Organizing Knowledge Essay

2775 words - 12 pages

Anthony Grafton and Bruno Latour may be considered as people of knowledge and education. They both were engaged in the process of knowledge acquiring and transforming it into their own ideas and new horizons of thought. For most aficionados, Princeton historian Anthony Grafton put the bon mot in play a few years ago in his elegant The Footnote: A Curious History (Harvard University Press). Now, however, in The Devil’s Details: A History of Footnotes (Invisible Cities Press), former Amherst College dean Chuck Zerby, in his odd doppelgänger to Grafton’s volume, merely credits Grafton with reusing the line while stating (see backhanded compliment at Zerby footnote No. 31), ...view middle of the document...

Despite Ranke’s impressive combination of narrative and analytical history and Gibbon’s blending of massive knowledge and high style, neither, according to Grafton, was the first to practice the art and craft of documented, critical history. Behind both were ancient, medieval, and Renaissance prototypes, numerous historians who not only told stories but cited evidence as well. Among them were the Italians Bernardino Corio, Leonardo Bruni, and Giannantonio Campano; the Englishmen Richard White and Ben Jonson; and, most impressively, the great French historian Jacques-Auguste de Thou. The latter wrote a “genuinely new kind of history” in what would prove to be the longest historical narrative before the twentieth century. (2)
Other prototypes of modern scholarship included seventeenth-century church historians and antiquaries, particularly the German Jesuit Athanasius Kircher, whose massive, illustrated study of ancient China marked the maturation of a tradition of historical documentation reaching all the way back to the fourth-century Christian historian Eusebius and the venerable eighth-century English monk known as Bede. Here, too, one can find a combination of technical argument and deep documentation that anticipates modern historical scholarship. Also helping to make the primary source supreme within this tradition of scholarship were the bitter tracts of warring Protestants and Catholics.
The seventeenth century was nonetheless a step up in historical scholarship because that century’s church historians and antiquaries, as well as exceptional scholars like de Thou, subjected documents to a higher degree of scrutiny, allowing “the [prior] age of primitive accumulation of ecclesiastical-learning . . . to give way to one of analysis and investment.” (4) However, Mr. Grafton again insists that the work of these scholars also provides an “insufficient” explanation for the rise of the footnote.
So who, or what, in the end was the key player in the birth of the new professional scholarship the footnote came to represent? For Grafton, that honor belongs to a scholar and a work he first discovered as a college undergraduate: the great Dictionnaire of Pierre Bayle. “Swarming” with footnotes and irreverencies, and aspiring to expose and correct all the mistakes then existing in other reference books, Bayle’s dictionary is truly a young man’s book. It was written against the background of the “deconstruction” of the scientific authority of the ancients at the hands of the new seventeenth-century scientists Rene Descartes, Francis Bacon, Blaise Pascal, and Robert Boyle. Here the modern “rules of scholarly procedure” and historical scholarship as we know them today finds their definitive statement. (3)
Although Grafton proclaims Bayle’s uniqueness, he diminishes it somewhat by his extensive honor roll of earlier prototypes and by the...

Other Essays Like Organizing Knowledge

Management of Health Services Essay

1175 words - 5 pages Bhagyashree Sood Management of Health services Professor Frank 11/15/2015 Evaluation #2 Managers have a big role to play in the success of a health services organizations. Since managers are the primary people one could reach out for assistance, they have to plan strategically and follow the key concepts and theories which enhances the performances of the organization. Planning and organizing is also a very important aspect in the process

Various Aspects to the Idea of Management

722 words - 3 pages functions of planning, organizing, leading, and controlling are widely considered the best means of describing the manager’s job as well as the best way to classify accumulated knowledge about the study of management. Even in today’s changing business environment, managers must be effective to be successful. The four functions of management are tools to help them meet their goals. Bibliography Page Management Functions." Encyclopedia of Management. Ed. Marilyn M. Helms. Gale Cengage, 2006. 2006. 2 Sep, 2009

Fucntions for the Company to Run and Operate Smoothly

1115 words - 5 pages . (University of Phoenix, 2009) Each level can usually determine which primary function the manager will perform. Top-level managers usually perform the controlling and leading function, leaving the lower and mid-level managers responsible for the planning and organizing. However, today’s trends are more geared toward teamwork and a working knowledge of all four functions. Management functions are leading, controlling, organizing and


1005 words - 5 pages , organizing, leading and controlling which each manager’s level is given with these responsibilities to work on. The first-line manager, are the ones who supervise those who are non-managerial employees. There is lesser planning and organizing in this level of managerial however they are the ones who will become the role model for the non-managerial employees and influencing and leading the non-managerial employees. They will dismantle any goals and

Functions of Management

1231 words - 5 pages Functions of Management University of Phoenix Functions of Management The functions of management are as vital in an organization as the employees themselves. Without a constant evolution of these functions: planning, organizing, leading, and controlling, the business would suffer and fail. Although together these functions produce a constant flow for a company individually each function is its own power all its own

Ralph W. Tyler's Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction

842 words - 4 pages assessing their students. Since then, Basic Principles of Curriculum and Instruction has been a standard reference for anyone working with curriculum development. Although not a strict how-to guide, the book shows how educators can critically approach curriculum planning, studying progress and retooling when needed. Its four sections focus on setting objectives, selecting learning experiences, organizing instruction, and evaluating progress. Readers

The Four Functions of Management

969 words - 4 pages people and resources to accomplish organizational objectives. The process behind meeting these goals begins with the four functions of management: planning, organizing, leading, and controlling. Planning is defined as “specifying the goals to be achieved and deciding in advance the appropriate actions needed to achieve those goals (Bateman, & Snell, 2009) . In this phase, managers devise an outline in which individuals, groups teams, or in

Company Management

2320 words - 10 pages one or more detailed plans to achieve optimum balance of needs or demands with the available resources. 2.ORGANIZING: The organizing function of leadership controls the overall structure of the company. The organizational structure is the foundation of a company; without this structure, the day-to-day operation of the business becomes difficult and unsuccessful. Organizing involves designating tasks and responsibilities to employees with the

the new job

875 words - 4 pages Recommendation Before designing the job, there are a few key features to be figured: 1. tasks to be carried, 2. complexity of the task, 3. workload and 4. flexibility of the place/time the tasks to be carried. As mentioned in the passage, this role is set to provide better support the marketing department in the administrative way, and the tasks includes arrangements of travel schedules, tracking accounts payable to the department, organizing meetings

Organization Paper

1065 words - 5 pages increased productivity and allow for freer exchange of information while creating clear structure for the organization. The organizing function of management impacts many levels of a business’s operations, from knowledge management, budgeting, human resources and many others areas. As presented by the examples, it is important for a company to utilize all the resources they have available, whether it be tangible or intangible assets. Not understanding or properly organizing these resources could have a catastrophic effect on a business succeeding and meeting the company’s goals.

Four Functions of Management

772 words - 4 pages monitor and measure business goals. Every business needs managers to run the company. No matter how many employees a manager has, he or she is going to need to know the four function of management. Using their knowledge of planning, organizing, leading and controlling can make a good manager a great manager. Within a company a manager needs to be the go to person for answers. Managers need to plan for what’s ahead, organize the workers to accomplish the tasks, be the leader when the time comes, and control what information the workers need.

Related Papers

Organizing Essay

1337 words - 6 pages This paper explains that the organizing function of management that impacts human resources and knowledge may strongly impact an organization's success. The organizing function of management in relation to human resources considers mission and service member needs, develops personnel organizational charts, incorporates internal and external factors and establishes goals for day-to-day management. It shows how the organizing function of

Organizing Functions Essay

1256 words - 6 pages diversity. Chase’s finance, human resources, organizing, and business management plays parallel roles in creating strategies growth, anticipating, and responding to business trends, and stabilizing the franchise by keeping a maintaining a dynamic environment (JP Morgan Chase & Co., 2012). Monetary. Finance and budget planning fits the category of organizing functions. Management should acquire knowledge about the standard budget process in place

Enterprise Wide Knowledge Management Systems Essay

871 words - 4 pages bulletin board postings. Enterprise content management systems provides databases and tools for organizing and storing structured documents and tools for organizing. It also, provides storing semi-structured knowledge, such as e-mail or rich media. Explicit knowledge that exists in formal documents, as well as in formal rules that organizations derive by observing experts and their decision-making behaviors is structured knowledge ( Laudon &amp

Organizing Jen Electric Essay

1007 words - 5 pages validation or discarded if it cannot be repaired. Conclusion Jen Electric is efficient in the organizing function of management as it relates to human resources, knowledge, and physical assets. JE has proven this by becoming the 3rd largest electrical company in 2004. Within the organization JE must coordinate the use of its own knowledge with human resources and physical assets. These three aspects of its organizational resources seem to go