Dr. Braddock and Dr. Tonelli use Aristotelian rhetoric in their article titled, “Physician Aid-in-Dying: Ethical Topic in Medicine.” The authors provide examples of logos by providing statistics about physician assisted suicide. In the article you will find pathos that will offer different emotions within the topic. These authors have many ethos or many years of credentials within the medical field.
In this article, Dr. Braddock and Dr. Tonelli explain the difference between physician assisted suicide and euthanasia. Physician assisted suicide is “Practice in which a physician provides a competent, terminally ill patient with a prescription for a lethal dose of medication, upon the ...view middle of the document...
Oregon became the first state in the U.S to have a legal act like this in place. Another, logos the authors write is “In November 2008, the citizens of Washington state passed I-1000,
The Washington State Death with Dignity Act (DwDA) by a margin of 57.8% to 42.2%” (Braddock and Tonelli). These statistics prove that in both these states, the Death with Dignity Act, won by a close margin of votes.
The ethos in this article is in Dr. Clarence H. Braddock III credentials. He became a M.D. in 1981, at the University of Chicago. He is currently the director of clinical ethics at Stanford Center for Bioethics. He is also, currently the medical director for quality, associate dean for medical education, and the director of scholarly concentration program in medical education at Stanford University. Dr. Braddock has written a number of medical ethic books, along with medical articles (Stanford University). Dr. Mark R. Tonelli is currently the professor of division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine. He is also the Pulmonary and Critical Care training director at the University of Washington Medical Center (University of Washington).
An emotional appeal or pathos, is that one could view that physician assisted suicide as playing god, because ultimately, the physician is providing the necessary tools for the patients death. The authors write that many people feel strongly about “letting die” or “killing” patients, also what the physicians duties are and challenges they may face with assisted suicide. “Even in states where it is illegal, some physicians will decide to help their patients” (Braddock and Tonelli).
The major premise in the syllogism is explaining the definition of physician assisted suicide and that it is a highly debatable subject, with each side having good arguments. The minor premise is that two states in the U.S have already legalized...