Mr Big Essay

615 words - 3 pages

Mr. Big: Exposing Undercover Investigations in Canada.

The book talks about false confessions obtained in Mr. Big operation, and wrongful convictions that occur as a result of this operations. After reading the book I was left confused, and disappointed about some of the decisions made by the Criminal Justice System and the RCMP.

I believe that confessions obtained in this type of operations are not reliable, and therefore should not be admissible in court, or as evidence. The confessions should be more investigative tools than evidence, like a polygraph that you use to find more about a case, but the results are not admissible in court as evidence since they are not completely reliable. But if it is going to be admitted in a court of law, I believe that there should be hard evidence against a person to be convicted, an example would be a ...view middle of the document...

E.g. aggressive scenarios, pretended murders, staged kidnaps, and beatings (p.20)
Making the jury believe that the target confessed because they are guilty, to not because of any other reasons. This made me ask why the Criminal Justice system is not doing more to protect society from cops who abuse the system and miss use their power to incriminate people? I understand that law enforcement officers are under a lot of pressure from society to catch criminals, but they should not abuse the power given to them.

The thing that troubled me the most is that in a lot of cases mentioned in the book we see known ways to obtain a false confession being used by the police (P. 44).
E.g. 1) Being lead a person to believe that the situation is unjust and hopeless and that the only way to help themselves is to confess. 2) Convinced a subject that they committed the crime but do not remembers, and confessing is the best course of action. We see this in the Mentuck case.3) the targets were vulnerable and impressionable, they did not have much money, education, and were involved in drugs, alcohol, and were not the smartest people, which are all reasons for false confessions (P.41, 42), also we see manipulation, deception, false promises, threats. Why are police officers allowed to do this?

Ultimately I believe that Mr. Big operations are necessary and that in many cases are very helpful, but there should be more rules about what can be done this operations, and should be closely regulated. Also they should videotape everything that happens in the investigation, that way this operations would be more transparent. I truly believe that with more and stricter regulations, and changes in the Mr. Big operations the number of false confessions in this operations would be lower or non-existent.

Other Essays Like mr big essay

Animal Farm Essay

639 words - 3 pages propaganda to get what he wants. State that Orwell is criticising Stalin’s manipulation of the Russian society a big ally of the propaganda is the animal’s ignorance and false memory Paragraph 3- Power of Napoleon State that Napoleon, whom represents Stalin, only gained and keeps his power through cruelty, treachery and making the other animals scared of him. Show that after the rebellion, Napoleon has taken the place of Mr Jones (seen through quote

Pride And Prejudice Essay

1763 words - 8 pages she had for reject him. Before Mr. Darcy's departure, he left a letter to Elizabeth explaining all the misunderstandings that made her prejudices grew up. After reading the letter, Elizabeth's feelings changed drastically and now she felt very ashamed about her prejudices against Mr. Darcy. When Elizabeth was in a way feeling attracted by Darcy, Lydia her youngest sister escaped with Mr. Wickham causing a big scandal. The Bennets were devastated

Bussiness Case Study Wendy's

1643 words - 7 pages good restaurants and take-aways in the area. Mr. Smith’s prices are less than half of what similar motels charge and only a fraction of what the big five-star properties are charging. And, really, he isn’t all that far away from the beach, shops and other attractions. The problem is occupancy. He has some regulars who come every holiday period (and have been doing so for the four years he has owned the property). Overall, occupancy is about 50

Doc, Docx

2578 words - 11 pages Jamie or me. I was trying to think who he meant when I heard Jamie say something under his breath. "What was that, James?" Jamie stood right in front of him, fists clenched, eyes like fire. I wriggled to get free, but Mr Fisher's arm gripped me. I saw Jamie stick his chin out like he did before a fight. "I said I know your game. You're after our Mum, you dirty big bastard!" Jamie fairly shouted. Suddenly Mum was there and the back of

Business Management

822 words - 4 pages to take her hu place. Because of tradition and only men being allowed to pick from box they let her undera pick. A women would never be allowed to pick from box no way no how. There tradition ma live in a way that only men had the power, they are the head and all decision come through th and last. Then there is the traditional practice of the lottery. When i think of the lottery big money comes Mr. Summers and the village folk

Dangerous Skinny Trend

585 words - 3 pages Sinem Bulut September 25, 2014 Composition 1, Section 018 Unit Essay 1, First Draft Professor Petillo Dangerous Skinny Trend Both journalist, Michele Ingrassia in her article, “The Body of The Beholder” and Guy Trebay in his article “The Vanishing Point” explore issues of body image. Ingrassia for female, Trebay for male, but they both have similar points of view. Somehow they both

Untitled

2024 words - 9 pages episode has aliens abducting Bill Clinton and Bob Dole and they end up running the United States. A political shot is taken at Ross Perot as he loses to the aliens who abducted the Democrat and Republican candidates. (Groening) Another shot is taken at the politicians in Washington during the episode, "Mr. Lisa goes to Washington." Lisa writes an essay and is sent to the national levels in Washington D.C. While in Washington she overhears her

Feeling Love

1713 words - 7 pages Mark Berger Mrs. Morais English 101 Sec 012 February 1, 2010 Essay #1 First Draft: Feeling Love What is love? How do we know when we actually find true love? These questions and many more about love have been getting asked since the start of time. Not all of these questions can ever get answered;because everyone has their own take on what it is and how to find it. Some people think that true love doesn’t even exist. Love is

Eng102 Fiction Essay

2095 words - 9 pages Thomas house, but nothing was stolen. T was the leader of the gang at the time the damage took place, but had some kind of sense not to steal to make a bad situation any more worse then what it is. The gang was Predator and Mr Thomas was the Prey. B.The Most Dangerous Game is about hunters. Rainsford was a big time hunter and didnt care how a jaguar felt, but ended up on an Island and came across a General who was also a hunter but not just

Why I Hate to Write Papers

717 words - 3 pages we learn in her class which was abosoultly nothing. No homework, with group quizes made the class too easy. She was stil ready us the material out the book before we even did our work. In my last year in middle school I had an english teacher that didn't speak english! That was the most confusing class of my life, he couldn't explain assiments or even explain why we got the grades we did. Mr. Gifford was a big reason towards my hate for writing

Essay If I Had Carlos Slim Money

587 words - 3 pages Name: Lucy Adamyan Subject: Business English Group: 5 Course: 4 IBS-M, RANEPA Essay If you had Carlos Slim money, what kind of business would you buy and what kind of lifestyle would you lead? Carlos Slim is a Mexican billionaire and the world’s richest or second-richest man, with a fortune estimated to be in excess of $67bn. Aged 11, he began his commercial activity from investing in government saving bonds. Then he became a

Related Papers

Suspense In Dr. Jekyll And Mr. Hyde

688 words - 3 pages about when I talk about this story. The big mystery in this story is that Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde are the same person! Dr. Jekyll made many potions in order to make his dual personality, Mr. Hyde. Mr. hyde resembles Dr. Jekyll's adventurous and even at times, evil side. This science-fiction story has marveled many readers for many years. Works Cited for Jekyll and Hyde essay "Essay: How Does Stevenson Create Intrigue and Engage the Reader in "Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde"?" Essays & Coursework Help. GCSE, A-Level, and University Essay and Coursework Library - Coursework.Info. Web. 08 Apr. 2010. .

Two Years Better Than Four Essay

844 words - 4 pages college does not receive enough recognition and importance. Due to this reason she decides to write this essay in order to show people that community college is a good option. In addition, Liz Addison refuse Mr. Pearlstein opinion who concludes that college experiences have come to the end; telling “My guess, reading between the lines, is that Mr. Pearlstein has never set a foot in an American College” (Two Years Are Better Than Four, 2007). She

Animal Farm Power Corrupts, Absoloute Power Corrupts Abosoloutely

632 words - 3 pages Animal Farm Essay Power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely. Power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutely is proven many times in the book Animal Farm by George Orwell. For example: The pigs were corrupt absolutely so much so that they resembled humans exactly. The farmer, Mr. Jones was so corrupt that on most nights would completely neglect the animals. Napoleon became corrupt by the little power that he shared with

How Does Robert Stevenson Build Up Our Expectations In The Story Of The Door: Dr Jekyll And Mr Hyde

590 words - 3 pages How Does The Writer Build Up The Readers Expectations In The Story Of The Door ? In the story of the door Robert Stevenson builds up the readers expectations by talking about the characters, setting, themes and mystery and suspence. In this essay i will look at all four points and explore the methods Stevenson uses to build up our expectations. In the opening paragraph of the story of the door, Stevenson starts by describing Mr. Utterson