Natural Perceptions Essay

2463 words - 10 pages

Chris Clarke on how Disney's treatment of animals
has altered our sense of the wild and cleared the way for environmental decline.

As the close of the twentieth century approaches and our world becomes more and more urban our knowledge of nature is increasingly second-hand. Those of us in cities, whose non-human neighbors tend toward rats, pigeons and dandelions, are dependent on the media for our understanding of the natural world – or at least that part of it not adapted to urban life. It is from movies, television and packaged tourism that we derive our sense of nature.
For the last half century, it has been Walt Disney and his corporate estate that have provided that sense. In doing ...view middle of the document...

They weren’t humans; that role was reserved for the film’s villain. They were, however, people. So that the death of Bambi’s mother at the hands of the Hunter is clearly murder.
Bambi was the prototype for Disney’s later nature work, most notably the ‘True-Life Adventures’, a series of what were loosely referred to as documentaries, set in habitats from the Sonoran Desert to the Canadian tundra.

Animal Stars
Rather than go through the arduous and costly process of filming actual wildlife, captive animals were coached to follow scripts. The results documented the intentions of the filmmakers far more than they did the behaviour of the animal stars. Yet from Disney’s first such work, 1948’s Seal Island, viewers readily accepted the films as authentic portrayals of nature.
The distortions in Disney’s nature films were part of a grand North American literary and artistic tradition. Painters of the Hudson River School took liberties with such trivia as proportion and scale. Writers like Ernest Thompson Seton enthralled hundreds of thousands of readers with stories such as those in Wild Animals I Have Known. The tales were exciting, went into great detail about the lives of wild animals and coincided only occasionally with reality. By 1910 Seton and his cohorts had been thoroughly discredited as the ‘nature fakers’. Naturalist John Burroughs referred to Seton’s magnum opus in the Atlantic Monthly as Wild Animals I Alone Have Known.
Perhaps with an eye to the nature fakers’ ignominy, Disney admitted the subjectivity in his True-Life Adventures series from the outset, claiming that his purpose was not to educate but to entertain. Critics blasted the films’ ecological inaccuracies anyway. Disney referred to animals as ‘courageous’, ‘jolly’, ‘lonely’, ‘treacherous’ and other terms best suited to a human ethical framework. Animal mothers were praised or condemned based on how closely their parental care standards coincided with the idealized model of an American family from the 1950s. In Bear Country the writers created an entity never before seen in nature: a bonded pair of bear parents in which Mama became a sort of ‘den-wife’ while Papa went out to bring home the bacon. Presumably the spectacle of Papa deciding the little cubs were a suitable meal, as would likely happen in the wild, wouldn’t have sold well.
Probably the most egregious misrepresentation of True Life occurred in White Wilderness (1958). The film crew brought a handful of lemmings from Manitoba to Alberta, placed them atop a large, snow-covered turntable, and filmed their movements from various angles. Later the crew brought the rodents to a precipice above a river and herded them off, faithfully recording the lemmings’ fatal leap.
In the film the lemmings were portrayed as engaged in a suicidal migration marching en masse to drown in the sea, or at least what passes for sea in landlocked Alberta. The fact that no such behaviour had ever been...

Other Essays Like Natural Perceptions

Romulus My Father Essay

1210 words - 5 pages The exploration of texts such as Raimond Gaita’s Romulus my father, Tim Burton’s Edward Scissorhands and Tim Winton’s Neighbours, all exemplify the universal theme of how our perceptions of belonging and not belonging can be influenced by connections to places. Romulus my father is a biographical memoir detailing the cultural struggles of belonging and segregation within unfamiliar surroundings. The text demonstrates how an individual’s

Swot Analysis

794 words - 4 pages , which may cause a disruption in some of our product offerings. Competitive Environment Our competitors include but are not limited to local, regional, national and international supermarkets, natural food stores, warehouse membership clubs, small specialty stores and restaurants. Their businesses compete with us for products, customers and locations. In addition, some are expanding more aggressively in marketing a range of natural and

7 Habits of Highly Effective People Book Summary

1015 words - 5 pages techniques to get other people to like them. Personality ethic is illusory and deceptive and trying to get high quality results with its techniques and quick fixes – not effective at all. Paradigm The book talks a lot about paradigm shifts and I remember having to look it up in the dictionary to find the true meaning of it; paradigm meaning: model, theory, perception, assumption, the way we see world. Conditioning affects our perceptions

The Role of Women

1267 words - 6 pages The role of women in Canadian society has changed dramatically over the past two centuries. These roles, which had been defined in various cultures for centuries, were based both on natural instinct and on necessity. When Canada was first settled, it was natural for immigrants to maintain traditional roles for men and women. By the eighteenth century, these distinct roles were strongly established in Canadian society. During the nineteenth


1736 words - 7 pages . The uniformity of nature is where the belief of the laws of nature will continue to commence, therefore it should be still commencing in days to come. The same can be said predicting tides, the rotation of our planet that give us the ability to calculate time, magnetism of the poles, and many other known natural occurrences that is continual. Through the lenses of emotion, another way to obtain knowledge is through perceptions. Perceptions

The Role of Women in Land Management and Conservation

3375 words - 14 pages an important role and their contribution to the farm income is often disproportionately high. The study aimed to understand the role and perceptions of women farmers in land management and conservation, and to identify possible pathways for better representation of women's' needs in onfarm land management and conservation. The study was conducted in a typical watershed in the Middle-Hill region of Nepal, with a high diversity of age, casts and

Describe The Following Barriers Which Managers Face And Briefly Recommend How They Might Best Be Overcome: (I) Barriers To Communication (Ii) Barriers To Change

808 words - 4 pages based on personal perceptions of those they communicate with.Barriers will be created where:- The transmitter or recipient is either distracted or not interested in communicating.- Recommendation: good communication is based on establishedrelationships so efforts to build trust and mutual respect pave the way for removal of this barrier.- The relationship between the two interferes with interpretation due to status differentials (e.g. inhibiting

Sensory Architecture

581 words - 3 pages within the building through haptics and visual senses. The main strategy in the interior design adopts different ways of dealing with the original building fabric. This involves exposing the original building fabric with contrasting materials, or the original building fabric will be hidden with materials that attempts to blend in. It is where individuals perceptions are found in built environment, the main senses created were not only of

Investment Opportunities and Roles of Public Relations and Advertising in Investment Promotion in Nigeria

593 words - 3 pages exploitation and export of natural gas, bitumen, limestone, coal, tin, columbite, gold, silver, lead-zinc, gypsum, glass sands, clays, asbestos, graphite, and iron ore, among others Power sector The power sector reform has moved the sector from the position of government ownership/management to a private-sector driven. Investment opportunities exist for power generation (gas, hydro, coal, wind, solar, etc) for local and foreign investors to


1704 words - 7 pages skills is a continuous cycle for which we must strive and takes a lifetime of commitment. Interpersonal communication is a facet to our everyday lives. Analyzing several entries from my journal for my Interpersonal Communications on-line class, I will discuss how stereotyping (perceptions), self-disclosure, bad communication and feedback, verbal and non-verbal messages, and listening affect our day-to-day professional and personal relationships

External Contributing Factors to Depression

2062 words - 9 pages with and in very harsh circumstances, can lead to suicide, which is clearly considered a serious clinical problem (Viava et al., 2011), which is why investigation on this subject is so important, and why the contributors to depression need to be identified. Several forms of depression treatments currently exist, including therapy and natural remedies, however the most common treatment form is antidepressants, more specifically those that

Related Papers

Dickinson And Belonging Essay

1295 words - 6 pages ". Through these two characters Stockett, like Dickinson, eloquently shows how the decision made by individuals and how those around them perceive them shape our experience of belonging.While this remains true, Dickinson does explore area situation where decisions and perceptions do not affect one's ability to belong, and that is in death. Through "I Died For Beauty" Dickinson explores the concept that since death is a natural consequence of being human

The Nature Of Space In Kafka's The Castle

2395 words - 10 pages ] he holds steadfast to his quest, "thinking of nothing else at all," [pg. 11] despite the obstacles placed in front of him by the villagers', their perceptions, and the Castle or natural world itself and his own perceptions of it. However, it is these very perceptions that demonstrate the true nature of physical space. It is nothing more than perceptions. Kafka demonstrates the futileness of K.'s quest through the

Frito Lay New Product Introduction Essay

1398 words - 6 pages , French onion and mild cheddar).Based on the results of the concept test it seems that before trials consumers perceive Sun Chips as being a healthier alternative that is not for everyday use with the natural flavor perceived as healthier, followed by Mild Cheddar and then the French Onion flavor. Postuse perceptions show that people who tried Sun Chips still rate them as a healthier product but now they perceive them as an everyday snack, postuse

Cross Cultural Consumer Behavior: An International Perspective In Consumer Behavior

945 words - 4 pages between 1946 and 1964 are today considered Baby Boomers (National Tour Association, 2002). So ads that are designed to attract anyone sixty eight and older are completely blocked from my perception. The surprising aspect of this is that after I had done some research I realized that as of April 2014 there are 84 Million Baby Boomers living in the United States (Lesonsky, 2011). By defining the needs, perceptions and attitudes of Baby Boomers