Perceptions On Belonging Or Not Belonging Prescribed Text The Crucible And Related Text The Drifters

657 words - 3 pages

Explore how perceptions of belonging or not belonging can be influenced by connections to a place(s). In your response, refer to your prescribed text and at least one related text of your own choice.
Both The Crucible by Arthur miller and Drifters by Bruce Dawe are influenced by connections to a place with belonging and not belonging. A sense of belonging emerges from the connections made with people, places, groups or communities.
Firstly, The Crucible is about belonging to a community. There are many characters who do and don’t belonging in the community of Salem. Belonging to a group empowers individuals. The girls of Salem acquire and abuse power because of their numbers. Abigail Williams is the leader of the circle of girls, although she does not belong to the Salem community because she is an orphan and finds she belongs and has power within the group of girls that follow her.
Abigail doesn’t ...view middle of the document...

It is more important for an individual to belong to a group that possesses integrity than it is to belong to a shameful majority. John Proctor refuses to sign a proclamation of guilt because he feels shame in condemn those he truly respects and in turn he suffers the ultimate consequence of death for mounting a protest against the authority of Salem.
When John Proctor stands before the Salem court accused of witchcraft he is presented with a choice-either he can support the court and confess to the charge of witchcraft or he can rebel against the court and deny the charge. "You are either with this court or you must be counted against it"
Proctor struggles to choose a plea because he has a good reputation in the community and if he confesses more people will believe in the witchcraft lie. Alternatively if he denies the charge he will be hung on the grounds that he has refused to denounce allegiance to Satan. After considerable anguish Proctor at first decides that his good reputation is not worth his life but when the court tries to pressure him into signing his name to a confession he refuses on the grounds that it will incriminate those he respects, who are willing to die.
Thirdly, Drifters is about belonging to a place. The family finds it hard to belong to a particular place as they are constantly moving due to the fathers work. “It’s time to start packing” indicates that the father follows the work and the wife always feels unstable.
The use of symbolism in this poem such as “the green and unripped tomatoes” is a used as an indicator of time, which shows how long the family have stayed in that place for. The change of the black berries shows the audience the stages of their movement from when they have first arrived at this house to the day when they are moving away.
The Crucible explores the concept of belonging through connections to a place. This is mainly through the characters of Abigail Williams and John Proctor attempting to belong to the Salem community. In contrast, Drifters explore this connection of belonging to a place through a family who struggles to find a sense of belonging.

Other Essays Like Perceptions on Belonging or Not Belonging - Prescribed Text the Crucible and Related Text the Drifters

Belonging Plus Related Essay

973 words - 4 pages to belonging we must take into account the idea of not belonging as the consequence of the choice to not belong or- non acceptance prevent belonging. There are many barriers in the concept of belonging which is explored in the poems “Migrant Hostel and “10 Mary Street” and in the film ‘Fight Club’. In Peter Skrzynecki’s “Migrant Hostel” the theme of belonging is portrayed in a sense that for some people, in this case immigrants, have the strong

Stimulus Text On "The Road Not Taken" By Robert Frost. (Speech)

501 words - 3 pages see the peaks of the mountains. In the road not taken the traveller at the crossroad is choosing an unpredictable journey. He does not know whether his experience will be positive or negative. Although this isn't stated, it is quite obvious experiences are positive or negative. Therefore these two texts have helped me gain a greater understanding of the impacts physical journeys have on all of us when we have to make important decisions, and this is shown not only through the texts but ideas and techniques.

The Lovely Bones and Belonging

580 words - 3 pages An individual shapes his or her own sense of Belonging.” Discuss *provide points for and/or against In Alice Sebold’s The lovely bones, she explores the concept of belonging and Susie’s journey to find belonging and accept what has happened, she did not chose her sense of belonging. Susie felt out of place in the “inbetween”. Her journey to self discovery was shaped by the people around her, her family, her murderer and eventually the

Great Expectations Summary- Warning: I'M Not an Author of This Text

2455 words - 10 pages quite place the look, but an expression on her face reminds him of someone. Pip stays away from Joe and Biddy's house and the forge, but walks around town, enjoying the admiring looks he gets from his past neighbors. Soon thereafter, a letter for Pip announces the death of Mrs. Joe Gragery. Pip returns home again to attend the funeral. Later, Joe and Pip sit comfortably by the fire like times of old. Biddy insinuates that Pip will not be

Hsc Belonging: Comparison Bretween the Simple Gift and Avata

1258 words - 6 pages identity, worth and connection leading to an experience of belonging. Another major similarity between the two texts is that the rules of society in both texts have bearing on an individual’s potential to belong. Belonging is to feel secure, be in a relationship or have or share affinity towards someone or something. ‘The Simple Gift’ by Steven Herrick is about a teenage boy who runs away from his abusive childhood to the rural town of Bendarat

Dickinson And Belonging

1295 words - 6 pages "To what extent is a persons sense of belonging shaped by both their own decisions and the perceptions of others"By instinctive nature, people have a deep desire to belong and to be connected with others whilst simultaneously not losing their own individual sense of self. Our sense of belonging is largely shaped by our personal, social and cultural ideals, as well as the judgments of others. Whhen these two clash, many experience a sense of

Belonging Skrzynecki and Goodfellas

1247 words - 5 pages individual which derives from that individual’s perceptions and beliefs. Peter Skrzynecki’s poetic novel “Immigrant Chronicle” and Martin Scorsese’s film “Goodfellas” are two texts that illustrate to their audiences what Skrzynecki and Scorsese respectively both believe what it means to belong. Through study and analysis of the poetic devices and ideas created in Skrzynecki’s “Immigrant Chronicle” illustrating belonging to place, and family as well as not belonging to family and Scorsese’s “Goodfellas” illustrating belonging to creed and place, audiences gain a rich understanding of what it means to belong.

Comparison of the Poems Drifters and Shooti

618 words - 3 pages buried them behind the tool shed. It was one of the last things I did before we left. Each time the gravel slid off the shovel it sounded like something trying to hang on by its nails. Philip Hodgins ‘Shooting the Dogs’ The speaker’s beliefs and values in each of the poems are hinted or directly said. In the poem Drifters the speaker’s beliefs are not openly portrayed. Her beliefs and values seem to have been suppressed by her husband

The Effects of Cell Phone and Text Message Distractions on True and False Recognition

915 words - 4 pages -phone and text-messaging distractions during study.” The participants were given a list of related words such as mother, crib, and diaper liked to non- related words such as baby. After they studied the list of words, the participants recalled or recognized the words. “Participants not only demonstrate high remembrance for presented words such as crib, but also recollection for non-related words such as baby.” The related words were examples of the

Displacement and Changing Relationships Alter the Sense of Belonging over Time

1019 words - 5 pages herself from the court and her father for her love of Rosalind. This alienation is significant, as the initial displacement of Rosalind’s father and the changing relationship with her once guilty uncle causes not only herself, but those around her to experience change and a search for acceptance. In all three texts displacement and changing relationships alter the sense of belonging over time, whether it is to belong through identity, acceptance and love or to be alienated through exclusion, isolation or the inability to accept someone for their differences.

The First Group, The Family, Has More Influence In Our Identity And Belonging

928 words - 4 pages tall on her own two feet.   Who we become as person originates from what we learn at home. Our values and beliefs are formulated from what is encouraged and practiced. Around the world, religion can play a significant role in ones' identity. The values and beliefs of Christianity differ from those of Buddhism or Hinduism. What is considered 'normal' in one family may not be for another. Something simple as saying grace before each meal, is not

Related Papers

Belonging And Related Text Essay

1114 words - 5 pages when he states, “Bendarat is the perfect town. A friendly librarian, a warm McDonalds, luxury train accommodation.” Likewise, the shot conveying the completion of the elephant’s journey, and his celebratory dance with his family in Capetown, demonstrates that same sense of comfort and belonging. e) An evaluation of the particular belonging concepts that are explored in your related and prescribed text There therefore exists a sense of

Belonging; Related Text Young Samurai Essay

1098 words - 5 pages The choice to belong or not belong may vary from one person to another. Our sense of belonging can only be achieved when we know who we are and where we are situated in our society. A sense of belong is forged when a person finds a connection between, places, people and the larger world. By refusing or not acknowledging the ideology and lifestyle of the society you live in, it would be difficult for you to achieve a sense of belonging. This

Belonging: Peter Skrzynecki And Related Text: Mending Wall

808 words - 4 pages created through the process of belonging. Only the individual can determine whether or not they belong and to shape a sense of self in their life. Migrant Hostel by Peter Skrzynecki demonstrates how individuals may not belong to other cultures. This can be portrayed through the use of a smile “Nationalities sought/ each other out distinctively/ like homing pigeons”. The use of simile in ‘homing pigeons’ suggest that the migrants are trying to

The Ways Belonging Or Not Belonging Can Shape Our Sense Of Identity

1447 words - 6 pages Discuss the ways belonging or not belonging can shape our sense of self and identity. Within Emily Dickinson’s poems ‘This is my Letter to the World’ and ‘I died for Beauty-but was scarce’, Curtis Sittenfeld’s 2005 novel ‘Prep’ and J.D. Salinger’s 1951 novel The Catcher in the Rye’, the composers represent the individual’s experience of belonging or not belonging. Our perception of belonging emerges from personal and social contexts, as well