Nature Vs Nurture: Do Genes Or Environment Matter More?

1084 words - 5 pages

Throughout the years, it has been debated whether
people are born the way they will be forever or if the society they
grow in creates all of their attributes. This nature versus nurture
debate affects many aspects of life, including the treatment of serial
killers and psychopaths, and recognition of emotional and mental
disorders, the acceptance of homosexuality, and even video game
regulation. The nature theory states that only a person’s genes develop
their personality, while the nurture theory states that personality is
developed only because of the impact of society (human). This debate
has been a controversial issue since the beginning of sociology, the
study of society and ...view middle of the document...

This data provides
support for the nature theory, backing up the idea that emotional
disorders are strictly from birth. In addition, though the majority of
serial killers lack education, they still possess wit and cleverness,
making them naturally candidates for violent behavior. Even though they
lack schooling, a major component of nurture, serial killers tend to
naturally have components that make them ideal for being a killer.
Also, twins have strikingly similar behaviors, even when reared apart.
Identical twins share 100% of their DNA and fraternal twins share 50%
of their DNA (Powell), and are created in the same womb simultaneously,
providing optimal conditions for determining if DNA is the ultimate
factor in personality development. When brought up together, they often
exhibit very similar traits. In one case where two identical twins were
brought up apart, they still exhibited very similar traits (Powell),
providing evidence that DNA is the main contributor to peoples’
personalities.
Although there is evidence supporting the nature theory,
many sociologists today believe that personality is developed through
society one is placed in. For example, reaction to narcotics would be
the same all over the world if DNA provided personality. Instead,
drunks in eastern Bolivia and Oaxaca, Mexico are not aggressive when
drunk like Americans and many eastern Europeans are. If it was human
nature that regulated how people acted under the influence of alcohol,
it would be the same everywhere and not vary regionally (Powell). In
addition, drunks among the Kaingang Indians in Brazil are very violent
while drinking, which is typically expected in that specific culture
(Powell). This study provides examples of society directly effecting
human behavior. Also, research shows violent video games make children
that play them consistently more violent. An experiment was conducted
in which two groups of teens played two types of video games, one
purely adrenal and the other violent. Brain scans were taken of the
teens directly after game play. The results showed decrease in brain
activity in the areas that involved self control, inhibition, and
attention in the brains of the children playing the violent game, but
not the adrenal one (Video). The results of the game were tested on
children with and without behavioral disorders, with the effects being
generally the same on both. This proves that the games are the cause...

Other Essays Like Nature Vs Nurture: Do Genes Or Environment Matter More?

Nature Vs. Nurture: Athletics Essay

558 words - 3 pages has a lot to do with this mgnificant gift too. A different factor in this topic is environment. This also goes along with booth being born a player and begin born to play. Somebody's parents or guardians must encourage their children in what they do. Guardians must also congratulate their children in their accomplishments in what ever sport they compete in. Guardians may not even have to directly introduce their children to a sport. If a guardian

Nature vs Nurture Research Proposal Essay

963 words - 4 pages Working Title: Nature VS Nurture – A Study of Criminal Behaviour Subject and Background: In this research paper, the researcher will analyze the ongoing and historical debate on whether human behaviour is reliant on one’s environment, as opposed to it being pre-determined by one’s heritable biological genes. The nature vs nurture debate dates back to the 19th century. Sigmund Frued – the father of psychoanalysis – stated in his

Are We Humans the Product of Nature or Nurture?

792 words - 4 pages Are we humans the product of nature or nurture? Nature is how much of your personality is genetic, what you were born with. Nurture is how much of your personality was caused because of your environment, how you were raised. So does nature or nurture contribute more to someone's personality and behaviour? Or do they both play a role in shaping our lives? I hope to come to a conclusion with this debate in the end of my thesis. With

Nature vs Nurture

830 words - 4 pages brain gives us the ability to move, to speak and understand language, generate information, to interact with the environment, to interact with inanimate objects, and the ability to communicate with others. The brain is divided into three different basic units, the forebrain, the midbrain, and the hindbrain. There are also five major structures of the human brain. The Myelencephalon, Metencephalon, Mesencephalon, Deincephalon, and Telencephalon

Do You Agree or Disagree: Technology Helps to Make People's Lives Simpler or Make People's Lives More Complicated?

528 words - 3 pages sum of money to revive them.But if we write on a paper,we never have such kinds of problems.In this way,technologies have complicated our life. Besides,more vigilance is required with the advent and advancement of technologies.With internet developing,all computers and databases are connected.,which expose us to a wealth of potential threats,such as financial data thefts or privacy violation.Take Target breach,which occurred last year,as an

Do You Agree or Disagree That with the Following Statement? It’s More Important for the Government to Spend Money to Build Art Museums and Music Performance Center Than to Build Recreational...

567 words - 3 pages Do you agree or disagree that with the following statement? It’s more important for the government to spend money to build art museums and music performance center than to build recreational facilities (such as swimming pool, playgrounds). Art museums, concert halls and recreational facilities are indispensable to any civilized society. When it comes to the issue of the arrangement of a government’s budget, some people suggest that the

Bill & Ben Reticulation Pty Ltd vs Port Cricket Club - Income to be regarded as taxable or capital nature??

318 words - 2 pages As a general rule, amounts received as compensation with the cancellation or variation of trade or other commercial contracts made in the course of carrying on business are in the nature of income. Referring to Heavy Minerals Pty Ltd V FCT (1996) , where compensation for loss of anticipated profits as a result of cancellation of a distribution contract was held to be income. The taxpayer was in the rutile mining business and entered a number of

Nature vs. Nuture

804 words - 4 pages seems to negate the significance of free will. More specifically, if all our traits are determined by our genes, by our environment, by chance, or by somecombination of these acting together, then there seems to be little room for free will. This line of reasoning suggests that the "nature versus nurture" debate tends to exaggerate the degree to which individual human behavior can be predicted based on knowledge of genetics and the environment. Furthermore, in this line of reasoning, it should also be pointed out that biology may determine our abilities, but free will still determines what we do with our abilities.

The Nature vs Nuture Debate

1899 words - 8 pages between genes and the environment, people will continue to study the effects of each in development. In these future studies, more groundbreaking advances will be made to aid humans in better understanding human behaviour. In the end, that is what both sides of the nature vs. nurture debate intended to accomplish.

Gender Identity Paper

1574 words - 7 pages fraternal twins raised under the same conditions would be alike, regardless of the differences in their genes. They do closely resemble each other more than non -twins, they also show the same similarities when raised apart as in studies done with identical twins. “The Nature Theory takes things a step further to say that more abstract traits such as intelligence, personality, aggression, and sexual orientation are also encoded in an individual's

Developmental Psychology

776 words - 4 pages separate entity Interdependent self vs. independent self Heredity & Environment How do nature and nurture work together?  Heritability: estimate of how much individual differences are due to genetics     Values range from 0 to 1.00 Kinship studies: compare characteristics of family members (i.e., compare identical twins) Estimates are of limited usefulness Heredity & Environment  Gene-environment correlation

Related Papers

Nature Vs. Nurture Essay

994 words - 4 pages Nature vs. Nurture Over the years there has been a pretty big debate over nature verses nurture and which one plays the larger role in human development and how they act. Nature is the genetics or hereditary influences of a person; basically nature is the genes you are born with that can’t be changed. Nurture is experiential or environmental influences that you develop over time after you are born, such as how your parents raise you which

Nature Vs Nurture Essay

969 words - 4 pages or past experiences nature or nurture, does that person have free will? The reality of free will is brought into the matter by theories of both. When it comes down to nature what we are uncovered to growing up good and bad and life lesson. When nurture starts at home but is not limited to the value and kind of cares that parent provide child to the time they walk out your front door and enter the real world as well as the new philosophy

Nature Vs Nurture Essay

1680 words - 7 pages Nature/Nurture Unit 4 – M1 & D1 M1 For many years there has been a considerable amount of debate regarding whether or not nature or nurture has the greatest impact, or influence on an individual specifically in regards to that individuals personality, growth and development. Nature can be described as the innate features an individual possess, these features are biological and thus are inherited through the genes passed down by an

Nature Vs. Nurture Essay

537 words - 3 pages Nature vs. Nurture The question of importance varies from one circumstance to the next. What is naturally a part of someone predetermines their ability to adapt. If you are born with what are considered “normal” factors your chances of growing and adapting to your surroundings are greater. Isn’t it natural to seek food and shelter? Certain things don’t have to be taught , such as crying, breathing and feeling. Isn’t it natural to want to be