No Moral Obligation To The Earth

1188 words - 5 pages

A relatively young philosophy and rapidly groving movement is environmentalism. It has roots in ethical philosophy. It presents a moral duty in having an obligation to the planet. However, its approach is misguided: While it is obviously useful to study and to be familiar with the the Earth we inhabit, presenting a moral obligation of protecting it is an incorrect approach. Many have been lead to accept this falsehood, guided by shaky logic and sentimental notions of no moral concern. We have no moral obligation to the Earth.

The Conceits of Humanity

We are a proud species - we are proud of our technology, our successes, our enlightenment, and our civilization. Occasionally we are ...view middle of the document...

Humans assume that the earth is at the center of the solar system. Eventually they learn that it is not. Humans assume that the Sun is at the center of our galaxy. Eventually they learn that it is not. Humans assume that their galaxy is at the center of the universe. Humans assume that there is something special about the Milky Way Galaxy. Eventually, they discover the same thing: the Milky Way is not the center of the universe, and it is one of billions of galaxies. Humans then assume that their solar system is the only one with planets. Again, they learn it is not.

I propose a new “demotion” to Sagan's list. Humanity assumes that it plays a role of great importance in the Earth's existence. The truth to eventually be discovered: they do not.

A Pragmatic and Utilitarian View

The costs of having a moral obligation to the Earth -- the planet itself -- are enormous. Attempting to combat issues purely related to the Earth is not justified in these levels of spending. The economic costs of instituting programs like the Kyoto Protocol are enormous, to the point of negatively affecting the economies of those involved. Humanity should not drive itself to destitution purely to save the planet. There are more important matters.

We should be looking at environment effects in a way that provides an analysis of cost - economic costs, human costs, and moral costs. If we can bring a significant portion of peoples out of poverty and destitution, the Earth need not be a primary concern. We should be looking at the end results of our actions. Are we helping people live better lives as a result of our actions?

Bjørn Lomberg, a Danish environmental writer, in his 2007 book Cool It: The Skeptical Environmentalist's Guide to Global Warming outlines how such reasonining might take place in the context of enrivonment ethics. In a compilation and analysis of numerous peer-reviewed studies on the effects of climate change and its impact on forestry, fisheries, water availability, human infrastructure, natural disasters, land erosion, pollution, and human migration, Lomberg places a bottom line on efforts we should take to mitigate it. An analysis of the Kyoto Protocol in this context reveals that if it were to be completely implemented by all of its signatories, the net benefits to the world over the next century would amount to around $2 trillion. However, the cost of implementing the agreement in its most efficient manner, hovers around $5...

Other Essays Like No Moral Obligation To The Earth

Can It Ever Be Moral to Cause the Death of Another Human Being?

1968 words - 8 pages which can only weaken further and inevitably led to death. Here we have the moral question with regard to the terminally ill patient of which is better, a slow lingering death, without pain but also no awareness of the world around you or one lethal injection or removal of life enhancing machinery. There is a very fine line between passive and active euthanasia. Even though we are commited, as human beings, to the fundamental belief that the

Do You Agree That Education Is No Longer the Key to Success?

989 words - 4 pages easily. Thus, the value of information has dropped significantly. There is no longer a need for people who have the ability to store information due to the omnipresence of computers and the Internet. In addition, the focus is now more on creating a knowledge-based Economy where creativity and innovation are the keys to success. In view of this, many of the current education provided by schools will not be sufficient. For example, the education

The Miranda Rights As They Are Today Are No Longer Appropriate And Need To Be Modified

1550 words - 7 pages Thesis: The Miranda Rights as they are today are no longer appropriate and need to be modified. A young couple is murdered in the middle of the night. The next night a single mother of two is raped and killed in her apartment. Her children murdered beside her. A killer is on the loose. The citizens are scared. The police form a task force. Finally, after weeks of investigations and false leads, a suspect is identified and

Assess The Moral Arguments And Political Actions Of Those Opposed To The Spread Of Slavery In The Context Of Two Of The Following

473 words - 2 pages Assess the moral arguments and political actions of those opposed to the spread of slavery in the context of two of the following:The Missouri CompromiseThe Mexican WarCompromise Of 1850Kansas-Nebraska Act The moral and political actions of those opposed to the spread of slavery in the context of The Mexican War and The Kansas-Nebraska Act are very conflicting. With the upset in balance of the Mexican War, antislavery activists

How Does Mary Shelley's Narrative Encourage the Reader to Make Links Between the Personalities, Experiences and Moral Conduct of Robert Walton, Victor Frankenstein and the Creature?

1023 words - 5 pages Shelly use of narrative with each of the three different characters in Frankenstein shows strong links in personality, experiences and moral conduct of each of the narrators. Being in narrative the entire book is written in first person, so anything that is written is the view or opinion of the person whose narration it is, therefore the reader cannot completely trust what is being said. Each of the characters has a main underlying desire to

"An Interdisciplinary Approach To The Study Of The Life Of Siddhartha Gautama, Focusing On His Moral And Ethical Context In Terms Of Actions, Influence And Response"

1532 words - 7 pages "lived for eighty years and had a teaching career that approached five decades" . Of particular relevance to his actions is the catalytic effect that poverty, death, disease and old age had on his moral perspectives.Historical research tells that Gautama left home in search of salvation, however, regardless of prominent instruction, found no great "awakening". To further this, he maintained that truth remained "veiled in asceticism" , and that

A Short Extra Credit Blurb On How The Holocuast Was A Challenge To Western Civilization; References To Schindler's List, Otherwise No Bibliography- A Good Starting Point For A More In Depth Paper

658 words - 3 pages in the process implored slavery.Through brute force the Jews were forced to leave their homes and follow the German armies to new homes, they were herded towards the ?ghettos?. On the way to these Ghettos, the luggage that the Jews brought with them were tossed aside, searched, sorted and pillaged by the German officers. The bottom line was that since the people were Jewish they were not considered people and thus had no rights to anything, not

In the Early Nineteenth Century Americans Sought to Resolve Their Political Disputes Through Compromise Yet by 1860 This No Longer Seemed Possible

849 words - 4 pages I. Every Greek God/Goddess is important to the Greek society. The ruler of the Gods is Zeus. Zeus has a brother name Hades who is the God of the underworld. Zeus also has another brother named Poseidon who rules the seas and earthquakes. The three brothers defeated the Titans and got control. With control the Gods became who they are. II. Body A. Names of Greek Gods/Goddesses. 1. Aphrodite is the goddess of love and beauty. 2

Business Ethics Across Cultures Article Review

1630 words - 7 pages which are: character, obligation, results, and equity (Bullard, 2009). Justly, consumer behavior is important in the understanding of global markets and how businesses function. Furthermore, it is our moral responsibility as consumers to uphold the four ethical perceptions, because as a consumer we are the formulation of the world markets. Generally speaking, this article adequately depicts the four ethical perspectives and gives the reader an

Billing Issues

2600 words - 11 pages exists 2. Moral judgment – judging which action is morally right/wrong 3. Moral motivation – prioritizing moral values relative to other values 4. Moral character – courage to carry out the morally right action There is no question that judgment is a critical element in moral behavior, but it is only one element. Without recognition of the other components, students will not gain a full understanding of moral behavior within

Current Ethics Paper

1037 words - 5 pages outages and flooding across most of the island. This is an ethical and moral issue for the owners. The ethical issue is the facility is unsafe, strong winds and rain caused power outages and flooding because the equipment is not strong enough to handle the output of power needed for such a large facility. This could lead to injuries to guest or staff in case of another or larger storm. The owners have a moral obligation to inform management

Related Papers

The Obligation To Endure Essay

1413 words - 6 pages “The discovery of agriculture was the first big step toward a civilized life.” (Arthur Keith) Civilization began with agriculture, and agriculture continues to be an integral part of our lives. Civilization brought knowledge, knowledge brought technology, and technology brought chemicals and pesticides to “improve” our world. “The Obligation to Endure” is an excerpt from Rachel Carson’s “Silent Spring,” a passionate and masterful work on

Journey To The Center Of The Earth

460 words - 2 pages The Journey to the Center of the EarthBy: Zoe GrossMrs. FlynnNo scientist has ever been to the center of the earth, not even machines. Nothing that scientist can do are able to get them past the crust, because the temperature and pressure increase the father you go down. Then how in the world do scientist know what's down there? Just like doctor's can tell what is in us by what comes out. Geologists are scientist who study earths inner by

Picture Of The Insight To Moral Issues

640 words - 3 pages whether to experience Pentecostalism Often identified as Protestant or Evangelicals No religious hierarchy, thus there is no one below God Glossolalia or speaking with tongues for a proof or evidence of the Holy Spirit Baptism Fastest growing Christian group of today due to denominational switching (yet quick exit rate) Denominational switching Only implies to those who change ‘within’ Christian

Intro To Life Sciences: Protecting The Ozone Layer That Protects Life On Earth

5410 words - 22 pages Protecting the Ozone PAGE 1 Protecting the Ozone Layer That Protects Life on EarthUniversity of PhoenixIntroduction to Life SciencesWord Count: 4,583Protecting the Ozone Layer That Protects Life on EarthOver the past few decades, researchers worldwide have been concerned about the gradual depletion of the ozone layer, which is the atmospheric layer in the stratosphere miles above the Earth that protects all life forms from harmful ultraviolet