind what is right

Comparing God in Daisy Miller, Huck Finn, and Country of the Pointed Firs

2093 words - 9 pages morality?   This essay will examine how Emily Dickinson, Sarah Orne Jewett, Henry James and Mark Twain wrote literature in this age coupled with war, inhumanity and despair in God.  This essay will show that: (1) Dickinson destroys any reliance on the Bible and a possibility of knowing God, but argues that one should instead praise Nature, which is tangible; (2) Jewett eliminates the omniscient narrator (or God-like figure) in The Country of the

Critical Thinking

1168 words - 5 pages oneself from suffering is by eliminating all desire.” These teachings connect to morality through the concepts of the right intentions, right effort, right speech, right action, and right livelihood. (http://www.accesstoinsight.org/lib/authors/bodhi/waytoend.html) 5. The Question of Destiny: The Buddhist People did not believe that their destiny was controlled by the Creator God but instead affirmed in a life force or energy power. Their own

Related Papers

"Doctor Faustus" As A Morality Play

909 words - 4 pages see a knowing Faustus deliberately setting himself upon an evil course. The supernatural context of Faustus’ tragedy and the central importance of the theological concepts of evil and suffering within that context distinguish it from all other tragedies of the time, and suggest its relationship to the Eng morality play. Even though Marlowe’s play seems by and large to grow directly from the English Faust Book rather than from the stage tradition

The Dead Of God In The Modern Society

2511 words - 11 pages the belief in God. As long as society focuses on knowledge, technology, and material, tangible things, society will continue to run away from God. Until the focus can be turned away from proof and turn towards faith, Nietzsche’s statement will continue to ring truth. Perhaps God is dead, but only through faith can He live again! THE PROBLEM OF MORALITY As far as morality is concerned, people have opted to develop and practice a secular and

Worldview Essay

817 words - 4 pages because of how we were born into this world, being a sinner. Scripture references to the question of morality are Romans 5:12-14 and John 13:34. 5. The Question of Destiny – Our destiny as Christians will be either in Heaven and Hell. Heaven is in the presence and blessing of God, while being in Hell we are separated from God. Salvation is the key and source to one getting into Heaven too. However, how we live our lives and our personal

Biblical World View Essay

649 words - 3 pages definitions. Secular Humanism, can be defined as a religious worldview based on atheism, naturalism, evolution, and ethical relativism. A biblical/Christian worldview can be defined as a religious worldview based on the belief in God, that the bible is God’s word, man consist of body and spirit and that God is the creator. Next I will compare the two worldviews as they relate to origin, identity, meaning/purpose, morality and destiny. Secular