This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Personal Identity And Psychological Reductionism Essay

2009 words - 9 pages

Personal Identity and Psychological Reductionism

When we tackle the question of 'What makes us the individual persons that we are?', one approach that we can take is to seek an answer to the question of what it is that is required for a person to continue to exist over time. If we could agree on what is required for it to be true that you continued to exist, then we would have good grounds to believe that we had discovered what makes someone the particular person they are, and by extension, what makes any person the person they are. In essence, what we are searching for are the necessary and sufficient conditions for personal identity over time.

In this essay we will focus on the ...view middle of the document...

Where Psychological Reductionists believe that Descartes went wrong was to suppose that personal identity was fixed by the substance that was doing the thinking, rather than the thoughts themselves. To illustrate this point we can look at John Locke's thought at experiment which, for many, dealt a fatal blow against the idea that the self is an immaterial substance. Locke's experiment is presented by Joseph Chandler as follows:

Let anyone reflect upon himself and conclude that he has in himself an immaterial spirit, which is that which thinks in him and in the constant change of his body keeps him the same. Let him also suppose it to be the same soul that was in Nestor or Theristes at the siege of Troy, but he now having no consciousness of any of the actions of either Nestor or Theristes, does he or can he conceive of himself to be the same person with either of them? Can he be concerned in either of their actions, attribute them to himself, or think of them his own, more than the actions of any other men that ever existed?

According to Chandler, in the above thought experiment we have to consider what would be the case if we had 'immaterial spirits', which were thought to be the basis of our personal identity. If this was so, then the kind of reincarnation described in the experiment would certainly be possible. So, according to Locke, if all this were true, it would nonetheless be absurd to say that you were the same person as Theristes. The reason being that because the whole idea of being the same person implies sameness of consciousness i.e. having the same thoughts, plans, feelings and memories. Now since this sameness of consciousness is not preserved in reincarnation, the continued existence of an immaterial spirit cannot be sufficient for the continued existence of a person.

John Locke is regarded by many as the originator of the psychological theory. He argued that a person at an earlier time is the same as a person at a later time if the later person remembers all the experiences of the earlier one. This is asking a lot. A more plausible definition would be based on chains of remembering — today you can remember most of yesterday's experiences and tomorrow you will remember most of today's, and the day after that most of tomorrow's, and so on. So in a year's time there will be a chain of remembering leading back to yesterday, and indeed leading back to your birth, which you will now have no memory at all. Locke clearly believed that memory was not the only factor and that a person at an earlier time is psychologically continuous with a person at a later time if from that later person there is a chain of linked memories and emotions and plans and character going back to the earlier time. So that what really matters to the psychological reductionist is that there is a continuity of mental life, so that although our beliefs, desires, plans and personalities do change, they do so gradually. Even though we do sometimes undergo...

Other Essays Like Personal Identity And Psychological Reductionism

Racial Identity & Mental Health Essay

3621 words - 15 pages ) did not have a significant on the personal identity variable (mental health). Possible contraindications and recommendations for future research are noted. Discourse on the psychology of African Americans has not been particularly affirming to African-Americans. Much of the literature pertaining to Black identity from 1936 and 1967 focused, primarily, on self-hatred and group rejection as a typical aspect of Black psychological functioning

Identity Theft Essay

650 words - 3 pages Judashia Eley Identity Theft Report Identity theft is a common crime in America. Every two seconds identity theft is committed. There are about 15 million victims a year from identity theft. Identity theft is the stealing and use of a person’s person information, which is usually for financial gain. Identity theft affects us every day. When an identity theft steals your personal information, they have access to your full name, social security

wk 2 Individual Assignment

2171 words - 9 pages  PSYCH 626 Bio-Psychosocial Perspective Dr. Mark Schmitz October 13, 2014 Bio-Psychosocial Perspective Detail the three systems and contexts that constitute the bio-psychosocial model. Demonstrate the influence of the bio-psychosocial model on the bio-medical viewpoint. Describe how the interaction of biological, psychological, and social factors influence a person's health. Establish a hypothetical

Nigrescence Model Of Racial Identity Development

870 words - 4 pages internalized their personal racial conflicts; come to terms with those conflicts; and established healthy relationships with members of other races. The fifth and final stage of Black racial identity development refers to internalization-commitment stage. This depicts the juncture in life when a black American reaches the ultimate cultural balance. This balance amalgamate the choices and experiences one has acquired within this identity process. These

Humanistic Psychology

2515 words - 11 pages , continues to grow, especially in the fields of health, education, and management theory, and in the personal and social lives of millions of Americans. (Leonard, Decement 1983). Philosophical and Historical Context : Throughout history many individuals and groups have affirmed the inherent value and dignity of human beings. In Western civilization we honor the times and places, such as Classical Greece and Europe of the Renaissance, when such

The formation of identity in "Climbing The Mango Trees" by Madhur Jaffrey

332 words - 2 pages We often speak of one's "personal identity" as what makes one the person one is. Your identity in this sense consists roughly of those properties that make you unique as an individual and different from others. Or it is the way you see or define yourself. Or it may be the network of values and convictions that structure your life.I think that identity consists of different part to form at the end whole personal identity. Part one is our

Personal Identity

487 words - 2 pages Alan Watts once said, "Trying to define yourself is like trying to bite your own teeth." Personal identity defines a quality of a human being that makes him or her unique. People must have images of themselves in their own minds, while identifying others with different images. In other words, both internal (mind) and external (body) aspects need to be considered to differentiate one person from another. There are several general philosophical


1522 words - 7 pages psychology is an exciting and relatively new field devoted to understanding psychological influences on how people stay healthy, why they become ill and how they respond when they do get ill? It focuses on health promotion and maintenance, prevention and treatment of illness and the understanding of the biopsychosocial aspects of physical and mental illness, improvement of the health care system and the formulation of health policy (S.E, Taylor

Identity Politics Challenging Universalism

994 words - 4 pages also explain a bit about particularism and how it relates to identity politics. Identity politics is the recognition of the importance of the differences within society. It is a political focus upon the individual and seeing them as embedded in a particular culture, social, institutional and ideological sense. In a way, identity politics is the link between the personal and the social aspects of our lives. Heywood states that, “Whereas ‘social

The Lawnmower Man and Posthuman Cyberspaces

1957 words - 8 pages Future) Robotics Institute researcher Hans Moravec supports this idea with his theory of “transmigration”; a process by which all facets of the human brain can be surgically extracted and transferred to computer software, leaving only the empty shell of the biological behind. (Dualism Through Reductionism) With the reliance on the biological successfully removed from the human equation by any method, the integration of humans and

Mental Health Community

3289 words - 14 pages of psychological functioning, social integration, and conduct. According to the American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM IV) the nature of such condition is biological in nature. The DSM IV defines mental disorder as follows: In the DSM, each of the mental disorders is conceptualized as a clinically significant behavioral or psychological syndrome or pattern that occurs in a person that is associated with

Related Papers

Attributes Of Intimate Social Relationships And Personal Identity

1363 words - 6 pages R; Harvey, Eileen J INTIMATE SOCIAL RELATIONSHIPS are acknowledged as vital to healthy psychological development from infancy on (Bowlby, 1971). Starting in adolescence, development of a sense of personal identity becomes another important psychological challenge. Together, intimacy and identity are often described as the main criteria for reaching psychological maturity in early adulthood. Yet, the relationships between these variables have

Personal Identity Essay

1240 words - 5 pages opinions of Derek Parfit and David Lewis. First, Parfit’s outlook on identity and survival will be explored accompanied by examples of fusion and fission. Following Parfit’s arguments on identity and survival, the contrasting views of David Lewis will be examined, specifically in relation to the identity of the time traveller. Derek Parfit’s notion of identity is as follows: psychological continuity does not equal personal identity, which, in

Self Identity Essay

1267 words - 6 pages of self-identity, namely psychosocial identity theory and Tajfel’s social identity theory. Discussion Psychosocial Identity Theory The theory proposed by Erik Erikson regarding the psychological development among the human beings is one of the most highly rated theories regarding personality in psychology. The theory has similarities with the Freudian school of thought as it states that the personality development in a person is not an

Summarise Two Theories Of Identity And Compare Their Usefulness For Explaining The Real World Issues Discussed In Chapter 1

665 words - 3 pages identity can be changed by switching groups and that identity is therefore socially dependant. Psychoanalyst Erik Erikson was the first theorist to view identity as psychosocial; this meant that he recognised that both personal and social factors influenced the development of identity. Erikson developed his theories from a combination of clinical and naturalistic observations and also from his analyses of biographies of famous men (Phoenix, 2007