This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Physician Assisted Suicide Must Be Legalized Essay

4687 words - 19 pages

Physician-Assisted Suicide Must Be Legalized
Sheryl Tello
GEN 499
Prof. David Ward
March 14, 2014

Physician-Assisted Suicide Must Be Legalized
Imagine that you just received a phone call from your physician’s nurse and she told you that the doctor wants to see you right away. When you ask her what is the problem; she tells you that it would be best if you came into the office as soon as possible. You tell her that there is no way that you can come in until next week; she asks if you can hold for a minute while she relays the message to your doctor, and the next thing you know your physician is on the phone and tells you that he wants to see you today. You try to rationalize ...view middle of the document...

Proponents also argue that legalizing PAS is necessary to insure that no one dies in painful agony and unremitting suffering. Advocates contend that there is very little difference between PAS and pain control since both use strong drugs and a patient’s death may be unintentionally hastened as a side effect of the narcotics used in palliative care. They also claim that doctors commonly engage in PAS surreptitiously and promote legalization as a way to protect vulnerable patients from abuses inherent in current unregulated practice. By acknowledging the worries over potential abuses, advocates assure that protective guidelines would be put into place that would protect the vulnerable from wrongful death while still allowing the terminally ill who are eligible for PAS to obtain a desired, peaceful death with dignity. Proponents also claim that opposition to PAS is primarily based in religion and therefore the laws prohibiting the practice are unconstitutional because they violate the division between the church and the state (Bonin, 2012).
Opponents on the other hand believe that the legalization of PAS would surely lead society down a dangerous slippery slope that will eventually permit the legalized killing of the disabled, the elderly, and people who are depressed, as well as the mentally incompetent. They say that protective guidelines will not protect these people. Opponents also argue that the economics of modern medicine will promote PAS as a form of health care cost containment, noting that the drugs used in PAS are a lot cheaper than the cost of providing palliative care to the terminally ill. Opponents also note that more than 44 million Americans do not have any form of health insurance; and that medicine is sometimes practiced in a discriminatory manner against certain minorities. It is for this reason that opponents argue that the last people to receive medical treatment will be the first people to receive PAS. They also deny that there is widespread surreptitious PAS practiced in medical clinics, and urge that hospice care along with the proper medical treatment provide a morally acceptable answer to the pain and suffering that is sometimes associated with the process of dying (Pereira, 2011). While these arguments continue with no end in sight, more and more of the terminally ill cry out in agony, for the right to end their suffering.
Terminally ill patients do not have a lot of options when it comes to ending their pain and suffering. The addition of just one more option can contribute to the psychological comfort of a terminally ill patient. In the article, Physician-Assisted Death in the United States: Are the Existing Last Resorts Enough? Timothy Quill outlines several aspects of PAS, specifically the fact that the terminally ill need as many options as they can possibly get. The whole time terminally ill patients are enduring tremendous suffering; they know that eventually they are going to die. Quill...

Other Essays Like Physician-Assisted Suicide Must Be Legalized

Ethics in Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

1673 words - 7 pages your belief. Without belief there can be no successful outcome.” Kevorkian believed in every terminal patient’s right to physician assisted suicide as he also once said famously that “Dying is not a crime.” In 1999 Kevorkian was sentenced to 10-25 years for second degree murder. He was released in 2007 after serving 8 ½ years after promising that he wouldn’t offer suicide advice to anyone. This is such a controversial topic even after

I Support Physician-Assisted Suicide Essay

1415 words - 6 pages states that legalized this means of ending life.  However, doctor assisted is still seen as a criminal act in thirty four states(Rosen 1).  In my opinion, doctor assisted suicide should be made legal throughout the nation.  If a terminally ill patient wants to take his or her life due to excruciating pain, he or she should have the ability to utilize euthanasia.  Ultimately, the decision should be that of the

Physician Assisted Suicide: a Contentious Topic Today

2614 words - 11 pages personnel can stop or prevent the pain. Sometimes the conditions that qualify for assisted suicide take away the patients dignity by making them helpless or cause them to enter a vegetative state. With physician assisted suicide legalized, the patients suffering from terminal conditions have the chance to die with dignity and peace, which means their death will be on their own terms, at their time, and hopefully with support by family and friends

The Legal and Ethical Dilemma of Physician Assisted Suicide

3512 words - 15 pages ethical dilemma surrounding PAS, it was not the act alone that resulted in Dr. Kevorkian’s arrest and sentence. Hosseini posed the question in his research “Is Physician-Assisted Suicide Ethical?” to which he answered “… this problem too has two sides to be considered; we can also find ethical justification for the other side of the argument.” (p 5). According to Hosseini (2012) there were arguments both in favor and against PAS. Hosseini began

Ethical and Legal Issues of Physician-Assisted Suicide

1235 words - 5 pages Although the physician does not directly end the patient’s life, physician-assisted suicide (PAS) occurs when the physician provides the means (i.e. information or drugs) to commit suicide. Patients who request PAS from their doctors usually suffer from terminal illnesses, such as AIDS, cancer, or neurological disorders, in which death is inevitable, and it is estimated that 12% of physicians receive at least one request for PAS per year (Beck

Should Assisted Suicide Be Legal?

1529 words - 7 pages end in sight. These patients or their families should have the right to make a life ending decision without the fear of legal ramifications. Physician assisted suicide should be legal. Patients, with the help of their physicians, should be able to decide if they want to end their own life. Only that person knows what kind of pain and suffering they are enduring. A court or judge cannot determine the level of pain and suffering a patient

assisted suicide

1556 words - 7 pages most hopeless moment of their life and nobody can offer help because of the laws is heartbreaking. On the other side, others argue that requests only come from those who have not received pain control or who are just depressed because they have not been treated. "A woman starved herself 25 days to death in addition to her unbearable pain, because physician assisted suicide is illegal in England" (Should Assisted Suicide Be Legalized?). The

Patient Assisted Suicide

1225 words - 5 pages different countries decide to legalize assisted suicide. Basically, these researchers are saying that if a patient experiences pain and wants euthanasia, then every effort should be made to provide better palliative care for them prior to distributing the medical procedure. Finding out why a patient may visit a doctor about receiving euthanasia is the fundamental question to ask before this medical process is legalized in any country. The

Assisted Suicide

870 words - 4 pages people who are against it are misunderstanding what it really means and that’s why the think of it as an immoral action. Assisted suicide refers to the process by which a registered physician can prescribe medicaments that will help to end someone’s life upon the patient’s request. It would be an option for those individuals who feel that they do not have anything else to do in this world because of their physical status. This would give

Assisted Suicide

736 words - 3 pages role which later demonstrated the apparent danger of following such a sequence. Unfortunately Americans are prone to short term memory and thus the debate has risen again. With the legalization of assisted suicide, must come an abundant amount of restrictions. Restrictions need to include an age limit on the patient, time passed after being diagnosed that the request will be considered, mandatory health screenings, physically and mentally

Legalizing Euthanasia: a Practical Approach

2357 words - 10 pages system is disputed by many who disagree with the legalization of voluntary euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. Research shows that while there is some agreement that Medicare money will be saved if voluntary euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide were legalized, the amount of savings is in dispute. The savings to Medicare by legalizing voluntary euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide is not exact because it is not known how many

Related Papers

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

632 words - 3 pages patients who want to escape their terminal illness. In the process of physician-assisted suicide, a physician provides the patient with information or actual ways to terminate their own life. In order to receive this process the patient must be an adult and two doctors must confirm that the patient is diagnosed with an incurable disease. The patient also has to read and sign a written request in front of two witnesses showing that the patient is

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

2520 words - 11 pages of the four states where physician-assisted suicide is legal have minimum standards and protocols the physicians must follow. Each state minus Montana requires that the resident be at least 18 years of age, with six months or less to live. They also require three separate requests to do so, two oral requests at least 15 days apart and one written request (ProCon.org, 2013). Montana is the only state that no legal protocol is in place and the

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

2561 words - 11 pages patients die, his approval rating dropped to 19%, while his unfavorable rating rose to 57%. Public support for physician assisted suicide was confined to the limited situation where a terminally ill patient would ask a doctor for help to commit suicide. Fifty four percent thought that doctors should be able to give a lethal dose to these patients. Thirty two percent said they shouldn’t. There is virtually no support for physician assisted suicide

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

936 words - 4 pages ). The major premise in the syllogism is explaining the definition of physician assisted suicide and that it is a highly debatable subject, with each side having good arguments. The minor premise is that two states in the U.S have already legalized the Death Act and more states are trying to pass it. “A Montana lower court has also determined that physician aid-in-dying is permitted under Montana's State Constitution. The Montana case is expected